https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2024-01-29/chronic-pain-health-wellness-mind-body * News + Home Page + California + Election 2024 + Housing & Homelessness + Politics + Science & Medicine + World & Nation * Business + Artificial Intelligence + Autos + Jobs, Labor & Workplace + Real Estate + Technology and the Internet * California + California Politics + Earthquakes + Education + Housing & Homelessness + L.A. Politics + Mental Health * Climate & Environment + Global Warming + Water & Drought * Entertainment & Arts + Arts + Books + Stand-Up Comedy + Company Town + The Envelope (Awards) + Movies + Music + Television + Things to Do * De Los * En Espanol * Food + 101 best restaurants + Recipes * Image * Lifestyle + Health & Wellness + Home Design + L.A. Affairs + Plants + Travel & Experiences + Weekend * Obituaries * Opinion + Editorials + Letters to the Editor + Op-Ed + Short Docs * Sports + Angels + Angel City FC + Chargers + Clippers + Dodgers + Ducks + Galaxy + High School Sports + Kings + Lakers + Olympics + USC + UCLA + Rams + Sparks * Times Everywhere + 404 by L.A. Times + Facebook + Instagram + LA Times Today + Newsletters + Photography + Podcasts + Short Docs + TikTok + Threads + Video + YouTube + X (Twitter) * For Subscribers * All Sections * _________________ * About Us + About Us + Archives + Company News + eNewspaper + For the Record + Got a Tip? + L.A. Times Careers + L.A. Times Store + L.A. Times Studios + News App: Apple IOS + News App: Google Play + Newsroom Directory + Public Affairs + Rights, Clearance & Permissions + Short Docs * Advertising + Place an Ad + Classifieds + Coupons + People on the Move + Find/Post Jobs + Local Ads Marketplace + Media Kit: Why the L.A. Times? + Hot Property Sections + Place an Open House + Sotheby's International Realty * Bestcovery + Compare * B2B Publishing * Business Visionaries * Hot Property * Crossword & Games * L.A. Times Events * L.A. Times Store * Subscriptions + Manage Subscription + EZPAY + Delivery Issue + eNewspaper + Students & Educators + Subscribe + Subscriber Terms + Gift Subscription Terms * Special Supplements + Best of the Southland + Branded Travel + Healthy Living + Las Vegas Guide + Philanthropy Copyright (c) 2024, Los Angeles Times | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | CA Notice of Collection | Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information Sections * California * Entertainment * Sports * Food * Climate * Image * Opinion * | * Bestcovery * Coupons * Crossword * eNewspaper Tap to enable a layout that focuses on the article. Focus mode Show Search [ ] Search Query Submit Search Advertisement Opinion Opinion: That pain in your back? It's really a pain in your brain A person seated at a desk with a hand on their lower back (Kinga Krzeminska/Getty Images) By Nathaniel Frank Jan. 29, 2024 3 AM PT * Facebook * Twitter * Show more sharing options ShareClose extra sharing options * Facebook * Twitter * LinkedIn * Email * Copy Link URLCopied! * Print As a chronic pain sufferer, I sometimes surprise people by telling them that my pain doesn't have a physical cause. It's a mind-body thing, I say, related to stress and emotions. To many, this sounds like admitting to being a little bit crazy. And when I up the ante by suggesting they've probably had this kind of pain too, some become outright angry, interpreting my words to mean their pain is "all in their head." All of which makes a new study published in the Journal of Pain a big deal. It offers robust evidence that the overwhelming majority of chronic back and neck pain cases -- among the most common chronic pain complaints -- come from the mind, despite the fact that most diagnoses cite a physical cause, such as bulging disks or bone spurs. In the new study, doctors assessed 222 consecutive pain patients at an orthopedic care clinic in Louisiana -- everyone who showed up, as long as they could complete a questionnaire. Just 12% showed evidence of a structural problem as the root of their pain. Eighty-eight percent, on the other hand, had what the researchers call "primary pain," which refers to symptoms generated by neural circuits in the brain rather than by "structural" damage to the body. OxyContin pills are arranged for a photo at a pharmacy in Montpelier, Vt. on Tuesday, Feb. 19, 2013. Drug overdose deaths rose for the 11th straight year, federal data show, and most of them were accidents involving addictive painkillers despite growing attention to risks from these medicines. As in previous recent years, opioid drugs -- which include OxyContin and Vicodin -- were the biggest problem, contributing to 3 out of 4 medication overdose deaths. (AP Photo/Toby Talbot) Opinion Op-Ed: Finally, some promising news on opioids for patients in severe pain This year brought progress for safely getting opioids to people with debilitating pain. Dec. 23, 2022 Advertisement Based on this and prior research, the authors believe that a process in the brain initiates the non-structural pain. The sensations could be the residual pain from a bodily wound that healed but didn't notify the brain. Or the brain may have generated pain in the absence of any injury, perhaps in an effort to protect the patients from emotional wounds by occupying their attention with physical sensations instead. The role of the brain and emotions in producing pain has long been known, and it has been validated by neuroimaging that shows that the brain processes physical pain and emotional distress in the same regions. Observational studies indicate that people feel more pain when primed with negative emotional stimuli. And additional research has shown that therapeutic interventions that help patients understand and reinterpret their pain can significantly reduce the symptoms. The theory is that pain is a danger signal, so as we come to feel safer and less threatened, our nervous systems shift out of fight-or-flight mode, and stop firing the pain signals. As a result, scientists now believe that all pain is essentially brain pain. The idea is that just as the brain generates sensory experiences such as vision and hearing, it also generates pain by consulting our memories, expectations and emotions, as well as whatever physical inputs our nerves may sense, and creating pain when it determines we are under threat. While our nerves detect sensations, it's the brain that decides if we'll experience them as pain. FILE - A protester gathers containers that look like OxyContin bottles at an anti-opioid demonstration in front of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services headquarters in Washington on April 5, 2019. A California judge has ruled for top drug manufacturers as local governments seek billions of dollars to cover their costs from the nation's opioid epidemic. Orange County Superior Court Judge Peter Wilson issued a tentative ruling Monday, Nov. 1, 2021, that said the governments hadn't proven the pharmaceutical companies used deceptive marketing to increase unnecessary opioid prescriptions and create a public nuisance. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky, File) Opinion Op-Ed: Opioids don't do enough for chronic pain sufferers Exercise and different types of cognitive and physical therapy are proven to be more effective for pain patients than opioids and other pain medications. Jan. 24, 2023 The implications for healthcare are profound. Chronic pain is among the top reasons people seek medical care. More than 1.5 billion people worldwide suffer from chronic pain, including 50 million to 100 million Americans. For the most part, these patients are spending billions of dollars pursuing physical treatments. If the cause is non-physical, the money is wasted and the suffering only mounts. And not only are we failing to alleviate the pain, we are creating dangerous side effects that include the opioid crisis as well as surgeries that may be unnecessary and can leave patients worse off. Advertisement Of course, sometimes chronic pain does have a physical cause, and distinguishing between when it does and doesn't is crucial. To address this key challenge, the researchers at the Louisiana clinic devised a rule-out/rule-in diagnosis method that should be adopted far and wide. [] Opinion Op-Ed: Is that pain you feel all in your head? Mind and body are both implicated when your body hurts. Recognizing the connection is crucial to treating pain. May 2, 2022 The process starts with a thorough patient exam and review of scans to rule out physical causes of the pain. There is a nuance: Just because an anomaly -- a squished disk in your back, for example -- shows up on a scan, it is not necessarily the cause of pain. As the study explains, research repeatedly shows that the majority of people without pain show similar anomalies. In other words, doctors diagnosing the source of chronic pain need to be aware of the poor correlation between scary scans and pain. The rule-in process further clarifies whether a patient has structural or mind-body pain. It consists of taking a detailed history of the patient's pain and life. Doctors need to know if prior treatments that should have resolved structural causes have failed; if treatments associated with a placebo response brought relief; if a patient's history contains significant stress or adversity; if they have other ailments associated with mind-body causes (headaches, gut and bladder conditions, fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue, tendonitis and more can have such associations). And they need to know if the pain is inconsistent -- does it move around in the body or come and go; is it triggered by biologically irrelevant stimuli like the weather, smells or sounds? These variables don't track well with structural causes. The process may sound a bit subjective, and it is. But no more than any other diagnostic approach. Medicine is not an exact science, and doctors must act on imperfect information. "We deal in probabilities," said Dr. Howard Schubiner, lead investigator of the Louisiana study and a clinical professor at Michigan State University College of Human Medicine. Using the careful criteria developed for the study offers as well-grounded a basis for action as anything: "When there is strong evidence using these criteria, a physician can be confident that what they're seeing is a mind-body problem." The existing medical paradigm assumes a physical cause for most chronic pain. The findings in the Louisiana study suggest that's often wrong. Advertisement Fortunately, my pain is much improved after years of pain education and good therapy helped my brain dial down my nervous system. Everyone deserves access to this new pain paradigm. And that requires ending the stigma still associated with mind-body symptoms, and understanding them as a universal human condition, not as the lot of people who are a little bit crazy. Nathaniel Frank is the director of the What We Know Project at Cornell University's Center for the Study of Inequality. He is writing a book about mind-body pain to be published by Mayo Clinic Press. OpinionScience & MedicineOp-EdHealth & Wellness Newsletter A cure for the common opinion Get thought-provoking perspectives with our weekly newsletter. Enter email address[ ] Sign Me Up You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times. More From the Los Angeles Times * Texas Gov. Greg Abbott speaks during an election night party Tuesday, Nov. 8, 2022, in McAllen, Texas. (AP Photo/David J. Phillip) Opinion Opinion: Texas Gov. Greg Abbott is defying a U.S. Supreme Court order. That's frightening * NEW YORK, NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 13: Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez attends The 2021 Met Gala Celebrating In America: A Lexicon Of Fashion at Metropolitan Museum of Art on September 13, 2021 in New York City. (Photo by Kevin Mazur/MG21/Getty Images For The Met Museum/Vogue) Opinion Opinion: No more billionaires? We can be more ambitious than that. No one needs more than $20 million Jan. 29, 2024 * MARIPOSA, CA - APRIL 29, 2020 - - Bill Evans, 72, walks home along Highway 140 in the heart of Mariposa on April 29, 2020. Evans, a retired computer programmer, has been living in Mariposa since 2004. Most of the storefronts have been closed since Gov. Gavin Newsom announced in mid-March that all Californians were being required to shelter in place to reduce the spread of coronavirus. Mariposa County is one of five California counties that as of April 28 only had one reported coronavirus case, despite the fact all the surroundings have. A 23-year-old woman in Marioposa County had tested positive for COVID-190. More than 47,000 Californians have tested positive for the novel coronavirus but in Mariposa County, Tuesday's result was the first. (Genaro Molina / Los Angeles Times) Opinion Opinion: What my grandma's California trailer taught me about housing and elder care Jan. 29, 2024 * YORBA LINDA, CA - JUNE 5, 2021: A tribute poster hangs outside the Calvary Chapel Yorba Linda where 6-year-old Aiden Leos is remembered at his funeral service on June 5, 2021 in Yorba Linda, California. Aiden was tragically killed while riding in his mom's car when someone fired a gun at the car on the 55 freeway in what is being called a road rage incident.(Gina Ferazzi / Los Angeles Times) Opinion Column: A road rage horror story, a child's murder and lessons for us all Jan. 28, 2024 Subscribers Are Reading * For Subscribers The year that killed L.A. restaurants: Here are more than 65 notable closures from 2023 * For Subscribers Palm Springs capped short-term rentals. Now some home prices are in free-fall * For Subscribers Science can explain a broken heart. Could science help heal mine? * For Subscribers Code words, smuggled phones, $50 tips: Mexican Mafia micro-manages drug deals from prison * For Subscribers Broken chargers, lax oversight: How California's troubled EV charging stations threaten emission goals Advertisement Opinion * FILE - Activists demonstrate as the Supreme Court hears oral arguments on a pair of cases that could decide the future of affirmative action in college admissions, in Washington, Oct. 31, 2022. The Supreme Court ruled Thursday, June 29, 2023, that colleges and universities must stop considering race in admissions, forcing institutions of higher education to look for new ways to achieve diverse student bodies. In a 6-3 decision, the court struck down admissions plans at Harvard and the University of North Carolina, the nation's oldest private and public colleges, respectively. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File) Guerrero: The Supreme Court is waging war on young people * Endorsement: The Times' recommendation for the 45th congressional district * Not every life is a 'success story.' Some land in homelessness. But everyone deserves dignity * Opinion: Depression and insomnia are part of my family history. Will my kids be OK? Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement A California Times publication Subscribe for unlimited access Site Map Follow Us * Twitter * Instagram * YouTube * Facebook * + eNewspaper + Coupons + Find/Post Jobs + Place an Ad + Media Kit: Why the L. A. Times? + Bestcovery * MORE FROM THE L.A. TIMES + Crossword + Obituaries + Recipes + L.A. Times Compare + L.A. Times Store + Wine Club + About/Contact + For the Record + L.A. Times Careers + Manage Subscription + Reprints and Permissions + Site Map Copyright (c) 2024, Los Angeles Times | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | CA Notice of Collection | Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information