https://thehustle.co/the-murky-math-of-the-new-york-times-bestsellers-list/ [ ] [ ] Search * News + Daily Headlines + Hustle Originals * Newsletter + Latest Newsletter + Newsletter Archive * Podcasts + The Hustle Daily Show + My First Million * YouTube * Trends * HubSpot join free [ ] Home > media & publishing > The murky math of the New York Times bestsellers list The murky math of the New York Times bestsellers list How to land one of the spots on the list. New York Times newspaper bestsellers Katherine Laidlaw October 27, 2023 Sy Montgomery spends money on three things: gas, groceries, and making the New York Times bestsellers list. For years, she and her husband have lived as freelance writers deep in the mountains of New Hampshire. They've eked out a living, she says, because they're so frugal that even at 65 years old she wears hand-me-down clothes from friends. "We can live off the smell of an oily rag," she says. When Montgomery learned that her publisher wasn't going to give her third book, The Soul of an Octopus, the national book tour that her first book, an international bestseller, had received, she took matters into her own hands. She hired a PR pro and self-funded a tour in 2015, charming audiences in bookshops across the country with tales of how animals can expand our consciousness. "I'm just lucky my husband let me gamble with our savings that way." Her bet worked -- The Soul of an Octopus hit the New York Times bestseller list the month of its release. Montgomery had learned an important lesson. Bestsellers don't just happen; they're made, by a murky engine of influence that includes the very list itself. The list effect The New York Times bestseller lists, of which there are weekly, monthly, and genre-specific varieties, have long been arbiters of culture, shadowy mixes of dictum and data. "It's a bully pulpit," Montgomery says. Which is to say, it offers a platform, but not a golden ticket. Making the list is a herculean task. Consider the number of books, more than 3m, published every year. And then consider that the number of slots on the NYT's coveted lists is ~6240. That gives authors a coolly aspirational 0.00208% chance to snag one. [svg][Q7CvtrStEl] The Hustle Numbers aside, the recipe for its creation has long been a trade secret. Behind the list is another list, one curated to include books projected by publishers, booksellers, and editors to be bestsellers, according to Laura B. McGrath, assistant professor of English at Temple University. How to make it onto that list is a mystery. "The New York Times only tracks the data for those pre-selected books, not for all books that get published. So the curatorial process is itself pretty dramatic," McGrath says. [svg][FXM7qCd9M6] Laura McGrath teaches a course on the history of the bestseller at Temple University. (via Laura B. McGrath) Publishers lobby hard to get their books in front of the editors who curate that list. Booksellers, who want to move copies, also push for titles they think will be promising. From there, sales of those books at a secretive list of shops across the country -- tens of thousands of stores, according to the company -- are examined by three Times staffers. And that data is what makes up the list, which has run every week in the paper since 1931. "Sometimes before a book has even sold a copy, it's deemed a bestseller, just by virtue of the expectations that are placed on it," McGrath says. Those expectations have, for decades, favored white authors -- so heavily that Essence magazine created its own parallel bestseller lists that drew data from only Black-owned bookstores to reflect what Black Americans were reading. That favoritism extends to every aspect of creating such a curated list, McGrath says. Publishers bring their own biases to the list of titles they project will do well. "If you're completely disconnected from the Black reading community, it's very unlikely you're going to say, 'I have this book by this Black author no one's ever heard of,'" McGrath says. "And if you do, it's only if that book by a Black author you think could do really well with the white reading community, which is what publishers are still basing their decisions on." [svg][P-UO98iY3B] The calculation method for the NYT bestsellers list turns up a different list than the USA Today list. (The Hustle) Beyond that, because the stores the Times includes are a secret, there's no way to know how many Black- or Latinx-owned bookstores are represented or to gauge the geographic diversity of stores. Historically, the Times used sales in New York as an index for what the country was reading. It has since broadened its reach. (When asked for comment, a Times spokesperson provided this link to its methodology.) A star is born The list has been one of publishing's most powerful marketing tools for generations. In 1940, writer Richard Wright learned he would be the first Black author chosen for the prestigious -- and widespread -- Book-of-the-Month selection. (Think Oprah's Book Club, as a subscription service.) The selection committee had just one condition: that he soften the language and remove one scene they thought might be offensive to their mostly white readership. Wright knew what the selection would mean for him and his career. He agreed to the changes. His novel, Native Son, went on to sell 215k copies in its first three weeks. He became the first Black bestselling author in US history. Since then, the list has catapulted unknown authors like Delia Owens, Colleen Hoover, and Bonnie Garmus into new stratospheres of literary and financial success. [svg][yp0JBeAee9] Author Richard Wright, the first Black bestselling author in US history, leans over a bridge in Venice in 1950. (Archivio Cameraphoto Epoche/Getty Images) Even a week on the list can have an impact -- provided an author has already earned out their advance. At an average list price of $27.99 for a hardcover, and 5k copies sold, that's a gross $140k. Authors make anywhere from 5%-15% royalties, which means that's a tidy $21k week. "If anything, what appearing on the list does is not so much cause your sales to increase from one week to the next, but rather to decrease at a slower rate," writes Alan Sorenson, a Stanford University business professor. Insert money-flying-away emoji here. Still, it's undeniably something between marketing tool and self-fulfilling prophecy, and remains one of the most coveted accolades in publishing. So, of course, over time, writers have tried to shortcut their way onto it. The dagger system To have a shot at a bestseller, 5k copies in a week is generally considered the threshold to clear; 10k if you want to be safe. And if you're a political figure, say (looking at you, Donald Trump), who already has some money in the bank, buying your way onto it isn't outside the realm of possibility. There's now an emoji for that: A dagger appears next to titles on the list suspected of rising thanks to the bulk-order cheat. And it has signaled nefarious business in a few high-profile cases: * When Trump's The Art of the Deal came out in 1991, he instructed staffers to place orders in the thousands to sell at his own properties. In 2016, he used the same strategy with Crippled America: How to Make America Great Again, buying $55k worth of copies himself to ensure the book's relevance. * In 2015, Mitt Romney put a twist on the bulk-order bilk: He took at least half of his hefty $50k speaking fee in book sales instead of cash. * NSYNC superstar JC Chasez's cousin, Lani Sarem, drew ire for placing bulk orders at shops across the country for her debut, Handbook for Mortals, only after confirming the shops would be reporting their data to the NYT. [svg][Ee6LhDCg_q] The Hustle Sarem, it turned out, had hired ResultSource, a shadowy San Diego-based consultancy that mounts bestseller campaigns by orchestrating bulk book orders but making them look organic. After involvement in several scandals of its own, ResultSource's website went dark. The company also didn't respond to The Hustle's requests for comment. But an older version of its website lists many bestseller campaigns it's executed for authors, including on Delivering Happiness, Payback Time, The One-Minute Entrepreneur, and If You're Not First, You're Last. According to Forbes, hiring ResultSource costs upwards of $20k, roughly the same amount an author would make from selling the requisite number of copies to land on the NYT list, and a premium if you want to buy your way to No. 1. Gaming the list While the dagger connotes malfeasance, there are more aboveboard ways to strategize one's way onto the list. A team of data scientists at Northeastern University crunched the numbers (nearly 4.5k of them) and traced patterns in eight years of NYT bestsellers, publishing their findings in the journal EPJ Data Science. The study reveals: * Some months you have better chances -- in February, selling ~3k copies will land you on the list, compared to December's ~10k threshold thanks to holiday shoppers * When it comes to nonfiction, memoirs and biographies have the best shot (though it obviously helps if you're already famous) * In fiction, suspense novels and thrillers are most likely to make it * If you're a woman, you're more likely to crack the fiction list, and if you're a first-time author, your chances are best in nonfiction rather than fiction, where repeat authors like James Patterson (260 bestsellers and counting) dominate [svg] [Lt0hOQwiVGjOfhLkkCktHwrotHDciAetWiLHY7Hx8NEJHZ6LxZwSSENgfr-am2i76tTbzxU9Pkw_jxfsQn4fvePN] The Hustle In March, Patterson accused the Times of gaming their own list in an open letter excoriating the paper for what he called "cooking the books." His new book came in at No. 6 on the list that week, but when Patterson compared the Times's list to the raw BookScan data -- considered the most reliable source tracking all book sales across the country -- he saw his name at No. 4. "Maybe I'm foolish for thinking 'best seller' is supposed to be a measure of what's most popular with my fellow book-buying readers, as opposed to some Times-decreed value judgment on the method by which the books were sold," he wrote. "At any rate, I'm asking you to please cut it out." 'I need to lie down' In 2020, University of Pennsylvania student Chloe Gong wrote a tweet. "My heart is going so fast I can't even type!! THESE VIOLENT DELIGHTS is a New York Times Best Seller!!! THANK YOU FOR READING AND PICKING UP THIS BOOK I NEED TO LIE DOWN." She'd just become one of the youngest New York Times bestselling authors in history. She wrote her book, These Violent Delights, on summer break after her first year of college, during late nights alone in her tiny apartment. For Gong, like many authors, the book's success had a compounding effect. Her next book was promoted with trailers played on screens in Times Square leading up to its release. For another, her publisher commissioned a mural of the cover on a building in New York. [svg][BaeBvelew2] Chloe Gong has landed on two New York Times bestseller lists. (Jeremy Chan Photography/Getty Images) And when Our Violent Ends, the sequel to Delights, debuted at No. 1 on the NYT young-adult bestseller list, Gong celebrated on TikTok with live recordings of her giggling as her editor delivered the news. She posted self-effacing videos joking, "the size of my ego when distant relatives brag about their kids going to Ivy League schools and my grandma pulls the 'my granddaughter graduated from an Ivy League as a New York Times bestseller' card." McGrath, the English professor, points out that the list is as much a cultural signifier as it is an accurate index of what the public is reading. The tagline makes it easier for readers to find a book within today's info glut and makes it easier for an author to convince a publisher to let them write another one. "It becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy," she says. "It has a cumulative, rich-get-richer effect, if you've managed it successfully." Sales come and go, but a NYT bestseller bio line is forever. Get the 5-minute roundup you'll actually read in your inbox Business and tech news in 5 minutes or less 100% free. We don't spam. Unsubscribe whenever. RECENT POSTS The murky math of the New York Times bestsellers listThe murky math of the New York Times bestsellers list * Stories The murky math of the New York Times bestsellers list By Katherine Laidlaw / October 27, 2023 How to land one of the spots on the list. Read More The Eliza effect, or why we love botsThe Eliza effect, or why we love bots * Brief The Eliza effect, or why we love bots By The Hustle / October 27, 2023 Do you think of Siri as your friend? That's the Eliza effect. Read More Another $250B going toward the greater good every year? Sounds nice, but it ain't happeningAnother $250B going toward the greater good every year? Sounds nice, but it ain't happening * Brief Another $250B going toward the greater good every year? Sounds nice, but it ain't happening By Ben Berkley / October 27, 2023 European economists dropped research this week backing the taxation of billionaires. It'll be an uphill climb. Read More Cold plunges are going corporateCold plunges are going corporate * Brief Cold plunges are going corporate By Sara Friedman / October 26, 2023 The obsession with ice baths reaches new depths. Read More AI... after darkAI... after dark * Brief AI... after dark By Ben Berkley / October 26, 2023 A wave of NSFW generative AI chatbots are entering the market, because of course they are. Read More Privacy, who? Gen Z is sharing its locationPrivacy, who? Gen Z is sharing its location * Brief Privacy, who? Gen Z is sharing its location By Sara Friedman / October 25, 2023 Location-sharing tech is becoming more popular as young people look to stay safe and stay connected. Read More If your vision of the future includes your dinner dancing itself around the plate to entertain you, congratsIf your vision of the future includes your dinner dancing itself around the plate to entertain you, congrats * Brief If your vision of the future includes your dinner dancing itself around the plate to entertain you, congrats By Ben Berkley / October 25, 2023 Scientists are putting technology to work on some wild culinary advancements. Read More The newest addition to workplace benefits? Caregiving supportThe newest addition to workplace benefits? Caregiving support * Brief The newest addition to workplace benefits? Caregiving support By Sara Friedman / October 24, 2023 In the race to retain top talent, employers are exploring a new category of benefits. Read More Can Discord clean up the internet's criminal justice system?Can Discord clean up the internet's criminal justice system? * Brief Can Discord clean up the internet's criminal justice system? By Ben Berkley / October 24, 2023 A leading social platform takes a gentler (and admirable, though dangerous) approach to moderating its users. Read More As the NBA returns, its boardroom is just as entertaining as the on-court productAs the NBA returns, its boardroom is just as entertaining as the on-court product * Brief As the NBA returns, its boardroom is just as entertaining as the on-court product By Ben Berkley / October 24, 2023 A new basketball season starts tonight and the business storylines are juicy. Read More TRENDING ORIGINALS 1. How Hollywood insures its biggest stunts Tom Cruise on a motorcycleTom Cruise on a motorcycle 2. The big business of bachelorette party buses women in a party scenewomen in a party scene 3. The wild business of desert island tourism person waving on a tiny islandperson waving on a tiny island 4. One man's quest to end cheating in virtual cycling indoor cyclingindoor cycling 5. Are superstar athletes good for the economy? football player holding moneyfootball player holding money Never Miss What's Happening In Business and Tech Trusted By 2.5M+ Readers trendstrends [svg][trends-logo] Vetted business ideas you can launch in a weekend Get 1,000+ Ideas "Entertaining, informative, keeps you coming back for more..." [svg][hustle-podcast-img] The Hustle Daily Show Listen on Apple Podcast Listen on Castro Listen on Spotify * Daily Headlines * Hustle Originals * Today's Newsletter * Podcast * Trends * HubSpot * * * * Copyright (c) 2023 HubSpot, Inc. Privacy Policy Terms of Use Psst How'd Bezos build a billion dollar empire? In 1994, Jeff Bezos discovered a shocking stat: Internet usage grew 2,300% per year. Data shows where markets are headed. And that's why we built Trends -- to show you up-and-coming market opportunities about to explode. Interested? YES, I WANT IN - We use cookies to make the Hustle website a better place. Cookies help to provide a more personalized experience and relevant advertising for you, and web analytics for us. To learn more about the different cookies we're using, check out our Cookie Settings. For further information, check out our Cookie Policy & our Privacy Policy . DeclineAllow Cookies Manage consent Close Privacy Overview This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience. Necessary [*] Necessary Always Enabled Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information. Functional [ ] functional Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. Cookie Duration Description __cf_bm 30 This cookie, set by Cloudflare, is used to support minutes Cloudflare Bot Management. Analytics [ ] analytics Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. Cookie Duration Description This cookie keeps track of sessions. This is used to determine if HubSpot should 30 increment the session number __hssc minutes and timestamps in the __hstc cookie. It contains the domain, viewCount (increments each pageView in a session), and session start timestamp. Whenever HubSpot changes the session cookie, this cookie is also set to determine if the visitor has restarted their __hssrc session browser. If this cookie does not exist when HubSpot manages cookies, it is considered a new session. It contains the value "1" when present. The main cookie for tracking visitors. It contains the domain, utk, initial timestamp __hstc 6 months (first visit), last timestamp (last visit), current timestamp (this visit), and session number (increments for each subsequent session). The _ga cookie, installed by Google Analytics, calculates visitor, session and campaign data and also keeps track of _ga 6 months site usage for the site's analytics report. The cookie stores information anonymously and assigns a randomly generated number to recognize unique visitors. This cookie is set by Google _gat_gtag_UA_58267113_7 1 minute and is used to distinguish users. This is a pattern type cookie set by Google Analytics, where the pattern element on the name contains the unique identity number of the account or _gat_UA-58267113-7 1 minute website it relates to. It appears to be a variation of the _gat cookie which is used to limit the amount of data recorded by Google on high traffic volume websites. Provided by Google Tag Manager _gcl_au 3 months to experiment advertisement efficiency of websites using their services. Installed by Google Analytics, _gid cookie stores information on how visitors use a website, while also creating an _gid 1 day analytics report of the website's performance. Some of the data that are collected include the number of visitors, their source, and the pages they visit anonymously. 30 This cookie is set by Hotjar. _hjAbsoluteSessionInProgress minutes Used to detect the first pageview session of a user. This cookie is set by Hotjar. Identifies a new user's first _hjFirstSeen session session. Used by Recording filters to identify new user sessions. This cookie is set by Hotjar. _hjIncludedInPageviewSample 30 Set to determine if a user is minutes included in the data sampling defined by the website limit. This cookie is set by Hotjar. 30 Set to determine if a user is _hjIncludedInSessionSample minutes included in the data sampling defined by your site's daily session limit. This cookie is set by Hotjar. 30 Holds current session data. _hjSession_1955701 minutes Ensures subsequent requests in the session window are attributed to the same session. This cookie is set by Hotjar. Set when a user first lands on a page. Persists the Hotjar _hjSessionUser_1955701 1 year User ID which is unique to that site. Ensures data from subsequent visits to the same site are attributed to the same user ID. The _omappvp cookie is set to distinguish new and returning _omappvp 6 months users and is used in conjunction with _omappvs cookie. The _omappvs cookie, used in conjunction with the _omappvp _omappvs 20 cookies, is used to determine minutes if the visitor has visited the website before, or if it is a new visitor. This cookie is set by OptinMonster. Used to store _omra 6 months interaction and conversion data for campaigns in conjunction with Revenue Attribution. This cookie keeps track of a visitor's identity. It is passed to HubSpot on form hubspotutk 6 months submission and used when deduplicating contacts. It contains an opaque GUID to represent the current visitor. Used to determine if a visitor om-wip10afyetrnlu70kibe 1 month has been shown a campaign by the slug This cookie is set by Sailthru. sailthru_content 1 year Tracks recent pageviews for all visitors, and can be used to populate a new user profile. 30 This cookie is set by Sailthru sailthru_pageviews minutes to tracks the number of page views for each user. This cookie is set by Sailthru. sailthru_visitor 1 year The cookie contains an id that is used to identify a user's pageviews within a session. The test_cookie is set by test_cookie 15 doubleclick.net and is used to minutes determine if the user's browser supports cookies. Advertisement [ ] advertisement Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. Cookie Duration Description This cookie is set by Microsoft Clarity. Persists the Clarity User ID and preferences, unique to that site, _clck 1 year on the browser. This ensures that behavior in subsequent visits to the same site will be attributed to the same user ID. This cookie is set by Microsoft _clsk 1 year Clarity. Connects multiple page views by a user into a single Clarity session recording. This cookie is set by CHEQ AI Technologies. Used to monitor the _cq_check Session technical information and use of devices that connect to our website to protect it from malicious traffic. This cookie is set by CHEQ AI Technologies. Used to monitor the _cq_duid 3 month technical information and use of devices that connect to our website to protect it from malicious traffic. This cookie is set by CHEQ AI Technologies. Used to monitor the _cq_suid Session technical information and use of devices that connect to our website to protect it from malicious traffic. This cookie is set by Facebook to display advertisements when either on _fbp 3 months Facebook or on a digital platform powered by Facebook advertising, after visiting the website. This cookie is set by LiveIntent. A _lc2_fpi 2 years random, unique, device identifier, stored as a 1st party cookie, to enable targeted advertising This cookie is set by LiveIntent. The _li_dcdm_c session domain name where the _lc2_fpi cookie was stored To measure and improve the performance _tt_enable_cookie 13 of your advertising campaigns and to months personalize the user's experience (including ads) on TikTok. To measure and improve the performance _tt_sessionId 13 of your advertising campaigns and to months personalize the user's experience (including ads) on TikTok. To measure and improve the performance _ttp 13 of your advertising campaigns and to months personalize the user's experience (including ads) on TikTok. This cookie is set by Twitter. It is _twclid 30 days used for tracking and personalization purposes, such as remembering a user's preferences and activity on the site. This cookie is set by Microsoft _uetsid 1 day Advertising. It contains the session ID for a unique session on the site. This cookie is set by Microsoft 13 Advertising. UET assigns this unique, _uetvid months anonymized visitor ID, representing a unique visitor. UET stores this data in a first-party cookie. Linkedin sets this cookie. Used to AnalyticsSyncHistory 1 month store information about the time a sync took place with the lms_analytics cookie This cookie is set by Microsoft 10 Clarity. Indicates whether MUID is ANONCHK minutes transferred to ANID, a cookie used for advertising. Clarity doesn't use ANID and so this is always set to 0. This cookie is set by Twitter. It is auth_token 5 years used for authentication purposes, to keep the user logged in to their Twitter account. This cookie is set by LinkedIn. Browser bcookie 1 year Identifier cookie to uniquely identify devices accessing LinkedIn to detect abuse on the platform. This cookie is set by Linkedin. Used bscookie 1 year for remembering that a logged in user is verified by two factor authentication. Sets a unique ID for the visitor that allows third-party advertisers to target the visitor with relevant cg_uuid 1 year advertisements. This pairing service is provided by third-party advertisement hubs, which facilitates real-time bidding for advertisers. CLID 1 year Identifies the first-time Clarity saw this user on any site using Clarity. Facebook sets this cookie to show relevant advertisements to users by fr 3 months tracking user behaviour across the web, on sites that have Facebook pixel or Facebook social plugin. guest_id 1 year This cookie is set by Twitter to identify and track the website visitor. This cookie is set due to Twitter guest_id_ads 1 year integration and sharing capabilities for the social media. guest_id_marketing 1 year Used to detect whether a user is logged into Twitter. This cookie is set by Linkedin. Used to remember a user's language setting to lang Session ensure LinkedIn.com displays in the language selected by the user in their settings. This cookie is set by Linkedin. Used to li_gc 6 months store consent of guests regarding the use of cookies for non-essential purposes. lidc 24 hours Linkedin sets this cookie. Used To facilitate data center selection. This cookie is set by LiveIntent. A lidid 2 years random, unique, device identifier, stored as a 3rd party cookie, used to enable targeted advertising Collects data on user behaviour and muc_ads 2 years interaction in order to optimize the website and make advertisement on the website more relevant This cookie is set by Microsoft Advertising. Identifies unique web MUID 9 months browsers visiting Microsoft sites. These cookies are used for advertising, site analytics, and other operational purposes. This cookie is set due to Twitter personalization_id 2 years integration and sharing capabilities for the social media. This cookie is set by Microsoft SM session Clarity. Used in synchronizing the MUID across Microsoft domains. 1 year This cookie is set by Microsoft SRM_B 24 days Clarity. Identifies unique web browsers visiting Microsoft sites. Linkedin sets this cookie. Used for id UserMatchHistory 1 month sync process. It stores the last sync time to avoid continually repeating the syncing process. This cookie is set by Snapchat. This is a tool used to combine or change X-AB 1 day content on the website. This allows the website to find the best variation/ edition of the site. Others [ ] others Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. Save & Accept Powered by CookieYes LogoCookieYes Logo Go to mobile version