https://www.theregister.com/2023/08/11/judge_denies_hps_request_to/ # # Sign in / up The Register(r) -- Biting the hand that feeds IT # # # Topics Security Security All SecurityCyber-crimePatchesResearchCSO (X) Off-Prem Off-Prem All Off-PremEdge + IoTChannelPaaS + IaaSSaaS (X) On-Prem On-Prem All On-PremSystemsStorageNetworksHPCPersonal Tech (X) Software Software All SoftwareAI + MLApplicationsDatabasesDevOpsOSesVirtualization (X) Offbeat Offbeat All OffbeatDebatesColumnistsScienceGeek's GuideBOFHLegalBootnotesSite NewsAbout Us (X) Special Features Special Features All Special Features Blackhat and DEF CON Sysadmin Month The Reg in Space Emerging Clean Energy Tech Week Spotlight on RSA Energy Efficient Datacenters Vendor Voice Vendor Voice Vendor Voice All Vendor VoiceAmazon Web Services (AWS) Business Transformation DataikuDDNGoogle Cloud for StartupsHewlett Packard Enterprise: AI & ML solutionsHewlett Packard Enterprise: Edge-to-Cloud PlatformIntel vProVMware (X) Resources Resources Whitepapers Webinars & Events Newsletters [personalte] Personal Tech 50 comment bubble on white Judge denies HP's plea to throw out all-in-one printer lockdown lawsuit 50 comment bubble on white AiO devices won't scan or fax without ink, and plaintiffs say IT giant illegally withheld that info from buyers icon Brandon Vigliarolo Fri 11 Aug 2023 // 23:28 UTC # HP all-in-one printer owners, upset that their devices wouldn't scan or fax when low on ink, were handed a partial win in a northern California court this week after a judge denied HP's motion to dismiss their suit. The plaintiffs argued in their amended class action complaint [PDF] that HP withheld vital information by including software in its all-in-one printer/scanner/fax machines that disabled non-printing functions when out of ink and not telling buyers that was the case. "It is well-documented that ink is not required in order to scan or to fax a document, and it is certainly possible to manufacture an All-in-One printer that scans or faxes when the device is out of ink," the plaintiffs argued in their complaint. The amended complaint was filed in February this year after US federal Judge Beth Labson Freeman dismissed the suit on the grounds that it hadn't properly stated a claim. [personalte] Armed with their amended complaint, lawyers for San Francsican Gary Freund and Minneapolis resident Wayne McMath have succeeded at not only making relevant claims, but also surviving an attempt by HP to have the entire case dismissed for a second time. [personalte] [personalte] In the amended complaint, Freund and McMath's lawyers argue that HP's move to disable devices that were low on ink was intentional, citing HP's own comments from a support forum post in which an HP support agent told a user complaining of similar issues that their "HP printer is designed in such a way that with the empty cartridge or without the cartridge [the] printer will not function." "At this stage, the message board post amounts to a factual allegation that bolster plaintiffs' allegations that HP designed its printers to disable certain functions when their ink is depleted," Judge Freeman said in her order [PDF] handed down yesterday. * HP pays $1.3m to settle dispute over printer security chip * HP Inc to lay off up to 6,000 staff, cut costs by $1.4 billion * Florida man might just stick it to HP for injecting sneaky DRM update into his printers that rejected non-HP ink * HP: That print-free-for-life deal we promised you? Well, now it's pay-per-month to continue using your printer ink Additionally, Judge Freeman found the plaintiffs had "adequately" described "the alleged defect and HP's knowledge of that defect," they had adequately pleaded that HP had a duty to disclose the restrictions, and that the defect occurred within the warranty period since the devices were shipped with ink cartridge limitations for non-printing features. Judge Freeman allowed other claims to stand as well, only dismissing the plaintiffs' request for equitable restitution under the Minnesota Deceptive Trade Practices Act. Otherwise, Freeman said, "these allegations are sufficient" to allow the case to proceed. [personalte] This isn't the first time HP has been taken to court over claims it improperly locked printers down. In 2022 the IT giant settled a European lawsuit for $1.35 million alleging it used security chips and DRM-like software to prevent any third-party cartridges from functioning in HP printers. The US corporation has dealt with similar cases in Australia and America, which were settled. HP hasn't responded to our questions about the latest lawsuit. Canon, another printer manufacturer that sells all-in-one devices, was sued in 2021 for the exact same reasons as Freund and McMath's suit against HP - that Canon all-in-ones disabled non-printing functions when ink was low. That case was settled late last year for an undisclosed sum. (r) Get our Tech Resources # Share More about * HP Inc * Lawsuit * Printer More like these x More about * HP Inc * Lawsuit * Printer Narrower topics * HP Instant Ink Broader topics * Hardware More about # Share 50 comment bubble on white COMMENTS More about * HP Inc * Lawsuit * Printer More like these x More about * HP Inc * Lawsuit * Printer Narrower topics * HP Instant Ink Broader topics * Hardware TIP US OFF Send us news --------------------------------------------------------------------- Other stories you might like SEC lawsuit against Terraform Labs and cofounder Do Kwon lives to fight another day Crypto bad boy's appeal denied, despite recent Ripple Labs ruling Legal1 Aug 2023 | 2 Epic snub by Supreme Court in battle to escape Apple App Store payment prison This fight over IAP is getting, dare we say, unreal Edge + IoT10 Aug 2023 | 6 Cigna sued for using software to deny healthcare insurance claims It's just some if-then statements, no AI here, insurer sniffs Applications26 Jul 2023 | 30 How to bridge data silos and enable cloud-like efficiency within on-prem infrastructure Unlocking data potential with HPE GreenLake Sponsored Feature [personalte] Apple owes Brit iOS app devs millions from excessively high commission, lawsuit claims Lawyers look to scale the walled garden Applications25 Jul 2023 | 21 Tesla board members to return $735M in compensation settlement Look who is learning to share: Deal includes no admission of fault, naturally Personal Tech18 Jul 2023 | 40 We will find you and we will sue you, Twitter tells 4 mystery alleged data-scrapers Lawyers say unknown John Does are profiting at Musk's expense Legal14 Jul 2023 | 90 Celsius feels the heat: Ex-CEO arrested, watchdogs line up to sue bankrupt crypto biz Exec faces fraud charges, one regulator wants $5 billion fine Cyber-crime13 Jul 2023 | 10 SpaceX says, sure, Starship blew up but you can forget about the rest of that lawsuit Won't someone think of the (checks notes) Kemp's Ridley sea turtle? Science6 Jul 2023 | 54 Obscure internet boutique Amazon sues EU for calling it a Very Large Online Platform If it walks like a duck... PaaS + IaaS11 Jul 2023 | 62 Should leaders place bets on new PCs or generative AI? Here's a hint: Leaders are putting laptop orders on ice Personal Tech11 Jul 2023 | 17 Microsoft stole our stolen dark web data, says security outfit Suit claims Redmond took far more than allowed from Hold's 360M-credential database Security12 Jun 2023 | 8 The Register icon Biting the hand that feeds IT About Us* * Contact us * Advertise with us * Who we are Our Websites* * The Next Platform * DevClass * Blocks and Files Your Privacy* * Cookies Policy * Privacy Policy * T's & C's * Do not sell my personal information Situation Publishing Copyright. All rights reserved (c) 1998-2023 no-js