https://www.wired.com/story/developers-revolt-apple-dma/ Skip to main content Open Navigation Menu To revisit this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Close Alert WIRED Developers Are in Open Revolt Over Apple's New App Store Rules * Backchannel * Business * Culture * Gear * Ideas * Politics * Science * Security * Merch More To revisit this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Close Alert Sign In Search * Backchannel * Business * Culture * Gear * Ideas * Politics * Science * Security * Merch * Podcasts * Video * Wired World * Artificial Intelligence * Climate * Games * Newsletters * Magazine * Events * Wired Insider * Jobs * Coupons Morgan Meaker Business Feb 12, 2024 4:00 AM Developers Are in Open Revolt Over Apple's New App Store Rules European app makers are seething, comparing Apple to "the Mafia" and piling pressure on lawmakers to act. * * * * Photo illustration showing the App store icon made of marble sitting over a pedestal defaced by graffiti. PHOTO-ILLUSTRATION: ANJALI NAIR; GETTY IMAGES Save Save A battle for control is taking place inside iPhones across Europe. While Apple introduced new rules that ostensibly loosen its control over the App Store, local developers are seething at the new system, which they say entrenches the power Apple already wields over their businesses. They're now breaking into a rare open revolt, mounting pressure on lawmakers to step in. So far, they have accused Apple's new business terms of being " abusive," "extortion," and "ludicrously punitive." "Apple holds app providers ransom like the Mafia," claims Matthias Pfau, CEO and cofounder of Tuta, an encrypted email provider. The tech giant treats iPhones as its territory, Pfau complains, tightly controlling developers' access before taking a chunk of their profits. "Anyone wanting to provide an iOS app must pay a ransom to Apple; there's no way around it." For years, Apple has rejected Tuta app updates if they include links to the company's website, he says. Like all iOS apps, Tuta has also been unable to take in-app payments directly from its customers. Apple acts as an intermediary and charges a fee. Pfau was hoping the App Store reforms mandated by the EU's Digital Markets Act (DMA) would make companies like his less tightly bound to Apple. Instead, he is left disappointed by the new terms on offer. "What they came up with is the best proof that they are massively abusing their market dominance," he says. "Apple is basically behaving like a dictator." Apple was designated a "gatekeeper" under the DMA after the EU decided that the App Store acts as an important gateway between businesses and consumers. The company, along with other tech giants, has until March 7 to make a raft of changes. To avoid fines that can reach up to 20 percent of global revenue, the smartphone maker announced its new rules in late January. The rules technically make it possible for users of its hardware to download apps from alternative app stores and also for developers to use their own payment systems--bypassing Apple's commission. But in order to access these new features, developers have to sign up to new business terms. Those terms include restrictions that disincentivize any developers moving away from the status quo, according to Pfau. If his company Tuta were to take advantage of the new system, iPhones would issue warnings--known by critics as "scare screens"--informing users about security risks linked to using payment systems that are not managed by Apple. From Tuta's testing of how popups affect in-app upgrades, he estimates these warnings would dissuade 50 percent of users from proceeding with their purchase. Additionally, although the new terms allow Pfau to make Tuta available in an alternative app store, they would also expose the company to a "core technology fee" every time it was downloaded or updated more than 1 million times in a one-year period. Pfau accepts that Tuta, which he claims has over 100,000 paying subscribers, might not have to pay this fee in the first year. "But we are growing," he insists. "So we would definitely have to pay it within the next couple of years." Most Popular * A Backroom Deal Looms Over a High-Stakes US Surveillance Fight Security A Backroom Deal Looms Over a High-Stakes US Surveillance Fight Dell Cameron * Deadpool & Wolverine Trailer Hopes Pegging Can Save the MCU Culture Deadpool & Wolverine Trailer Hopes Pegging Can Save the MCU Angela Watercutter * The City of Tomorrow Will Run on Your Toilet Water Science The City of Tomorrow Will Run on Your Toilet Water Matt Simon * What Should Your Sex Toys Be Made of? Gear What Should Your Sex Toys Be Made of? Jaina Grey * For Sweden's Spotify, the download fee is more of an immediate problem if the company were to accept Apple's new business terms. "With our EU Apple install base in the 100 million range, this new tax on downloads and updates could skyrocket our customer acquisition costs, potentially increasing them tenfold," Spotify CEO Daniel Ek said on X soon after Apple released its proposal. "While Apple has behaved badly for years, what they did yesterday represents a new low, even for them." For that reason, Spotify, like other apps, believes it has no choice but to stick with its current agreement, Ek elaborated in a call with investors last week. That means still paying commission to Apple and listing their iOS app exclusively on Apple's App Store. "No sane developer wants to pick any of the new terms," Ek said. Sticking with the current system doesn't make the situation worse for companies like Spotify, he added, but it does mean they are missing out on revenues from users buying products such as audiobooks, a new focus for the platform, through the company's app. (Spotify does not sell audiobooks in their iOS app in order to avoid Apple's commission fee.) "So some of these more innovative things that we would like to do, we're currently restricted in doing on the iOS ecosystem." Apple maintains its changes are compliant with the DMA while also being necessary to protect its EU users' devices from the security risks that, it says, are introduced by the new law. "Apple's approach to the Digital Markets Act was guided by two simple goals: complying with the law and reducing the inevitable, increased risks the DMA creates for our EU users," says Apple spokesperson Julien Trosdorf. "That meant creating safeguards to protect EU users to the greatest extent possible and to respond to new threats, including new vectors for malware and viruses, opportunities for scams and fraud, and challenges to ensuring apps are functional on Apple's platforms." App developers don't have much power on their own to make Apple change course. But they hope their criticism will force the European Commission, a branch of the EU's government, to take action. After the March 7 deadline, officials are expected to assess both Apple's proposals and the market's reaction. "Now [the European Commission] must reject Apple's proposal and even consider imposing a fine if no further improvements are made," says Sebastiano Toffaletti, secretary general of the European DIGITAL SME Alliance, an industry group. Andy Yen, CEO of Swiss email and cloud service Proton, is less diplomatic. "If I was the European Commission, I would probably look at this as an insult," he says of Apple's proposed business terms. "It's a slap in the face." You Might Also Like ... * Get the long view on tech with Steven Levy's Plaintext newsletter * My parents' dementia felt like the end of joy. Then came the robots * Cops used DNA to predict a suspect's face--and tried to run facial recognition on it * The world's essential aquifers are in deep trouble * We tried a dating app that lets a chatbot break the ice for you. It got weird * How to choose and customize a mechanical keyboard * Our Gear team has branched out with a new guide to the best sleeping pads and fresh picks for the best coolers and binoculars Morgan Meaker is a senior writer at WIRED covering European business. Before that, she was a technology reporter at The Telegraph and also worked for Dutch magazine De Correspondent. In 2019 she won Technology Journalist of the Year at the Words by Women Awards. She was born in Scotland, lives... Read more Senior Writer * Topicsappleeuropean unionepic More from WIRED Linda Yaccarino Says X Needs More Moderators After All Linda Yaccarino Says X Needs More Moderators After All X CEO Linda Yaccarino told US senators she's hiring more trust and safety staffers. She didn't mention that Elon Musk fired most people policing content on the platform when he acquired it in 2022. Vittoria Elliott This Tech Exec Quit His Job to Fight Generative AI's Original Sin This Tech Exec Quit His Job to Fight Generative AI's Original Sin Ed Newton-Rex quit his job at startup Stability AI over ethical concerns about its collection of training data. His nonprofit Fairly Trained aims to deter startups from scraping the web. Kate Knibbs Google Search Is a Mess. Can Mobile AI Make It Better? Google Search Is a Mess. Can Mobile AI Make It Better? Two new enhancements coming to Google's search tools on phones use machine intelligence to make the search experience more efficient. Lauren Goode I Tested a Next-Gen AI Assistant. It Will Blow You Away I Tested a Next-Gen AI Assistant. It Will Blow You Away WIRED experimented with a new form of voice assistant that can browse the web and perform tasks online. Siri, Alexa, and other virtual helpers could soon be much more powerful. Will Knight Apple Turned Its Epic Defeat Into Another App Store Victory Apple Turned Its Epic Defeat Into Another App Store Victory Despite expensive legal battles and regulatory pressure, Apple's and Google's mobile app stores are mostly unchanged. This week, Apple introduced a new fee on developers to protect its business. Paresh Dave The Mystery of the $400 Million FTX Heist May Have Been Solved The Mystery of the $400 Million FTX Heist May Have Been Solved An indictment against three Americans suggests that at least some of the culprits behind the theft of an FTX crypto fortune may be in custody. Andy Greenberg Cable Firms to FTC: We Shouldn't Have to Let Users Cancel Service With a Click Cable Firms to FTC: We Shouldn't Have to Let Users Cancel Service With a Click Customers may "misunderstand the consequences of canceling," cable lobby says. Jon Brodkin, Ars Technica Apple Shares the Secret of Why the 40-Year-Old Mac Still Rules Apple Shares the Secret of Why the 40-Year-Old Mac Still Rules The pioneering PC revolutionized how people interact with computers. As the Mac enters its fifth decade, Apple says it will continue to evolve. Steven Levy WIRED WIRED is where tomorrow is realized. It is the essential source of information and ideas that make sense of a world in constant transformation. The WIRED conversation illuminates how technology is changing every aspect of our lives--from culture to business, science to design. The breakthroughs and innovations that we uncover lead to new ways of thinking, new connections, and new industries. More From WIRED * Subscribe * Newsletters * FAQ * WIRED Staff * Editorial Standards * Archive * RSS * Accessibility Help Reviews and Guides * Reviews * Buying Guides * Coupons * Mattresses * Electric Bikes * Fitness Trackers * Streaming Guides * Advertise * Contact Us * Customer Care * Jobs * Press Center * Conde Nast Store * User Agreement * Privacy Policy & Cookie Statement * Your California Privacy Rights (c) 2024 Conde Nast. All rights reserved. WIRED may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Conde Nast. Ad Choices Select international site United States * UK * Italia * Japon * Czech Republic & Slovakia * * * * * * Do Not Sell My Personal Info