https://www.fsf.org/blogs/community/web-environment-integrity-is-an-all-out-attack-on-the-free-internet Become a part of the community. Let's work together to improve and spread free software. Join the FSF today for $10/month ($5 for students) to foster free software projects, amplify your voice, and show your support for software freedom. Help us grow the community by another 25 new associate members before July 28! Read more | Join Join Renew Donate Skip to content, sitemap or skip to search. [logo-new] Personal tools * Log in * Help! * Members forum Join now * About * Campaigns * Licensing * Membership * Resources * Community * Donate * Shop * Search You are here: Home > Blogs > Community > "Web Environment Integrity" is an all-out attack on the free Internet Info "Web Environment Integrity" is an all-out attack on the free Internet by Greg Farough Contributions -- Published on Jul 28, 2023 10:29 AM Read why "Web Environment Integrity" is terrible, and why we must vocally oppose it now. Google's latest maneuver, if we don't act to stop it, threatens our freedom to explore the Internet with browsers of our choice. Editorial note: For greater visibility, this article has been published here, on fsf.org. You can also find it on defectivebydesign.org, which also has other DRM-related articles and materials. Using a free browser is now more important than ever. We've written recently on this topic, but the issue we wrote about there was minor compared to the gross injustice Google is now attempting to force down the throats of web users around the world. The so-called "Web Environment Integrity" (WEI) is the worst stunt we've seen from them in some time. Beginning its life as an innocuous, if worrying, policy document posted to Microsoft GitHub, Google has now fast-tracked its development into their Chromium browser. At its current rate of progress, WEI will be upon us in no time. By giving developers an API through which they can approve certain browser configurations while forbidding others, WEI is a tremendous step toward the "enshittification" of the web as a whole. Many of us have grown up with a specific idea of the Internet, the notion of it as a collection of hyperlinked pages that can be accessed by a wide variety of different machines, programs, and operating systems. WEI is this idea's antithesis. Compared to its staggering potential effects, the technical means through which WEI will accomplish its ends is relatively simple. Before serving a web page, a server can ask a third-party "verification" service to make sure that the user's browsing environment has not been "tampered" with. A translation of the policy's terminology will help us here: this Google-owned server will be asked to make sure that the browser does not deviate in any way from Google's accepted browser configuration, precluding any meaningful use of the four freedoms. It is not far-fetched to imagine a future in which sites simply refuse to serve pages to users running free browsers or free operating systems. If WEI isn't stopped now, that future will come sooner than we think. While Web Environment Integrity has a policy document that attempts to explain valid ways in which it could be used, these are all non-issues compared to the way that we know it will be used. It will be used by governments to ensure that only their officially "approved" (read: backdoored) browsers are able to access the Internet; it will be used by corporations like Netflix to further Digital Restrictions Management (DRM); it will be used by Google to deny access to their services unless you are using a browser that gels with their profit margin. Once upon a time, Google's official policy was "don't be evil." With the rapid progress they've made on Web Environment Integrity in such a short time, we can say very safely that their policy is now to pioneer evil. As we write this, talented and well-paid Google engineers and executives are working to dismantle what makes the web the web. Given that Google is one of the largest corporations on the planet, our only hope of saving the Internet as we know it is a clear and principled stance for freedom, a collective upholding of the communal principles on which the web was based. Let us repeat: there is absolutely no legitimate justification for WEI. The use cases that the policy document highlights are nothing compared to its real use case, which is developing a method to obtain complete and total restriction of the free Internet. We urge everyone involved in a decision-making capacity at Google to consider the principles on which the web was founded, and to carefully contemplate whether Web Environment Integrity aligns with those principles. We hope that they will realize WEI's fundamental incompatibility with the free Internet and cease work on the standard immediately. And if they don't? Well, they ought to be ashamed. Document Actions * Share on social networks * Syndicate: * News * Events * Blogs * Jobs * GNU * 1PC9aZC4hNX2rmmrt7uHTfYAS3hRbph4UN [ ] [Search] Take Action Let the representatives of your government know that end-to-end encryption is vital, and share your message on social media to inspire others. * FSF community blog * Licensing Compliance Lab blog * Associate Membership blog * System Administrator's blog * Free Software Directory blog * GNU Press blog Sign up Enter your email address to receive our monthly newsletter, the Free Software Supporter [ ] [Subscribe me] RSS feed News News Item The next round of FSF board candidate discussions will start on July 24 Jul 20, 2023 News Item The FSF board candidate discussions will start on May 29 May 16, 2023 News Item Announcing the FSF's board candidates May 02, 2023 More news... RSS feed Recent blogs "Web Environment Integrity" is an all-out attack on the free Internet From pro-democracy activists to minorities: Why people use Tor and encrypted chats Working together for free software: Meet Ali "Miracle" Abdulghani Working together for free software: Our interview with Protesilaos Stavrou Recent blogs - More... RSS feed Upcoming Events Event C source code Free Software Directory meeting on IRC: Friday, August 04, starting at 12:00 EDT (16:00 UTC) Aug 04, 2023 12:00 PM - 03:00 PM -- #fsf on libera.chat Previous events... Upcoming events... The FSF is a charity with a worldwide mission to advance software freedom -- learn about our history and work. Copyright (c) 2004-2023 Free Software Foundation, Inc. Privacy Policy. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 license (or later version) -- Why this license? Skip sitemap or skip to licensing items * About + Staff and Board + Contact Us + Press Information + Jobs + Volunteering and Internships + History * Privacy Policy * JavaScript Licenses * Hardware Database * Free Software Directory * Free Software Resources * Copyright Infringement Notification Skip to general items * Campaigns + Freedom Ladder + Fight to Repair + Free JavaScript + High Priority Free Software Projects + Secure Boot vs Restricted Boot + Surveillance + Upgrade from Windows + Working Together for Free Software + GNU Operating System + Defective by Design + End Software Patents + OpenDocument + Free BIOS + Connect with free software users Skip to philosophical items * Licensing + Education + Licenses o GNU GPL o GNU AGPL o GNU LGPL o GNU FDL + Licensing FAQ + Compliance + How to use GNU licenses for your own software * Latest News + Upcoming Events + FSF Blogs Skip list * Donate to the FSF * Join the FSF * Patrons * Associate Members * My Account * Working Together for Free Software Fund * Philosophy + The Free Software Definition + Copyleft: Pragmatic Idealism + Free Software and Free Manuals + Selling Free Software + Motives for Writing Free Software + The Right To Read + Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software * Complete Sitemap fsf.org is powered by: * Plone * Zope * Python * CiviCRM * HTML5 [English ] [Select language] Send your feedback on our translations and new translations of pages to campaigns@fsf.org.