https://www.eff.org/press/releases/appeals-court-upholds-publicresourceorgs-right-post-public-laws-and-regulations Skip to main content * About + Contact + Press + People + Opportunities * Issues + Free Speech + Privacy + Creativity and Innovation + Transparency + International + Security * Our Work + Deeplinks Blog + Press Releases + Events + Legal Cases + Whitepapers + Podcast + Annual Reports * Take Action + Action Center + Electronic Frontier Alliance + Volunteer * Tools + Privacy Badger + HTTPS Everywhere + Surveillance Self-Defense + Certbot + Atlas of Surveillance + Cover Your Tracks + Crocodile Hunter * Donate + Donate to EFF + Giving Societies + Shop + Other Ways to Give + Membership FAQ * Donate + Donate to EFF + Shop + Other Ways to Give * Search form Search [ ] --------------------------------------------------------------------- Email updates on news, actions, and events in your area. Join EFF Lists * Copyright (CC BY) * Trademark * Privacy Policy * Thanks Electronic Frontier Foundation Donate [effawardss] [eff_awards] Electronic Frontier Foundation * About + Contact + Press + People + Opportunities * Issues + Free Speech + Privacy + Creativity and Innovation + Transparency + International + Security * Our Work + Deeplinks Blog + Press Releases + Events + Legal Cases + Whitepapers + Podcast + Annual Reports * Take Action + Action Center + Electronic Frontier Alliance + Volunteer * Tools + Privacy Badger + HTTPS Everywhere + Surveillance Self-Defense + Certbot + Atlas of Surveillance + Cover Your Tracks + Crocodile Hunter * Donate + Donate to EFF + Giving Societies + Shop + Other Ways to Give + Membership FAQ * Donate + Donate to EFF + Shop + Other Ways to Give * Search form Search [ ] Appeals Court Upholds Public.Resource.Org's Right to Post Public Laws and Regulations Online Our laws belong to all of us, and we should be able to find, read, and share them free of registration requirements, fees, and other roadblocks. PRESS RELEASE Press Release September 12, 2023 Appeals Court Upholds Public.Resource.Org's Right to Post Public Laws and Regulations Online Share It Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Copy link SAN FRANCISCO--Technical standards like fire and electrical codes developed by private organizations but incorporated into public law can be freely disseminated without any liability for copyright infringement, a federal appeals court ruled Tuesday. Tuesday's ruling by a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit upholds the idea that our laws belong to all of us, and we should be able to find, read, and share them free of registration requirements, fees, and other roadblocks. It's a long-awaited victory for Public.Resource.org, a nonprofit organization founded in 2007 by open records advocate Carl Malamud of Healdsburg, Calif., and represented in this case by the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) with co-counsel Fenwick & West and David Halperin. "In a nation governed by the rule of law, private parties have no business controlling who can read, share, and speak the rules to which we are all subject," EFF Legal Director Corynne McSherry said. "We are pleased that the Court of Appeals upheld what other U.S. courts, including the Supreme Court, have said for almost 200 years: No one should control access to the law." As part of its mission of promoting public access to all kinds of government information, Public Resource acquires and posts online a wide variety of public documents, such as nonprofits' tax returns, government-produced videos, and standards incorporated into law by reference. These standards include electrical, fire safety, and consumer safety codes that have been mandated by governments. But without Public Resource's work, they are often difficult to access, much less share with others, which means that areas of law that profoundly affect our daily life are obscured from our view. Even courts have had trouble accessing the laws that they are supposed to apply. The American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM), National Fire Protection Association Inc. (NFPA), and American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) are organizations that develop private sector codes and standards aimed at advancing public safety, ensuring compatibility across products and services, facilitating training, and spurring innovation. ASTM, NFPA, and ASHRAE sued Public Resource in 2013 for copyright and trademark infringement and unfair competition. Affirming a trial court's March 2022 decision, the appeals court found Tuesday that Public Resource's use is for nonprofit, educational purposes, and that this use serves a different purpose than that of the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs "seek to advance science and industry by producing standards reflecting industry or engineering best practices," the court wrote, while "Public Resource's mission in republishing the standards is very different--to provide the public with a free and comprehensive repository of the law." "Public Resource posts standards that government agencies have incorporated into law--no more and no less," the appeals court ruled. "If an agency has given legal effect to an entire standard, then its entire reproduction is reasonable in relation to the purpose of the copying, which is to provide the public with a free and comprehensive repository of the law." The appeals court also found that although Public Resource has been posting incorporated standards for 15 years, the plaintiffs haven't shown any evidence that this harmed them financially. And "even if Public Resource's postings were likely to lower demand for the plaintiffs' standards, we would also have to consider the substantial public benefits of free and easy access to the law," the court ruled. The appeals court rejected the plaintiffs' argument that because they make standards available for free in online reading rooms, Public Resource's use cannot be transformative fair use. All but one of these rooms opened after Public Resource began posting incorporated standards, the court noted, and those reading rooms fail to provide convenient access. "Among other things, text is not searchable, cannot be printed or downloaded, and cannot be magnified without becoming blurry. Often, a reader can view only a portion of each page at a time and, upon zooming in, must scroll from right to left to read a single line of text. Public Resource's postings suffer from none of these shortcomings." Malamud praised the appeals court's decision and said Public Resource will redouble its efforts. "It has been over 10 years since plaintiffs filed suit in this case," he said. "Today, the U.S. Court of Appeals has found decisively in favor of the proposition that citizens must not be relegated to economy-class access to the law. This win would not have been possible without the untiring and dedicated work by the legal team of EFF, Fenwick & West, and David Halperin, as well as the dozens of amicus briefs filed on our behalf. I'm very grateful for all their help." For the opinion of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit: https://www.eff.org/document/opinion-7 For more on the Public Resource case: https://www.eff.org/cases/ publicresource-freeingthelaw Contact: Corynne McSherry Mitch Stoltz Related Issues Fair Use Transparency Related Cases Freeing the Law with Public.Resource.Org Share It Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Copy link Join EFF Lists Discover more. Email updates on news, actions, events in your area, and more. Email Address [ ] Postal Code (optional) [ ] Anti-spam question: Enter the three-letter abbreviation for Electronic Frontier Foundation: [ ] Don't fill out this field (required) [ ] [Submit] Thanks, you're awesome! Please check your email for a confirmation link. Oops something is broken right now, please try again later. Related Updates [social-icons_0] Deeplinks Blog by Karen Gullo | July 20, 2023 Victory! Embedded Links to Photos on Instagram Don't Infringe Photographers' Copyrights, Court Rules Every day, we visit websites or read news articles that contain photos embedded from somewhere else, usually other websites or servers where the images were first published or stored. What's happening behind the scenes when you click on a website chock full of photos and text is a basic function... 4 icons representing saving News from big tech Deeplinks Blog by Cory Doctorow | May 24, 2023 To Save the News, We Must Shatter Ad-Tech This is part two of an ongoing, five-part series. Part one, the introduction, is here. Part three, about banning surveillance ads, is here. Part four, about opening up app stores, is here. Part five, about enshrining "end-to-end" delivery on social media, is here. Download this... Supreme Court Deeplinks Blog by Corynne McSherry, Cara Gagliano, Katharine Trendacosta | May 23, 2023 What the Supreme Court's Decision in Warhol Means for Fair Use The Supreme Court has issued its long-awaited decision in Andy Warhol Foundation v. Goldsmith, a fair use case that raised fundamental questions about rights and obligations of commercial artists. The Court's opinion did not answer many of those questions, but happily it affirmed both important fair use precedents and the... [fair-use-og-1] Deeplinks Blog by Corynne McSherry | April 24, 2023 The DMCA Cannot Protect You From Your Own Words There is a loud debate raging over what companies should and shouldn't be doing about the things people say on their platforms. What people often seem to forget is that we already know the dangers of providing a quick way for people to remove criticism of themselves from the internet.... Copyrightability of input formats and output designs Deeplinks Blog by Michael Barclay | April 10, 2023 In SAS v. WPL, the Federal Circuit Finally Gets Something Right on Computer Copyright Figuring out the correct boundaries of software copyright protection is a difficult task. As several judges have put it, "applying copyright law to computer programs is like assembling a jigsaw puzzle whose pieces do not quite fit." Last week, the U.S. Court... Copyright Symbol Deeplinks Blog by Cara Gagliano | January 20, 2023 For Would-Be Censors and the Thin-Skinned, Copyright Law Offers Powerful Tools We're taking part in Copyright Week, a series of actions and discussions supporting key principles that should guide copyright policy. Every day this week, various groups are taking on different elements of copyright law and policy, and addressing what's at stake, and what we need to do to make... [og-copyrightweek2] Deeplinks Blog by Corynne McSherry | January 19, 2023 Fair Use Creep Is A Feature, Not a Bug Lawyers, scholars, and activists, including EFF, often highlight Section 512 of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and Section 230 (originally of the Communications Decency Act) as the legal foundations of the internet. But there's another, much older, doctrine that's at least as important: Fair use, which dates back many decades... [fair-use-og-1] Deeplinks Blog by Kit Walsh | December 7, 2022 DC Circuit Evades Important Questions in Disappointing Ruling on Section 1201 of the DMCA The Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit has issued a disappointing ruling in the case of Green v. DOJ. The ruling left intact a law that has stifled speech and innovation for decades and forced researchers, advocates, teachers, and tinkerers to beg for government permission to do... [secret-identity-2] Deeplinks Blog by Cindy Cohn | July 13, 2022 Impact Litigation in Action: Building the Caselaw Behind a Win for Free Speech A recent District Court decision in In re DMCA 512(h) Subpoena to Twitter, Inc. is a great win for free speech. The Court firmly rejected the argument that copyright law creates a shortcut around the First Amendment's protections for anonymous critics. In the case, a company tried to... [eff-pr-og] Press Release | July 8, 2022 Internet Archive Seeks Summary Judgment in Federal Lawsuit Filed By Publishing Companies SAN FRANCISCO--The Internet Archive has asked a federal judge to rule in its favor and end a radical lawsuit, filed by four major publishing companies, that aims to criminalize library lending.The Internet Archive, headquartered in San Francisco, is a 501(c)(3) non-profit library which preserves and provides access to cultural artifacts... Back to top EFF Home Follow EFF: * x * facebook * instagram * youtube * flicker * linkedin * mastodon * tiktok Check out our 4-star rating on Charity Navigator. Contact * General * Legal * Security * Membership * Press About * Calendar * Volunteer * Victories * History * Internships * Jobs * Staff * Diversity & Inclusion Issues * Free Speech * Privacy * Creativity & Innovation * Transparency * International * Security Updates * Blog * Press Releases * Events * Legal Cases * Whitepapers * EFFector Newsletter Press * Press Contact Donate * Join or Renew Membership Online * One-Time Donation Online * Giving Societies * Shop * Other Ways to Give * Copyright (CC BY) * Trademark * Privacy Policy * Thanks JavaScript license information *