https://www.politico.eu/article/germanys-energy-efficiency-open-windows-ventilation/ * Thursday, December 14, 2023 * EU * UK * FR * US * POLITICO Live + About POLITICO Live + Upcoming Events * More Info + About Us + Media Solutions + Content Studio + Press + Print Edition + Contact Us + Jobs + Careers at POLITICO Primary Menu Politico Pro Sign up to newsletters Sign In Search for: [ ] Submit Politico Pro * Explore * Newsletters & podcasts * Featured Sections + Brussels + France + Germany + Britain + Migration + Elections in Europe + Defense + Foreign Policy + Poll of Polls + Continent + EU-China + Special Reports * Policy Areas + Agriculture and Food + Competition and Industrial Policy + Cybersecurity and Data Protection + Energy and Climate + Energy and Climate UK + EU-UK + Defense + Financial Services + Central Banker + Health Care + Mobility + Sustainability + Technology + Technology UK + Trade + Trade UK + Paris Influence * Featured Series + POLITICO 28 Series + Global Policy Lab + Climate, Changed + Work Reloaded + Silent Killers + After Corona + The Road to COP26 + Telescope: AIDS + EU in Africa + Changemakers + The wonk's survival guide to the EU Green Deal * Commentary + Unpacked + Beyond The Bubble + From Across the Pond + Club Med + Declassified POLITICO Live * See all future events * See all past events * About POLITICO Live Editions * EU Edition * U.K. Edition * U.S. Edition * California * New York Publications * Print Edition POLITICO Research and Analysis Division * About * Newsletters + Brussels Playbook + London Playbook + Playbook Paris + Dimanchissime + Global Playbook + Sunday Crunch + Berlin Bulletin + London Influence + EU Influence + Digital Bridge + China Watcher + Politico Confidential + Global Policy Lab: Living Cities * Podcasts + EU Confidential + Westminster Insider + Power Play + Campaign Confidential + Davos Confidential + Politics at Jack and Sam's * our apps + POLITICO Pro app Play Store + POLITICO Pro app App Store * Social Links + Facebook + Twitter + LinkedIn Discover POLITICO Pro In-depth reporting, data and actionable intelligence for policy professionals - all in one place. What is POLITICO Pro? Policy areas Our Pro coverage Request a demo Contact us Hot Topics * The Qatargate Files * Israel-Hamas war * COP28 * War in Ukraine * EU-China * Poll of Polls Politico Pro Free From Germany's inefficient love affair with open windows A devotion to fresh air is undermining Berlin's push to make buildings more energy efficient. Queen Margrethe II Of Denmark Visits Berlin - Day 1 Germans' ventilation habits are hampering their efforts to make buildings more energy efficient | Sean Gallup/Getty Images By Aitor Hernandez-Morales March 23, 2021 6:26 pm CET 5 minutes read * Share on Facebook * Share on Twitter * Share on Linkedin * Share on WhatsApp * Mail * Print Press play to listen to this article Voiced by artificial intelligence. Germans are obsessed with luften, the act, or art, of ventilating their homes -- but it is undermining efforts to make buildings more energy efficient. Long considered to be a key measure for good respiratory hygiene, Germans often crack open windows to let nasty, stale air out and fresh, but cold, air in, even in the dead of winter. But for all the enthusiasm for crisp air circulation, researchers suggest that the national devotion to luften may be actively undermining buildings' energy efficiency -- and Berlin's emissions reduction goals. Buildings are responsible for approximately 40 percent of the EU's energy consumption and 36 percent of the bloc's CO2 emissions. As part of its drive to achieve climate neutrality by 2050, Brussels is pushing to make member countries' building stock emissions-free. Initiatives like its Renovation Wave strategy aim to improve the quality of the roughly three-quarters of EU buildings that aren't energy efficient. You may like Climate summit makes 'historic progress' -- but the world still can't quit oil By Karl Mathiesen, Zia Weise, Zack Colman and Sara Schonhardt COP28 ends with first ever call to move away from fossil fuels By Karl Mathiesen, Zack Colman, Zia Weise and Sara Schonhardt Building safer spaces for teenagers online By POLITICO Studio Germany has tackled the issue through its wider Energiewende green energy scheme, which set the goal of slashing primary energy consumption in residential and non-residential buildings by 80 percent by 2050. It also introduced tougher rules in its energy savings directive, which regulates heating technology and thermal insulation. But despite those efforts, CO2 savings in the building sector since 2010 have been very moderate. One reason the impact may have been less than expected is that while Berlin's guidelines have resulted in buildings that are technically very well insulated, costly energy efficiency elements have been largely undercut by residents' luften practices, according to an article in the journal Energy and Social Science. "The buildings we looked at were well insulated, but residents didn't fully understand the heating features, or the air recovery systems incorporated into the home," said Amelie Bauer, a researcher at Munich's Ludwig Maximilian University and one of the study's authors. "They stuck to their habits and kept opening windows to ventilate in accordance with their preferences." In the study, Bauer and her colleagues highlighted the different ventilation and temperature preferences of two residents of the same apartment building. One was a German woman who kept her windows open so that her living room was a brisk 19 degrees. The other was a Greek man, who preferred his home to be a balmy 27 degrees. "Those different preferences and habits place big demands on a single building when it is equipped with smart technology to keep air circulating and conserve heat, " Bauer said. "There's a tendency to create passive housing that is designed to be energy efficient without residents doing anything, but that ignores the fact that people are stubborn and do things anyway, and not in the standard way that's been recorded in engineers' labs." Shock ventilation An added problem is that German ventilation habits may themselves be very inefficient. "The correct way to ventilate a home is to employ the Stossluften, or shock ventilation method. You open your windows completely for three minutes if it's windy, five to 10 minutes if it's not," said Raymond Galvin, a researcher at the University of Aachen and Cambridge, who has written extensively about energy efficiency in Germany. "The problem is that, although most Germans swear that they only practice Stossluften, my research has found that hardly anyone actually does," he said, adding that the shock ventilation method was likely little used because of a fundamental design flaw in German homes. "In a country like Germany, windowsills are prime real estate for potted plants that need light, and framed pictures of your favorite grandmother," Galvin said. "But in Germany, the windows open inward, and nobody has time to clear that all out twice a day to fully open the window, so instead, people just open their window to a slightly tilted position." According to the researcher, it can take up to two hours to ventilate a room with windows that aren't fully open, and in that time, the walls cool fully, meaning more energy in needed to warm the room up again. Galvin conceded that it was unlikely Germany would change such a fundamental element of its housing design, but said it was a shame that a country that was "generally very good at moderately high-tech design is bad at basic stuff like noticing that there's a socio-technical mismatch between residents' needs and what windows are designed to do." The answer, Bauer said, might be to simply insulate less. "The key may be to have less insulation, because the current system seems to be too airtight to accomodate for residents' differing preferences," she said. "There are around 90 million buildings in Germany and about half will need to be renovated in the next 20 years, so less intense and less costly renovations would let us make more of them energy efficient faster." She added that the government would do well to expand its focus beyond just energy efficiency and look into how Germans really live. "People are living in increasingly big homes, so even though the energy costs per square meter have declined, the gains we've made through energy efficiency have been eaten up by the increase in living space per capita," she said, adding that Berlin might be well-served by teaching people to "live better with less." This article is part of POLITICO's premium policy service: Pro Energy and Climate. From climate change, emissions targets, alternative fuels and more, our specialized journalists keep you on top of the topics driving the Energy and Climate policy agenda. Email [email protected] for a complimentary trial. More from ... Aitor Hernandez-Morales Most Read Articles * 1 'End of reign': Macron faces ungovernable France after shock immigration loss December 12, 2023 6:57 pm CET * 2 The rumored resurrection of Austria-Hungary December 13, 2023 4:02 am CET * 3 Rishi Sunak's Brexit deal is up and running. It's 'cataclysmic' for UK food exports December 13, 2023 4:30 am CET * 4 'Cockroach strategy': How Europe failed to sap Russia's energy profits December 12, 2023 8:22 pm CET * 5 Donald Tusk sworn in as Polish PM December 13, 2023 1:35 pm CET Related Content * 'Cockroach strategy': How Europe failed to sap Russia's energy profits Russia's largest private oil firm Lukoil dominates Bulgaria's fuel production with its sprawling Black Sea refinery | Vassil Donev/EPA-EFE * Zelenskyy in Lilliput: Someone shrunk Ukraine's war coalition Juan Medina - Pool/Getty Images * UK flies its COP28 chief home early to help save Rishi Sunak's skin Graham Stuart's departure sparked a furious reaction from climate campaigners | Tolga Akmen/EFE via EPA * Trump who? Republicans in Dubai try to carve out their own climate agenda. Rep. Garret Graves (R-LA) talks to reporters as he leaves a House Republican caucus meeting | Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images * Anger erupts as fossil fuel 'phaseout' is dropped from proposed climate deal COP28 climate summit President Sultan al-Jaber, who also leads the United Arab Emirates' state-owned oil company, claps during a session Monday in Dubai | Sean Gallup/Getty Images Careers at POLITICO * Accounts Receivable Accountant Location: Brussels | Department: Finance & Legal * Customer Success, Team Lead (Brussels) Location: Brussels | Department: Sales & Biz Dev * Charge Marketing H/F (DII, Paris) Location: Paris | Department: DII * All job postings Careers at POLITICO View the Latest Issue [print-issue] Read the latest print issue online Next up The 2 days that salvaged a climate deal The 2 days that salvaged a climate deal December 13, 2023 11:03 pm CET By Karl Mathiesen, Sara Schonhardt, Zia Weise and Zack Colman Bulgaria moves to end Russia sanctions opt-out as pressure mounts Bulgaria moves to end Russia sanctions opt-out as pressure mounts December 13, 2023 8:05 pm CET By Victor Jack Latest EU sanctions package in limbo over Austrian checks Latest EU sanctions package in limbo over Austrian checks December 13, 2023 6:14 pm CET By Camille Gijs, Jacopo Barigazzi and Barbara Moens The price tag of COP28's renewable energy pledge The price tag of COP28's renewable energy pledge December 13, 2023 11:54 am CET By Giovanna Coi Related Tags Buildings Cities Emissions Energy Energy efficiency Green building Related Countries Germany Explore politico EU * Brussels Latest news, analysis and comment from POLITICO's editors and guest writers in Europe. * Germany Latest news, analysis and comment on German politics and beyond. * France Latest news, analysis and comment on French politics and beyond. * Elections in Europe Latest news, analysis and comment on elections in Europe and beyond. * Coronavirus in Europe The latest news, data and analysis on the world's pandemic response. * Migration Latest news, analysis and comment on migration in Europe and beyond. * Defense Latest news, analysis and comment on defense in Europe and beyond. * Continent Latest news, analysis and comment from POLITICO's editors and guest writers on the continent. * Policy Areas + Agriculture and Food + Competition and Industrial Policy + Cybersecurity and Data Protection + Health Care + Energy and Climate + Energy and Climate UK + EU-UK + Defense + Financial Services + Central Banker + Mobility + Sustainability + Technology + Technology UK + Trade + Trade UK + Paris Influence * Newsletters + Brussels Playbook + Playbook Paris + Dimanchissime + London Playbook + Global Playbook + Sunday Crunch + Politico Confidential + London Influence + EU Influence + Global Policy Lab: Living Cities + Berlin Bulletin + Digital Bridge + China Watcher Explore Products * Series + POLITICO 28 Series + Global Policy Lab + Climate, Changed + Work Reloaded + Silent Killers + After Corona + The Road to COP26 + Telescope: AIDS + EU in Africa + Changemakers + The wonk's survival guide to the EU Green Deal * Commentary + Unpacked + Beyond the Bubble + From Across the Pond + Club Med + Declassified * Podcasts + EU Confidential + Westminster Insider + Power Play + Davos Confidential + Campaign Confidential + Politics at Jack and Sam's * our apps + Play Store POLITICO Pro app + App Store POLITICO Pro app + Print Edition * POLITICO Live Explore the live extension of our journalism * Discover POLITICO Pro In-depth reporting, data and actionable intelligence for policy professionals - all in one place. * POLITICO Research and Analysis Division Politico Logo * About us * Contact us * Privacy Policy * Cookie Policy * Media Solutions * Research and Analysis Division * Press * Print Edition * Jobs * Careers at POLITICO * Ts&Cs * FAQs * Manage Privacy Settings Close login modal Log in Log in to access content and manage your profile. If you do not have an account you can register here. Email address [ ] Password [ ] Forgot your password? [*] Remember me Log in By logging in, you confirm acceptance of our POLITICO Privacy Policy.