https://www.pcgamer.com/for-the-love-of-all-that-is-holy-its-2023why-is-it-still-so-annoying-to-respec-in-singleplayer-rpgs/ Skip to main content (*) ( ) Open menu Close menu PC Gamer THE GLOBAL AUTHORITY ON PC GAMES [ ] Search Search PC Gamer [ ] Subscribe US Edition flag of US flag of UK UK flag of US US flag of Canada Canada flag of Australia Australia PC Gamer Magazine Subscription PC Gamer Magazine Subscription Why subscribe? * Subscribe to the world's #1 PC gaming mag * Try a single issue or save on a subscription * Issues delivered straight to your door or device From$10.99 View * * News * Reviews * Hardware * Best Of * Magazine * The Top 100 * Forum * More + PC Gaming Show + Podcasts + Coupons + Newsletter SignUp + Community Guidelines + Affiliate Links + Meet the team + About PC Gamer Popular * Black Friday Deals * Steam Deck OLED * GTA 6 * CS2 * Alan Wake 2 * BlizzCon When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here's how it works. 1. Features 2. RPG For the love of all that is holy, it's 2023--why is it still so annoying to respec in singleplayer RPGs? By Harvey Randall published 20 November 2023 You've got to get mad! * * * * * * * * Comments My V from Cyberpunk 2077 crouches and stares at the ground in raw dread, having just read some memorial messages which broke his heart. (Image credit: CD Projekt Red) I cannot for the life of me figure out why respeccing--reallocating your skill points, your attribute points, your trait points, your P-Engine, whatever--is always so complicated in singleplayer games. In some infuriating cases, it's not possible at all. I understand that game design is a huge and complicated discipline. Every game's a network of systems stacked on top of each other like a Jenga tower--seemingly innocent changes can see the whole thing collapse in on itself. It's never as simple as "why don't the devs just". Because of this, there are design choices that stick around for a long time. Not because they're good, but because that's how it's always been done. Human beings don't like change. For example: in some of ye olden MMORPGs, you'd usually have to spend a couple of minutes resting after every fight. Eating food to restore HP, drinking to restore mana, re-applying buffs, that sort of thing. This served a purpose back when those games were built to facilitate a chat engine, while that was still a new and novel concept. It's an opportunity to banter with your mates. MMOs eventually became far less reliant on the social aspect. Dungeon finders happened, questing needed to become solo-friendly, and jolly cooperation in the overworld grew into an optional activity. Nowadays it'll only take a few seconds to get all your resources back, sure, but the shift wasn't instant. It was gradual. When it comes to respecs, though, all I have are my own personal theories. I can only offer up my two cents as to why this arcane design choice is still plaguing our single-player games, in the hopes it'll go away entirely. Complexity's not in vogue Minthara BG3 looking upset (Image credit: Larian) RPGs used to be a lot more complex. Fallout, Baldur's Gate, The Elder Scrolls--their systems have become easier to navigate as time's gone by. You can still get your hyper-complex, number-crunching fix, but that's not the mainstream play anymore. Even Baldur's Gate 3 uses 5th edition Dungeons & Dragons. While D&D can still be complex for newcomers, 5th edition is still a far cry from the number swarm of D&D 3.5. RPGs also used to be, on average, brutally difficult. That too has taken a backseat. Both of these things made resource management genuinely important. Players were rewarded for their prior knowledge and mastery of a game's systems. Fumbling your way through your first playthrough and ending up with a busted child that couldn't finish the game was sort of the charm. But that's not the world we live in anymore. I like a bit of teeth on my RPG, but I shouldn't need to start a whole new playthrough because I buggered up my character the first time. The tutorial for a game shouldn't end when you get fed up enough to delete your first save. Luckily, games have mostly figured this out--so why does it still cost cash to respec your character, if you can even respec them at all? Money talk Darth Malgus (Image credit: EA) For the RPG's massively multiplayer cousin, costly respecs make sense. Every activity in the game essentially prints money, pouring it into the virtual economy. This makes it possible to sleepwalk your way into a Star Wars: The Old Republic situation where the auction house is pretty much unusable for new players, and even simple items cost millions of credits. Inflation's a nightmare. To counterbalance that, designers need to add in stuff that takes money out of the economy. Repair bills are the most familiar example, ensuring every player has a steady thinning of their wallets. Cosmetics, dyes, pricey mounts, auction house fees--every little helps. It's a necessary evil, sure, but it's also how economies work Absolutely none of this applies to the single-player RPG, which is my point. The problem A witch from Remnant 2's DLC, The Awakened King, looking violently at the player with malice in her glowing eyes. (Image credit: Gunfire Games / Gearbox) Some designers figure this out after the fact. If you've been following Remnant 2, you might've heard about the Orb of Undoing. This was a consumable item that let you respec your trait points. For some reason, it cost like 2,500 scrap (which is a lot). It sucked. Now, buying the Orb of Undoing is a one-time thing. You can ponder the orb, and your character's build, as much as you want. On the other side of the coin, there's Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty, which has an absolutely maddening design choice wedged into it like a splinter. The game has a couple ways of building out a character: Attribute Points, which govern certain stats (and what perks are available) and Perk Points, which are used to buy perks. When the 2.0 update came out, CD Projekt Red gave characters the ability to respec their Attribute Points. Once. I don't know what fascinating tangle of dream logic led to this decision, because despite the fact that 2.0's a victory in every other area, this makes zero goddamn sense. You can shuffle your Perk Points around as much as you like. Cyberware only takes a little cash to re-arrange. Why can't you move your Attribute Points around? Or, more to the point, why not? You can argue that limiting respecs encourages the player to do multiple playthroughs. That's technically true, but I have no idea how that benefits the devs of a single-player RPG more than it frustrates players. Cyberpunk 2077 isn't a live-service game. There's no need to keep player retention up beyond making sure the game doesn't suck. Moreover, a playthrough can take dozens of hours to complete, so it's a massive time sink. Cyberpunk 2077 character Johnny Silverhand with arms crossed looks away from the camera and smiles (Image credit: Tyler C. / CD Projekt) Elden Ring has a very similar issue. Obviously, since Elden Ring falls under the 'it's meant to be difficult' umbrella, it's a touch more forgivable--but only a touch. If you mess up your build, you're 'meant' to be punished for it in the same way you might be punished for dying without getting your runes back. It's also technically not a single-player game but, come on. The Lands Between doesn't have a market board. It does do a few things better than its contemporaries, though--you get over a dozen Larval Tears scattered through the game on any playthrough, and by the end of the game you're replete with materials to upgrade your weapons with. But the fact you need to chew through a 90-plus hour game to reach the point where you can throw that much money towards experimenting is a problem in itself. Elden Ring has so many different builds you can toy with, and I've only used one of them--because by the time I had the dough to muck about, I was pretty much finished with the game. You know what? It doesn't matter how cheap the respec cost is. I'm willing to die on this hill: every single-player game with a respec cost is being silly about it. Yes, even Baldur's Gate 3, which has a laughably piddly fee. Why does Withers need my cash? He's an immortal mummy man. He doesn't eat. Does Withers have a secret lover he's hiding? Is Withers somebody's undead sugar daddy mummy? It's fine, I'm fine. I'm calm. If a game doesn't have a player economy to worry about, I don't really think respec costs add anything substantial. They're just a weird hurdle we're all still jumping over because we've always had to jump over it. I'm tired of pretending like we need them, and you should be too. PC Gamer Newsletter Sign up to get the best content of the week, and great gaming deals, as picked by the editors. [ ][ ]Contact me with news and offers from other Future brands[ ]Receive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsors[Sign me up] By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over. Harvey Randall Social Links Navigation Staff Writer Harvey's history with games started when he first begged his parents for a World of Warcraft subscription aged 12, though he's since been cursed with Final Fantasy 14-brain and a huge crush on G'raha Tia. He made his start as a freelancer, writing for websites like Techradar, The Escapist, Dicebreaker, The Gamer, Into the Spine--and of course, PC Gamer. He'll sink his teeth into anything that looks interesting, though he has a soft spot for RPGs, soulslikes, roguelikes, deckbuilders, MMOs, and weird indie titles. He also plays a shelf load of TTRPGs in his offline time. Don't ask him what his favourite system is, he has too many. More features WoW's 19th anniversary world boss locations - the Azure Worldchiller mount is dropped by Doomwalker Here are the 19th-anniversary world boss locations in World of Warcraft A shot of Steam in Big Picture Mode on a living room TV. It's 2023 and my PC should be a better console Latest Bluey: The videogame Bluey: The Videogame review See more latest > See comments Most Popular [missing-im]Looking for a new game to binge post-Starfield? Here's the best of what PC Game Pass has to offer By Robert ZakNovember 21, 2023 [missing-im]I spent years hunting down a rare copy of Windows 95 anime adventure Dinosaur Island, and it's still so candy cute it makes my teeth hurt By Kerry BrunskillNovember 20, 2023 [missing-im]For the love of all that is holy, it's 2023--why is it still so annoying to respec in singleplayer RPGs? By Harvey RandallNovember 20, 2023 [missing-im]Here is my advice on how to ensure you get a good Black Friday deal, without spending too much or being caught out by a bad offer By Nick EvansonNovember 20, 2023 [missing-im]This is the ultimate gaming setup you need By Jacob YorkNovember 20, 2023 [missing-im]Why I Love Fallout 3's Tranquility Lane By Jody MacgregorNovember 19, 2023 [missing-im]8 things we want from GTA 6 By Christopher LivingstonNovember 17, 2023 [missing-im]30 things PC Gamer has outlived over the past 30 years By Christopher LivingstonNovember 17, 2023 [missing-im]PC Gamer's least accurate predictions of all time By Robin ValentineNovember 17, 2023 [missing-im]Should facts or vibes determine whether an 'indie game' is really indie? By Tyler WildeNovember 17, 2023 [missing-im]How to acquire a Cyphered Tablet in Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 zombies By Sean MartinNovember 17, 2023 Load Comments Recommended [missing-im] The best deals in the 2023 Steam Autumn Sale [missing-im] For the love of all that is holy, it's 2023--why is it still so annoying to respec in singleplayer RPGs? HARDWARE BUYING GUIDESLATEST GAME REVIEWS 1. Don't compromise on power or portability with the best gaming laptops. 1 Best gaming laptops in 2023: I've had my pick of portable powerhouses and these are the best 2. 2 Best gaming chairs in 2023: the seats I'd suggest for any gamer 3. 3 Best graphics cards in 2023: the GPUs I recommend for every budget 4. 4 Best gaming monitors in 2023: the pixel-perfect panels I'd buy myself 5. 5 Best gaming PCs in 2023: these are the builds and brands I recommend 1. Bluey: The videogame 1 Bluey: The Videogame review 2. 2 LG OLED Flex 42 review 3. 3 Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 review 4. 4 The Last Faith review 5. 5 Risk of Rain Returns review PC Gamer is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site. * About Us * Contact Future's experts * Terms and conditions * Privacy policy * Cookies policy * Advertise with us * Accessibility Statement * Careers (c) Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.