https://www.businessinsider.com/uber-amazon-pay-using-ai-different-wages-same-work-discrimination-2023-4 Jump to 1. Main content 2. Search 3. Account A vertical stack of three evenly spaced horizontal lines. A magnifying glass. It indicates, "Click to perform a search". The word "Insider". 0 Newsletters An icon in the shape of a person's head and shoulders. It often indicates a user profile. Log in An icon in the shape of a person's head and shoulders. It often indicates a user profile. Subscribe * Business + Tech + Finance + Markets + Strategy + Retail + Advertising + Healthcare + Premium * Life + Entertainment + Culture + Travel + Food + Health + Parenting + Beauty + Style * News + Politics + Military & Defense + Sports + Opinion * Reviews + Tech + Streaming + Home + Kitchen + Style + Beauty + Gifts + Deals + Pets + Parenting + Coupons + Health + Learning + Hobbies & Crafts + Travel * All + A-Z + Advertising + Business + Careers + Coupons o DoorDash o Walmart o Dell o Staples o Under Armour + Culture + Design + Entertainment + Executive Lifestyle + Finance + Food + Health + Healthcare + Intelligence + Latest + Life + Markets Insider + Media + Military & Defense + News + Opinion + People + Personal Finance o Banking o Credit Cards o Insurance o Investing o Loans o Mortgages + Politics + Premium + Retail + Reviews + Science + Sports + Strategy + Tech + Transportation + Travel + TV o Beauty Explorers o Best in Town o Bonkers Closets o Festival Foodies o Movies Insider o Pop Culture Decoded o The Making Of o The Ultimate List + Featured + Talent Insider + About + About + Advertise + Careers + Code of Ethics + Contact Us + Corporate + Corrections Policy + Follow + RSS + Sitemap + Facebook + Twitter + Instagram + YouTube + LinkedIn + Subscriptions + Intelligence + Premium US Markets Loading... H M S In the news Two crossed lines that form an 'X'. It indicates a way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification. It indicates an expandable section or menu, or sometimes previous / next navigation options. HOMEPAGE 0 Newsletters An icon in the shape of a person's head and shoulders. It often indicates a user profile. Log in Subscribe Home It indicates an expandable section or menu, or sometimes previous / next navigation options. Economy Companies like Uber and Amazon use AI to pay people different wages for the same work, a new study finds Jacob Zinkula 2023-04-13T13:43:02Z A bookmark The letter F. An envelope. It indicates the ability to send an email. An curved arrow pointing right. A stylized bird with an open mouth, tweeting. Twitter The word "in". LinkedIn A stylized letter F. Flipboard The letter F. Facebook An envelope. It indicates the ability to send an email. Email An image of a chain link. It symobilizes a website link url. Copy Link Read in app An Amazon.com Inc. delivery driver carries boxes PATRICK T. FALLON/AFP via Getty Images [top-left] [bottom-rig] Redeem now * Some companies use AI to pay workers "different amount for the same amount of work," per new research. * Veena Dubal, a law professor at UC Hastings and the paper's author, calls this "algorithmic wage discrimination." * As companies adopt AI, she's concerned these practices could become prevalent in other industries. Top editors give you the stories you want -- delivered right to your inbox each weekday. Something is loading. Thanks for signing up! Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go. download the app Email address [ ] [Sign up] By clicking 'Sign up', you agree to receive marketing emails from Insider as well as other partner offers and accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Gig workers are doing the same jobs for different pay, and this model could come to your workplace someday. That's according to new research from Veena Dubal, a law professor at University of California Hastings, who drew upon six years and thousands of hours of interviews and observations with hundreds of Uber and Lyft drivers, many of whom worked for more than one gig platform. According to Dubal, companies like Amazon and Uber have "massive data sets" on the contract workers using their delivery or rideshare platforms, including when they work, for how long, and what kind of pay they've taken for past jobs. These companies are able to utilize this data to "calculate the exact wage rates necessary to incentivize desired behaviors," she told the Los Angeles Times, a practice she calls "algorithmic wage discrimination." "From Amazon to Uber to the healthcare sector, workers are being paid different amounts for the same amount of work that is conducted for the same amount of time," said Dubal, whose research was published in the Social Science Research Network in January and will be included in a forthcoming Columbia Law Review. Dubal said these instances could take the form of a food delivery driver being offered a lower rate than another driver would have been -- because the AI algorithm predicted the first driver would be more likely to accept that rate. If a driver tends to work until they hit a certain daily mark, say $100, she said the algorithm might offer them lower rates to keep the driver working longer. "It's basically variable pay that's personalized to individuals based on what is really, really a lot of data that's accumulated on those workers while they're working," Dubal said. One Uber driver Dubal interviewed, Domingo, recalled being one ride of short of unlocking a $100 bonus one evening, but then said he experienced 45 minutes of "dead time" in a popular area before he was able to get another ride. "It feels like the algorithm is turned against you," he said, adding that it "literally feels like you're being punished by some unknown spiteful God." Dubal described the alleged variable pay system as the "gamblification of work," a sentiment other gig workers shared. "It's like gambling," said Ben, a rideshare driver. "The house always wins." When reached for comment, an Uber spokesperson told Insider: "It's a good thing that Professor Dubal's paper is still a draft, because its central premise about how Uber presents Upfront Fares to drivers is simply wrong. We do not tailor individual fares for individual drivers "as little as the system determines that they may be willing to accept." Moreover, factors like a driver's race, ethnicity, Quest promotion status, acceptance rate, total earnings, or prior trip history are not considered in calculating fares and, where Upfront Fares is available, drivers see exactly what they will make and where they are going before deciding if it's worth their time or declining the request. Moving away from a rate card that only looks at time and distance while on a trip allows Uber's pricing technology to better account for things like long pick up times and whether a driver is going to a destination where there is typically low demand." Amazon spokeswoman Simone Griffin told Insider, "We created the Amazon Flex program to give individuals the opportunity to set their own schedule and be their own boss, with competitive earnings that exceed $26 per scheduled hour on average. We hear from most of the Amazon Flex delivery partners that they love the program, and we're proud of the work they do on behalf of our customers every day." Lyft did not respond to Insider's request for comment. While the potential implications of artificial intelligence technologies have come under greater scrutiny ever since ChatGPT was rolled out in November, companies have been using AI tools for years to help set prices, make decisions, and even hire and fire workers. In her paper, Dubal cited algorithmic wage discrimination as among the reasons the California Labor Commission sued Uber and Lyft in 2020 -- and claimed the companies owed drivers a combined $1.3 billion in payments for their hours worked. The lawsuits are still ongoing. As companies incorporate AI technologies going forward, Dubal is concerned that algorithmic wage discrimination practices "have the great potential to seep into the firm practices of other sectors," which would mean more than just gig workers would be impacted. Dubal said that there should be a ban on the use of algorithms and AI to set wages and called on the federal government to take a closer look at the issue. "To address these problems, this Article invites lawmakers and regulators to direct their attention, not just to the problems of transparency and accuracy of automation technologies at work, but also to an evaluation of the social harms embedded in the logic of the algorithmic systems themselves," she wrote in the paper's concluding line. Are you a gig worker willing to share your story about pay, schedule, and tipping? If so, reach out to this reporter at jzinkula@insider.com. Editor's note, April 13, 2023: This story was updated after publication to include an updated comment from Uber. A picture of a switch and lightbulb [light-swit] Sign up for notifications from Insider! Stay up to date with what you want to know. Subscribe to push notifications Read next NOW WATCH: What is ChatGPT, and should we be afraid of AI chatbots? [svg] [64271da445] Economy Amazon Uber More... Two crossed lines that form an 'X'. It indicates a way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification. Recommended Video Insider [Insider-lo] Business Insider [BI-logo-da] Follow us on: [svg] [facebook] [svg] [twitter] [svg] [linkedin] [svg] [youtube] [svg] [instagram] Download on the App Store [app-store-] Get it on Google Play [google-pla] * * Copyright (c) 2023 Insider Inc. All rights reserved. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our * Terms of Service , Privacy Policy and Cookies Policy . * Contact Us * Masthead * Sitemap * Disclaimer * Accessibility * Commerce Policy * Advertising Policies * CA Privacy Rights * Coupons * Made in NYC * Jobs @ Insider * Stock quotes by finanzen.net * Reprints & Permissions Your Privacy Choices California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) Opt-Out Icon [privacy-op] * International Editions: * United States US * International INTL * Asia AS * Deutschland & Osterreich AT * Deutschland DE * Espana ES * India IN * Japan JP * Mexico MX * Netherlands NL * Polska PL Insider.com TM Logo [insider-co] Insider-Inc Logo [insider-in] Business Insider DE Logo [BI-DE-Blac] Tech Insider Logo [Tech-Insid]