https://english.elpais.com/economy-and-business/2024-01-29/the-horrors-experienced-by-meta-moderators-i-didnt-know-what-humans-are-capable-of.html _ _ _ _ Select: * - - - * Espana * America + Mexico + Colombia + Chile + Argentina * USA EL PAIS Economy And Business subscribeHHOLALOG IN Economy And Business Latest News _ META The horrors experienced by Meta moderators: 'I didn't know what humans are capable of' A court ruling in Spain that attributes a content moderator's mental health problems to the job paves the way for acknowledging that fact for at least 25 other employees as well Merlin PropertiesThe Glories tower in Barcelona, Spain, where Meta's subcontractor for content filtering is located.Reuters Josep Cata Figuls Josep Cata Figuls Barcelona - Jan 29, 2024 - 05:00 CET After having to repeatedly watch numerous videos of suicides, murders, dismemberment and rapes, he had a panic attack and asked for help. This employee worked as a content moderator at a company that serves Meta, which owns Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp. He was told to go to the fun floor: a large game room located in Barcelona's Glories tower, where the content moderation offices for the Californian tech giant are located. He sat staring blankly at a ping pong table. The fun floor didn't help him at all. On another occasion, two hours after he had another panic attack, his boss gave him permission to go see a company psychologist. She was on another floor, the psychology floor. He spent over half an hour talking to her, getting it all out. When he finished, she told him that his work was very important to society, that they were all heroes, that he should be stronger. And that their time was up. Content moderators are in charge of leaving walls and feeds clean and peaceful on Facebook and Instagram. Millions of people use these platforms every day and are unaware that this dark side exists. These workers are the ones who decide whether or not to publish fake news or photos that do not comply with Meta's policy. But they are also the ones who have to deal with the most brutal content: viewing it, evaluating it, censoring it and, if necessary, sending it to the police. In 2018, the company CCC Barcelona Digital Services moved into the Glories tower. The announcement was very well received by the Catalan authorities, as the subcontractor of this large technological company came to swell the ranks of innovative companies located in Barcelona, and to occupy part of a building that had just lost the opportunity to house the headquarters of the European Medicines Agency. The company began to hire people -- primarily young foreigners who spoke several languages -- to moderate content from different markets. Last October, an investigation by La Vanguardia exposed the conditions under which these moderators work. Before that, Catalonia's Labor Inspectorate launched an investigation in 2021, and the following year imposed a fine of over EUR40,000 ($43,314) on the company for deficiencies in the evaluation and prevention of psychosocial risks in the workplace. In 2020, the company was acquired by Canadian Telus International, which claims that the accusations are false and that they have sufficient safety measures in place. This worker started there in 2018 and stayed until 2020, when he obtained a medical leave for his mental health problems. The company and the mutual insurance company classified it as a common illness. "We then requested a change of contingencies, because his case fit perfectly with that of occupational accident. The National Institute of Social Security agreed with us, and the company appealed, which triggered the legal process," explains Francesc Feliu, a partner in the law firm Espacio Juridico Feliu Fins, which specializes in healthcare issues. On January 12, the 28th Labor Court of Barcelona rejected the company's claim and ruled that the worker's sick leave should be classified as an accident at work. This is the first judgment that recognizes that the mental illness a content moderator suffers is caused by his work. "Work-related stress is the sole, exclusive and unquestionable trigger" of the disorders, says the ruling, which can still be appealed. Feliu has some 25 other workers who are waiting for their illness to be recognized as an occupational accident, and in October he also filed a criminal complaint against the company, alleging the lack of safety measures. The worker has requested anonymity, because he is subject to strict confidentiality agreements, and he prefers not to talk about how he feels or about very personal issues, because the wounds left by this work are still fresh. He is having a hard time with the news coverage of the ruling, which make him relive what he saw. "But at least this is encouraging more people to seek justice," he notes. When he started working at the company, he had no idea of the violence of the videos he would have to watch. "They told me, but superficially, and then when you start you see that things are much, much worse...," he says. The lawyer explains that the work is well paid (about EUR2,400 [$2600] gross per month, although there are salary differences between workers who are responsible for different markets, for which another office has also gone to court), no experience or training is required, and young foreigners are attracted to it: "They say 'look, how cool, I'll work for Meta," explains Feliu. The affected worker points out that the illusions don't last long: "People are not at all aware of what is going on. Before I worked there, I assure you that I didn't know what humans were capable of." The workers suspect that they were training AI Feliu explains that at that time -- "the conditions may have changed now," he says -- the content moderators with the best efficiency scores (as determined by a monthly worker evaluation) were placed in a high-priority section. That is, they continued to receive videos of all kinds, photos and posts in which suicides and terrorist acts appeared. That was the section where the worker from the case worked: "Constantly seeing this makes you more sensitive to everything. After a while I couldn't even see a suicide letter," he explains. You had to strictly follow Meta's policy, and often watch the videos to the end, several times with different moderators. "For example, you had to keep watching a live video of someone explaining that they wanted to commit suicide, and you couldn't delete it or alert the police if you didn't see something in the scene that suggested suicide, a gun, an open window.... Sometimes they would suddenly pull out the gun and shoot themselves, without you being able to do anything," he laments. To remove a video, they had to spell out the decision: "You had to rate the video by the worst thing that happened [in it], according to a scale. If the video started with some kind of violence, you had to wait for something more serious, like murder, dismemberment or sexual abuse, to rate it as the most serious. If the most serious violence came up at first, the system would let you delete it." This procedure made the workers suspicious. "If you already see that something is violent at second 10, why do you have to wait? You come to the conclusion that what they are doing is training artificial intelligence (AI), that [workers] are cannon fodder," says Feliu. When asked about this, a spokesman for the subcontractor does not clarify whether this project exists or / and refers all questions to Meta. The company employs some 2,000 people, after cutbacks at Meta led to the subcontractor's workforce being reduced through layoffs last year. The works council has not responded to questions from this newspaper, and the company has appealed the ruling. In a statement, Telus explains that "thanks to the comprehensive wellness program," in December of last year, it had reduced sick leave to 14% of the workforce, and that only "between 1% and 2%" were work-related mental health leaves. The company claims that it has engaged outside medical support, that the team has a range of counselors available to them 24 hours a day, can call for breaks and emergency sessions whenever workers see disturbing content, and has technology to blur videos or turn off the sound, if necessary. "Any suggestion that employees are constantly exposed to disturbing content for eight hours a day is false," the note says, adding that its workers' well-being is a priority. At the trial, the company denied that there was a link between the employee's mental illness and his work, arguing that he had seen a psychologist when he was 16 years old. The worker explains that when he was with the company, there were timed five-minute breaks every hour, during which time he could not go outside to get some fresh air because just going down in the elevator used up the allotted time. The lunch break was 20 minutes, and workers had activities such as yoga sessions and games, "but [there was] no specific follow-up" for employees who evaluated some 400 pieces of content every day. In addition, the rotating schedules -- one week in the morning, one week in the afternoon, one week in the evening, one week at night --disturbed their rest, "which was already difficult because of the nightmares." Feliu says that "25% of people were systematically on sick leave, plus all those who left the job before taking sick leave." The attorney believes that the court ruling, and future workers will help the company to change things: "Content moderators are essential for social media, but so are their [working] conditions." Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAIS USA Edition More information Donald Trump supporters on Capitol Hill Kicking toxic people off social media reduces hate speech on the internet Emanoelle Santos Taylor Swift imagenes porno falsas IA The internet is filled with 'deepfake' Taylor Swift porn, evidencing the dangers of AI for women Clara Angela Brascia Archived In * Meta * Facebook * Instagram Adheres toThe Trust ProjectMore information If you are interested in licensing this content, please contact ventacontenidos@prisamedia.com _ newsletter Sign up to EL PAIS in English Edition bulletin Apuntate Most viewed 1. Child Tax Credit: How to apply, and what changes will it have in 2024 2. Ecuador uncovers largest stash of cocaine in its history: 22 tons hidden in a pig farm 3. Fentanyl, the portrait of a mass murderer 4. 'How can someone from drama school learn what you've learned?': How Jason Statham rose from the streets to stardom 5. Oscars 2024: Where to stream the nominated movies Recomendaciones EL PAIS * Cursos * Centros * Frances online * Ingles online * Italiano online * Aleman online * Crucigramas & Juegos Cursos cursos Maestria en linea en Administracion de Empresas con concentracion en Marketing Digital Maestria en linea en Administracion de Empresas con concentracion en Marketing Digital cursos Maestria en linea en Direccion de Recursos Humanos Maestria en linea en Direccion de Recursos Humanos cursos Maestria en linea en Psicopedagogia Maestria en linea en Psicopedagogia cursos Curso en linea de Diseno Grafico Curso en linea de Diseno Grafico Centros cursosonline Maestria en Administracion de Empresas con concentracion en Transformacion Digital y Desarrollo de Negocios Maestria en Administracion de Empresas con concentracion en Transformacion Digital y Desarrollo de Negocios cursosonline Curso en linea de experto en Calidad Industrial y Procesos Farmaceuticos Curso en linea de experto en Calidad Industrial y Procesos Farmaceuticos cursosonline Maestria en linea en Programacion Web Maestria en linea en Programacion Web cursosonline Maestria en linea en Ciencias en Educacion Virtual Maestria en linea en Ciencias en Educacion Virtual Frances online cursosingles Mejora tu frances con 15 minutos al dia Mejora tu frances con 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfruta de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfruta de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita de nuestro curso de frances 'online' 21 dias de prueba gratuita de nuestro curso de frances 'online' Ingles online cursosingles Mejore su ingles con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia Mejore su ingles con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas cursosingles Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado cursosingles Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Italiano online cursosingles Mejore su italiano con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia Mejore su italiano con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas cursosingles Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado cursosingles Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Aleman online cursosingles Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas cursosingles Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado cursosingles Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Crucigramas & Juegos juegos Crucigramas minis Crucigramas minis juegos Crucigramas Tarkus Crucigramas Tarkus juegos Sudokus mini Sudokus mini juegos Sopas de letras Sopas de letras Recomendaciones EL PAIS * Cursos * Centros * Italiano online * Frances online * Aleman online * Crucigramas & Juegos Cursos cursos Maestria en Direccion Financiera. Clases 100% en linea Maestria en Direccion Financiera. Clases 100% en linea cursos Maestria en Supply Chain Management & Logistics. Presencial en Madrid, Espana Maestria en Supply Chain Management & Logistics. Presencial en Madrid, Espana cursos Maestria en Seguridad Industrial y Proteccion Ambiental. Con un 56% de descuento Maestria en Seguridad Industrial y Proteccion Ambiental. Con un 56% de descuento cursos Maestria Global en Project Management. Semipresencial en Madrid, Espana Maestria Global en Project Management. Semipresencial en Madrid, Espana Centros cursosonline Curso de Marketing Digital. Metodologia en linea Curso de Marketing Digital. Metodologia en linea cursosonline MBA Administracion y Direccion de Empresas. Con un 81% de descuento MBA Administracion y Direccion de Empresas. Con un 81% de descuento cursosonline Maestria en Programacion Web. Clases 100% en linea Maestria en Programacion Web. Clases 100% en linea cursosonline Descubra un completo Directorio de Centros de Formacion Descubra un completo Directorio de Centros de Formacion Italiano online cursosingles Mejore su italiano con solo 15 minutos al dia Mejore su italiano con solo 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! Frances online cursosingles Mejore su frances con solo 15 minutos al dia Mejore su frances con solo 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! Aleman online cursosingles Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! Crucigramas & Juegos juegos !Disfruta con nuestros Crucigramas para expertos! !Disfruta con nuestros Crucigramas para expertos! juegos Resuelve los ultimos Crucigramas de Mambrino Resuelve los ultimos Crucigramas de Mambrino juegos Juega a nuestros Sudoku para Expertos y mejora dia a dia tu nivel Juega a nuestros Sudoku para Expertos y mejora dia a dia tu nivel juegos Juega a las nuevas Sopas de letras clasicas y tematicas de EL PAIS Juega a las nuevas Sopas de letras clasicas y tematicas de EL PAIS _ _ Inicia sesion o registrate gratis para continuar leyendo en incognito Registrate gratisInicia sesion Suscribete y lee sin limites Ver opciones de suscripcion HOLA Subscribe for EUR 1 * My activity * My Subscription * My personal data * My newsletters * Rights and de-registration * Events and experiences logout change contrast: Select: * - - - * Espana * America + Mexico + Colombia + Chile + Argentina * USA If you want to follow all the latest news without any limits, subscribe to EL PAIS for just EUR1 the first month SUBSCRIBE NOW * International * U.S. * Economy And Business * Science * Health * Technology * Climate * People * Lifestyle * Opinion * Culture * Sports * EPS * Latest News Newsletter Follow on: ;