https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/mar/21/danish-man-found-guilty-of-fraudulently-profiting-from-music-streaming-royalties [p] Skip to main contentSkip to navigation Close dialogue1/1Next imagePrevious imageToggle caption Skip to navigation Print subscriptions Sign in Search jobs Search US edition[ ] * US edition * UK edition * Australia edition * International edition * Europe edition The Guardian - Back to homeThe Guardian [ ] * News * Opinion * Sport * Culture * Lifestyle ShowMoreShow More * [ ]News + View all News + US news + US elections 2024 + World news + Environment + Ukraine + Soccer + Business + Tech + Science + Newsletters + Wellness * [ ]Opinion + View all Opinion + The Guardian view + Columnists + Letters + Opinion videos + Cartoons * [ ]Sport + View all Sport + Soccer + NFL + Tennis + MLB + MLS + NBA + NHL + F1 + Golf * [ ]Culture + View all Culture + Film + Books + Music + Art & design + TV & radio + Stage + Classical + Games * [ ]Lifestyle + View all Lifestyle + Wellness + Fashion + Food + Recipes + Love & sex + Home & garden + Health & fitness + Family + Travel + Money * Search input [ ] google-search Search + Support us + Print subscriptions * [ ]US edition + UK edition + Australia edition + International edition + Europe edition * + Search jobs + Digital Archive + Guardian Licensing + About Us + The Guardian app + Video + Podcasts + Pictures + Inside the Guardian + Guardian Weekly + Crosswords + Wordiply + Corrections * + Facebook + Twitter * + Search jobs + Digital Archive + Guardian Licensing + About Us * World * Europe * US * Americas * Asia * Australia * Middle East * Africa * Inequality * Global development Headphones on blue and pink background [ ] A court in Aarhus also found that the man had breached copyright on 37 tracks. Photograph: Dash_med/Getty Images/iStockphoto View image in fullscreen A court in Aarhus also found that the man had breached copyright on 37 tracks. Photograph: Dash_med/Getty Images/iStockphoto Denmark Danish man found guilty of fraudulently profiting from music streaming royalties Unnamed 53-year-old made at least PS230,000 from artificially generated plays of hundreds of tracks Miranda Bryant in Stockholm Thu 21 Mar 2024 12.14 EDTLast modified on Thu 21 Mar 2024 16.48 EDT Share A Danish man has been sentenced to prison in a "historic" case after being found guilty of fraudulently profiting from royalties on hundreds of tracks on music streaming sites. In the country's first case of its kind, the 53-year-old man from East Jutland, whom the Danish press has decided not to name, was convicted on Thursday of making at least 2m Danish kroner (PS229,676) from artificially generated streams of "several hundred" music tracks. Prosecutors had said that the numbers of streams required to generate that amount of money could not have been generated by genuine users and that unauthorised techniques were likely to have been deployed instead. He was also found guilty by the court in Aarhus of breaching copyright on 37 of the tracks, which were edited versions of other musicians' work. Prosecutors had accused him of taking works from other artists, changing their length and tempo, and publishing them under his own name. He was sentenced to one year and six months - three months of which he must serve in prison - and the judge confiscated 2m Danish kroner (half of which will be taken from the man and half from his company). He was also fined 200,000 Danish kroner. Such was the volume of the artificially generated streams that he became Denmark's 46th highest-earning composer for streaming between 2014 and 2017. Musicians, artists, composers and copyright campaigners hailed what they described as a historic verdict. Maria Fredenslund, the chief executive of the Danish Rights Alliance, which reported the case in 2018, said: "We are pleased that the court has affirmed that streaming fraud is deeply criminal and serious. It's a historic verdict that sends a strong signal about the severity of stream manipulation challenges. The case also shows that this type of fraud can be detected, and that both rights holders and authorities take the issue seriously." She said it also sets an important precedent for the future. "It will be an important starting point to prevent similar cases in the future, especially with the development within artificial intelligence." Anna Lidell, chair of Autor, the largest Danish association for composers, songwriters, lyricists and producers, said: "It's truly an important and historic case, and it sends a message that you cannot infringe upon our rights as songwriters." She added: "The man cheated his way to millions of listens, but also violated copyright by speeding up the tracks and releasing them. It's a mockery to those who struggle to make music every day and earn peanuts." skip past newsletter promotion Sign up to This is Europe Free weekly newsletter The most pressing stories and debates for Europeans - from identity to economics to the environment Enter your email address [ ]Sign up Privacy Notice: Newsletters may contain info about charities, online ads, and content funded by outside parties. For more information see our Privacy Policy. We use Google reCaptcha to protect our website and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. after newsletter promotion He was originally accused of making 4.38m kroner from streams of 689 pieces of music across services including Spotify, Apple Music and YouSee Musik. But on Thursday, the court said it did not have sufficient data to confirm exactly how many artificially generated tracks were played, how many times or the royalties generated. Amir Amirian, the senior specialist prosecutor on the case, told the Guardian: "This is a principal case and from what I know it's the first of its type in Denmark. This is important because if we see similar cases in the future this will be the primary case to refer to and it's important from my perspective that the judge ruled that this is data fraud. This is actually illegal, it's not a gap in legislation or something like that." He added that he hoped the case would send a clear warning to others not to attempt such schemes. The convicted man indicated on Thursday that he would appeal against the verdict in the high court. Explore more on these topics * Denmark * Europe * Internet * Spotify * Apple Music * Artificial intelligence (AI) * news Share Reuse this content More on this story More on this story * [8256] Apple says Spotify wants 'limitless' access to its tools without paying 22 Feb 2024 * [7952] Danish man on trial over alleged PS500k music streaming fraud 20 Feb 2024 * [5016] Why is Apple facing a EUR500m fine from EU over music streaming? 19 Feb 2024 * [4285] Spotify announces CFO to leave, days after he cashed in $9.3m in shares 8 Dec 2023 * [3744] Spotify CFO cashes in PS7.2m in shares after value surges on news of job cuts 7 Dec 2023 * [3270] Spotify cuts more than 1,500 jobs amid rising costs 4 Dec 2023 * [6000] Deezer and Universal Music sign deal to focus royalties on big artists 6 Sept 2023 * [3700] Spotify increases premium price plans as streaming services feel strain 25 Jul 2023 Most viewed Most viewed * World * Europe * US * Americas * Asia * Australia * Middle East * Africa * Inequality * Global development * News * Opinion * Sport * Culture * Lifestyle Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning Sign up for our email * About us * Help * Complaints & corrections * SecureDrop * Work for us * * Privacy policy * Cookie policy * Terms & conditions * Contact us * All topics * All writers * Digital newspaper archive * Facebook * YouTube * Instagram * LinkedIn * Twitter * Newsletters * Advertise with us * Guardian Labs * Search jobs Back to top (c) 2024 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. (dcr)