https://www.niemanlab.org/2023/12/the-web-floods/ Nieman Lab. Predictions for Journalism, 2024. Prediction The web floods Name Ben Werdmuller Excerpt "Newsrooms that commit to AI-driven storytelling as a way to cut costs while increasing output will be lost in a sea of similarly bland content and spammy marketing." Prediction ID 42656e205765 In 2024, more for-profit newsrooms will produce content using AI in an effort to reduce costs and increase pageviews. They will be joined by thousands of other businesses, industries, and marketers who will use AI at scale to try and gain attention and leads by any means necessary. Marketers are already bragging about their ability to "steal" traffic by generating thousands of articles near-instantly on subjects likely to attract attention for their clients. For private equity firms seeking to maximize investment in their portfolio of advertising-funded publishing businesses, the allure may be too much to resist. Over the last year, more publishers have chosen to create AI content; more publishers have also unquestioningly run sponsored content from marketers who used AI. This trend will accelerate next year. In a world where the web is flooded with robot content, traditional search engines will be less effective ways to find information. Vendors like Google will prioritize providing quick answers to user questions using their own AI models instead of primarily displaying listings that click through to websites. SEO, in turn, will stop being an effective traffic-building tactic. Social media will begin to follow in its wake. AI-driven bots will overcome obstacles created by social media platforms in order to share messages and seek to sway opinion at a far greater rate than we've seen previously. They will be enabled by new models that allow them to seem more natural; they'll be motivated by the election. Cutting through the noise to inform the public will be harder than ever before -- and more important than ever before. Newsrooms will need to build direct connections if they are to survive. This means moving beyond the traditional idea of an "audience" to engage with readers, members, and volunteers in a participative manner. They will need to listen, converse, and adapt to what their communities tell them they need. They will need to adopt a service-oriented approach rather than one of institutional authority. In doing so, newsrooms must deliver unique, irreplaceable value to their communities. While simple reporting may be approximated by AI, deep journalism cannot be. Software agents cannot speak to sources, uncover misconduct, follow leads, or speak truth to power. Because AI models replicate the biases and systemic injustices of the data they're trained on, they also cannot speak for diverse communities. They can't elevate points of view and highlight the lived experiences of underrepresented voices, because those points of view and lived experiences are also underrepresented in the datasets they were trained on. AI can't investigate, it can't represent, and it can't advocate for change. It also can't, by technical definition, create the kind of truly original work that is worth sharing. Newsrooms that commit to AI-driven storytelling as a way to cut costs while increasing output will be lost in a sea of similarly bland content and spammy marketing. Newsrooms that cling to traditional SEO and social media tactics will find that they become less and less effective in the face of more and more noise. In contrast, the newsrooms that survive the flooding of the web are going to be the ones that report deeply, commit to diverse representation, invest in investigative journalism in the public interest, and choose to meet their communities where they're at by doing things that don't scale to engage them. These newsrooms are more likely to be smaller nonprofits that already report in the public interest, which support themselves through membership communities of people who pay simply because they want the journalism to exist. They're more likely to build teams that are more representative of their communities. Some are already building "street teams" of diverse volunteers who can reach out to groups they are a part of. They're reporting new stories that other newsrooms have failed to uncover. They're reaching out across community spaces and new social media platforms, with a bias towards experimentation and learning. They're collaborating by republishing each other's stories and building coalitions across organizational lines. These tactics are already working; these newsrooms are already growing. When the web floods, they will lead the way. Ben Werdmuller is an independent technology leader working in public interest journalism. [ben-werdmuller-1] In 2024, more for-profit newsrooms will produce content using AI in an effort to reduce costs and increase pageviews. They will be joined by thousands of other businesses, industries, and marketers who will use AI at scale to try and gain attention and leads by any means necessary. Marketers are already bragging about their ability to "steal" traffic by generating thousands of articles near-instantly on subjects likely to attract attention for their clients. For private equity firms seeking to maximize investment in their portfolio of advertising-funded publishing businesses, the allure may be too much to resist. Over the last year, more publishers have chosen to create AI content; more publishers have also unquestioningly run sponsored content from marketers who used AI. This trend will accelerate next year. In a world where the web is flooded with robot content, traditional search engines will be less effective ways to find information. Vendors like Google will prioritize providing quick answers to user questions using their own AI models instead of primarily displaying listings that click through to websites. SEO, in turn, will stop being an effective traffic-building tactic. Social media will begin to follow in its wake. AI-driven bots will overcome obstacles created by social media platforms in order to share messages and seek to sway opinion at a far greater rate than we've seen previously. They will be enabled by new models that allow them to seem more natural; they'll be motivated by the election. Cutting through the noise to inform the public will be harder than ever before -- and more important than ever before. Newsrooms will need to build direct connections if they are to survive. This means moving beyond the traditional idea of an "audience" to engage with readers, members, and volunteers in a participative manner. They will need to listen, converse, and adapt to what their communities tell them they need. They will need to adopt a service-oriented approach rather than one of institutional authority. In doing so, newsrooms must deliver unique, irreplaceable value to their communities. While simple reporting may be approximated by AI, deep journalism cannot be. Software agents cannot speak to sources, uncover misconduct, follow leads, or speak truth to power. Because AI models replicate the biases and systemic injustices of the data they're trained on, they also cannot speak for diverse communities. They can't elevate points of view and highlight the lived experiences of underrepresented voices, because those points of view and lived experiences are also underrepresented in the datasets they were trained on. AI can't investigate, it can't represent, and it can't advocate for change. It also can't, by technical definition, create the kind of truly original work that is worth sharing. Newsrooms that commit to AI-driven storytelling as a way to cut costs while increasing output will be lost in a sea of similarly bland content and spammy marketing. Newsrooms that cling to traditional SEO and social media tactics will find that they become less and less effective in the face of more and more noise. In contrast, the newsrooms that survive the flooding of the web are going to be the ones that report deeply, commit to diverse representation, invest in investigative journalism in the public interest, and choose to meet their communities where they're at by doing things that don't scale to engage them. These newsrooms are more likely to be smaller nonprofits that already report in the public interest, which support themselves through membership communities of people who pay simply because they want the journalism to exist. They're more likely to build teams that are more representative of their communities. Some are already building "street teams" of diverse volunteers who can reach out to groups they are a part of. They're reporting new stories that other newsrooms have failed to uncover. They're reaching out across community spaces and new social media platforms, with a bias towards experimentation and learning. They're collaborating by republishing each other's stories and building coalitions across organizational lines. These tactics are already working; these newsrooms are already growing. When the web floods, they will lead the way. Ben Werdmuller is an independent technology leader working in public interest journalism. Each year, Nieman Lab asks some of the smartest people in journalism what they think is coming in the new year. Here are their predictions for 2024. See the full list - Meredith Artley For more engagement and trust, try this one weird trick Eric Nuzum This election year, don't forget there's more than one story Christa Scharfenberg More public funding for local news Cindy Royal AI changes everything...and nothing Mauricio Cabrera The year of the horizontal newsroom Dominic-Madori Davis Experts -- not influencers -- will cover more Black news Candace Amos News publishers find their brand voice on social Brian Stelter Media owners in the crosshairs as Trump craves retribution Rubina Madan Fillion Humans hold their own against the robots Brian Moritz A major sports betting journalism scandal is coming Dannagal G. Young TV rewards the authoritarian candidate Anya Schiffrin Publishers keep trying to extract revenue from Google Ben Werdmuller The web floods Joshua P. Darr Local news will adapt to low demand Sisi Wei News mirages (not news deserts) are the scarier problem Eugene Sonn Durable over disposable Chase Davis Trust good, crap bad Bassey Etim Rise of the news DJs Jessica Maddox TV reporters become TikTok influencers Alvaro Liuzzi The algorithm will be the message Gordon Crovitz AI gets accurate Kristen Muller An open letter to the incoming CEO of NPR Burt Herman More open source AI Stephen Fowler The "touch grass" election cycle Mario Garcia AI takes center stage Alfred Hermida Journalism prepares for a post-search, post-social future Cherian George In a year of polarized elections, media will be a target Alexandra Borchardt Everyone in the newsroom gets training Ryan Kellett Celebrities will endorse publishers (and get paid for it) Ernest Kung AI gets widely adopted by smaller newsrooms Phoebe Connelly Peer support will be a critical part of newsroom resilience Thomas Baekdal Returning to a contextual focus Richard Tofel The AI copyright watershed comes into view Adam Thomas Nonprofits embrace profits Andrew Losowsky Publishers will finally be influenced by influencers Rasmus Kleis Nielsen Ignore the coming election bump Laxmi Parthasarathy It's time to prioritize audiences we know we can't monetize Matt DeRienzo One issue will dominate election coverage in both red and blue states Dana Lacey Publishers embrace open source Stale Grut The press adopts a new level of transparency around images Simon Galperin Local news' library moment Sam Guzik Devices are the new gatekeepers Fernanda Santos Journalism outside urban areas thrives Amethyst J. Davis Press Forward must prove itself to the Black press Anika Anand Journalism intermediaries start to coordinate Ashley Woods Branch Collaboration with ethnic and identity publishers becomes a must Robin Kwong Newsrooms (re)discover the magic of project management Nikki Usher The future-of-journalism crowd stops ignoring local TV news A.J. Bauer Hyperlocal information warfare rises up Gina Chua Too many news orgs adopt right-wing frames about trans people Julia Munslow Journalists will go on camera for social video Linda Solomon Wood After the breakup, Canadian news orgs learn to live without Facebook Rodney Gibbs The rise of the AI class Upasna Gautam We get agile Sam Cholke News confronts reaching audiences in a post-social world Jean Friedman Rudovsky We learn to unlearn Sarah Marshall We get past "post-platform" Updating until Dec. 21 What to read next These stories are our most popular on Twitter over the past 30 days. See all our most recent pieces [fuego-logo] Fuego is our heat-seeking Twitter bot, tracking the links the future-of-journalism crowd is talking about most on Twitter. Here are a few of the top links Fuego's currently watching. Get the full Fuego [encyclo-new-logo-futura] Encyclo is our encyclopedia of the future of news, chronicling the key players in journalism's evolution. Here are a few of the entries you'll find in Encyclo. Get the full Encyclo International Consortium of Investigative Journalists Newsday Corporation for Public Broadcasting BBC News Center for Public Integrity MediaNews Group Byliner OpenFile The Batavian Mashable Upworthy Suck.com [lab-logo-c] * Subscribe * Twitter * Facebook * iPhone app * RSS * * About * Contact * Archives * Encyclo * Fuego Help advance the Nieman Foundation's mission "to promote and elevate the standards of journalism" by making a donation. [foundation] To promote and elevate the standards of journalism [reports-lo] Covering thought leadership in journalism [lab-logo-c] Pushing to the future of journalism [storyboard] Exploring the art and craft of story (c) 2023 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College / Some rights reserved Harvard Trademark Privacy Walter Lippmann House One Francis Ave. Cambridge, MA 02138 617 495 2237 The Nieman Journalism Lab is a collaborative attempt to figure out how quality journalism can survive and thrive in the Internet age. It's a project of the Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard University. Follow us * Subscribe to our email * Follow us on Twitter * Like us on Facebook * Download our iPhone app * Subscribe via RSS Subscribe to our work - The basics * About us * Contact * Archives Projects * Encyclo * Fuego * Tweet archive About us - Director Joshua Benton Staff writers Justin Ellis Caroline O'Donovan (c) President and Fellows of Harvard College, unless otherwise noted. Some rights reserved. Quantcast