https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/ptolemy-geocentrism-almagest-copernicus * * Trips [aoa_logo_a] Take your next trip with Atlas Obscura! Our small-group adventures are inspired by our Atlas of the world's most fascinating places, the stories behind them, and the people who bring them to life. Visit Adventures Trips Highlight A puffin along Vestmannaeyjar. Iceland * 10 days, 9 nights Iceland in Summer: Where Myths and Nature Collide from $5,990 USD [blank-f2c3] Italy * 9 days, 8 nights NEW -- Italian Food & Wine: Eating Regionally from $5,950 USD View all trips * Experiences Upcoming Experiences View All Experiences >> [blank-f2c3] Members only Gazing Into Totality: How to Prep for an Eclipse w/ Dr. Kate Russo [blank-f2c3] Hot Springs Atlas Obscura's Ecliptic Festival [blank-f2c3] Fort Myer The Spies of Arlington National Cemetery [blank-f2c3] Washington The Spies of Georgetown [blank-f2c3] Washington The Spies of Embassy Row * Courses Upcoming Courses View All Courses >> [blank-f2c3] Transforming Fairy Tales With Anca Szilagyi [blank-f2c3] Creating Crossword Puzzles With Brooke Husic & Natan Last [blank-f2c3] Playing Ancient Games: History & Mythology With John Bucher [blank-f2c3] How to Forge a Michelangelo: The History and Practice of Forgery With Noah Charney [blank-f2c3] Galactic Mythology: A Journey Through Stars & Stories With John Bucher * Places + Top Destinations + Latest Places + Most Popular Places + Random Place + Lists + Itineraries + ------------------------------------------------------------- Add a Place ------------------------------------------------------------- + Download the App Latest Places View All Places >> Order fresh fish by weight. Belem, Brazil Mercado Ver-o-Peso -1.4525, -48.5037 [blank-f2c3] Jacksonville, Florida Grave of Laura Adorkor Kofi 30.3329, -81.6492 Frontal view of the head of the goddess Bath, England Head of Sulis Minerva 51.3811, -2.3596 Joan of Arc in Meridian Hill Park Washington, D.C. Joan of Arc Equestrian Statue 38.9207, -77.0357 Top Destinations View All Destinations >> Countries + Australia + Canada + China + France + Germany + India + Italy + Japan Cities + Amsterdam + Barcelona + Beijing + Berlin + Boston + Budapest + Chicago + London + Los Angeles + Mexico City + Montreal + Moscow + New Orleans + New York City + Paris + Philadelphia + Rome + San Francisco + Seattle + Stockholm + Tokyo + Toronto + Vienna + Washington, D.C. * Foods Latest Places to Eat & Drink View All Places to Eat >> Order fresh fish by weight. Mercado Ver-o-Peso The apple weighs more than 1,000 pounds. The Big Apple of New England Yo quiero Taco Bell. Miniature Taco Bell This chocolatier is one of the oldest in the United States. The Hebert Candy Mansion Prosecco makes for a lighter twist on a Negroni. Bar Basso * Stories + Recent Stories + All Stories + Puzzles + Video + Podcast Most Recent Stories View All Stories >> [blank-f2c3] New York City and London Could Have Looked Very Different Butterfingers Binding's latest project is a collaboration between three or four makers, and a gift for a friend. It is mostly made form reclaimed materials. The Emerging Art of 'Fanbinding' Norval Morrisseau's Migration (1973), at the Royal Ontario Museum in Toronto, Canada. Wonder Is Everywhere: Ancient Lipstick, Darwin's Library, and More From Around the Web Hogarth's "O the Roast Beef of Old England (The Gate of Calais)" captured his sentiments as a society member. A Rare Look Inside Britain's 'Sublime Society of Beefsteaks' * Newsletters * Sign In Join * Explore Newsletters * Sign In ----------------------------------------------------------------- Join * Places near me Random place How One of Science's Biggest Errors Persisted for 1,500 Years Ptolemy's compendium, later known as the Almagest, dominated Western astronomy for 15 centuries. It was also wrong, and it took the fall of an empire to fix it. by Rebecca Boyle February 28, 2024 How One of Science's Biggest Errors Persisted for 1,500 Years Copy Link Facebook Twitter Reddit Flipboard Pocket Illustration: Carmen Deno for Atlas Obscura Illustration: Carmen Deno for Atlas Obscura [bF9uZXcucG] Columns See More [blank-f2c3] A basic understanding of the solar system is something we take for granted today, but Western science had things wrong for some 1,500 years. Blame the Moon, and blame a man named Claudius Ptolemy. Around the year 150, the Roman Alexandrian scholar wrote a massive compendium of ancient math later (and famously) called the Almagest. It was a stunning achievement, and laid the mathematical foundations for an Earth-centric universe. It also set everyone from Constantinople to Krakow on the wrong path. Sorting it all out took the fall of the Byzantine Empire, a refugee scholar, an overzealous translator, and a detail-oriented Pole named Copernicus. The journey through history, math, and physics is convoluted, but worth it, so buckle in for the tale of one of science's oldest and biggest errors. First, consider an obvious fact: The Moon goes around the Earth. Watch as the Moon cycles through a month, and you can tell that it is lit by the Sun, and that its appearance changes as it goes around our world. This could be one reason why humanity believed in geocentrism in the first place. If it's clear that the Moon revolves around Earth, then it's logical to imagine that everything else does, too. Why would the universe be arranged in any other way? Moreover, how would solar eclipses work, if the Sun and the Moon didn't follow a similar path around our planet? Most people throughout antiquity were certain the Sun orbited the Earth. It made sense, and that was that. Claudius Ptolemy was the first person to come up with complicated physics that could explain just how this arrangement would work. With the great library of Alexandria at his disposal, he distilled the collected knowledge of Greece, Egypt, Babylon, and Rome into a treatise full of numerical tables, data sets, and his own interpretations. He called it Mathematical Arrangement. The name Almagest comes from an Arabic translation calling it "the greatest compilation." Using astronomical records, Ptolemy invented a scheme for how the Sun, the other planets, and the Moon could all orbit the Earth. It involved epicycles, which are convoluted circles-within-circles. A copy of a 15th-century chart, attributed to Regiomontanus, to plot the movement of the Moon using a string attached to the chart's center.A copy of a 15th-century chart, attributed to Regiomontanus, to plot the movement of the Moon using a string attached to the chart's center. Public Domain However, our Moon didn't quite fit his model. Ptolemy suggested that its orbital path must be tilted with respect to the other heavenly bodies, but problems remained. His math suggests that the Moon's size would change dramatically throughout the month. Like epicycles themselves, this is not a thing. Yet Ptolemy's complicated, bizarre system stood for 15 centuries as the textbook for cosmology because it seemed to work, or at least work well enough. Ptolemy wrote in Greek, but centuries after he published it, Almagest was translated into Arabic. Some Islamic Arab scholars openly doubted Ptolemy's conclusions, but no one really challenged his complex mathematical proofs, and people in the Western, Christian world were mostly comfortable believing that we humans were the center of the universe. Around the middle of the 12th century, a scholar working in the Arab court of Toledo produced the first Arabic-to-Latin translation of Almagest. His name was Gerard of Cremona, and he remains one of the world's most important translators of ancient texts. According to a 2023 paper published in the Journal for the History of Astronomy, Gerard may have tried to fix some of Ptolemy's math. In doing so, it appears that he helped perpetuate antiquity's grand error--that the Sun orbits the Earth--at least for a few more centuries. The paper's author, Stefan Zieme of Humboldt University in Berlin, examined some texts Gerard used for his translations, and found that some of the numbers weren't matching up among the Latin, Greek, and Arabic versions. The corrections were both minor and major, and ranged from declination values, which describe the positions of stars and planets in the sky, to rising times, vital for casting accurate horoscopes. Gerard's attempted corrections may have made it easier for readers to accept Ptolemy's unusual, obtuse, and occasionally mismatched numbers. Perhaps this made it even easier to accept geocentrism, too. Gerard's translation made the rounds in Europe during the medieval period, and was copied multiple times. Then came the fall of Constantinople, and the beginning of the end for Ptolemy's convoluted Earth-centric cosmology. An illustration of Ptolemy and Regiomontanus from the frontispiece of a 15th-century edition of Epitome of the Almagest.An illustration of Ptolemy and Regiomontanus from the frontispiece of a 15th-century edition of Epitome of the Almagest. Public Domain After the invading Turkish Army took Constantinople in May 1453, the Greek-speaking world drained out of the remains of the Byzantine Empire. Refugee scholars salvaged their texts and translations of works from antiquity. In 1460, one of these men, a cardinal named Basilios Bessarion, arrived in Vienna, carrying a copy of Ptolemy's Mathematical Arrangement in the original Greek. In Vienna, Bessarion met a scholar named Regiomontanus, who produced a fresh Latin translation of Ptolemy's seminal work to be used for teaching. It was the first edition produced on a printing press. Like many students' textbooks, this new version, called the Epitome of the Almagest, included a reader's guide with interpretations from the translators. Central among the critiques that Regiomontanus included in the guide: Ptolemy was wrong about the Moon. In 1491, a university student named Nicolaus Copernicus read a copy of the Epitome of the Almagest and also doubted some of Ptolemy's elaborate explanations. You probably know what happened next. Copernicus measured eclipses and relied on observations of our satellite to develop his new, accurate worldview: The Moon orbits Earth, yes, but Earth orbits the Sun, and so do all the other planets. Copernicus, Regiomontanus, and Ptolemy himself would have looked forward to April's total solar eclipse with great interest. To see the Moon cross in front of our star, blocking all but its outer atmosphere, is one of the most unusual, terrifying, beautiful experiences we can have on this planet. And it is a wondrous way to witness, and to study, the movement of the heavenly bodies. We now know that the Moon blocks the Sun during total eclipses because of an astonishing cosmic coincidence, no epicycles needed. Thanks to a mathematical fluke, the much larger but much more distant Sun appears to be the same size in the sky as the Moon, and the two bodies seem to cross paths overhead now and then. This random accident of geometry never ceases to astound me. It's almost enough to make me reach for Ptolemy, seeking a mathematically grounded arrangement, one designed by providence, even, and not just by chance. Wondersky columnist Rebecca Boyle is the author of Our Moon: How Earth's Celestial Companion Transformed the Planet, Guided Evolution, and Made Us Who We Are (January 2024, Random House). She is a featured speaker at Atlas Obscura's Ecliptic Festival, April 5-8, 2024, in Hot Springs, Ark. Next in series How to See Where Lunar X Marks the Spot on a First Quarter Moon Many of us see a face or a rabbit in the Moon--examples of pareidolia that, when conditions are right, also include the letters X and V. [blank-f2c3] wonderskysunstargazingsolar systemmoonmathematicsphysicsastronomy columnshistory Want to see fewer ads? Become a Member. Want to see fewer ads? Become a Member. Using an ad blocker? We depend on ad revenue to craft and curate stories about the world's hidden wonders. Consider supporting our work by becoming a member for as little as $5 a month. Continue Using Ad-Block Support Us Keep Exploring The Tomnaverie Stone Circle is a dramatic megalithic monument devoted to the Moon. A large recumbent stone, arranged between two smaller, upright stones, is visible just to the left of the image's center. megalithic Scotland's Ancient Stone Circles Mark Our Deep Connection to the Moon Unlike Sun-focused Stonehenge and other megalithic monuments, Tomnaverie and similar stone circles hint at the Moon's importance to ancient people. Rebecca Boyle January 17, 2024 An annular eclipse over the northern Chinese city of Jinan in 2010. astronomy During an Annular Eclipse, Look to the Shadows While some people in the Western Hemisphere will witness a "ring of fire" during the eclipse, many more will experience the phenomenon of crescent sunlight. Rebecca Boyle October 11, 2023 A illustration imagines the aftermath of Earth's collision with Theia, and how the material ejected by it slowly began to reform into an orbital body. science Theia and the Collision That Gave Birth to the Moon Evidence deep within the planet suggests that remnants of Earth's catastrophic twin might still lie below. Robin George Andrews December 4, 2023 Science has not fully explained why we perceive the Moon to be so much larger than it actually is when it's near the horizon. astronomy Is It a Super Blue Moon or a Blue Supermoon? Whatever you call it, this week's full moon is particularly rare--we won't see one again until 2037. Rebecca Boyle August 28, 2023 [ZW5TVElMTC] Video * PinDrop A 30-Acre Garden Inspired by the Principles of Modern Physics 1:32 [V29uZGVyLm] Video All Roads Lead to Texas: Big Wonder 05:24 Sponsored by Travel Texas [aWlTdGlsbC] Video * AO Docs Hawai`i's Native-Language Newspaper Archive 3:35 Sponsored by Olukai [cmNoMDIuan] Video * AO Docs 'Discovering' Mexico's Monarch Butterfly Migration 6:46 [dXJlcyAwMy] Video * Object of Intrigue The Real Story Behind George Washington's Dentures 3:30 [anBn] Video * Object of Intrigue Behold, the Vampire-Killing Kit 4:19 [cGc] Video See the Mysterious Horned Helmet of Henry VIII 4:00 [LmpwZw] Video All Roads Lead to Texas: Sounds of the Lonestar State 0:00 Sponsored by Travel Texas [LmpwZw] Video * Let Your Florida Adventure Begin Atlas Obscura Tries: Tarpon Fishing 0:00 Sponsored by VISIT FLORIDA [dC1zdGlsbC] Video In Maine, the Art of Basketry Hangs On By a Thread 5:22 Sponsored by Maine Office of Tourism Want to see fewer ads? Become a Member. From Around the Web ATLAS OBSCURA COURSES Learn with Us! Check out our lineup of courses taught by world-class experts from around the world. See Courses Gastro Obscura Book See Fewer Ads Become an Atlas Obscura member and experience far fewer ads and no pop-ups. Learn More Get Our Email Newsletter [ ] Thanks for subscribing! View all newsletters >> [Submit] Follow Us * * * * * * Get the app Download on the Apple App Store Get it on Google Play Download the App Places * All Places * Latest Places * Most Popular * Places to Eat * Random * Nearby * Add a Place Editorial * Stories * Food & Drink * Itineraries * Lists * Puzzles * Video * Podcast * Newsletters Trips * All Trips * Trips Blog * Art & Culture Trips * Food Trips * Hidden City Trips * History Trips * Wildlife & Nature Trips * FAQ Experiences * Experiences * Online Courses * Online Experience FAQ * Online Course FAQ * Eclipse Festival 2024 Community * Membership * Feedback & Ideas * Community Guidelines * Product Blog * Unique Gifts * Work With Us Company * About * Contact Us * FAQ * Invest In Us * Advertise With Us * Advertising Guidelines * Press * Privacy Policy * Cookie Policy * Terms of Use (c) 2024 Atlas Obscura. All rights reserved. Questions or Feedback? Contact Us Thanks for sharing! Follow us on Twitter to get the latest on the world's hidden wonders. Like us on Facebook to get the latest on the world's hidden wonders. Follow us on Twitter Like us on Facebook Want a Free Book? Sign up for our newsletter and enter to win the second edition of our book, Atlas Obscura: An Explorer's Guide to the World's Hidden Wonders. [ ] Subscribe No Thanks Visit AtlasObscura.com Atlas Obscura: An Explorer's Guide to the World's Hidden Wonders Stay in Touch! Follow us on social media to add even more wonder to your day. Follow us on Twitter Like us on Facebook Follow Us on Instagram No Thanks Visit AtlasObscura.com No purchase necessary. Winner will be selected at random on 04/01/ 2024. Offer available only in the U.S. (including Puerto Rico). Offer subject to change without notice. See contest rules for full details. Add Some Wonder to Your Inbox Every weekday we compile our most wondrous stories and deliver them straight to you. [ ] Subscribe No Thanks We'd Like You to Like Us Like Atlas Obscura and get our latest and greatest stories in your Facebook feed. No Thanks [p] Quantcast **