https://www.openculture.com/2023/09/noam-chomsky-explains-why-nobody-is-really-a-moral-relativist-even-michel-foucault.html * Online Courses * Certificates * Degrees & Mini-Degrees * Audio Books * Movies * Podcasts * K-12 * eBooks * Languages * Donate * + + + + * [ ] [] * [] Noam Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is Really a Moral Relativist, Even Michel Foucault in Philosophy | September 28th, 2023 1 Comment FacebookTwitterReddit SubscribeGoogleWhatsappPinterestDiggLinkedinStumbleuponVkPrint DeliciousBufferPocketXingTumblrMailYummlyTelegramFlipboard Noam Chomsky made his name as a linguist, which is easy to forget amid the wide range of subjects he has addressed, and continues to address, in his long career as a public intellectual. But on a deeper level, his commentary on politics, society, media, and a host of other broad fields sounds not unlike a natural outgrowth of his specialized linguistic theories. Throughout the past five or six decades, he's occasionally made the connection explicit, or nearly so, by drawing analogies between language and other domains of human activity. Take the panel-discussion clip above, in which Chomsky faces the question of why he doesn't accept the notion of cultural relativism, which holds moral norms as not absolute but created wholly within particular cultural contexts. "There are no skeptics," Chomsky says. "You can discuss it in a philosophy seminar, but no human being can, in fact, be a skeptic. They wouldn't survive for two minutes if they were. I think pretty much the same is true of moral relativism. There are no moral relativists: there are people who profess it, you can discuss it abstractly, but it doesn't exist in ordinary life." He identifies "a tendency to move from the uncontroversial concept of moral relativism" -- that, say, certain cultures at certain times hold certain moral values, and other cultures at other times hold other ones -- "to a concept that is, in fact, incoherent, and that is to say that moral values can range indefinitely," tethered to no objective basis. If morality is transmitted through culture, "how does a person acquire his or her culture? You don't get it by taking a pill. You acquire your culture by observing a rather limited number of behaviors and actions, and from those, constructing, somehow, in your mind, the set of attitudes and beliefs that constitutes culture." He draws a natural comparison between this process and that of language acquisition, which also depends on "having a rich built-in array of constraints that allow the leap from scattered data to whatever it is that you acquire. That's virtually logic." And so, "even if you're the most extreme cultural relativist, you are presupposing universal moral values. Those can be discovered." When he spoke of "the most extreme cultural relativist," he was thinking of Michel Foucault? Back in 1971, Chomsky engaged the French philosopher of power in a debate, broadcast on Dutch television, about human nature and the origin of morality. There he practically lead with linguistics: a child learning to talk starts "with the knowledge that he's hearing a human language of a very narrow and explicit type that permits a very small range of variation." This "highly organized and very restrictive schematism" allows him to "make the huge leap from scattered and degenerate data to highly organized knowledge." This mechanism "is one fundamental constituent of human nature," in not just language but "other domains of human intelligence and other domains of human cognition and even behavior" as well. Perhaps we do have the freedom to speak, think, and act however we wish -- but that very freedom, if Chomsky is correct, emerges only within strict, absolute, wholly un-relative natural boundaries. Related content: Michel Foucault and Noam Chomsky Debate Human Nature & Power on Dutch TV (1971) An Animated Introduction to Michel Foucault, "Philosopher of Power" A Brief Animated Introduction to Noam Chomsky's Linguistic Theory, Narrated by The X-Files' Gillian Anderson Michel Foucault Offers a Clear, Compelling Introduction to His Philosophical Project (1966) Noam Chomsky Explains the Best Way for Ordinary People to Make Change in the World, Even When It Seems Daunting Moralities of Everyday Life: A Free Online Course from Yale University Based in Seoul, Colin Marshall writes and broadcasts on cities, language, and culture. His projects include the Substack newsletter Books on Cities, the book The Stateless City: a Walk through 21st-Century Los Angeles and the video series The City in Cinema. Follow him on Twitter at @colinmarshall or on Facebook. FacebookTwitterReddit SubscribeGoogleWhatsappPinterestDiggLinkedinStumbleuponVkPrint DeliciousBufferPocketXingTumblrMailYummlyTelegramFlipboard by Colin Marshall | Permalink | Comments (1) | Support Open Culture We're hoping to rely on our loyal readers rather than erratic ads. To support Open Culture's educational mission, please consider making a donation. We accept PayPal, Venmo (@openculture), Patreon and Crypto! Please find all options here. We thank you! [placeholder] [btn_donate_cc_147x4] Comments (1) You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed. * aga says: September 28, 2023 at 1:03 am Nu, chto zhe, pust' v'ebet govna. Reply Leave a Reply Name (required) [ ] Email (required) [ ] Message [ ] [Submit] Click here to cancel reply. Wordpress Hashcash needs javascript to work, but your browser has javascript disabled. Your comment will be queued in Akismet! * Essentials + 1,700 Free Online Courses + 200 Online Certificate Programs + 100+ Online Degree & Mini-Degree Programs + 1,150 Free Movies + 1,000 Free Audio Books + 150+ Best Podcasts + 800 Free eBooks + 200 Free Textbooks + 300 Free Language Lessons + 150 Free Business Courses + Free K-12 Education + Get Our Daily Email * Support Us We're hoping to rely on loyal readers, rather than erratic ads. Please click the Donate button and support Open Culture. You can use Paypal, Venmo, Patreon, even Crypto! We thank you! [btn_donate_cc_147x4] * Free Courses + Art & Art History + Astronomy + Biology + Business + Chemistry + Classics/Ancient World + Computer Science + Data Science + Economics + Engineering + Environment + History + Literature + Math + Philosophy + Physics + Political Science + Psychology + Religion + Writing & Journalism + All 1500 Free Courses + 1000+ MOOCs & Certificate Courses * * Receive our Daily Email FREE UPDATES! GET OUR DAILY EMAIL Get the best cultural and educational resources on the web curated for you in a daily email. We never spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Click Here to sign up for our newsletter FOLLOW ON SOCIAL MEDIA + + + + * Free Movies + 1150 Free Movies Online + Free Film Noir + Silent Films + Documentaries + Martial Arts/Kung Fu + Animations + Free Hitchcock Films + Free Charlie Chaplin + Free John Wayne Movies + Free Tarkovsky Films + Free Dziga Vertov + Free Oscar Winners * Free Language Lessons + Arabic + Chinese + English + French + German + Italian + Russian + Spanish + All Languages * Free eBooks + 700 Free eBooks + Free Philosophy eBooks + The Harvard Classics + Philip K. Dick Stories + Neil Gaiman Stories + David Foster Wallace Stories & Essays + Hemingway Stories + Great Gatsby & Other Fitzgerald Novels + HP Lovecraft + Edgar Allan Poe + Free Alice Munro Stories + Jennifer Egan Stories + George Saunders Stories + Hunter S. Thompson Essays + Joan Didion Essays + Gabriel Garcia Marquez Stories + David Sedaris Stories + Stephen King + Chomsky + Golden Age Comics + Free Books by UC Press + Life Changing Books * Free Audio Books + 700 Free Audio Books + Free Audio Books: Fiction + Free Audio Books: Poetry + Free Audio Books: Non-Fiction * Free Textbooks + 200 Free Textbooks + Free Physics Textbooks + Free Computer Science Textbooks + Free Math Textbooks * K-12 Resources + Free Books + Free Video Lessons + Web Resources by Subject + Free Language Lessons + Quality YouTube Channels + Teacher Resources + Test Prep + All Free Kids Resources * Free Art & Images + All Art Images & Books + The Met + The Getty + The Rijksmuseum + Smithsonian + The Guggenheim + The Tate + The National Gallery + The Whitney + LA County Museum + Stanford University + British Library + Google Art Project + French Revolution + Getty Images + Guggenheim Art Books + Met Art Books + Getty Art Books + New York Public Library Maps + Museum of New Zealand + Street Art + Smarthistory + Rembrandt + Van Gogh + Coloring Books * Free Music + All Bach Organ Works + All of Bach + 80,000 Classical Music Scores + Free Classical Music + Live Classical Music + 9,000 Grateful Dead Concerts + Alan Lomax Blues & Folk Archive * Writing Tips + Hemingway + Fitzgerald + Stephen King + Ray Bradbury + William Zinsser + Kurt Vonnegut + Toni Morrison + Edgar Allan Poe + Margaret Atwood + David Ogilvy + Steinbeck + Billy Wilder * Archive + All posts by date * Categories + Amazon Kindle + Animation + Apple + Architecture + Archives + Art + Astronomy + Audio Books + Beat & Tweets + Biology + Books + Business + Chemistry + Coloring Books + Comedy + Comics/Cartoons + Computer Science + Creativity + Current Affairs + Dance + Data + Deals + Design + e-books + Economics + Education + English Language + Entrepreneurship + Environment + Fashion + Film + Finance + Food & Drink + Games + Gender + Google + Graduation Speech + Harvard + Health + History + How to Learn for Free + Internet Archive + iPad + iPhone + Jazz + K-12 + Language + Language Lessons + Law + Letters + Libraries + Life + Literature + Magazines + Maps + Math + Media + MIT + MOOCs + Most Popular + Museums + Music + Nature + Neuroscience + Online Courses + Opera + Philosophy + Photography + Physics + Podcasts + Poetry + Politics + Pretty Much Pop + Productivity + Psychology + Radio + Random + Religion + Sci Fi + Science + Software + Sports + Stanford + Technology + TED Talks + Television + Theatre + Travel + Twitter + UC Berkeley + Uncategorized + Video - Arts & Culture + Video - Politics/Society + Video - Science + Video Games + Web/Tech + Wikipedia + Writing + Yale + YouTube * * Great Lectures + Michel Foucault + Sun Ra at UC Berkeley + Richard Feynman + Joseph Campbell + Carl Sagan + Margaret Atwood + Jorge Luis Borges + Leonard Bernstein + Richard Dawkins + Buckminster Fuller + Walter Kaufmann on Existentialism + Jacques Lacan + Roland Barthes + Nobel Lectures by Writers + Toni Morrison + Bertrand Russell + Oxford Philosophy Lectures * About Us [open-cultu] Open Culture scours the web for the best educational media. We find the free courses and audio books you need, the language lessons & educational videos you want, and plenty of enlightenment in between. Advertise With Us * Great Recordings + T.S. Eliot Reads Waste Land + Sylvia Plath - Ariel + Joyce Reads Ulysses + Joyce - Finnegans Wake + Patti Smith Reads Virginia Woolf + Albert Einstein + Charles Bukowski + Bill Murray + Hemingway + Fitzgerald Reads Shakespeare + William Faulkner + Flannery O'Connor + Tolkien - The Hobbit + Allen Ginsberg - Howl + W.B Yeats + Ezra Pound + Dylan Thomas + Anne Sexton + John Cheever + David Foster Wallace * Subscribe to our Newsletter Subscribe * Book Lists By + Neil deGrasse Tyson + Ernest Hemingway + F. Scott Fitzgerald + Allen Ginsberg + Patti Smith + Brian Eno + Henry Miller + Christopher Hitchens + Joseph Brodsky + W.H. Auden + Donald Barthelme + Carl Sagan + David Bowie + Samuel Beckett + Art Garfunkel + Marilyn Monroe + Jorge Luis Borges + Picks by Female Creatives * * * Syllabi + WH Auden + David Foster Wallace + Donald Barthelme + Allen Ginsberg + Zadie Smith & Gary Shteyngart + Spike Lee + Lynda Barry + Junot Diaz * Favorite Movies + Kubrick + Kurosawa's 100 + Tarantino + Scorsese + Tarkovsky + David Lynch + Werner Herzog + Woody Allen + Wes Anderson + Luis Bunuel + Roger Ebert + Susan Sontag + Scorsese Foreign Films + Philosophy Films * Archives + September 2023 + August 2023 + July 2023 + June 2023 + May 2023 + April 2023 + March 2023 + February 2023 + January 2023 + December 2022 + November 2022 + October 2022 + September 2022 + August 2022 + July 2022 + June 2022 + May 2022 + April 2022 + March 2022 + February 2022 + January 2022 + December 2021 + November 2021 + October 2021 + September 2021 + August 2021 + July 2021 + June 2021 + May 2021 + April 2021 + March 2021 + February 2021 + January 2021 + December 2020 + November 2020 + October 2020 + September 2020 + August 2020 + July 2020 + June 2020 + May 2020 + April 2020 + March 2020 + February 2020 + January 2020 + December 2019 + November 2019 + October 2019 + September 2019 + August 2019 + July 2019 + June 2019 + May 2019 + April 2019 + March 2019 + February 2019 + January 2019 + December 2018 + November 2018 + October 2018 + September 2018 + August 2018 + July 2018 + June 2018 + May 2018 + April 2018 + March 2018 + February 2018 + January 2018 + December 2017 + November 2017 + October 2017 + September 2017 + August 2017 + July 2017 + June 2017 + May 2017 + April 2017 + March 2017 + February 2017 + January 2017 + December 2016 + November 2016 + October 2016 + September 2016 + August 2016 + July 2016 + June 2016 + May 2016 + April 2016 + March 2016 + February 2016 + January 2016 + December 2015 + November 2015 + October 2015 + September 2015 + August 2015 + July 2015 + June 2015 + May 2015 + April 2015 + March 2015 + February 2015 + January 2015 + December 2014 + November 2014 + October 2014 + September 2014 + August 2014 + July 2014 + June 2014 + May 2014 + April 2014 + March 2014 + February 2014 + January 2014 + December 2013 + November 2013 + October 2013 + September 2013 + August 2013 + July 2013 + June 2013 + May 2013 + April 2013 + March 2013 + February 2013 + January 2013 + December 2012 + November 2012 + October 2012 + September 2012 + August 2012 + July 2012 + June 2012 + May 2012 + April 2012 + March 2012 + February 2012 + January 2012 + December 2011 + November 2011 + October 2011 + September 2011 + August 2011 + July 2011 + June 2011 + May 2011 + April 2011 + March 2011 + February 2011 + January 2011 + December 2010 + November 2010 + October 2010 + September 2010 + August 2010 + July 2010 + June 2010 + May 2010 + April 2010 + March 2010 + February 2010 + January 2010 + December 2009 + November 2009 + October 2009 + September 2009 + August 2009 + July 2009 + June 2009 + May 2009 + April 2009 + March 2009 + February 2009 + January 2009 + December 2008 + November 2008 + October 2008 + September 2008 + August 2008 + July 2008 + June 2008 + May 2008 + April 2008 + March 2008 + February 2008 + January 2008 + December 2007 + November 2007 + October 2007 + September 2007 + August 2007 + July 2007 + June 2007 + May 2007 + April 2007 + March 2007 + February 2007 + January 2007 + December 2006 + November 2006 + October 2006 + September 2006 * Search [open-cultu] (c)2006-2023 Open Culture, LLC. All rights reserved. * Home * About Us * Advertise with Us * Copyright Policy * Privacy Policy * Terms of Use * Bio * Audio Books * Online Courses * MOOCs * Movies * Languages * Textbooks * eBooks * * * * Quantcast Open Culture was founded by Dan Colman. Cleantalk Pixel Close Do you want more open culture? if you like our Facebook fanpage, you'll receive more articles like the one you just read! --------------------------------------------------------------------- Do you already like us on Facebook? Do not ask me again for Facebook --------------------------------------------------------------------- Continue to the article >>