https://mashable.com/article/x-twitter-elon-musk-bots-fake-traffic Tech Science Life Social Good Entertainment Deals Shopping Travel [ ] Search Cancel * * Search Result ----------------------------------------------------------------- Tech Apps & Software Artificial Intelligence Cybersecurity Cryptocurrency Mobile Smart Home Social Media Tech Industry Transportation All Tech Science Space Climate Change Environment Video All Science Life Digital Culture Family & Parenting Health & Wellness Sex, Dating & Relationships Sleep Careers Mental Health All Life Social Good Activism Gender LGBTQ Racial Justice Sustainability Politics All Social Good Entertainment Games Movies Podcasts TV Shows Video Reviews Watch Guides All Entertainment SHOP THE BEST Home Tech Kitchen Fitness Sex Toys Apps & Software Dating Gift Guides Mashable Choice Mashable Selects Gaming All Best Products Travel Deals Best of All Travel Product Reviews Tech Life Beauty Tech Kitchen Kids/Toys Gaming Fitness Sex Toys Apps & Software All Product Reviews DEALS Home Tech TV Laptop VPN Vacuum Gaming Streaming Apple Mashable Shop All Deals Newsletters VIDEOS Mashable Shows All Videos Home > Tech The majority of traffic from Elon Musk's X may have been fake during the Super Bowl, report suggests These numbers are legitimately shocking. By Matt Binder on February 16, 2024 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Flipboard Elon Musk New data shows that X has a bot problem unlike any other. Credit: Beata Zawrzel/NurPhoto via Getty Images --------------------------------------------------------------------- This week, Super Bowl 2024 shattered records, with the NFL championship broadcast on CBS becoming the most-watched televised event in U.S. history. Also riding high from the big game? Elon Musk's X. The company formerly known as Twitter published its own press release, lauding Super Bowl LVIII as one of the biggest events ever on the social media platform with more than 10 billion impressions and over 1 billion video views. Tweet may have been deleted However, it appears that a significant portion of that traffic on X could be fake, according to data provided to Mashable by CHEQ, a leading cybersecurity firm that tracks bots and fake users. According to CHEQ, a whopping 75.85 percent of traffic from X to its advertising clients' websites during the weekend of the Super Bowl was fake. SEE ALSO: Elon Musk's X comes out in favor of pro-censorship law "I've never seen anything even remotely close to 50 percent, not to mention 76 percent," CHEQ founder and CEO Guy Tytunovich told Mashable regarding X's fake traffic data. "I'm amazed...I've never, ever, ever, ever seen anything even remotely close." CHEQ's data for this report is based on 144,000 visits to its clients' sites that came from X during Super Bowl weekend, from Friday, Feb. 9 up until the end of Super Bowl Sunday on Feb. 11. The data was collected from across CHEQ's 15,000 total clients. It's a small portion of the relevant data, and it's not scientifically sampled, but it nonetheless suggests a dramatic trend. CHEQ monitors bots and fake users across the internet in order to minimize online ad fraud for its clients. Tytunovich's company accomplishes this by tracking how visitors from different sources, such as X, interact with a client's page after they click one of their links. The company can also tell when a bot is passing itself off as a real user, such as when a fraudulent user is faking what type of operating system they are using to view a website. Most X users who are regularly on the platform can attest to a noticeable uptick in seemingly inauthentic activity in recent months. When a post goes viral on X, its now commonplace to find bots filling the replies with AI-generated responses or accounts with randomly generated usernames spamming a user's mentions with unsolicited "link-in-bio" promotions. Now, there's data which backs up that user experience. Advertisers have also noticed X's bot issues. In a recently published piece in The Guardian, Gene Marks, a small business owner shared his ad campaign results from X. After a small $50 advertising spend, X's analytics shows that his website had received 350 clicks from approximately 29,000 views. However, according to Google Analytics, X wasn't the source of any of the actual traffic his website had received during that time period. In our conversation with Tytunovich, he referenced an often cited stat that roughly half of all internet traffic is made up of bots, and how he's long been skeptical of that data based on what CHEQ itself sees. "We were always the conservative ones," Tytunovich explained regarding CHEQ's approach to fake user data. "We protect a lot of our customers on Google Ads, YouTube, and even TikTok, which I'm not a fan of, and we've always said 50 percent [being fake] is a bit opportunistic." "I almost decided not to go out [and publish the X bot data] because we've never seen anything like it," he said. X has a bot problem unlike anything else seen on competing platforms When X's Super Bowl traffic is compared to other social media platforms during the same time period, the bot issue on Musk's platform appears even more stark. CHEQ also provided data to Mashable pertaining to Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok. In terms of fake traffic, no other platform came close to X's nearly 76 percent. Out of more than 40 million visits from TikTok, only 2.56 percent were determined to be fake. Facebook sent 8.1 million visits and 2.01 percent of the monitored visits were classified as inauthentic. And over on Instagram, only 0.73 percent of the 68,700 visits from the platform were fake. Tytunovich tells Mashable that it's not out of the ordinary to see spikes in fake traffic on social media platforms during big events like U.S. elections. However, he has never seen anything close to X's 75.85 percent. And, unfortunately for X, its bot problem goes beyond the big game too. CHEQ also provided Mashable with fake traffic data from the entire month of January 2024. TikTok, Facebook, and Instagram all had very similar stats to each platform's respective Super Bowl weekend numbers. Slightly more than 2.8 percent of the 306 million visits sent from TikTok were determined to be fake. Out of the 90 million visits that came from Facebook, a bit more than 2 percent were fake. And Instagram's traffic was only 0.96 percent fake, based on 749,000 visits. But, X once again fared the worst. Of the 759,000 visits from X, 31.82 percent of that traffic was determined to be fake. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Related Stories --------------------------------------------------------------------- * Elon Musk tells Twitter/X advertisers to 'f**k yourself,' but admits it will die without them * Why you'll see even less political content on Instagram and Threads * TikTok quietly kills hashtag view count feature * 200,000 Facebook Marketplace user records were leaked on the dark web * Snapchat's My AI chatbot posted a Story then stopped responding. Users freaked out. Tytunovich, who has met with Musk previously and pushed the X owner to address the bot problem, stressed to Mashable that his company cannot tell how many fake users are on social media platforms themselves. The data only details how many bots came to CHEQ's clients' sites from those platforms. However, as Tytunovich explained, his company has a wide range of clients, including large, Fortune 500 companies, and this fake activity coming from X was seen across the board regardless of industry or market. Mashable reached out to X for information or a statement but received an automated message from the company reading "Busy now, please check back later." An Elon Musk problem X didn't always have a bot problem of this magnitude, according to CHEQ, something Tytunovich demonstrated by providing Mashable with data from last year's Super Bowl. During the comparable weekend in February 2023, fake traffic from the platform then-known as Twitter only accounted for 2.81 percent out of 159,000 visits. That's around 72 percent less than this year's game. Last year's Super Bowl occurred just a few months after Elon Musk acquired the platform in late October of 2022. And a lot has changed on X between last February and today under Musk's leadership. The platform was still known as Twitter then. Notable users still had their legacy verified blue checkmarks. Only around 200,000 to 300,000 users were subscribed to Twitter Blue, which is now called X Premium. X's creator monetization program, where paying X Premium subscribers can make money off of ads displaying on their content, did not yet exist. All of these changes can factor into X's current bot problem. In addition, since Musk's take over, 80 percent of the company's Trust and Safety team's engineers have been laid off, along with half of the company's content moderators. Thousands of employees have been laid off across the company. X has struggled with advertisers since Musk's takeover. Big brands and major companies like Disney have suspended ad campaigns on the platform due to hate speech and pro-Nazi content proliferating on X, as well as antisemitic comments made by Musk himself. According to a Bloomberg report last month, X is planning to open a Trust and Safety center in Austin, Texas and is hiring 100 employees to work in that department in order to address some of advertisers' concerns. But, X's problems clearly go well beyond the type of content being posted by real human beings. Advertisers typically pay social media companies based on impressions and/or clicks on their advertisements. And based on this traffic data, advertisers could potentially be paying Musk and company for visits from an audience consisting mostly of bots. Topics Cybersecurity Social Media Super Bowl Twitter Elon Musk --------------------------------------------------------------------- Recommended For You Disney+ is now restricting password sharing in the U.S. Fun's over. 02/07/2024 By Alex Perry Disney Plus logo on phone screen Disney Plus logo on phone screen --------------------------------------------------------------------- How to watch Northern Illinois vs. Arkansas State football without cable Watch the Huskies take on the Red Wolves in the 2023 Camellia Bowl. 12/22/2023 By Erik Hall An Arkansas State player runs downfield. An Arkansas State player runs downfield. --------------------------------------------------------------------- A24's moving 'Tuesday' trailer sees Julia Louis-Dreyfus confronting death If the trailer is this emotional, we're done for in the film. 01/25/2024 By Shannon Connellan A woman in a field A woman in a field --------------------------------------------------------------------- Meet the 'cursed family' behind pro-wrestling biopic 'The Iron Claw' "He could have been Vince McMahon." 12/22/2023 By Emmett Smith Zac Efron, Jeremy Allen White, and Stanley Simmons of 'The Iron Claw' Zac Efron, Jeremy Allen White, and Stanley Simmons of 'The Iron Claw' --------------------------------------------------------------------- CES 2024: AI wearable uses 'good vibes' to cure my social anxiety But I'm not sold on its other claims. 01/10/2024 By Kimberly Gedeon Apollo Neuro Apollo Neuro --------------------------------------------------------------------- Trending on Mashable NYT Connections today: See hints and answers for February 16 Everything you need to solve 'Connections' #250. 20 hours ago By Mashable Team A phone displaying the New York Times game 'Connections.' A phone displaying the New York Times game 'Connections.' --------------------------------------------------------------------- How to try Sora, OpenAI's AI video generator Most of us will have to wait. 02/15/2024 By Cecily Mauran OpenAI logo on a smartphone OpenAI logo on a smartphone --------------------------------------------------------------------- Wordle today: Here's the answer and hints for February 16 Here are some tips and tricks to help you find the answer to "Wordle" #972. 19 hours ago By Mashable Team a phone displaying Wordle a phone displaying Wordle --------------------------------------------------------------------- NYT Connections today: See hints and answers for February 15 Everything you need to solve 'Connections' #249. 02/15/2024 By Mashable Team A phone displaying the New York Times game 'Connections.' A phone displaying the New York Times game 'Connections.' --------------------------------------------------------------------- OpenAI announces Sora, a wild AI text-to-video model. See it in action. Welcome to the AI video era. 02/15/2024 By Cecily Mauran OpenAI logo on a smartphone against a gray backdrop OpenAI logo on a smartphone against a gray backdrop The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox. [ ] Loading... Subscribe This newsletter may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. Subscribing to a newsletter indicates your consent to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe from the newsletters at any time. Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox! * TECH * SCIENCE * LIFE * SOCIAL GOOD * ENTERTAINMENT * BEST PRODUCTS * DEALS * About Mashable * Contact Us * We're Hiring * Newsletters * Sitemap * * * * * * * * * Group Black Mashable supports Group Black and its mission to increase greater diversity in media voices and media ownership. Group Black's collective includes Essence, TheShadeRoom and Afro-Punk. (c)2005-2024 Mashable, Inc., a Ziff Davis company. All Rights Reserved. Mashable is a registered trademark of Ziff Davis and may not be used by third parties without express written permission. * About Ziff Davis * Privacy Policy * Terms of Use * Advertise * Accessibility * Do Not Sell My Personal Information * * ZiffDavis AdChoicesAdChoices