https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-01530-y Skip to main content Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript. Advertisement Advertisement Nature * View all journals * Search * Log in * Explore content * About the journal * Publish with us * Subscribe * Sign up for alerts * RSS feed 1. nature 2. news 3. article * NEWS * 04 May 2023 Hard feelings over mission change for NASA's Pluto spacecraft US space agency plans to shift the New Horizons planetary probe to studying heliophysics, and some scientists don't agree. * Alexandra Witze 1. Alexandra Witze View author publications You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar * Twitter * Facebook * Email You have full access to this article via your institution. Download PDF [d41586-023] NASA's New Horizons spacecraft snapped this image of Pluto (lower right) and its moon Charon (upper left) as it passed by in 2015. Credit: NASA/Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory/ Southwest Research Institute In the distant reaches of the Solar System, more than 8 billion kilometres from Earth, NASA's New Horizons spacecraft is at the centre of a dispute over its future. [d41586-023] Pluto's geology is unlike any other The craft, which snapped stunning images during humanity's first visit to Pluto in 2015, is within a few years of exiting the Kuiper belt, the realm of frozen objects that orbit the Sun beyond Neptune. In addition to Pluto, it has flown past another Kuiper belt object called Arrokoth, but has not found a third object to visit before it leaves. So NASA now plans to repurpose the spacecraft mainly as a heliophysics mission, to study space weather and other phenomena that it can measure from its unique location in the Solar System. But some are unhappy with the decision, and worry that planetary studies are being truncated too soon. "Scientifically, I just don't feel that we're at diminishing returns yet," says Kelsi Singer, the mission's project scientist at the Southwest Research Institute in Boulder, Colorado. Shifting New Horizons from being a planetary explorer to an interstellar emissary echoes what the agency did with the twin Voyager spacecraft after they visited the outer planets in the 1980s. "We have this perfectly working spacecraft that's in a unique area," says Nicola Fox, head of NASA's science mission directorate in Washington DC. The agency wants to get the "best use" out of it, she says, as well as "open it up to as many scientists from as many disciplines as are interested". A mission takeover? No one disputes that New Horizons has made stunning discoveries in the Kuiper belt, which contains debris left over from the Solar System's early history. The spacecraft has uncovered secrets of Pluto's icy surface and revealed more about how the building blocks of planets might have come together. Its 2019 fly-by of Arrokoth, a 35-kilometre-long Kuiper belt object made of two chunks of stuck-together space rock, "taught us so much about fundamental properties of planetary formation -- completely transformational", says Michele Bannister, a planetary scientist at the University of Canterbury in Christchurch, New Zealand. [d41586-023] New Horizons visited the Kuiper belt object Arrokoth in 2019.Credit: NASA/Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory/Southwest Research Institute/Roman Tkachenko Without another Kuiper belt object to fly by, the planetary science for New Horizons becomes harder to justify, some say. Tensions arose last year after NASA's planetary science division conducted a 'senior review' of its operational missions, as it does every few years. A panel of scientists evaluated eight missions, including New Horizons, for their recent scientific performance and future promise. That review rated New Horizons' current science as "excellent/very good" if planetary science, astrophysics and heliophysics were all included. The rating slid to "very good/good" for planetary science alone, in part because the science team's proposed studies of Kuiper belt objects were "unlikely to dramatically improve the state of knowledge", the review said. (The mission's science team disputes that conclusion.) NASA used the review in its decision to shift the spacecraft to being managed as a heliophysics mission, says Lori Glaze, head of the agency's planetary science division. "Because that's where the strength lies -- in the science that can be conducted from here forward," she says. [d41586-023] Solar System's distant snowman comes into sharp focus NASA will fund the mission from its planetary science budget until 30 September 2024. After that, management could be taken over by the much smaller heliophysics division, potentially involving a new group of scientists. In March, NASA asked US researchers for ideas on what science New Horizons could do across all disciplines, "to gauge the level of interest of the wider science community in pursuing the next phase of science leadership for the mission, and to estimate appropriate annual costs". To the mission's current science team, this amounts to a takeover. "There's going to be a boarding party on the first of October next year," says Alan Stern, the mission's principal investigator, who is also at the Southwest Research Institute. Fox responds that the New Horizons team was invited to submit a proposal to lead the spacecraft's science in the heliophysics division starting in October 2024, and that the researchers declined. Full replacement of a mission's science team is relatively rare, says Amanda Hendrix, a researcher at the Planetary Science Institute in Boulder, Colorado. "This is kind of new territory that we're getting into." In a 'unique position' Now the question is what science can still be done with New Horizons, and how. Although its plutonium power source is waning with time, it has enough to last probably another quarter of a century. The craft is currently in the outer part of the Kuiper belt (see 'Out there'), about which little is known because it can't be observed well from Earth. "New Horizons is in a very unique position, and there's basically no other way to get this information," Singer says. OUT THERE. Map showing the route and current position of NASA's New Horizons spacecraft. Source: NASA/Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory/ Southwest Research Institute Among other studies, New Horizons has been taking repeated pictures of distant Kuiper belt objects, building up information on their shapes and surface properties. The spacecraft also analyses dust in the Kuiper belt -- data that can shed light on how often space rocks smash into each other. In recent years, the spacecraft has begun to broaden its focus. In astrophysics, New Horizons' location allows it to study several types of background light that permeate the Solar System. And in heliophysics, ongoing and future studies are exploring the floods of charged particles emanating from the Sun. "It's very valuable in conjunction with the two Voyagers," says Stamatios Krimigis, a space physicist and the only scientist who has been involved with missions to all of the Solar System's planets and Pluto. New Horizons, which cost US$780 million to build, launch and fly past Pluto, currently costs NASA around $10 million annually. Both Fox and Glaze told Nature that the decision to shift the mission away from planetary science was not driven by budgetary issues, such as those that have delayed a Venus mission and raised concerns over the cost of Mars sample return. Both also said that if a Kuiper belt object were found that New Horizons could reach, NASA would be open to discussing that, even if the mission had already been shifted to heliophysics. Stern and his team continue to look for a fly-by target in the time they have left. doi: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-023-01530-y Related Articles * [d41586-023] Pluto's dark side spills its secrets -- including hints of a hidden ocean * [d41586-023] Solar System's distant snowman comes into sharp focus * [d41586-023] Pluto's geology is unlike any other Subjects * Planetary science * Asteroids, comets and Kuiper belt * Astronomy and astrophysics * Astronomical instrumentation Latest on: Planetary science The lunar solid inner core and the mantle overturn The lunar solid inner core and the mantle overturn Article 03 MAY 23 Moon mission failure: why is it so hard to pull off a lunar landing? Moon mission failure: why is it so hard to pull off a lunar landing? News Explainer 27 APR 23 Photochemically produced SO2 in the atmosphere of WASP-39b Photochemically produced SO2 in the atmosphere of WASP-39b Article 26 APR 23 Astronomy and astrophysics What Russia's continued participation in the ISS means for science What Russia's continued participation in the ISS means for science News 05 MAY 23 They're a couple: JWST is first to spot pair of mysterious 'Y dwarfs' They're a couple: JWST is first to spot pair of mysterious 'Y dwarfs' Research Highlight 03 MAY 23 Planet swallowed after venturing too close to its star Planet swallowed after venturing too close to its star News & Views 03 MAY 23 Nature Careers Jobs * Faculty Biostatistics & Epidemiology/Clinical Trials - Quantitative Health Sciences Faculty Biostatistics & Epidemiology/Clinical Trials - Quantitative Health Sciences, Cleveland Clinic Cleveland, Ohio (US) Cleveland Clinic [] * Helmholtz-Lund International Graduate School (HELIOS): 5 open PhD positions (copy) For our location at DESY in Hamburg we are seeking: Helmholtz-Lund International Graduate School (HELIOS): 5 open PhD positions across various phys... Hamburg (DE) HELIOS Helmholtz-Lund International Graduate School [] * Postdoctoral Fellow - Dr. Steven Chan Lab The long-term objective of the Centre for Oncology and Immunology is to identify druggable cancer targets of recalcitrant malignancies and developi... Hong Kong (HK) Centre for Oncology and Immunology [] * PhD student in Experimental Physics The Department of Physics, Umea University, is now looking for a PhD student in experimental physics, with a focus on organic electronics. Umea, Sweden Umea University [] * Postdoctoral position in innate immunity and host-pathogen interactions Innate immunity and host-pathogen interactions Newark, New Jersey (US) Rutgers New Jersey Medical School [] You have full access to this article via your institution. Download PDF Related Articles * [d41586-023] Pluto's dark side spills its secrets -- including hints of a hidden ocean * [d41586-023] Solar System's distant snowman comes into sharp focus * [d41586-023] Pluto's geology is unlike any other Subjects * Planetary science * Asteroids, comets and Kuiper belt * Astronomy and astrophysics * Astronomical instrumentation Advertisement Sign up to Nature Briefing An essential round-up of science news, opinion and analysis, delivered to your inbox every weekday. Email address [ ] [ ] Yes! Sign me up to receive the daily Nature Briefing email. I agree my information will be processed in accordance with the Nature and Springer Nature Limited Privacy Policy. Sign up * Close Nature Briefing Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter -- what matters in science, free to your inbox daily. Email address [ ] Sign up [ ] I agree my information will be processed in accordance with the Nature and Springer Nature Limited Privacy Policy. Close Get the most important science stories of the day, free in your inbox. Sign up for Nature Briefing Explore content * Research articles * News * Opinion * Research Analysis * Careers * Books & Culture * Podcasts * Videos * Current issue * Browse issues * Collections * Subjects * Follow us on Facebook * Follow us on Twitter * Subscribe * Sign up for alerts * RSS feed About the journal * Journal Staff * About the Editors * Journal Information * Our publishing models * Editorial Values Statement * Journal Metrics * Awards * Contact * Editorial policies * History of Nature * Send a news tip Publish with us * For Authors * For Referees * Language editing services * Submit manuscript Search Search articles by subject, keyword or author [ ] Show results from [All journals] Search Advanced search Quick links * Explore articles by subject * Find a job * Guide to authors * Editorial policies Nature (Nature) ISSN 1476-4687 (online) ISSN 0028-0836 (print) nature.com sitemap About Nature Portfolio * About us * Press releases * Press office * Contact us Discover content * Journals A-Z * Articles by subject * Nano * Protocol Exchange * Nature Index Publishing policies * Nature portfolio policies * Open access Author & Researcher services * Reprints & permissions * Research data * Language editing * Scientific editing * Nature Masterclasses * Nature Research Academies * Research Solutions Libraries & institutions * Librarian service & tools * Librarian portal * Open research * Recommend to library Advertising & partnerships * Advertising * Partnerships & Services * Media kits * Branded content Career development * Nature Careers * Nature Conferences * Nature events Regional websites * Nature Africa * Nature China * Nature India * Nature Italy * Nature Japan * Nature Korea * Nature Middle East * Privacy Policy * Use of cookies * Manage cookies/Do not sell my data * Legal notice * Accessibility statement * Terms & Conditions * California Privacy Statement Springer Nature (c) 2023 Springer Nature Limited