https://californiawaterblog.com/2023/04/22/the-banality-of-floods-and-droughts/ California WaterBlog A biologist, economist, engineer and geologist walk onto a bar... [cropped-dsc_0690] Skip to content * Home * About - Lake Tulare (and its fishes) shall rise again The Banality of Floods (and Droughts) Posted on April 22, 2023 by jaylund By Jay Lund California's ongoing floods and very wet year overall will continue to grab headlines, provide great pictures, and break some local records, but overall this year is unlikely to be truly extreme from historical or broader water policy and management perspectives. It can still be a very useful wet year, beyond just having lots of water. Wet year water statistics and record-breaking Today's essay reflects on our obsession to identify unique aspects of flooding in California this year. Were floods on the Cosumnes, Russian, Salinas, and other rivers "record-breaking"? Is the ongoing and coming flooding in the Tulare Basin "record-breaking"? (DWR 2023; Moyle 2023) In most cases no, even though 2023 is a very wet year for most of California, and naturally invites search for such comparisons. California has over 100 years of fairly good flood and water records - for any given year to be record-breaking probably requires some teasing of data. Because any major hydrologic event is complex, it is not especially hard to find some way that any sizable high or low flow event is "record-breaking." "Record-breaking" could be in terms of any aspect of magnitude, duration, number of peaks, rapidity of water's rise or fall, the duration of flow above some threshold, repetition frequency, temperature, rate of change in temperature, etc., etc. (Just as every human is unique, we are normal in most regards. And good social policies must reflect both our uniqueness and banality.) Identifying new extremes serves various interests, agencies, and advocates by bringing attention, funding, and legislation to their issues. In the complex governance of water in California, a little panic can be essential for mobilizing diverse units of government and elected leaders toward individual action and seems especially important for forging collective action (Pinter et al. 2019). In a land of common (if not routine) hydrologic extremes, the search for "record-breaking" events is easy, attractive to both water professionals and the curious public, and is often irrelevant and distracting for management, policy, and the public interest. Our obsessions with record-breaking aspects of recent flooding will be rewarded with interesting stories from the many basins and locations affected, their interesting histories, and how these events differ from those in the past. Among the hundreds of basins and thousands of locations and miles of levees, it would be incredible if a set of major storms did not create such stories, including quite a few real human and social tragedies. Banality of Effective Flood Management Even the unusual major flooding in the Tulare Lake basin is not a lot of water for the Tulare basin (which has the most human water use of any hydrologic region in California, about 9 million acre-feet/year). The major flooding issue is that the Tulare Lake basin has no direct outlet to the sea, so flood water collects in the old Tulare Lake bed and similar nearby dead-end lakes (such as Buena Vista Lake), until they individually or collectively overflow into the San Joaquin River (a rare event), evaporate, seep to groundwater, or are pumped for crop irrigation (Arax and Wartzman 2005). For a basin with an average natural streamflow of about 3.3 million acre-ft/year and an average annual groundwater overdraft of about 2 million acre-feet, having 2-3 million acre-feet of flood waters collecting in the Tulare Lake bed this year is about one year of average basin overdraft and not even half of the annual 6 million acre-ft of groundwater overdraft seen in recent drought years (Lund et al. 2018). Capturing flood waters can be useful, but will never be nearly enough to make up this region's long-term deficits. These interesting and important stories stand in contrast to the relative effectiveness of California's rather fragmented flood management system, despite its gaps, lacks, and imperfections in organization, funding, and implementations of state, federal, and local flood plans. California has major floods, with relatively little major flooding, and even fewer major deaths, economic losses, and flood insurance claims (at least so far this year). The effectiveness of flood predictions, warnings, evacuations, and infrastructure, while never perfect and always in need of improvement, largely do the system and the people of California proud. Overall, the non-record-breaking floods this year offer important reminders that: 1. California has floods (as well as droughts). 2. California's localities and regions, as well as state and federal governments, need to organize, prepare, and invest for floods. 3. Local agencies are the most important part of flood management in most of California. Most flood preparations, warnings, and evacuations are organized by local agencies. Most deaths and damage this year resulted from local and private decisions - ranging from local levee maintenance and land use decisions to personal driving behavior into moving flood waters. 4. Flood waters come at times and places where capturing it is often (but not always) expensive, inconvenient, or even dangerous to collect, so we will never be able or willing to capture most of it. 5. Flood forecasting, warning, and evacuation systems remain fundamental for reducing flood deaths and damages in California. This system of forecasts, warnings, and evacuations is a wonderful orchestra of national, state, regional, and local agencies - galvanized by a common knowledge that a major flood can occur anywhere in California in any year (even a nominal drought year). 6. With many thousands of miles of local and system levees managed by hundreds of local flood agencies and organizations with only tentative funding, we should expect more problems than we actually have seen (and presumably we can expect to see more problems with a warming and more variable climate). We should place our discussions and coverage of floods (as well as droughts) in perspective. Floods are more exciting than droughts (which are exciting enough). But we learn and prepare better for future floods and droughts, if we focus more on the banality of these events and banal aspects of their management than on their unique extreme behavior and conditions. Banality of Effective Drought Management Similar reflections have been made on droughts (Lund 2015): "By focusing on unique aspects of a drought, any drought can become an incredibly rare event. Becoming engrossed in the superlatives, however, can distract from the business of managing water shortages and preparing longer-term solutions. What's more relevant for water policy and management is the banality of drought. We should expect to see droughts in California of severity similar to the current drought about once or twice in a generation. Given climate change and the growth in expectations and values for diverse water uses, it seems reasonable to expect such droughts a bit more frequently than in the past. The warmer temperatures in this drought seem likely to become normal for future droughts, with disproportionate effects on ecosystems and small streams. Agencies, cities, bankers, insurers, farmers and residents should prepare for greater regularity of droughts as harsh as the current one. Severe drought in California should be reclassified from a rare "act of God" to something more like a business cycle swing that recurs several times in a lifetime or career. It is more important to focus on managing the dry event and preparing for future ones than understanding the fascinating intricacies of drought origins and statistics. But we probably will continue to obsess about drought statistics and El Nino anyway." Lessons for managing major water problems We should obsess less with the cute facts and shiny science, and use the opportunities of extreme events and failures more to reflect on what could and should work better. Like aviation safety, we make flood and drought management more effective by learning and adapting from failures, even small and moderate failures. Ultimately, it is primarily failures and honest problem-solving responses to failure that keep management effective (Pinter et al. 2019). Arguably, if we want to succeed in any problem, we need to organize ruthlessly to learn from failures and then provide sufficient resources, authority, accountability, and science to translate failures into smaller and less frequent future failures. We have had good success with this approach in aviation safety, public health, drinking water safety, and flood and drought management. For problems lacking in political or professional will, a natural political tendency arises to ignore or normalize failures, or maintain that nothing can be done about them. We certainly do this in abundance with ecosystem failures and numerous social problems, which becomes a self-fulfilling strategy, rather than a problem-solving strategy. Every major extreme event deserves an independently-minded postmortem identification of lessons and opportunities for improvement, more than a mere statistical discussion. Further Reading Arax, M. and R. Wartzman, 2005. The King of California: J. G. Boswell and the making of a secret American empire. Perseus Books. DWR, California's Snowpack is Now One of the Largest Ever, Bringing Drought Relief, Flooding Concerns, April 3, 2023. Moyle, P. (2023), Lake Tulare (and its fishes) shall rise again, CaliforniaWaterBlog.com, April 16, 2023 Lund, J. (2015), The banality of California's '1,200-year' drought, CaliforniaWaterBlog.com, September 23, 2015. Lund, J.R., J. Medellin-Azuara, J. Durand, and K. Stone, "Lessons from California's 2012-2016 Drought," J. of Water Resources Planning and Management, Vol 144, No. 10, October 2018. Pinter, N., J. Lund, and P. Moyle. "The California Water Model: Resilience through Failure," Hydrological Processes, Vol. 22, Iss. 12, pp. 1775-1779, 2019. Share this: * Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) * Click to print (Opens in new window) * Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) * Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window) * Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) * Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) * Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) * Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) * More * * Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window) * Like this: Like Loading... [82c9181][82c9181] About jaylund Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering Director, Center for Watershed Sciences University of California - Davis View all posts by jaylund - This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. - Lake Tulare (and its fishes) shall rise again 3 Responses to The Banality of Floods (and Droughts) 1. [4bfc][4bfc] parackal thomas says: April 23, 2023 at 2:47 am WELL WRITTEN LONG ARTICLE;BUT FIRST 5 PARAGRAPHS CAN BE SUMMARIZED IN FOUR ENTENCES. ALSO SOME STATISTIS OF RECORDBREAKING SAY THE 25 YEARS DATA COLD BE GIVEN AS AN SDDENDUM. THAT WAY THIS ARTICLE CAN BE MORE USEFUL. Loading... Reply 2. Pingback: Hong Shui (toGan batsu)noFan Yong Xing - Shi Jie noHua Ti woRi Ben Yu dezatsukuri Su Zao kuQue Ren ! 3. Pingback: HackerNews Zhai Yao (2023-04-24 10AM) - GPT Du Xin Wen Leave a Reply Cancel reply * Email Subscription Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Email Address [ ] Sign me up! Join 14,313 other subscribers * Search for: [ ] [Search] * Recent Posts + The Banality of Floods (and Droughts) + Lake Tulare (and its fishes) shall rise again + Perspectives on DairyMAR + New methods emerging for water management in California + This Drought is Dead - Long Live the Drought * CA Water Topics + adaptive management + agriculture + Amber Manfree + Ann Willis + Big Springs Creek + Brian Gray + Buzz Thompson + Caitrin Chappelle + California + California water + Carson Jeffres + Central Valley + Chinook salmon + Chris Bowman + climate change + Coho salmon + dam removal + dams + Delta + Delta islands + Delta smelt + drought + Duncan MacEwan + economics + ecosystem + Ellen Hanak + extinction + fish biology + fish conservation + fish migration + floodplain + floods + floodwaters + Graham Fogg + Greg Gartrell + groundwater management + Halloween + Helen Dahlke + humor + irrigation + Jay Lund + Jeffrey Mount + John Durand + Joshua Viers + Josue Medellin-Azuara + Katrina Jessoe + Klamath River + levees + Megan Nguyen + Moyle + native fish + Nicholas Pinter + Peter Moyle + reconciliation + restoration + Richard Frank + Richard Howitt + Robert Lusardi + Robyn Suddeth + Rui Hui + Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta + salmon + Sarah Yarnell + Shasta River + stream restoration + subsidence + Thomas Harter + UC Davis Center for Watershed Sciences + water conservation + water management + water planning + water rights + water storage + water supply + William Fleenor * Posts by Date + April 2023 (4) + March 2023 (4) + February 2023 (4) + January 2023 (5) + December 2022 (4) + November 2022 (3) + October 2022 (5) + September 2022 (3) + August 2022 (4) + July 2022 (4) + June 2022 (4) + May 2022 (5) + April 2022 (4) + March 2022 (4) + February 2022 (4) + January 2022 (5) + December 2021 (4) + November 2021 (4) + October 2021 (5) + September 2021 (4) + August 2021 (4) + July 2021 (5) + June 2021 (4) + May 2021 (6) + April 2021 (4) + March 2021 (4) + February 2021 (4) + January 2021 (5) + December 2020 (4) + November 2020 (4) + October 2020 (4) + September 2020 (3) + August 2020 (4) + July 2020 (3) + June 2020 (4) + May 2020 (4) + April 2020 (4) + March 2020 (6) + February 2020 (1) + January 2020 (3) + December 2019 (4) + November 2019 (2) + October 2019 (4) + September 2019 (4) + August 2019 (4) + July 2019 (3) + June 2019 (5) + May 2019 (4) + April 2019 (5) + March 2019 (4) + February 2019 (4) + January 2019 (3) + December 2018 (1) + November 2018 (5) + October 2018 (2) + September 2018 (1) + August 2018 (4) + July 2018 (1) + June 2018 (2) + May 2018 (4) + April 2018 (5) + March 2018 (4) + February 2018 (5) + January 2018 (4) + December 2017 (5) + November 2017 (2) + October 2017 (5) + September 2017 (5) + August 2017 (5) + July 2017 (5) + June 2017 (4) + May 2017 (3) + April 2017 (5) + March 2017 (4) + February 2017 (4) + January 2017 (4) + December 2016 (4) + November 2016 (4) + October 2016 (5) + September 2016 (4) + August 2016 (4) + July 2016 (4) + June 2016 (4) + May 2016 (4) + April 2016 (5) + March 2016 (4) + February 2016 (4) + January 2016 (5) + December 2015 (4) + November 2015 (4) + October 2015 (5) + September 2015 (3) + August 2015 (4) + July 2015 (4) + June 2015 (5) + May 2015 (4) + April 2015 (5) + March 2015 (5) + February 2015 (6) + January 2015 (2) + December 2014 (3) + November 2014 (4) + October 2014 (4) + September 2014 (2) + August 2014 (4) + July 2014 (4) + June 2014 (6) + May 2014 (4) + April 2014 (5) + March 2014 (3) + February 2014 (2) + January 2014 (3) + December 2013 (2) + November 2013 (2) + October 2013 (4) + September 2013 (3) + August 2013 (1) + July 2013 (3) + June 2013 (3) + May 2013 (4) + April 2013 (4) + March 2013 (2) + February 2013 (1) + January 2013 (2) + December 2012 (1) + November 2012 (3) + October 2012 (3) + September 2012 (2) + July 2012 (1) + June 2012 (1) + May 2012 (3) + April 2012 (1) + March 2012 (4) + February 2012 (4) + January 2012 (3) + December 2011 (2) + November 2011 (4) + October 2011 (3) + September 2011 (2) + August 2011 (4) + July 2011 (4) + June 2011 (5) + May 2011 (2) + April 2011 (4) + March 2011 (4) + February 2011 (3) + January 2011 (1) * UC Davis Center for Watershed Sciences UC Davis Center for Watershed Sciences * Top Posts & Pages + Lake Tulare (and its fishes) shall rise again + The Banality of Floods (and Droughts) + Perspectives on DairyMAR + Crawdads: Naturalized Californians + Preliminary Analysis of Hurricane Harvey Flooding in Harris County, Texas + Striped Bass in the Pacific Ocean: When, where and why? + Reflections on Cadillac Desert + The Spawning Dead: Why Zombie Fish are the Anti-Apocalypse + Who governs California's drinking water systems? + This Drought is Dead - Long Live the Drought California WaterBlog Powered by WordPress.com. %d bloggers like this: