http://mobileopportunity.blogspot.com/2023/06/how-does-amazon-think-about-devices.html skip to main | skip to sidebar * * Map the Future * Mobile Opportunity * Links * Contact * About * Michael Mace's homepage [gse_multipart16531] How does Amazon think about devices? A bad dialog box made me wonder today about the limits of Amazon's business model. The dialog box was on the Kindle Paperwhite, my preferred ebook reader: [Kindle] I'm dog-sitting this weekend at my daughter's house, and hadn't yet connected my Kindle to the home Wi-Fi network. The Kindle's home screen suggests books you might want to read, and when I tapped on one of them, that was the dialog box I saw. I think there are three important things wrong with it. Can you spot all of them? 1. Lack of clarity. The first problem is that your choices are ambiguous. What does the Yes button mean? * -Yes, I want to cancel * -Yes, I want to connect to Wi-Fi * -Yes, I understand that I need to either cancel or connect to Wi-Fi I guess that pressing Yes will probably try to connect to Wi-Fi, but I'm not at all sure. Mostly I am peeved at the device for confusing me. A better way to structure the dialog would be to ask the question in a yes/no format: "To view this book in the store, you need to connect to Wi-Fi. Do you want to do that now?" Or you could label the buttons differently. The left one could be "Cancel," and the right one could be "Connect to Wi-Fi." Some companies have guidelines that you should put only one or two words in a button, but I am a fan of clarity over brevity. There's enough room to make the buttons bigger. Okay, that's the first problem. Can you spot the second one? 2. Mixed usage paradigms. Why is the Yes button black and the No button white? On a computer, one button is usually highlighted to show you what will happen if you press the Enter key on the keyboard. My Kindle doesn't have a keyboard; all I can do is tap or swipe (or turn it off). So the highlighting is meaningless. Why is it there? I think either: * -The software was designed to be used with or without a keyboard, and they did not bother to insert cases for different device types, or * -The design tool used to build the software insisted on highlighting one of the buttons, or * -We're dealing with a designer who was having an off day. This problem doesn't necessarily confuse the user, but it's sloppy design. There are many other examples of this in Kindle. For example, if I press Yes in the dialog box above, here's what I see next: [Kindle] At least neither of the buttons are highlighted, but what does pressing WPS do? And why is it in the right-hand position, the place where Yes was in the previous dialog box? Does that mean WPS is the preferred choice? Why don't the buttons have boxes around them the way they did in the previous dialog? Why can this one be dismissed by tapping an X, but the other one could not? (I know, technically they are two different types of dialog boxes, but why change the basic interface elements common to both of them?) Oh, and here's what happens after you enter the password and hit Connect: [Kindle] Does the Kindle remember that I wanted to know about a particular book? No, it just dumps me back to the Home screen. I have to tap the book again to see a short description of it. I'm not sure yet if I want to buy it, so I'll cancel that and go back to home, and... [Kindle] Hey presto, the recommendations have updated and the book I was looking at disappeared. How do I get back to it now? Sigh. This brings me to what I think is the third problem: 3. Lack of systems thinking. Too often, the Kindle interface acts like a piece of software, rather than a seamless part of an integrated hardware-software experience. For example, since the device is designed to push new books at me on the home screen, and since we know that an ebook reader will often be used in places where there's poor or no wireless coverage (a beach, an airplane, etc), why aren't the descriptions of the promoted books cached on the device ahead of time? Why can't I decide to buy one now, and then have it downloaded later when I connect? (I know, that could create a different user satisfaction problem, but at least give me an option to put the book in the shopping cart to buy later, just like...oh, wait, just like the Amazon store normally works). Individually, these are all small problems, but there are many more of them, and they're irritating. I get the feeling that Amazon is just kind of mailing it in when it comes to Kindle. Maybe that's because Amazon famously operates in small, lean development teams that work like startups. That's a great way to move fast and learn in software, but when you're creating hardware-software systems it can lead to devices that are extremely adequate rather than wonderful. Don't get me wrong, I am a deep admirer of Amazon and I know the people there are super smart. But I wonder if their well-documented struggles in hardware might be partly a result of thinking of devices as a way to sell stuff rather than a way to delight customers. What do you think? PS: Probably one of Amazon's design challenges with Kindle is that it's awkward to do user tests with a device when you can't directly record its screen. If you can't test something, it's hard to optimize it. Here's a hint: Have testers use their smartphones to video themselves using your device. This is easy to set up with a testing system like UserTesting; you don't even need help from our pro services team. Ping me if you want the details. PPS: I'm curious to see which method of publishing gets more eyeballs, LinkedIn or my blog, so I posted this in both places. Let me know if that's irritating. Posted by Michael Mace at 5:20 PM Permalink. 3 comments. Click here to read post with comments. # 3 comments: Ben Combee said... Glad to see you posting again! Saturday, June 17, 2023 5:55:00 PM [icon_delet] Avi Greengart said... It's a competition issue -- there isn't any, so Amazon hasn't been forced to go back properly evaluate and refresh the Kindle UI. Amazon does go back and look at the Fire TV UX from time to time -- plenty of competition from Apple and Roku and Google there -- and there are all sorts of updates to Alexa -- to stay ahead of Google and Apple -- but the Kindle just gets new hardware that's good enough for a refresh cycle and Amazon can call it a day. Saturday, June 17, 2023 7:28:00 PM [icon_delet] Anonymous said... Thanks, Ben! It's nice to hear from you. Avi, I'm sure that's part of it. But they just did a pretty thorough interface refresh about a year ago, and you'd think they would have caught this stuff. --Mike Saturday, June 17, 2023 8:54:00 PM [icon_delet] Post a Comment Older Post Home Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom) About This Blog The walls between the web, wireless, entertainment, and computer industries are coming down. This weblog explores the opportunities that result. You may want to subscribe to the feed or e-mail service. My Book Map the Future is my book on how to create better business strategies. You can read all about it here. "I wish I'd had a guide like Map the Future when I started my career." Sidebar Contents * About Michael Mace * Recommended Posts * Recent Posts & Archive * Recent Comments * Suggestion Box * Search This Blog * Recommended Sites * Subscribe * Translation * Statistics * Most Popular Posts About Michael Mace I'm VP of product marketing at UserTesting. In ten years at Apple, my roles included Director of Worldwide Customer & Competitive Analysis and director of Mac Platform Marketing. At Palm I was Chief Competitive Officer and VP of Product Planning. For more info on me, visit my website. Note: The things I write here are my own opinions and do not represent the views of my employer(s). View my complete profile Recommended Posts Although most blog posts go out of date pretty quickly, I think some that I've written in the past are still relevant and worthy of your attention. Here are the ones I recommend: * The Big Picture: How Mobile, Personal Computing, Media, and the Internet All Fit Together * The Market(s) for Mobile Devices * The Shape of the Smartphone and Mobile Data Markets * Desperately Seeking the Info Pad * Will the Smartphone Kill the PC? * European vs. American Mobile Phone Use * The Mobile Platform Wars * Nokia, the Computer Company * Nokia Declares War on Apple * Hypenotized by Apple * Is Apple Too Powerful? * Adobe and Apple: Let's Get Real * What's Really Wrong With BlackBerry? * Who Killed Symbian? * The Rise of Web Apps * "Software as a Service" Misses the Point * Who's Really Using Web Apps, and Why * How Web Communities Work * The Web as an Apps Platform * The Web as a Medium for Creating New Media * Web 2.0 Doesn't Cut it for Mobile Devices * Operating Systems & Infrastructure * A Quick History of Software * It's the Ecosystem, Stupid * The Mobile Data Apocalypse * Mobile Applications, RIP * Content Distribution * Removing the Middleman * Removing the Middleman, Part 2: Music * Removing the Middleman, Part 3: Books * The Future of Publishing: Why Ebooks Failed in 2000 * And Also... * The Cluetrain Manifesto Revisited * Bring on the Singularity! * The Three Laws of Technology Strategy Recent Posts * V 2023 (1) + V June (1) o How does Amazon think about devices? * > 2020 (2) + > October (1) + > February (1) * > 2018 (2) + > June (1) + > March (1) * > 2017 (1) + > June (1) * > 2016 (2) + > December (2) * > 2014 (10) + > July (1) + > May (4) + > April (1) + > March (2) + > January (2) * > 2013 (11) + > December (1) + > September (1) + > July (1) + > June (2) + > May (1) + > April (2) + > March (3) * > 2012 (18) + > October (2) + > September (2) + > August (1) + > July (1) + > June (1) + > May (2) + > April (4) + > March (2) + > February (2) + > January (1) * > 2011 (29) + > December (1) + > November (1) + > September (2) + > August (7) + > June (5) + > May (1) + > April (4) + > February (7) + > January (1) * > 2010 (21) + > December (1) + > November (2) + > October (2) + > September (1) + > August (1) + > July (1) + > May (1) + > April (3) + > March (2) + > February (2) + > January (5) * > 2009 (22) + > November (3) + > October (1) + > September (1) + > August (2) + > July (1) + > June (2) + > May (1) + > April (5) + > March (1) + > February (1) + > January (4) * > 2008 (33) + > December (4) + > October (1) + > September (2) + > August (2) + > July (1) + > June (3) + > May (3) + > April (3) + > March (7) + > February (4) + > January (3) * > 2007 (61) + > November (8) + > October (1) + > September (5) + > August (4) + > July (4) + > June (2) + > May (4) + > April (5) + > March (10) + > February (6) + > January (12) * > 2006 (73) + > December (7) + > November (4) + > October (7) + > September (6) + > August (4) + > July (4) + > June (7) + > May (5) + > April (8) + > March (6) + > February (6) + > January (9) * > 2005 (22) + > December (9) + > November (6) + > October (7) Suggestion Box Click here to make a comment or suggestion about Mobile Opportunity. Search This Blog [ ] [Google Search] ( ) Web (*) This blog Recommended Sites * Tech-related sites: * Michael Gartenberg * Muni Wireless * The Register * Rough Type * What Japan Thinks * Community Group Therapy * DW2.0 * Asymco * Technologizer * Mobile sites: * Lifeblog * Telepocalypse * Wireless Watch Japan * Software Everywhere * Disruptive Wireless * Techype * Mobile commentary aggregators: * Carnival of the Mobilists * Wireless Watch Community Subscribe You can subscribe to Mobile Opportunity in several ways: Enter your email address here to subscribe by email (you'll receive a copy of each post): [ ] [Subscribe me!] Powered by FeedBlitz You can follow me on Twitter @michaelmace, where I announce new posts. Feeds: Subscribe to posts (Atom) Subscribe to all comments (Atom) [fbapix] You can also subscribe to the comments for individual posts. Just click "permalink" at the end of the post, scroll down to the bottom of the page that opens, and you'll find the link to subscribe. Translation Translation by Google: # # # # # # # # # Code by Digital Inspiration Statistics free stats visitors since January 2007. Counted by StatCounter. Locations of visitors to this page [MobileOppor] Quantcast Most Popular Posts * Fear and Loathing and Windows 8 (Or: Why Windows 8 Scares Me -- and Should Scare You Too) I was very excited when I saw the first demos of Windows 8. After years of sett... * What's really wrong with BlackBerry (and what to do about it) Just a couple of weeks after Research in Motion turned in a good earnings report, the death watch over the company has resumed, with Busines... * European vs. American mobile phone use In last week's post about Palm's phone plans, I made a passing comment about the right way to display your mobile phone at dinner i... * Windows 8: The Beginning of the End of Windows I have a longstanding rule for evaluating new tech products: Don't judge anything by the demo. I've seen far too many product previ... * Has Microsoft Gone Nuts? The rumors floating out of Microsoft these days are remarkable: --Microsoft's Nokia business is working on an Android phone, and Microsoft ... * The Real Meaning of the Fire Phone People have been asking my opinion of the new Amazon Fire Phone, but I've had a lot of trouble answering. My first reaction was overwhelming... * Google Logic: Why Google Does the Things it Does "What does Google want?" A favorite pastime among people who watch the tech industry is trying to figure out why Google does things. The V... * Amazon vs. Apple? No, it's Amazon and Apple vs. Everyone Else To me, there's something magnificent about a well-executed product strategy. Features and price and marketing all come together to deli... * Microsoft + Nokia: Now We're All Like Apple Ten years ago, everybody in the tech industry -- and I mean everybody -- was convinced that the best way to dominate a technology market was t... * Mobile applications, RIP Summary: The business of making native apps for mobile devices is dying, crushed by a fragmented market and restrictive business practices.... Advertisement Messages placed by Google: (c) 2005-2009 Michael Mace | Design by Mike Rohde | Powered by Blogger