https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/judge-pares-down-artists-ai-copyright-lawsuit-against-midjourney-stability-ai-2023-10-30/ Skip to main content Exclusive news, data and analytics for financial market professionals Learn more aboutRefinitiv Reuters home * World * Business * Markets * Sustainability * Legal * Breakingviews * Technology * Investigations * More My View Register * Litigation * Copyright * Litigation * Technology * Intellectual Property Judge pares down artists' AI copyright lawsuit against Midjourney, Stability AI By Blake Brittain October 30, 20239:53 PM UTCUpdated ago * * * * * * * * FILE PHOTO: Illustration shows AI (Artificial Intelligence) letters and computer motherboard FILE PHOTO: AI (Artificial Intelligence) letters are placed on computer motherboard in this illustration taken June 23, 2023. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo Acquire Licensing Rights * Summary * Law Firms * Judge dismisses claims over AI output, publicity rights * Key claim over use of artists' images in Stability AI training continues Oct 30 (Reuters) - A judge in California federal court on Monday trimmed a lawsuit by visual artists who accuse Stability AI, Midjourney and DeviantArt of misusing their copyrighted work in connection with the companies' generative artificial intelligence systems. U.S. District Judge William Orrick dismissed some claims from the proposed class action brought by Sarah Andersen, Kelly McKernan and Karla Ortiz, including all of the allegations against Midjourney and DeviantArt. The judge said the artists could file an amended complaint against the two companies, whose systems utilize Stability's Stable Diffusion text-to-image technology. Orrick also dismissed McKernan and Ortiz's copyright infringement claims entirely. The judge allowed Andersen to continue pursuing her key claim that Stability's alleged use of her work to train Stable Diffusion infringed her copyrights. The same allegation is at the heart of other lawsuits brought by artists, authors and other copyright owners against generative AI companies. "Even Stability recognizes that determination of the truth of these allegations - whether copying in violation of the Copyright Act occurred in the context of training Stable Diffusion or occurs when Stable Diffusion is run - cannot be resolved at this juncture," Orrick said. The artists' attorneys Joseph Saveri and Matthew Butterick said in a statement that their "core claim" survived, and that they were confident that they could address the court's concerns about their other claims in an amended complaint to be filed next month. A spokesperson for Stability declined to comment on the decision. Representatives for Midjourney and DeviantArt did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The artists said in their January complaint that Stability used billions of images "scraped" from the internet, including theirs, without permission to teach Stable Diffusion to create its own images. Orrick agreed with all three companies that the images the systems actually created likely did not infringe the artists' copyrights. He allowed the claims to be amended but said he was "not convinced" that allegations based on the systems' output could survive without showing that the images were substantially similar to the artists' work. The judge also dismissed other claims from the artists, including that the companies violated their publicity rights and competed with them unfairly, with permission to refile. Orrick dismissed McKernan and Ortiz's copyright claims because they had not registered their images with the U.S. Copyright Office, a requirement for bringing a copyright lawsuit. The case is Andersen v. Stability AI Ltd, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, No. 3:23-cv-00201. For the artists: Joseph Saveri of Joseph Saveri Law Firm; and Matthew Butterick For Stability: Paul Schoenhard of Fried Frank Harris Shriver & Jacobson For Midjourney: Angela Dunning of Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton For DeviantArt: Andy Gass of Latham & Watkins Read more: Lawsuits accuse AI content creators of misusing copyrighted work AI companies ask U.S. court to dismiss artists' copyright lawsuit US judge finds flaws in artists' lawsuit against AI companies Reporting by Blake Brittain in Washington Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. * * * * * Acquire Licensing Rights, opens new tab [e80269c0-8] Blake Brittain Thomson Reuters Blake Brittain reports on intellectual property law, including patents, trademarks, copyrights and trade secrets, for Reuters Legal. He has previously written for Bloomberg Law and Thomson Reuters Practical Law and practiced as an attorney. Contact: +12029385713 * * * Read Next / Editor's Picks * Logo of GM atop the company headquarters World at Workcategory UAW reaches deal with GM, ending strike against Detroit automakers 10:53 PM UTC * Updated ago * British PM Johnson walks outside his home, in London Worldcategory Boris Johnson's response to COVID was 'mad and dangerous'- top official 7:36 PM UTC * The company logo for Unilever is displayed on a screen on the floor of the NYSE Businesscategory Unilever to freeze new CEO's fixed pay for two years 6:19 PM UTC * UAW strike continues in Wayne, Michigan. World at Workcategory UAW's record deal could boost others' wages as labor notches another victory 3:08 PM UTC LSEG Workspace More from Reuters Industry Insight * Industry InsightCompanies need to integrate climate reporting across functions to comply with California's new law [be4488a2-3] Henry Engler October 20, 2023 * LegalCellino, Barnes firms battle former colleagues over fees, years after split [4QXBW6RP45] Diana Novak Jones September 27, 2023 * LegalUS appeals judge faults probe of Federal Circuit's Pauline Newman [4QXBW6RP45] Andrew Goudsward September 20, 2023 * LegalLaw firm Clifford Chance posts increased revenue, stalled profits [2792c31e-7] Sara Merken July 19, 2023 Site Index Browse * World * Business * Markets * Sustainability * Legal * Breakingviews * Technology * Investigations, opens new tab * Sports * Science * Lifestyle About Reuters * About Reuters, opens new tab * Careers, opens new tab * Reuters News Agency, opens new tab * Brand Attribution Guidelines, opens new tab * Reuters Leadership, opens new tab * Reuters Fact Check, opens new tab * Reuters Diversity Report, opens new tab Stay Informed * Download the App, opens new tab * Newsletters, opens new tab Information you can trust Reuters, the news and media division of Thomson Reuters, is the world's largest multimedia news provider, reaching billions of people worldwide every day. Reuters provides business, financial, national and international news to professionals via desktop terminals, the world's media organizations, industry events and directly to consumers. Follow Us * * * * * Thomson Reuters Products * Westlaw, opens new tab Build the strongest argument relying on authoritative content, attorney-editor expertise, and industry defining technology. * Onesource, opens new tab The most comprehensive solution to manage all your complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs. * Checkpoint, opens new tab The industry leader for online information for tax, accounting and finance professionals. LSEG Products * Workspace, opens new tab Access unmatched financial data, news and content in a highly-customised workflow experience on desktop, web and mobile. * Data Catalogue, opens new tab Browse an unrivalled portfolio of real-time and historical market data and insights from worldwide sources and experts. * World-Check, opens new tab Screen for heightened risk individual and entities globally to help uncover hidden risks in business relationships and human networks. * Advertise With Us, opens new tab * Advertising Guidelines, opens new tab * Coupons, opens new tab * Acquire Licensing Rights, opens new tab * Cookies, opens new tab * Terms of Use, opens new tab * Privacy, opens new tab * Digital Accessibility, opens new tab * Corrections, opens new tab * Site Feedback, opens new tab All quotes delayed a minimum of 15 minutes. See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. (c) 2023 Reuters. All rights reserved