https://theintercept.com/2023/12/20/new-york-times-doxxes-source-human-trafficking/ Search for: [ ] [Search] * Politics * Justice * National Security * World * Technology * Environment * Special Investigations * Voices * Podcasts * Videos * Documents Become A Member * About * Policies And Reports * Become a Source * Join Newsletter * * * * * * * * * (c) THE INTERCEPT ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Terms of Use Privacy BERLIN, GERMANY - OCTOBER 06: In this photo illustration the Logo of Newspaper New York Times App is illuminated on a smartphone close to a finger on October 06, 2023 in Berlin, Germany. (Photo Illustration by Thomas Trutschel/Photothek via Getty Images) Donate Become a member New York Times Doxxes Source Trafficked by Chinese Gang Logo of the New York Times app on a smartphone on Oct. 6, 2023 in Berlin. Photo Illustration: Thomas Trutschel/Photothek via Getty Images New York Times Doxxes Source Trafficked by Chinese Gang An at-risk source entrusted the paper with protecting his sensitive personal information. Then the Times published it for the world to see. Nikita Mazurov December 20 2023, 3:51 p.m. Donate BERLIN, GERMANY - OCTOBER 06: In this photo illustration the Logo of Newspaper New York Times App is illuminated on a smartphone close to a finger on October 06, 2023 in Berlin, Germany. (Photo Illustration by Thomas Trutschel/Photothek via Getty Images) Logo of the New York Times app on a smartphone on Oct. 6, 2023 in Berlin. Photo Illustration: Thomas Trutschel/Photothek via Getty Images The New York Times this week published the harrowing account of a man who thought he was applying for a translator job at an e-commerce company in Thailand, but was instead abducted and sold to a Chinese gang who forced him to work for a scam operation in Myanmar. The Times, which withheld Neo Lu's real name at his request for safety reasons, revealed identifying information about Lu to the public -- and potentially the Chinese gangsters who took him hostage -- by publishing what appears to be his passport number. Most Read [GettyImage] Secret Pakistan Document Undermines Espionage Case Against Imran Khan Ryan Grim, Murtaza Hussain [siegler-pa] Kelly Siegler Is a True-Crime Celebrity. Did She Frame an Innocent Man for Murder? Jordan Smith, Liliana Segura [GettyImage] A Defense-Linked Contractor Took Over a Successful CDC Anti-Overdose Initiative. It Imploded in a Day. Noah Hurowitz "Mr. Lu, who goes by the nickname Neo for the character in the Matrix movies, spoke to The New York Times on the condition that his full name not be used, for fear of retribution from the criminals," reporter Isabelle Qian wrote in the Times story. According to the account in the newspaper, Lu had provided the Times with photos of his time at the scam work camp, as well as copies of his travel documents to verify the authenticity of his situation. While the Times published several of photos of the camp, the paper also published a photo of a visa page that appears to be from Lu's passport, publicly revealing his passport number. Though the photo revealed what appeared to be Lu's passport number alongside travel visa information, it did not display the story subject's full name. Join Our Newsletter Original reporting. Fearless journalism. Delivered to you. I'm in The photo did not appear in the online version of the article, but it was publicly accessible on the Times website through its specific web address. After The Intercept contacted the paper, on the same day that the story was published, the Times removed the photo from its public website. In response to a request for comment, Nicole Taylor, a spokesperson for the New York Times, said, "Mr. Lu supplied a range of photos and documents to The Times, which we used with his permission. We removed this photo out of an abundance of caution and within 24 hours of publication." Taylor added that "the source is aware and has not raised concerns." Other images that appeared to not be intended for public consumption were also subsequently removed from the Times's website after The Intercept informed the Times of their presence. Among them was a graphic photo Lu apparently snapped of himself showing scars on his body, as well as a snippet of a text message conversation appearing to show a discussion between the gang and Lu's parents regarding the ransom the gang had demanded for Lu. Once the photos were removed, the old image URLs began displaying the message, "We're sorry, we seem to have lost this page, but we don't want to lose you," the standard error message the Times displays when accessing an unavailable webpage. The revelation of Lu's passport number could potentially identify Lu to the gang that held him at the labor camp. According to the article, "The gangs often take away the abductees' passports and let their visas expire" -- meaning the gang could have access to Lu's passport information. The Times story feature art -- at the top of the article -- is a mosaic composed of various images apparently supplied by Lu, including interior and exterior shots of the work camp. The mosaic is composed of 10 images. In the original article, the images' URLs had irregular numbering, jumping from four to 20. Though only 10 of those 20 images were utilized in the opening mosaic by the Times, it was possible to view any of the 20 images by changing the image number in the file name listed in the image's URL. [AP23172035123109-new-york-times-archive] Related New York Times Doesn't Want Its Stories Archived The unused assets being publicly available is not new; the practice is particularly common with video game developers, with gamers routinely finding unused game assets in the file systems of video game releases. The issue has arisen with nongovernmental organizations as well. This is not the first time the Times has unintentionally revealed personally identifiable information about story subjects. Last year, the Times revealed phone numbers of Russian soldiers and their family members who were being critical of Vladimir Putin and the war effort. The Times later went so far as to remove the news story from the website archival service the Wayback Machine; the paper has been actively antagonistic to having its site archived. Software developers have automated tools to help them scan their source code to prevent inadvertently publicly revealing sensitive information. As a best practice in journalism, however, there is no substitute for human discretion when handling sensitive materials entrusted to a newsroom by an at-risk source. Contact the author: Head shot of Nikita Mazurov Nikita Mazurov Related The New York Times logo is displayed outside their building, Tuesday, June 20, 2023, in New York. (Aaron M. Sprecher via AP) New York Times Doesn't Want Its Stories Archived The New York Times Building in New York City on February 1, 2022. - The New York Times announced on January 31, 2022, it had bought Wordle, a phenomenon played by millions just four months after the game burst onto the Internet, for an "undisclosed price in the low seven figures." Created by engineer Josh Wardle, the game consists of guessing one five-letter word per day in just six tries. (Photo by ANGELA WEISS / AFP) (Photo by ANGELA WEISS/AFP via Getty Images) New York Times Makes Glaring Error About Iraq War -- Then Corrects It Incorrectly The National Security Agency and Central Security Service (NSA CSS) building in Fort Meade, Md., (Photo by Brooks Kraft LLC/Corbis via Getty Images) New York Times Spokesperson Came to Paper From National Security Agency An Iraqi civilian looks through personal files, Thursday April 10, 2003, scattered on the floor of the bombed out White Lion, the building that housed the secret police documents, jail cells, and interrogation chambers where Saddam Hussein's Baath Party leaders kept political prisoners in basra, Iraq. (AP Photo/David Guttenfelder) A U.S. Journalist Took Thousands of ISIS Files Out of Iraq, Reigniting a Bitter Dispute Over the Theft of Iraqi History Latest Stories The Treasury Building is viewed in Washington, May 4, 2021. The U.S. government has imposed sanctions on a Bosnian state prosecutor who is accused of being complicit in corruption and undermining democratic processes or institutions in the Western Balkans. The Treasury Department says its Office of Foreign Assets Control designated Diana Kajmakovic for sanctions. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky, File) Barring Speakers Under U.S. Sanctions Puts Ideas Off-Limits, Say Free Speech Advocates Murtaza Hussain - 12:28 pm "The question at the core of the case is what control the U.S. government has over the American mind." TOPSHOT - In this picture taken during a media tour organized by the Israeli military on December 15, 2023, an Israeli soldier exits a tunnel that Hamas reportedly used to attack Israel through the Erez border crossing on October 7. The Israeli army said on December 17, 2023 it had uncovered the biggest Hamas tunnel in the Gaza Strip so far, just a few hundred meters from the Erez border crossing. (Photo by JACK GUEZ / AFP) (Photo by JACK GUEZ/AFP via Getty Images) Israel's War on Gaza Industrial Killing of Civilians in Gaza Won't Defeat the Armed Insurgency Jeremy Scahill - 12:14 pm As Israel excels in massacring civilians and destroying Gaza's infrastructure, its ground offensive against Hamas is becoming a quagmire. NPS / Jacob W. Frank Grizzly Bear Poachers Flout the Endangered Species Act -- and Get Away With It Ryan Devereaux, Jimmy Tobias - 12:00 pm A trove of investigative files reveals that the Department of Justice almost never prosecutes grizzly bear killers under the powerful law. Join The Conversation Join Our Newsletter Original reporting. Fearless journalism. Delivered to you. [ ] [ ] I'm in Become a Member By signing up, I agree to receive emails from The Intercept and to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. * About * Policies And Reports * Become a Source * Join Newsletter * Become A Member * Terms of Use * Privacy * SECUREDROP (c) The Intercept. All rights reserved