https://www.lemonde.fr/en/le-monde-africa/article/2023/12/10/the-united-arab-emirates-takeover-of-african-forests_6328426_124.html Monday, December 11, 2023 12:01 am (Paris) Navigation Go Back to the HomePage Sign in Sign in Subscribe * * Home nav_back_to_home * News In the news + Israel-Hamas war + COP28 + France + War in Ukraine + Europe + United States + Environment + Emmanuel Macron + Paris Olympics 2024 All sections + Global issues + Economy + Science + Investigations + Magazine + Obituaries + Food + Sports + Lifestyle + Culture + Travel + Intimacy + Pixels + Les Decodeurs + Religion + About Us * International + International + United States + United Kingdom + Europe + Africa + Letters from [1611ad7_5075541-01-06] International Zelensky, Bolsonaro to attend Javier Milei's inauguration ceremony in Argentina The Ukrainian army during training on Thursday November 23 in the Zaporizhzhia region. International Why is Ukraine's counteroffensive failing? [9926cef_1702055833981-27] International Subscribers only Besieged once again, Gaza's health system is in agony Damon prison, near Mount Carmel, south of Haifa (Israel), December 7, 2023. International Subscribers only The trauma of Israeli Arab women freed in exchanges with Hamas * Videos + Videos + Investigations + Explainers [827e51f_1700418966835-uk] Videos Why are Ukrainian special forces fighting Russia's Wagner mercenaries in Sudan? [07992e0_2023-10-21t13465] Videos Why is the United States Israel's closest ally? [eb37203_1698682824241-is] Videos Israel-Palestine: Six videos to understand the context behind the war in Gaza [5641181_1697718160518-00] Videos Why does Israel build settlements in the occupied West Bank? * Environment + Environment + Climate + Nature + Energy + Oceans [d993b19_1702051041899-08] Environment Subscribers only Covid-19 soars in France as Christmas nears COP28, Dubai, December 5, 2023. Environment Subscribers only COP28: Fossil fuel taxation at the heart of the battle to finance climate transition A pollution simulation zone at COP28, Dubai, United Arab Emirates, December 4, 2023. Environment Subscribers only COP28: Opposite positions on fossil fuels divide the UN climate conference Screenshot of a video made by members of the NGO PETA, in one of the seven frog capture and slaughter centers in Java, Bali and Sumatra, in 2023. Environment Subscribers only The dark side of eating frogs: Animal suffering and declining amphibian populations * France + France + French Politics + Emmanuel Macron + Paris [a047877_1702046168257-00] France Subscribers only Complex trial ends with conviction of six teenagers over 2020 beheading of French teacher Emmanuel Macron at the celebration of the 105th anniversary of the November 11, 1918 armistice, in Paris, November 11, 2023. France Subscribers only As social tensions heighten in France, Macron tells Le Monde he wants to restore hope in the future [af36f22_1701703853383-ro] France Subscribers only After the killing of a teenager, a chasm opened in a French town Ultra-right-wing demonstrators at a rally in Saint-Brevin-les-Pins (Loire-Atlantique), February 25, 2023. France Subscribers only What is the Martel Division, the neonazi group banned by the French government? * Opinion + Opinion + Editorials + Columns + Op-Eds + Analysis Caisse d'allocations familiales du Languedoc-Roussillon, Montpellier, October 15, 2019. Opinion Subscribers only Thomas Piketty: 'Anti-poor ideology ultimately leads to a general deterioration in the quality of public service' Activist and journalist Narges Mohammadi, at an unknown date; photo provided by the Narges Mohammadi Foundation on October 2, 2023. Opinion Subscribers only Narges Mohammadi: 'Our cause is more about survival than the improvement of our quality of life' Emmanuel Macron, presenting his plan for the future of French research, at the Elysee Palace, Paris, December 7, 2023. Editorial The huge challenge of revamping French research The US aircraft carrier International Subscribers only Israel-Hamas war: 'The conflict in Gaza is extending out to sea' * French Delights + French Delights + Exhibitions + Gastronomy + Culture Dorothee Gilbert and Guillaume Diop in rehearsal for Rudolf Nureyev's ballet Culture Subscribers only Backstage at the Paris Opera's 'Nutcracker' ballet [60e25bc_1701427750087-1] Culture Subscribers only A Gazan museum takes shape in the clouds at Paris's Institut de Monde Arabe [62aed2f_1699453964080-mo] Lifestyle Subscribers only Fashion and sport team up at the Musee des Arts Decoratifs Mark Rothko, in New York in March 1961, during the MoMA exhibition. Culture Subscribers only Rothko, painter of the intimate and the intense * Africa * COP28 The United Arab Emirates' takeover of African forests As the oil-rich country hosts COP28, an Emirati company has signed agreements in Liberia, Tanzania, Zambia and Zimbabwe to convert part of their land into carbon credits - acts of 'greenwashing' and 'colonialism,' some NGOs say. By Clement Bonnerot Published yesterday at 5:09 am (Paris), updated yesterday at 5:09 am Time to 5 min. Lire en francais * Share Share + Share on Twitter + Share on Messenger + Share on Facebook + Share by email + Share on Linkedin + Copy link Bopolu forest, Liberia, November 2021. Bopolu forest, Liberia, November 2021. Bopolu forest, Liberia, November 2021. JOHN WESSELS/ AFP With a handshake and a discreet smile, Sheikh Ahmed Dalmook al-Maktoum, accompanied by the Liberian finance minister, gave nothing away in front of photographers on March 25. The young member of the ruling family of Dubai, one of the seven emirates in the United Arab Emirates (UAE), had just signed an unprecedented memorandum of understanding with Liberia. Under the terms of the agreement, the Liberian government will grant the company he heads, Blue Carbon LLC, exclusive rights to one million hectares of its forests - 10% of the West African country's total forest area - for 30 years. Read more Article reserve a nos abonnes Liberia set to concede 10% of its territory to Emirati company for carbon credit production "This bilateral association marks another milestone for Blue Carbon," the prince told the Emirati press. The aim is ambitious: to "help transition to a low-carbon economical system" by enabling governments around the world reach "their Net Zero goals in compliance with the transferability of credits under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement." The "credits" referred to by the sheikh are carbon credits, which companies can buy to avoid having to reduce their emissions. Article 6 of the Paris Climate Agreement, reached in December 2015 at COP21, authorized signatory countries to work together to achieve their greenhouse gas emission reduction targets. Put simply, a country reducing its emissions beyond its forecasts can sell its surpluses in the form of credits to a more polluting country, which can use them to offset its own emissions. 'Escaping responsibilities' "This notion of offsetting is the subject of much debate," explained Jutta Kill, a biologist by training and a specialist in carbon markets. "Allowing industrialized countries to use carbon credits under the Paris Agreement allows them to escape their responsibilities, simply because they can afford to pay." On its website, Blue Carbon simply states that it wants to "help" governments take advantage of this mechanism. Created in August 2022, the company has signed memorandums of understanding for forest management projects with four African countries in record time. These arrangements cover 10% of the total surface area of Liberia, as well as Tanzania, Zambia and 20% of Zimbabwe, for a total of 25 million hectares - almost half that of France. Read more Article reserve a nos abonnes COP28: For the US, the climate battle will be won with oil companies, not at their expense For the time being, these agreements are preliminary. The rules governing the trading of carbon credits are due to be set at COP28, held in the UAE from November 30. "Countries are still waiting for clear, concrete rules for using this tool, for example regarding project registration and monitoring," said Erika Lennon, a researcher at the US-based Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL). Contacted by Le Monde, Blue Carbon confirmed that it is particularly looking forward to "Article 6.4 operationalization," which provides for the creation of a global carbon market, controlled by a supervisory body placed under the aegis of the United Nations. Officially, Blue Carbon is a private company, independent of the Emirati state, and it insists that the carbon credits generated by its projects are intended to be sold to various countries, "not only the UAE." 'From rule-breaker to rule-maker' But the family ties of its founder and a confidential, provisional and unsigned version of the memorandum of understanding between Blue Carbon and the Liberian government suggest an alignment between the company's interests and those of the UAE. In an appendix to this document, which Le Monde was able to consult, a timetable envisages the signing of a "framework agreement" for the transfer of carbon credits between the Emirati and Liberian governments at COP28. Partner service Learn French with Gymglish Thanks to a daily lesson, an original story and a personalized correction, in 15 minutes per day. Try for free When questioned on the subject, Blue Carbon refused to comment on "a mere draft". If confirmed, this framework agreement would be the latest in a series of initiatives attesting to the UAE's growing interest in these transactions. In June, several major companies with ties to the Emirates joined forces to form the UAE Carbon Alliance to develop a national carbon market. In September, the organization announced its intention to purchase over EUR410 million worth of African carbon credits by 2030. Opinion Article reserve a nos abonnes COP28: 'The UAE is the ideal place to put the question of the exit from fossil oil and gas on the table' This interest comes as no surprise. The world's 7^th-largest oil producer has no intention of abandoning fossil fuel extraction, even though this has been identified as the main cause of global warming, but it will not remain on the sidelines of climate negotiations either. "Rhe UAE used to be a rule breaker in its staunch defense of fossil fuels. More recently, and as host of COP28, the UAE is adopting a rule shaping function whereby it tries to massage or influence conversations around fossil fuels to maximize space for the latter's continued existence," said Li-Chen Sim, a non-resident researcher at the American think-tank Middle East Institute. COP28 is chaired by Sultan al-Jaber, the Emirati industry minister and CEO of the national oil company, Abu Dhabi National Oil Company (ADNOC). In November 2022, Adnoc announced plans to increase its production capacity to 5 million barrels per day by 2027. Read more Article reserve a nos abonnes COP28 president says he 'respects' climate science after leaked video Cleaning up the polluter's image To sidestep calls to phase out fossil fuels, "the UAE is trying to further the general concept and acceptability of offsets," said Souparna Lahiri, climate advisor to the Global Forest Coalition. "Having a few allies [with several countries willing to work with Blue Carbon] is a good strategy for them." But there are also fears of a vast public relations campaign to clean up their image as polluters: "These credits will be used by UAE and other rich polluting countries to increase their fossil fuel production," said Alexandra Benjamin, an expert in forest governance with the Dutch NGO Fern. "It will further increase the climate crisis." Concerns are further reinforced by the fact that the very effectiveness of these carbon credits is being called into question. In January, a joint survey by SourceMaterial, The Guardian and Die Zeit revealed that 94% of credits from forest management projects were of no benefit to the climate. Read more COP28: The phase-out of fossil fuels should finally be brought to the table These projects are in fact based on a complex calculation: Developers must quantify the volume of CO2 that would be emitted in the absence of their project and then that which their project can avoid. The difference between the two corresponds to the number of carbon credits that can be sold. "Several methodologies have been developed by project developers themselves," explained specialist Kill. "The problem is that these are not measurements, but estimates. Developers have every interest in overestimating their calculations." In its response to Le Monde, Blue Carbon urged NGOs "not to assume that entities like ours are seeking to implement old, outdated and much-criticized frameworks." But it did not specify what methodology it intended to use. Lion's share According to Axel Michaelowa, a researcher in international climate policy at the University of Zurich, the company could generate up to 250 million carbon credits a year. Enough to offset, in theory, the entire CO2 emissions of the United Arab Emirates. Meanwhile, in Liberia, more than a million people could see their livelihoods affected by Blue Carbon's project, according to the NGO Fern. The transfer of land to the company would constitute a violation of the land rights of the communities that depend on it, warned the Independent Coordination of Forest Monitoring, which is made up of Liberian civil society organizations, in July. Christine Umutoni, the UN resident coordinator in the country, echoed this view to the Liberian government in August. "Proceeding without thorough public consultation all but guarantees legal conflict, continued negative perception of the project, and devaluation of the very credits you are hoping to bring to market," she wrote in the letter, which Le Monde has been able to consult. According to the memorandum of understanding, Blue Carbon would also receive 70% of revenues from the sale of carbon credits, while the Liberian government would receive only 30%. "Who owns the forest?" asked Andrew Zeleman, secretary of the National Union of Liberia's Community Forestry Development Committee, "There shouldn't be a middleman taking the lion's share." Against this backdrop, NGOs such as Fern, which specializes in forest protection, described the practices as "carbon colonialism." "These deals also undermine these countries' chance to use these forests to meet their own climate commitments," said Benjamin. "These deals are large-scale land grabs (...) a false solution to the climate crisis." This investigation was carried out in partnership with the British investigative collective SourceMaterial and The Telegraph. Clement Bonnerot Translation of an original article published in French on lemonde.fr; the publisher may only be liable for the French version. Lecture du Monde en cours sur un autre appareil. Vous pouvez lire Le Monde sur un seul appareil a la fois Continuer a lire ici Ce message s'affichera sur l'autre appareil. Decouvrir les offres multicomptes Pourquoi voyez-vous ce message ? * Parce qu'une autre personne (ou vous) est en train de lire Le Monde avec ce compte sur un autre appareil. Vous ne pouvez lire Le Monde que sur un seul appareil a la fois (ordinateur, telephone ou tablette). * Comment ne plus voir ce message ? En cliquant sur << Continuer a lire ici >> et en vous assurant que vous etes la seule personne a consulter Le Monde avec ce compte. * Que se passera-t-il si vous continuez a lire ici ? Ce message s'affichera sur l'autre appareil. Ce dernier restera connecte avec ce compte. * Y a-t-il d'autres limites ? Non. Vous pouvez vous connecter avec votre compte sur autant d'appareils que vous le souhaitez, mais en les utilisant a des moments differents. * Vous ignorez qui est l'autre personne ? Nous vous conseillons de modifier votre mot de passe. Lecture restreinte Votre abonnement n'autorise pas la lecture de cet article Pour plus d'informations, merci de contacter notre service commercial. Subscribe to help support the work of our entire newsroom. Why are you seeing this message ? You have opted to refuse the use of cookies while browsing our website, including personalized advertising cookies. The content of this website is the work of over 530 journalists who deliver high-quality, reliable and comprehensive news and innovative online services every day. This work is supported by additional revenue from advertising and subscriptions. Subscribe Already a subscriber ? Sign in [ ] Sections * International * French politics * France * Les Decodeurs * Sports * Environment * Science * Campus * Le Monde Africa * Pixels * Health * Obituaries * Archives * About Us [ ] French Focus * Rugby World Cup 2023 * Tour de France 2023 * Paris Olympics 2024 * Emmanuel Macron [ ] Opinion * Editorials * Columns * Analysis Subscription Sign up Sign In Le Monde in English Sign up to receive our future daily selection of "Le Monde" articles translated into English. Sign up [ ] Informations legales le Monde * Mentions legales * Conditions generales * Charte du Groupe * Politique de confidentialite * Aide (FAQ) * Legal Information * Group Policy * Privacy Policy * Cookie Preferences * Terms & Conditions * FAQ Follow Le Monde * Facebook * Youtube * Twitter * Instagram * RSS feed