https://element.io/blog/india-bans-flagship-client-for-the-matrix-network/

[element-bl]
See all posts
Go to full site
[element-lo] See all postsGo to full site

India bans flagship client for the Matrix network

May 05, 2023
Matrix

Once again we see bureaucrats with a poor understanding of how modern
technology works  deny ordinary people their right to privacy, as
enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Article 12).

This time it's India, where Element is one of 14 messaging apps
blocked by the Central Indian Government which - we believe from
media reports - relates to Section 69A of the Information Technology
Act, 2000.

Element is a small company, so we concentrate our Legal, Compliance
and Trust & Safety functions in the UK. We will, of course, respect
local laws where we are obligated to and have always made it clear
that we cooperate with authorities where required by law. As we
understand it, Indian government officials claim to have approved the
ban due to Element (and other apps) not having representatives in
India.

That is a bit of guesswork on our part, because we did not receive
any prior notice of the decision; clarification from the Ministry of
Electronics and Information Technology would be most welcome.

While Element never compromises end-to-end encryption or user
privacy, we have been contacted by Indian authorities in the past and
addressed them in a constructive fashion (typically responding
same-day). Indeed our Trust & Safety team works with governments to
build safer secure communications for everyone; while ensuring user
privacy and protecting end-to-end encryption.

As much as people in India will be able to trivially circumvent the
blocking of the 14 messaging apps, we want to resolve this situation
and be available as usual in India. That resolution will have to be,
of course, in a way that respects our users and understands our
commitment to everyone's right to private and secure communications.
We look forward to talking with the Ministry about how to make that
happen.

Delisted for being decentralised?

We assume that this ban on Element is a result of a misunderstanding
around decentralised and federated services such as Matrix (an open
standard for real time communication). The Element app is just one of
many apps that give access to the Matrix network. A simple parallel
is that banning Element because it gives access to the Matrix network
is the equivalent to blocking Google Chrome because it gives people
access to the web, or Gmail because it gives people access to email.

Some governments see undermining encryption as the most effective way
to combat the ills of terrorism or other illegal behaviour. That
approach is completely flawed; it just removes ordinary people's
ability to communicate in private which leaves them vulnerable to all
types of surveillance, crime and subjugation.

In actual fact, end-to-end encryption strengthens national security
which is why Element has various parts of the French, German,
Swedish, UK and US governments as customers.

Undermining end-to-end encryption is an attack on people's basic
human right to privacy and security of communications. Rather than
accept that as a cost to pay, we look to preserve and protect those
rights, and to work with governments, journalists, non-profits,
academic researchers and the rest of the tech industry to rise to the
challenge of reducing those harms.

So, as always, we will proactively engage with the authorities - in
this case the Central Indian Government - to champion the importance
of secure and private communications. The right to private
communication is an essential part of democracy, and protects against
oppressive regimes. Technology should protect those rights, not
destroy them.

[562cc867-9]Denise Almeida

Related Posts

 
Government
dSam and eSam endorse Matrix for secure and federated communications
in the Swedish public sector
Element och Matrix har deltagit i eSams utvardering av leverantorer
som godkanda digitala kommunikationslosningar i kategorierna
bestaende chatt och videokonferens.
[20221031_1]
Magnus Hult
1/12/2022
 
VoIP
Introducing Native Matrix VoIP with Element Call!
Hopefully in-person meet-ups will prove
[Avatar]
Jake Bowen-Bate
4/03/2022
 
Interoperability
What is App Fog? How do I solve it?
Messaging apps are meant to
[Profile-Pi]
Caitlin Smith
3/02/2022
 
Bridging
2021: It's been a busy year for Element!
From time to time it's worth stepping back and looking at progress.
[8819cfc0f3]
Amandine Le Pape
23/12/2021

By the same author

 
Preparing data for a choppy sea crossing
'When the tide goes out
[562cc867-9]
Denise Almeida
14/12/2020
 
Privacy shield judgement points to a decentralised future
In something reminiscent of David and Goliath, the stone of Max
Schrems' landmark legal challenge has shattered the Privacy Shield
that protects centralised service providers.
[562cc867-9]
Denise Almeida
10/08/2020

Element is the fast, simple and private way to communicate with
family, friends, teams, colleagues, organisations and the wider
world.

Thanks for reading our blog-- if you got this far, you should head to
element.ioto learn more!

Try Element

For Web, Android, iOS, macOS, Windows & Linux