https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/11/five-big-carmakers-beat-lawsuits-alleging-infotainment-systems-invade-privacy/ Skip to main content * Biz & IT * Tech * Science * Policy * Cars * Gaming & Culture * Store * Forums Subscribe [ ] Close Navigate * Store * Subscribe * Videos * Features * Reviews * RSS Feeds * Mobile Site * About Ars * Staff Directory * Contact Us * Advertise with Ars * Reprints Filter by topic * Biz & IT * Tech * Science * Policy * Cars * Gaming & Culture * Store * Forums Settings Front page layout Grid List Site theme light dark Sign in Connected car privacy -- Five big carmakers beat lawsuits alleging infotainment systems invade privacy Cars downloading text messages from phones doesn't violate state privacy law. Jon Brodkin - Nov 9, 2023 8:11 pm UTC A Ford Escape infotainment system shows a list of messages. Enlarge / Infotainment system in a 2016 Ford Escape. Getty Images | Todd Korol reader comments 86 with A federal appeals court rejected lawsuits that alleged five major carmakers violated a Washington state privacy law. The lawsuits centered on car infotainment systems that store text messages in a way that potentially allows the messages to be retrieved by law enforcement using specialized hardware and software. The rulings in the carmakers' favor came in cases against Ford, General Motors, Honda, Toyota, and Volkswagen. A three-judge panel at the US Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit unanimously upheld US District Court rulings that dismissed the five class-action lawsuits, which were almost identical. The appeals court ruled in Ford's favor on October 27, then issued rulings upholding the dismissals of the other four cases on Tuesday this week. We'll cover the Ford ruling here since the other decisions don't go into the same level of detail, and the arguments were similar in all five cases. The simple version is that the cases failed because the plaintiffs' data stayed in the car systems and apparently was never transmitted to law enforcement, Ford, or anyone else. The class-action "complaint alleges that the vehicle's system downloads all text messages and call logs from Plaintiffs' cellphones as soon as they are connected," the Ford ruling said. "The complaint also alleges that the infotainment system permanently stores the private communications without Plaintiffs' knowledge or consent." The complaint's allegations refer to Ford cars made in 2014 and after. Advertisement Plaintiffs alleged that there is no way to delete the text messages and call logs from the car system. "If text messages or call logs are deleted from a cellphone, the vehicle nevertheless retains the communications on the vehicle's on-board memory, even after the cellphone is disconnected. Vehicle owners cannot access or delete their personal information once it has been stored," the ruling's summary of the complaint said. Products can extract messages and call logs Ford's website provides instructions for a factory reset that "erases all stored data, such as call history, text messages, previously paired phones," and other data. That's useful before one sells or transfers a car but doesn't allow drivers to manually delete specific messages or call logs while they're still using the vehicle with a connected phone. There was no allegation that Ford or the other carmakers directly accessed text messages or call logs, or that they stored the data in their own systems. The privacy concern comes from the fact that a company called Berla sells specialized data-retrieval products to law enforcement, which could use the products to obtain messages and logs from a car. Berla's website boasts that "having access to a suspect's connected vehicle is the next best thing behind having the actual phone itself." In a statement quoted in the plaintiffs' complaint, Berla also says that if "a driver uses the infotainment interface to 'delete' their device, that device information often remains in unallocated space and can be recovered." "According to the Plaintiffs, Berla produces hardware and software capable of extracting stored text messages and call logs stored on a vehicle's on-board memory," the appeals court ruling said. "Berla products are not generally available to the public, and sales access is restricted to law enforcement, the military, civil and regulatory agencies, and select private investigation service providers." Page: 1 2 Next - reader comments 86 with Jon Brodkin Jon has been a reporter for Ars Technica since 2011 and covers a wide array of telecom and tech policy topics. Jon graduated from Boston University with a degree in journalism and has been a full-time journalist for over 20 years. Advertisement Channel Ars Technica - Previous story Next story - Related Stories Today on Ars * Store * Subscribe * About Us * RSS Feeds * View Mobile Site * Contact Us * Staff * Advertise with us * Reprints Newsletter Signup Join the Ars Orbital Transmission mailing list to get weekly updates delivered to your inbox. Sign me up - CNMN Collection WIRED Media Group (c) 2023 Conde Nast. All rights reserved. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (updated 1/1/20) and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement (updated 1/1 /20) and Ars Technica Addendum (effective 8/21/2018). Ars may earn compensation on sales from links on this site. Read our affiliate link policy. Your California Privacy Rights | [privacyopt] Do Not Sell My Personal Information The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Conde Nast. Ad Choices