https://www.cnn.com/2024/02/14/tech/billions-in-ai-patents-get-new-regulations/index.html CNN values your feedback 1. How relevant is this ad to you? ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) 2. Did you encounter any technical issues? [ ] Video player was slow to load content [ ] Video content never loaded [ ] Ad froze or did not finish loading [ ] Video content did not start after ad [ ] Audio on ad was too loud [ ] Other issues [ ] Ad never loaded [ ] Ad prevented/slowed the page from loading [ ] Content moved around while ad loaded [ ] Ad was repetitive to ads I've seen previously [ ] Other issues [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] Cancel Submit Thank You! Your effort and contribution in providing this feedback is much appreciated. Close Ad Feedback Markets Tech Media Calculators Videos More Markets Tech Media Calculators Videos Audio Live TV Log In My Account * Settings * Topics You Follow * Log Out Your CNN account Log in to your CNN account [ ] Search Log In My Account * Settings * Topics You Follow * Log Out Your CNN account Log in to your CNN account --------------------------------------------------------------------- Live TV Audio Edition US International Arabic Espanol Edition * US * International * Arabic * Espanol --------------------------------------------------------------------- Markets Tech Media Calculators Videos Follow CNN Business * * * --------------------------------------------------------------------- * US + Crime + Justice + Energy + Environment + Extreme Weather + Space + Science * World + Africa + Americas + Asia + Australia + China + Europe + India + Middle East + United Kingdom * Politics + SCOTUS + Congress + Facts First + 2024 Elections * Business + Tech + Media + Calculators + Video * Markets + Pre-markets + After-Hours + Market Movers + Fear & Greed + World Markets + Investing + Markets Now + Before the Bell + Nightcap * Opinion + Political Op-Eds + Social Commentary * Health + Life, But Better + Fitness + Food + Sleep + Mindfulness + Relationships * Entertainment + Movies + Television + Celebrity * Tech + Innovate + Gadget + Foreseeable Future + Mission: Ahead + Upstarts + Work Transformed + Innovative Cities * Style + Arts + Design + Fashion + Architecture + Luxury + Beauty + Video * Travel + Destinations + Food & Drink + Stay + Videos * Sports + Pro Football + College Football + Basketball + Baseball + Soccer + Olympics + Hockey * Watch + Live TV + CNN Headlines + CNN Max + Digital Studios + CNN Films + HLN + TV Schedule + TV Shows A-Z + CNNVR * Listen * CNN Underscored + Electronics + Fashion + Beauty + Health & Fitness + Home + Reviews + Deals + Money + Gifts + Travel + Outdoors + Pets + CNN Store * Coupons * Weather + Climate + Storm Tracker + Wildfire Tracker + Video * About CNN + Photos + Investigations + CNN Profiles + CNN Leadership + CNN Newsletters + Work for CNN Markets DOW S&P 500 NASDAQ Hot Stocks Fear & Greed Index ----- is driving the US market Latest Market News Delta paying $1.4 billion in profit sharing payments to employees 1 in 3 Republicans believes baseless Taylor Swift election conspiracy theory, poll finds Shipping CEO Angela Chao, sister of former Cabinet member Elaine Chao, dies in car crash Hot Stocks ----- is driving the US market Something isn't loading properly. Please check back later. Ad Feedback Ad Feedback Business / Tech Only real people can patent inventions -- not AI -- US government says Brian Fung By Brian Fung, CNN 4 minute read Updated 10:20 AM EST, Wed February 14, 2024 Link Copied! Follow: AI See all topics GettyImages-1476979127.jpg skynesher/E+/Getty Images CNN -- Artificial intelligence promises to supercharge scientific research and entrepreneurial innovation, helping researchers and inventors make new discoveries and creations. But how will patent protections apply to inventions made with the help of AI tools, particularly generative AI? For the first time, the US government has provided an answer, one that will shape how everyone from large businesses to home tinkerers alike can apply for intellectual property protections. The decision could influence the future of billions of dollars in investments and subtly guide how artificial intelligence is marketed and used. On Tuesday, the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) said that to obtain a patent, a real person must have made a "significant contribution" to the invention and that only a human being can be named as an inventor on a patent. The official guidance published this week provides a boost to innovators by reassuring them that their inventions involving AI can be patented, while continuing to enshrine human creativity and ingenuity by establishing basic expectations about how AI could make or break a patent application. The guidelines reflect the Biden administration's swift moves to get ahead of artificial intelligence issues. In a sweeping executive order last fall, the White House had directed the USPTO to issue its inventorship guidelines by the end of February. Precisely what constitutes a "significant contribution" is a little bit fuzzy and case-specific, and much of how the guidelines work will necessarily be figured out in real-time as they are applied and, perhaps in some situations, debated in court. "The challenge will be in implementing the guidance," said Jamie Nafziger, an attorney at the law firm Dorsey & Whitney. "How sophisticated of a prompt will be required for a given invention? In connection with training an AI system, what level of planning will be required? Patent examiners will surely have some interesting challenges ahead." Still, the overall picture the USPTO has painted is one where real people continue to sit at the center of the US patent system, in what experts describe as a logical extension of the status quo. How inventors can still patent AI-assisted creations The USPTO has provided some hypothetical examples of ways that its guidelines could work. For instance, an inventor who simply asks an AI chatbot to design a critical part for a remote-control car would not be eligible for a patent on the car, because he or she didn't make enough of a contribution to the car's invention. It was the AI that did the hard part, not the human. "A natural person who only presents a problem to an AI system may not be a proper inventor" of something, the USPTO said. "However, a significant contribution could be shown by the way the person constructs the prompt in view of a specific problem to elicit a particular solution from the AI system." If an inventor could show the work he or she did to get the AI chatbot to produce a specific design that enabled the remote-control car to function, then that could open the door to a patent, according to the USPTO. The USPTO guidance builds on existing case law. A federal appeals court already held last year, in a case known as Thaler v. Vidal, that only actual people can be listed as inventors on US patents, effectively ruling out the possibility for AI to be named as an inventor or co-inventor. In that case, the USPTO had rejected the patent applications of an inventor who had given his AI system sole credit for the inventions. A man walks through the public search facility at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) headquarters in Alexandria, Virginia, U.S., on Friday, April 4, 2014. A man walks through the public search facility at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) headquarters in Alexandria, Virginia, U.S., on Friday, April 4, 2014. Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg/Getty Images The inventorship guidelines will help everyone understand the boundaries of patent protections as AI is increasingly used in the inventive process. That may resolve some of the uncertainties that could otherwise slow the development and use of AI, said Randy McCarthy, an attorney at the law firm Hall Estill. It's also consistent with how the US Copyright Office is approaching copyright protections in relation to AI, McCarthy added. "Some sort of human agency is required, or no protection is available," he said. "A practical result is that, when creating a new design, artwork, invention, novel, or even computer code, a human can use an AI-based system to assist in the creation of this content, but must make sure that they are sufficiently involved in the process." At the same time, the USPTO guidelines don't require inventors to disclose the use of AI, and some worry it could encourage so-called patent trolls to apply for broad patents that don't lead to any actual creations but serve as the foundation for bogus patent lawsuits. "The economy already is harmed by a surplus of low-quality patents which leads to unproductive litigation, rent-seeking and transfers of wealth from productive businesses to those who are experts at navigating the legal system," said John Bergmayer, legal director at the consumer advocacy group Public Knowledge. "My worry would be that AI-assisted "inventions" [where the involvement of AI might be concealed] or just AI-assisted patent applications supercharges this." Related Ad Feedback More from CNN Business Starlink satellite antennas are seen at the Internationale Funkausstellung (IFA), the international trade show for consumer electronics and home appliances, on August 31, 2023 during a preview at the fair grounds in Berlin. Starlink is a satellite internet provider operated by Elon Musk's American aerospace company SpaceX. Odd Andersen/AFP/Getty Images Elon Musk's Starlink internet service is coming to a Gaza hospital Feb 14, 2024 A Waymo car drives along a street on March 01, 2023 in San Francisco, California. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images/FILE Waymo recalls software after two self-driving cars hit the same truck Feb 14, 2024 Ad Feedback CNN Business Videos SYMBOL - 30 January 2023, Baden-Wurttemberg, Rottweil: Dating apps can be seen on the display of an iPhone SE. Photo: Silas Stein/dpa (Photo by Silas Stein/picture alliance via Getty Images) Silas Stein/dpa/picture alliance/Getty Images People are tired of dating apps. Here's what they're doing instead 1:50 Feb 14, 2024 exp inflation report cpi january us vause foroohar intv 02141aseg2 cnni business_00003001.png Inflation has cooled in U.S., but less than expected 2:41 Feb 14, 2024 A woman reading the label on a food item while out shopping for groceries in her local supermarket. Tom Werner/Digital Vision/Getty Images Lower prices may sound nice, but they're a bad sign for the economy. Here's why 2:18 Feb 13, 2024 exp markets inflation Fed Interest Rates intv 021303PSEG1 cnni business_00020418.png Invesco Chief Strategist: Important not to overreact to U.S. CPI 2:11 Feb 13, 2024 Ad Feedback Ad Feedback [ ] Search Log In My Account * Settings * Topics You Follow * Log Out Your CNN account Log in to your CNN account --------------------------------------------------------------------- Live TV Listen Watch --------------------------------------------------------------------- * US + Crime + Justice + Energy + Environment + Extreme Weather + Space + Science * World + Africa + Americas + Asia + Australia + China + Europe + India + Middle East + United Kingdom * Politics + SCOTUS + Congress + Facts First + 2024 Elections * Business + Tech + Media + Calculators + Videos * Markets + Pre-markets + After-Hours + Market Movers + Fear & Greed + World Markets + Investing + Markets Now + Before the Bell + Nightcap * Opinion + Political Op-Eds + Social Commentary * Health + Life, But Better + Fitness + Food + Sleep + Mindfulness + Relationships * Entertainment + Movies + Television + Celebrity * Tech + Innovate + Gadget + Foreseeable Future + Mission: Ahead + Upstarts + Work Transformed + Innovative Cities * Style + Arts + Design + Fashion + Architecture + Luxury + Beauty + Video * Travel + Destinations + Food & Drink + Stay + News + Videos * Sports + Pro Football + College Football + Basketball + Baseball + Soccer + Olympics + Hockey * Watch + Live TV + CNN Headlines + CNN Max + Digital Studios + CNN Films + HLN + TV Schedule + TV Shows A-Z + CNNVR * Listen * CNN Underscored + Electronics + Fashion + Beauty + Health & Fitness + Home + Reviews + Deals + Money + Gifts + Travel + Outdoors + Pets + CNN Store * Coupons * Weather + Climate + Storm Tracker + Wildfire Tracker + Video * About CNN + Photos + Investigations + CNN Profiles + CNN Leadership + CNN Newsletters + Work for CNN --------------------------------------------------------------------- Watch Listen Live TV Follow CNN Business * * * * Log In My Account * Settings * Topics You Follow * Log Out Your CNN account Log in to your CNN account --------------------------------------------------------------------- Most stock quote data provided by BATS. US market indices are shown in real time, except for the S&P 500 which is refreshed every two minutes. All times are ET. Factset: FactSet Research Systems Inc. All rights reserved. Chicago Mercantile: Certain market data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved. Dow Jones: The Dow Jones branded indices are proprietary to and are calculated, distributed and marketed by DJI Opco, a subsidiary of S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC and have been licensed for use to S&P Opco, LLC and CNN. Standard & Poor's and S&P are registered trademarks of Standard & Poor's Financial Services LLC and Dow Jones is a registered trademark of Dow Jones Trademark Holdings LLC. All content of the Dow Jones branded indices Copyright S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC and/or its affiliates. Fair value provided by IndexArb.com. Market holidays and trading hours provided by Copp Clark Limited. Terms of Use Privacy Policy Ad Choices Accessibility & CC About Newsletters Transcripts (c) 2024 Cable News Network. A Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All Rights Reserved. CNN Sans (tm) & (c) 2016 Cable News Network.