https://www.tampabay.com/opinion/2024/01/17/did-you-know-that-most-stem-grads-dont-work-stem-jobs/ [ ]Search Subscribe Manage profile Donate LoginLog out Menu Close Subscribe Home Log in Log out Search Newsletters Help Chat Go to the e-NewspaperGo to the e-Newspaper Featured DeSantisDeadly DoseLatest News Regions PinellasHillsboroughPascoHernandoSt. PetersburgTampaClearwater Topics EducationBusinessReal EstatePoliticsCrime Obituaries Weather Sports Bucs iconBucsRays iconRaysLightning iconLightning High Schools Bulls iconBullsGators iconGatorsSeminoles iconSeminoles Opinion Life & Culture Things To DoCalendar Food Videos Photos Investigations Connect with us Games & Puzzles Shop The words "Tampa Bay Times" written in a Gothic font * + News + Sports + Opinion + Life & Culture + Food * + + Obituaries + Classifieds * + + Today's Paper + Newsletters + e-Newspaper + e-Newspaper Subscribe Advertisement Opinion | Guest Column John D. Skrentny Did you know that most STEM grads don't work in STEM jobs? Without reforms and shifts, STEM majors will continue to be oversold. The OpenAI logo is seen displayed on a cell phone with an image on a computer screen generated by ChatGPT's Dall-E text-to-image model on Dec. 8, 2023, in Boston. (AP Photo/Michael Dwyer) The OpenAI logo is seen displayed on a cell phone with an image on a computer screen generated by ChatGPT's Dall-E text-to-image model on Dec. 8, 2023, in Boston. (AP Photo/Michael Dwyer) [ MICHAEL DWYER | AP ] Published Earlier today Republicans and Democrats don't seem to agree on much these days. But despite the gridlock in Congress, both political parties have for years supported spending billions on Science, Technology, Engineering and Math (STEM) education. Their goals include reducing perceived shortages of STEM workers, boosting American innovation and competitiveness and diversifying this highly paid workforce. The message of lucrative STEM careers appears to have reached students and tuition-paying parents -- the number of STEM majors has surged in recent years. John D. Skrentny John D. Skrentny [ Provided ] But there is a problem with these massive investments: Most STEM graduates don't work in STEM occupations. The Census Bureau reported in 2021 that a paltry 28% of STEM grads are working in these supposedly in-demand, highly paid and important STEM jobs. These include diverse sectors such as pharmaceuticals, chemicals and energy, but about half of STEM jobs are in computers, and tech firms typically complain the loudest of STEM shortages. What's causing this disconnect? It's pretty straightforward: Employers, and the investors who drive their behavior, depress the national returns on STEM education investments. One key factor is wages. Many able STEM grads bolt for better-paying careers, especially in business, finance, management and medicine (government programs focused on STEM exclude medical practitioners and are not designed to increase those numbers). Some do find high salaries in STEM jobs, many right out of college, especially in hot fields such as AI. But STEM grads even in the most dynamic sectors, including computer science and engineering, see their salary advantage fade over time, increasing the odds that they'll leave for greener pastures. It is employers, of course, who set wages at their firms, and current wage levels are not keeping most STEM grads in STEM jobs. Some of the wealthiest companies -- Apple, Google, Adobe Systems and Intel -- settled a class-action lawsuit for $415 million in 2015 after workers alleged employers used illegal means to prevent salary increases. Employers also incentivize moves from technical work to management with higher salaries at their own firms, yet many bemoan a shortage of technical STEM workers, not managers. STEM grads may also flee the "burn-and-churn" management common in STEM jobs. We've been bombarded by images of young, happy-go-lucky STEM workers playing foosball and skateboarding to free snacks or meditation pods. But the more common experience, especially in tech, is grueling "crunch time" to rush a product out the door while worrying about the next performance review. Media accounts of the most famous companies describe workplaces that are aggressive, both for employees and for the "shadow workforce" toiling on short-term contracts. This work stress affects both physical and mental health. Employees at Uber, Facebook and Google have taken their own lives, prompting discussion of the role of workplace culture in their deaths. Adding to the stress is the constant threat of layoffs. Even the richest firms regularly shed STEM workers as technologies or markets change or investors demand cost reductions. When Elon Musk took over Twitter and sacked more than half the workforce, other CEOs cheered. Musk was hardly a STEM trailblazer; workers in the high-demand field of IT are more likely to face layoffs than workers in most other industries. Especially vulnerable are expensive older workers and those who didn't, or couldn't, self-train to keep their skills relevant -- an increasingly important practice because employer-provided training has dwindled over recent decades. Spend your days with Hayes Spend your days with Hayes Subscribe to our free Stephinitely newsletter Columnist Stephanie Hayes will share thoughts, feelings and funny business with you every Monday. Loading... You're all signed up! Want more of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let's get started. Explore all your options Employers facing STEM shortages should bend over backward to keep their scarce talent. Instead, research finds that STEM employers maintain unwelcoming environments for older workers as well as women and underrepresented minorities. Sheryl Sandberg, the former COO of Facebook (now Meta), blamed Facebook's dearth of female software developers on universities and society for not graduating more female computer science and engineering majors. But why would women choose a sector where the numbers indicate they aren't welcome? Where even blatant sexual harassment can go unpunished? Some STEM grads also reject STEM jobs because so many are meaningless or even harmful. Workers have fled social media companies following concerns that they spread misinformation, erode democracy and foster teen depression. Fossil fuel companies struggle for STEM talent due to their damage to the planet. Trillion-dollar tech companies are often accused of unfair trade practices and "surveillance capitalism" that mines users for personal data. STEM grads who want to make the world a better place may struggle to find a fit. The poor return on investments in STEM education can improve. Employers facing STEM worker shortages must understand that their wounds are self-inflicted. They can raise wages, utilize worker-friendly management, retrain obsolete workers rather than lay them off, follow best practices on workplace inclusiveness and eschew destructive business models. But investors repeatedly reward employers for treating STEM grads like fast fashion -- discarded when broken or no longer appealing -- or for deploying STEM skills in lucrative yet harmful business models. A better return on STEM education will require corporations to move away from maximizing short-term shareholder value and consider more stakeholders and moral limits on money making. Meanwhile, governments can lure investors to put more money in planet-saving technologies, as Congress did with the Inflation Reduction Act. Without these or similar shifts, STEM majors will continue to be oversold. John D. Skrentny is the author of "Wasted Education: How We Fail Our Graduates in Science, Technology, Engineering and Math" and is a professor of sociology at UC San Diego. (c)2024 Los Angeles Times. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency LLC. Up next:Is Florida road rage really a Republican thing? | Letters MORE FOR YOU * Here's why the courts should settle the Andrew Warren-Ron DeSantis case now | EditorialJan. 12* Opinion Here's why the courts should settle the Andrew Warren-Ron DeSantis case now | Editorial * The pope is wrong on surrogate mothers. Just ask my friends born this way. | LettersJan. 14* Opinion The pope is wrong on surrogate mothers. Just ask my friends born this way. | Letters * Advertisement * * Trump official who OK'd drugs from Canada chairs company behind Florida's import planYesterday* News Trump official who OK'd drugs from Canada chairs company behind Florida's import plan * What would a second Trump presidency look like for health care? Earlier today* News What would a second Trump presidency look like for health care? * I'm a retired rear admiral, and here's why Ukraine needs our supportJan. 11* Opinion I'm a retired rear admiral, and here's why Ukraine needs our support * Is Florida road rage really a Republican thing? | LettersEarlier today* Opinion Is Florida road rage really a Republican thing? | Letters * Florida's oldest county is really old. Here's why that matters. Jan. 11* Opinion Florida's oldest county is really old. Here's why that matters. * Here's a bipartisan blueprint to harden Florida homes against hurricanes and rising seasJan. 11* Opinion Here's a bipartisan blueprint to harden Florida homes against hurricanes and rising seas * On Florida's roads, rage is stupid here, stupid there, stupid everywhereJan. 12* Opinion On Florida's roads, rage is stupid here, stupid there, stupid everywhere * Tampa Bay Rays could name a new ball field after St. PeteJan. 12* Opinion Tampa Bay Rays could name a new ball field after St. Pete * Welcome to the Old South, the myth that refuses to dieJan. 10* Opinion Welcome to the Old South, the myth that refuses to die * In Florida, it's the will of some people | LettersJan. 10* Opinion In Florida, it's the will of some people | Letters Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement The words "Tampa Bay Times" written in a Gothic font Contact Help ChatCustomer ServiceSubmit a News TipContact Account Digital accessHome deliveryNewslettersManage my accountDonate Subscriber FAQe-Newspaper FAQe-Newspaper App FAQ About Times Publishing CompanyAbout usConnect with usCareers Advertise Times Total MediaMedia KitPlace an adPublic NoticesClassifiedsBest of the BestLocal Ads[florida-] Shop Champa Bay ShopBucs Hardcover BookLightning Hardcover BookPhoto ReprintsArticle ReprintsArticle LicensingHistoric Front PagesMeeting Backgrounds More News in EducationExposHomesSponsored ContentSpecial SectionsApps PodcastsArchives (c) 2024 All Rights Reserved Times Publishing Company Privacy Policy ONLY AVAILABLE FOR SUBSCRIBERS The Tampa Bay Times e-Newspaper is a digital replica of the printed paper seven days a week that is available to read on desktop, mobile, and our app for subscribers only. To enjoy the e-Newspaper every day, please subscribe. SubscribeLog in