https://easydns.com/blog/2023/07/26/uk-version-of-online-harms-bill-wants-to-prefilter-content-without-due-process/ * Skip to primary navigation * Skip to main content * Skip to primary sidebar * Skip to footer easyDNS easyDNS Power & Freedom * Call 1.855.321.EASY (3279) * Contact * Login * Support * Renew * Renew * Support * Login * Contact * Domains + Domain Registration o Register Domains o Register .ca Domains o Transfer Domains o Domain Plus + Domain Security o Set and Forget DNSSEC(tm) o Registry Lock o myPrivacy Protection * DNS Hosting + Anycast DNS o DNS Standard o DNS Pro o Enterprise DNS o 30 Day Free Trial + DNS Services o DYNDNS o DNSSEC o High Availability DNS o Reverse DNS Service + DNS Integrations o Proactive Nameservers o easyRoute53 + DNS Pricing + DNS Subscription Block Pricing * Web Hosting + easyVPS + easyWeb Self-Managed (cPanel) o cPanel Plans o cPanel Specs + Managed WordPress o WordPress Plans o WordPress Specs * Email + Email Products + easyMail Standalone + easyOutbound SMTP Service + Email Tools + Webmail Login * More + Features + Blog + About Us + #AxisOfEasy + Our Guarantee + SSL Certificates & Trust + easyBackup Cloud Storage + True Stories * Help + Account Management + Domain Management + DNS Management + easyMail Management + Contact EasyDNS + Open Account [ ] Name Variation SEARCH >> + .app, .guru, .co, .io, .us, .rocks and more... UK Version of "Online Harms Bill" wants to prefilter content without due process July 26, 2023 by Mark E. Jeftovic Leave a Comment [svg][minority-report-1-e1690389767969] Experts warn that ISPs would use black-box AI to comply Like our piece on Canada's Cyber-Security Bill earlier this year, this item was flagged in my work for the Internet Society, Canada Chapter, but this post does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the ISCC. It concerns a legal opinion drafted by the UK's Open Rights Group (similar mission to Internet Society and other civil society groups), on that country's planned "Online Harms Bill". Recall that here in Canada, we also have Online Harms legislation in the works. When Steven Guilbeault was Heritage Minister, he began crafting Bill C-36, which would seek (among other things), to designate political dissent as "hate speech", criminalize the criticism of politicians and may require ISPs to implement "an internet kill switch to block websites deemed hurtful". The major red flag in the UK bill is the concept of "prior restraint ". In communications to the ISOC, Dr Monica Horten expressed Open Rights Group's concerns that, "This is the concept of banning content before publication, or blocking publication without due process, and may be interpreted as an 'upload filter'. Whilst the legal Advice does not directly address the provisions that affect encrypted messaging services, it could have implications. It addresses Clause 9 (2) which requires online providers to 'prevent users encountering' illegal content. The same language is used in Clause 111 which establishes the power for Ofcom to require encrypted messaging services to screen users' communications. For this reason, we would like to draw your attention to it. The Advice warns that the Online Safety Bill could fundamentally alter online communication by enforcing 'prior restraint through AI, stifling freedom of expression by blocking content deemed 'illegal' without - explanation, notification or due process' for the censored user. The Advice considers that Clause 9 (2) provides for state-sanctioned 'prior restraint' on freedom of expression through the use of proprietorial processes by private companies. This will lead to interference with freedom of expression which is not "prescribed by law" - meaning that it would not be sufficiently accessible, clear and foreseeable to allow individuals to regulate their conduct accordingly for the purposes of Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights." As Thomas Sowell would say, "Oh dear, where to begin?" We saw under the Covid years how pre-emptive shaping of permissible speech on the part of governments, the Big Tech platforms and various private "fact checking" rackets, resulted in wholesale censorship, deplatforming, and even coordinated defamation and professional harm. In short, people had their lives and careers destroyed for speaking out, for questioning the "official" narrative, or for proposing alternative mitigation methodologies than those espoused by unelected, unaccountable technocrats. In many cases, those prevailing, official narratives have turned out to be fallacious or incorrect to the point of being somewhere on a spectrum between misinformation and institutionalized gaslighting. Governments, Big Tech, and the corporate media should be slinking off into a corner and licking the wounds of their now shattered credibility, while trying to figure out ways to rebuild trust amongst a public that they have all betrayed beyond redemption. Instead, they are trying to ram through new legislation, more rules, and opaque algos that would seek to further penalize dissent, criminalize non-conforming thought, and as Dr. Horten spells out plainly: violate universal human rights. It would also thrust the implementation phase of this Brave New World onto ISPs, service providers and communications services, which for the most part, are built to do the exact opposite of what these new initiatives propose. In many cases we are now dealing with decentralized, open source protocols for which such new legislation would be pointless and unenforcible, if not absurd. All so that they can double-down on their own failures and escape facing any accountability for getting every meaningful talking point around the pandemic dead wrong. Meanwhile, In Canada... Moving the Online Safety legislation down the field is now under the purview of Pablo Rodriguez, Canada's current former Heritage Minister (he's out in a cabinet reshuffle moments ago), who was currently embroiled in the debacle of having single-handedly deplatformed the Canadian corporate media from Big Tech platforms with the deeply flawed Bill C-18 (C-36's original architect Steven Guilbeault is currently Environment Minister). On it's own C-36 would be bad enough, but in concert with the myriad other pieces of legislation * C-11 put the Internet under the regulatory oversight of the CRTC * C-26 (the Cyber-Security bill) would grant sweeping, unsupervised power to bureaucrats and even quasi-government agencies to literally command and censor internet communications by decree * C-18 - aforementioned - trying to strong arm tech platforms into subsidizing Canada's flailing corporate media ...we continue to see some very disturbing convergences both here at home and internationally. Subscribe to the easyDNS #AxisOfEasy newsletter for a weekly digest and podcast covering internet security, censorship and privacy, and follow @AxisOfEasy on Twitter, or Nostr via npub1za32zx2xg99nfut4ch5y7km8vpumvsj48d4hakjnslhvjuzq2v6qm5qkml Filed Under: Of Interest, Uncategorized Tagged With: Bill C-3, Dr Monica Horten, Online Harms Bill, Open Rights Group, Pablo Rodriguez, Steven Guilbeault Reader Interactions Leave a Reply Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] Comment * [ ] Name * [ ] Email * [ ] Website [ ] [Post Comment] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] D[ ] Primary Sidebar #AxisOfEasy Sign up for our weekly newsletter [ ] Subscribe Search Blog Search this website[ ][Search] What Are You Waiting For? Get easyDNS on your side and move your domains or DNS today. * Transfer a domain * Register a new domain * Get anycast DNS Recent Posts * UK Version of "Online Harms Bill" wants to prefilter content without due process * Announcing easyNostr-NIP05 for WordPress * easyNostr: Setup your NIP-05 ID under your own domain (or use one of ours) * .INFO and .MOBI price increase * Canada's Bill C-26: Yet Another Government Power Grab * .NET 2023 price increase * Move over Mastodon, here comes Nostr Network Status * View Current Network Status New Knowledge Base [svg][kb] Managing Mission Critical Domains & DNS: The Book [svg][q]** We literally wrote the book on this stuff, Learn more. Categories * #AxisOfEasy * Alerts * Avis aux members * Customer-centrism * Going Paperless * Help and Support * Howto's and Help * In Beta * Industry Watch * Jobs * Member Mailouts * Metaviews * News * Of Interest * Open Source * Punch Above Your Weight * Resolved * status * Takedowns and Shakedowns * Tips and Tricks * Uncategorized * Updated * Using URLs Effectively * via DomainHELP.com * What's New * Who Uses easyDNS? [ ]SEARCH >> + .app, .guru, .co, .io, .us, .rocks and more... easyDNSeasyDNS Footer easyDNS Technologies, Inc. Founded In 1998 4243C Dundas St. W, Suite 405 Etobicoke, ON M8X 1Y3 Phone: +1.855.321.EASY (3279) Fax: +1.647.438.6227 support@easydns.com Products & Services * Domain Names * DNS * Web Hosting * Email Hosting * SSL Certificates & Trust Support/Help * Phone +1.855.321.EASY (3279) * Contact * Knowledge Base Resources & Tools * #AxisOfEasy About easyDNS * About Us * Blog * Our Guarantee * Email Hosting * Web Hosting Better Business Bureau Accredited BusinessBetter Business Bureau Accredited BusinessICANN Accredited RegistrarICANN Accredited Registrar.ca Certified Registrar.ca Certified Registrar Follow us on TwitterFollow us on TwitterLike us on FacebookLike us on Facebook (c) 1998-2023 easyDNS Technologies Inc. * All Rights Reserved * Terms of Service * Privacy * Contact x Login ALREADY HAVE AN ACCOUNT? LOG IN Username [ ] Password [ ] Forgot Password? Login x Forgot Password FORGOT PASSWORD? WE CAN HELP! Lost or forgotten your password? We can help! All your need to do is answer some questions, and we will assign you with a new password which you can later change to something (hopefully) more memorable. First, you will need to fill in one of the following two fields, and click next. Complete ONE of the following two fields Your easyDNS user name is [ ] OR One of your domain names is [ ] Next x Create Account NEW CUSTOMER? CREATE ACCOUNT Create a username [ ] Use 5-32 characters, no _ or . at the beginning, no __ or _. or ._ or .. inside, and no _ or . at the end. Create your password [ ] Use 8-128 characters, with at least one uppercase, one lowercase, and one number. Re-enter your password [ ] Email address [ ] Use a valid email address as this is where we will contact you about your account. First Name [ ] Last Name [ ] Organization / Company [ ] Street Address [ ] Street Address 2 [ ] Street Address 3 [ ] City [ ] Country [] Province [] Zip / Postal Code [ ] Phone [ ] Format: +1.1234567890[x1234] CloseCreate Account AxisOfEasy Weekly Newsletter Enter your email below to receive a concise, insightful weekly briefing and stay informed about cyberthreats and relevant tech happenings. For the time being you do not have to be an easyDNS member to receive #AxisOfEasy, however when you subscribe we'll send you a $10 coupon in case you ever decide to try out one of our many web services. Email [ ] Email [ ] This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. [Sign up now (Free)] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] D[ ] CLOSE Get on the #AxisOfEasy List AxisOfEasy Weekly Enter your email below to receive a concise, insightful weekly briefing and stay informed about cyberthreats and relevant tech happenings. For the time being you do not have to be an easyDNS member to receive #AxisOfEasy, however when you subscribe we'll send you a $10 coupon in case you ever decide to try out one of our many web services. * Email [ ] * Name [ ] This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. [Sign up now (Free)] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] D[ ] x Domain Portfolio Inquiry "*" indicates required fields Contact Information Name* [ ] First [ ] Last Phone* [ ] Email* [ ] Website [ ] How can we help? Where specifically can we help? [ ] Consolidate registrar to easyDNS [ ] Require DNS services [ ] Interested in brand protection, web hosting, email or other Please check all that apply Domains under management* ( ) Small to medium sized portfolio (10 to 100 names) ( ) Large portfolio > 100 domains ( ) Commercial portfolio, multiple downstream users (ISP's, webhosts) Please select the use case that most closely describes your situation Tell us more Verify You're Human [svg][486166734] [ ] Message [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] Email [ ] This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. [Submit] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] D[ ] X Real Time Web AnalyticsReal Time Web Analytics Clicky