https://www.livescience.com/physics-mathematics/dark-energy/the-expansion-of-the-universe-could-be-a-mirage-new-theoretical-study-suggests Skip to main content (*) ( ) Open menu Close menu Live Science [ ] Search Search Live Science [ ] Subscribe RSS How It Works Magazine How It Works Magazine Why subscribe? * The ultimate action-packed science and technology magazine bursting with exciting information about the universe * Subscribe today and save an extra 5% with checkout code 'LOVE5' * Engaging articles, amazing illustrations & exclusive interviews * Issues delivered straight to your door or device From$3.99 View * * Space * Health * Planet Earth * Animals * Archaeology * Physics & Math * Human Behavior * Technology * Chemistry * More + Science news + About Us + Forum Trending * Missing Titanic submersible * Summer solstice * Mystery orca stranding * Deepest point in the ocean * Best air purifiers for allergies When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here's how it works. 1. Home 2. Physics & Mathematics 3. Dark Energy The expansion of the universe could be a mirage, new theoretical study suggests News By Robert Lea published 20 June 2023 New research looking at the cosmological constant problem suggests the expansion of the universe could be an illusion. * * * * * * * Comments (3) A blue nebula looks like an eye in this NASA image Astronomers use the light from distant stars, such as the Helix Nebula seen here, to measure the apparent expansion of the universe. New resaerch suggests there may be more to the pictue that we're not seeing. (Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/SSC) The expansion of the universe could be a mirage, a potentially controversial new study suggests. This rethinking of the cosmos also suggests solutions for the puzzles of dark energy and dark matter, which scientists believe account for around 95% of the universe's total energy and matter but remain shrouded in mystery. The novel new approach is detailed in a paper published June 2 in the journal Classical and Quantum Gravity, by University of Geneva professor of theoretical physics Lucas Lombriser. Related: Dark energy could lead to a second (and third, and fourth) Big Bang, new research suggests Scientists know the universe is expanding because of redshift, the stretching of light's wavelength towards the redder end of the spectrum as the object emitting it moves away from us. Distant galaxies have a higher redshift than those nearer to us, suggesting those galaxies are moving ever further from Earth. More recently, scientists have found evidence that the universe's expansion isn't fixed, but is actually accelerating faster and faster. This accelerating expansion is captured by a term known as the cosmological constant, or lambda. The cosmological constant has been a headache for cosmologists because predictions of its value made by particle physics differ from actual observations by 120 orders of magnitude. The cosmological constant has therefore been described as "the worst prediction in the history of physics." Cosmologists often try to resolve the discrepancy between the different values of lambda by proposing new particles or physical forces but Lombriser tackles it by reconceptualizing what's already there.. "In this work, we put on a new pair of glasses to look at the cosmos and its unsolved puzzles by performing a mathematical transformation of the physical laws that govern it," Lombriser told Live Science via email. In Lombriser's mathematical interpretation, the universe isn't expanding but is flat and static, as Einstein once believed. The effects we observe that point to expansion are instead explained by the evolution of the masses of particles -- such as protons and electrons -- over time. In this picture, these particles arise from a field that permeates space-time. The cosmological constant is set by the field's mass and because this field fluctuates, the masses of the particles it gives birth to also fluctuate. The cosmological constant still varies with time, but in this model that variation is due to changing particle mass over time, not the expansion of the universe. In the model, these field fluctuations result in larger redshifts for distant galaxy clusters than traditional cosmological models predict. And so, the cosmological constant remains true to the model's predictions. "I was surprised that the cosmological constant problem simply seems to disappear in this new perspective on the cosmos," Lombriser said. A recipe for the dark universe Lombriser's new framework also tackles some of cosmology's other pressing problems, including the nature of dark matter. This invisible material outnumbers ordinary matter particles by a ratio of 5 to 1, but remains mysterious because it doesn't interact with light. Lombriser suggested that fluctuations in the field could also behave like a so-called axion field, with axions being hypothetical particles that are one of the suggested candidates for dark matter. These fluctuations could also do away with dark energy, the hypothetical force stretching the fabric of space and thus driving galaxies apart faster and faster. In this model, the effect of dark energy, according to Lombriser, would be explained by particle masses taking a different evolutionary path at later times in the universe. In this picture "there is, in principle, no need for dark energy," Lombriser added. related stories --Something is wrong with Einstein's theory of gravity --Da Vinci understood key aspect of gravity centuries before Einstein, lost sketches reveal --Are black holes wormholes? Post-doctoral researcher at the Universidad ECCI, Bogota, Colombia, Luz Angela Garcia, was impressed with Lombriser's new interpretation and how many problems it resolves. "The paper is pretty interesting, and it provides an unusual outcome for multiple problems in cosmology," Garcia, who was not involved in the research, told Live Science. "The theory provides an outlet for the current tensions in cosmology." However, Garcia urged caution in assessing the paper's findings, saying it contains elements in its theoretical model that likely can't be tested observationally, at least in the near future. Editor's note: This article was corrected at 1:30 p.m. ET on June 20, to reflect that redshift is evidence of cosmic expansion, but not evidence of accelerated cosmic expansion. Live Science newsletter Stay up to date on the latest science news by signing up for our Essentials newsletter. [ ][ ]Contact me with news and offers from other Future brands[ ]Receive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsors[Sign me up] By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over. Robert Lea Robert Lea Social Links Navigation Robert Lea is a science journalist in the U.K. who specializes in science, space, physics, astronomy, astrophysics, cosmology, quantum mechanics and technology. Rob's articles have been published in Physics World, New Scientist, Astronomy Magazine, All About Space and ZME Science. He also writes about science communication for Elsevier and the European Journal of Physics. Rob holds a bachelor of science degree in physics and astronomy from the U.K.'s Open University Latest Hundreds of lightning bolts illuminate the night sky during thunderstorm Electrifying time-lapse image captures 100 lightning bolts torching the sky over Turkey two boulders in a stream with vertebrate fossils Deadly cyclone unearths fossils of giant marine creatures that lived 80 million years ago The Titan submersible prior to descending from the surface. Missing Titanic submersible: What do we know about OceanGate's Titan sub disappearance? See more latest > See all comments (3) [ ] 3 Comments Comment from the forums * LaraK Is this new? I thought this already was a way to throw out the need for a dark matter and dark energy. Isn't that why protons decaying is something we want to observe? Reply * Johnnyreddogg Another theoretical and unobserved opinion. Acceleration has already been proven by observation and sound science. Reply * Aby "In this picture, these particles arise from a field that permeates space-time." How is this different from the Higgs Field? Reply * View All 3 Comments Most Popular [missing-im]Human impact on Earth's tilt leaves researchers 'surprised and concerned' By Sascha PareJune 20, 2023 [missing-im]Mystery orcas with bulbous heads wash up dead in unexplained mass stranding By Ethan FreedmanJune 20, 2023 [missing-im]2 planets will align with the 'Earth-shining' moon on the summer solstice. Here's how to watch. By Jamie CarterJune 19, 2023 [missing-im]Humans inhale a credit card's worth of microplastics every week. Here's where it ends up. By Ben TurnerJune 19, 2023 [missing-im]Enormous 240 million-year-old sea monster had its head torn off in one clean bite By Hannah OsborneJune 19, 2023 [missing-im]Mysterious spiral signals in the human brain could be key to our cognition By Ben TurnerJune 19, 2023 [missing-im]1st over-the-counter gel for erectile dysfunction approved by the FDA By Jennifer NalewickiJune 19, 2023 [missing-im]For a billion years, Earth may have had 19-hour days. Here's why. By Kiley PriceJune 19, 2023 [missing-im]'Hot Jupiter' planet killed and ate its Mercury-sized neighbor By Robert LeaJune 19, 2023 [missing-im]1st gene-edited snakes use mysterious 'Turing patterns' to achieve near-perfect hexagonal scales By Jennifer NalewickiJune 19, 2023 [missing-im]'Completely unique' Roman mausoleum discovered in rubble of London building site By Sascha PareJune 19, 2023 MOST READMOST SHARED 1. Scientists think a traumatized orca initiated the assault on boats after a "critical moment of agony" and that the behavior is spreading among the population through social learning. 1 Orcas have sunk 3 boats in Europe and appear to be teaching others to do the same. But why? 2. 2 Rare 1,760-pound goblin shark pregnant with 6 pups trawled up from Taiwan waters 3. 3 Enormous 240 million-year-old sea monster had its head torn off in one clean bite 4. 4 Mysterious spiral signals in the human brain could be key to our cognition 5. 5 86,000-year-old human bone found in Laos cave hints at 'failed population' from prehistory 1. Scientists think a traumatized orca initiated the assault on boats after a "critical moment of agony" and that the behavior is spreading among the population through social learning. 1 Orcas have sunk 3 boats in Europe and appear to be teaching others to do the same. But why? 2. 2 Australia's 'worst female serial killer' freed after her children's deadly gene mutations come to light 3. 3 A 79-year-old mathematician may have just solved an infinite dimension puzzle that's vexed theorists for decades 4. 4 Gigantic, 9.4-foot-long catfish is the largest ever caught 5. 5 Vast cemetery of Bronze Age burial mounds unearthed near Stonehenge Live Science is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site. * About Us * Contact Future's experts * Terms and conditions * Privacy policy * Cookies policy * Accessibility Statement * Advertise with us * Web notifications * Careers (c) Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.