https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-01546-4

Skip to main content

Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version
with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we
recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off
compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure
continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and
JavaScript.

Advertisement

Advertisement
Nature

  * View all journals
  * Search
  * Log in

  * Explore content
  * About the journal
  * Publish with us
  * Subscribe

  * Sign up for alerts
  * RSS feed

 1. nature
 2. editorials
 3. article

Why Nature will not allow the use of generative AI in images and
video
Download PDF

  * EDITORIAL
  * 07 June 2023

Why Nature will not allow the use of generative AI in images and
video

Saying 'no' to this kind of visual content is a question of research
integrity, consent, privacy and intellectual-property protection.

  * Twitter
  * Facebook
  * Email

You have full access to this article via your institution.

Download PDF

Download PDF
Using OpenAI DALL-E on phone. Woman testing artificial intelligence
image generator.

Nature will not publish imagery created wholly or partly using
generative AI.Credit: Artem Medvediev/Alamy

Should Nature allow generative artificial intelligence (AI) to be
used in the creation of images and videos? This journal has been
discussing, debating and consulting on this question for several
months following the explosion of content created using generative AI
tools such as ChatGPT and Midjourney, and the rapid increase in these
platforms' capabilities.

Apart from in articles that are specifically about AI, Nature will
not be publishing any content in which photography, videos or
illustrations have been created wholly or partly using generative AI,
at least for the foreseeable future.

Artists, filmmakers, illustrators and photographers whom we
commission and work with will be asked to confirm that none of the
work they submit has been generated or augmented using generative AI
(see go.nature.com/3c5vrtm).

[d41586-023]

Tools such as ChatGPT threaten transparent science; here are our
ground rules for their use

Why are we disallowing the use of generative AI in visual content?
Ultimately, it is a question of integrity. The process of publishing
-- as far as both science and art are concerned -- is underpinned by a
shared commitment to integrity. That includes transparency. As
researchers, editors and publishers, we all need to know the sources
of data and images, so that these can be verified as accurate and
true. Existing generative AI tools do not provide access to their
sources so that such verification can happen.

Then there's attribution: when existing work is used or cited, it
must be attributed. This is a core principle of science and art, and
generative AI tools do not conform to this expectation.

Consent and permission are also factors. These must be obtained if,
for example, people are being identified or the intellectual property
of artists and illustrators is involved. Again, common applications
of generative AI fail these tests.

Generative AI systems are being trained on images for which no
efforts have been made to identify the source. Copyright-protected
works are routinely being used to train generative AI without
appropriate permissions. In some cases, privacy is also being
violated -- for example, when generative AI systems create what look
like photographs or videos of people without their consent. In
addition to privacy concerns, the ease with which these 'deepfakes'
can be created is accelerating the spread of false information.

Appropriate caveats

For now, Nature is allowing the inclusion of text that has been
produced with the assistance of generative AI, providing this is done
with appropriate caveats (see go.nature.com/3cbrjbb). The use of such
large language model (LLM) tools needs to be documented in a paper's
methods or acknowledgements section, and we expect authors to provide
sources for all data, including those generated with the assistance
of AI. Furthermore, no LLM tool will be accepted as an author on a
research paper.

The world is on the brink of an AI revolution. This revolution holds
great promise, but AI -- and particularly generative AI -- is also
rapidly upending long-established conventions in science, art,
publishing and more. These conventions have, in some cases, taken
centuries to develop, but the result is a system that protects
integrity in science and protects content creators from exploitation.
If we're not careful in our handling of AI, all of these gains are at
risk of unravelling.

Many national regulatory and legal systems are still formulating
their responses to the rise of generative AI. Until they catch up, as
a publisher of research and creative works, Nature's stance will
remain a simple 'no' to the inclusion of visual content created using
generative AI.

Nature 618, 214 (2023)

doi: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-023-01546-4

Related Articles

  * [d41586-023] Tools such as ChatGPT threaten transparent science;
    here are our ground rules for their use

  * [d41586-023] How Nature readers are using ChatGPT

  * [d41586-023] 'Arms race with automation': professors fret about
    AI-generated coursework

Subjects

  * Publishing
  * Machine learning
  * Authorship
  * Education

Latest on:

Publishing
Revealed: the millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit
journal guidelines

Revealed: the millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit
journal guidelines

News 08 JUN 23

 

Preserve cultural diversity in author names

Correspondence 06 JUN 23

Tanzania's researchers offered US$22,000 to publish in international
journals

Tanzania's researchers offered US$22,000 to publish in international
journals

News 06 JUN 23

Machine learning
AI learns to write sorting software on its own

AI learns to write sorting software on its own

News & Views 07 JUN 23

DeepMind AI creates algorithms that sort data faster than those built
by people

DeepMind AI creates algorithms that sort data faster than those built
by people

News 07 JUN 23

 

ChatGPT: standard reporting guidelines for responsible use

Correspondence 06 JUN 23

Authorship
Anonymizing peer review makes the process more just

Anonymizing peer review makes the process more just

Career News 26 MAY 23

China overtakes United States on contribution to research in Nature
Index

China overtakes United States on contribution to research in Nature
Index

Nature Index 19 MAY 23

Why it's worth making computational methods easy to use

Why it's worth making computational methods easy to use

Career Column 27 APR 23

Nature Careers

Jobs

  * Announcement of Nanchang University on Open Recruitment of Deans
    of Schools and Affiliates

    All outstanding talents are warmly welcome to join Nanchang
    University to contribute yours wisdoms, realize your dreams and
    seek common development!

    Nanchang, Jiangxi, China

    Nanchang University

    []
  * Postdoctoral fellowship: The land-sea continuum; burial of
    terrestrial carbon in marine sediments

    Two-year postdoctoral fellowship on carbon burial in marine
    sediments at Umea University, Sweden

    Umea, Sweden

    Umea University (KBC)

    []
  * ECUST Seeking Global Talents

    Join Us and Create a Bright Future Together!

    Shanghai, China

    East China University of Science and Technology (ECUST)

    []
  * Faculty Positions at SUSTech School of Medicine

    Southern University of Science and Technology (SUSTech) is a
    public research university funded by Shenzhen city. Widely
    regarded as a pioneer and i...

    Shenzhen

    Southern University of Science and Technology (SUSTech)

    []
  * Lab Head Position in Neuroscience

    Chinese Academy of Sciences, seeks exceptional, creative
    scientists to join its faculty.

    Shanghai, China

    The Institute of Neuroscience,Center for Excellence in Brain
    Science and Intelligence Technology,CAS

    []

You have full access to this article via your institution.

Download PDF

Download PDF

Related Articles

  * [d41586-023] Tools such as ChatGPT threaten transparent science;
    here are our ground rules for their use

  * [d41586-023] How Nature readers are using ChatGPT

  * [d41586-023] 'Arms race with automation': professors fret about
    AI-generated coursework

Subjects

  * Publishing
  * Machine learning
  * Authorship
  * Education

Advertisement

Sign up to Nature Briefing

An essential round-up of science news, opinion and analysis,
delivered to your inbox every weekday.

Email address [                    ]
[ ] Yes! Sign me up to receive the daily Nature Briefing email. I
agree my information will be processed in accordance with the Nature
and Springer Nature Limited Privacy Policy.
Sign up
*
Close
Nature Briefing

Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter -- what matters in science,
free to your inbox daily.

Email address
[                    ] Sign up
[ ] I agree my information will be processed in accordance with the
Nature and Springer Nature Limited Privacy Policy.
Close
Get the most important science stories of the day, free in your
inbox. Sign up for Nature Briefing

Explore content

  * Research articles
  * News
  * Opinion
  * Research Analysis
  * Careers
  * Books & Culture
  * Podcasts
  * Videos
  * Current issue
  * Browse issues
  * Collections
  * Subjects

  * Follow us on Facebook
  * Follow us on Twitter
  * Subscribe
  * Sign up for alerts
  * RSS feed

About the journal

  * Journal Staff
  * About the Editors
  * Journal Information
  * Our publishing models
  * Editorial Values Statement
  * Journal Metrics
  * Awards
  * Contact
  * Editorial policies
  * History of Nature
  * Send a news tip

Publish with us

  * For Authors
  * For Referees
  * Language editing services
  * Submit manuscript

Search

Search articles by subject, keyword or author
[                    ]
Show results from [All journals]
Search
Advanced search

Quick links

  * Explore articles by subject
  * Find a job
  * Guide to authors
  * Editorial policies

Nature (Nature) ISSN 1476-4687 (online) ISSN 0028-0836 (print)

nature.com sitemap

About Nature Portfolio

  * About us
  * Press releases
  * Press office
  * Contact us

Discover content

  * Journals A-Z
  * Articles by subject
  * Nano
  * Protocol Exchange
  * Nature Index

Publishing policies

  * Nature portfolio policies
  * Open access

Author & Researcher services

  * Reprints & permissions
  * Research data
  * Language editing
  * Scientific editing
  * Nature Masterclasses
  * Live Expert Trainer-led workshops
  * Research Solutions

Libraries & institutions

  * Librarian service & tools
  * Librarian portal
  * Open research
  * Recommend to library

Advertising & partnerships

  * Advertising
  * Partnerships & Services
  * Media kits
  * Branded content

Career development

  * Nature Careers
  * Nature Conferences
  * Nature events

Regional websites

  * Nature Africa
  * Nature China
  * Nature India
  * Nature Italy
  * Nature Japan
  * Nature Korea
  * Nature Middle East

  * Privacy Policy
  * Use of cookies
  * Your privacy choices/Manage cookies
  * Legal notice
  * Accessibility statement
  * Terms & Conditions
  * Your US state privacy rights

Springer Nature

(c) 2023 Springer Nature Limited