https://www.ft.com/content/c331b279-00e5-4e7d-954f-468f4ee44c31 Accessibility helpSkip to navigationSkip to contentSkip to footer Cookies on FT Sites We use cookies and other data for a number of reasons, such as keeping FT Sites reliable and secure, personalising content and ads, providing social media features and to analyse how our Sites are used. Accept cookies Manage cookies * Sign In * Subscribe Open side navigation menuOpen search bar SubscribeSign InmyFT Search the FT[ ]SearchClose search bar * Home * World Sections + World Home + Global Economy + UK + US + China + Africa + Asia Pacific + Emerging Markets + Europe + War in Ukraine + Americas + Middle East & North Africa + Australia & NZ Most Read + China stalls Antony Blinken's Beijing visit over 'spy balloon' concerns + Lula vows partnership with China to 'balance world geopolitics' + Air Guardsman charged over US classified document leak + Alexei Navalny 'seriously ill' in Russian jail + Japanese PM unharmed after 'smoke bomb' attack * US Sections + US Home + US Economy + US Companies + US Politics & Policy Most Read * Companies Sections + Companies Home + Energy + Financials + Health + Industrials + Media + Professional Services + Retail & Consumer + Tech Sector + Telecoms + Transport Most Read + Julie Boland: the EY leader in the middle of a 'civil war' + Dubai court orders KPMG to pay $231mn for Abraaj fund audit failure + Top Republican donor sours on Florida governor's stance on social issues + Singapore asks banks to keep quiet on wealth inflows during China boom + Asda price: how buyers bagged a PS6.8bn supermarket chain for PS200mn * Tech * Markets Sections + Markets Home + Alphaville + Markets Data + Cryptofinance + Capital Markets + Commodities + Currencies + Equities + Fund Management + Trading + Moral Money + ETF Hub Most Read + US regulator calls for greater scrutiny of hedge funds after bond turmoil + Ghana default puts domestic debt 'can of worms' in the spotlight + BlackRock hunts 'transformational' opportunities as assets hit $9.1tn + Banks crisis looks short but lessons must be more enduring + Investors trapped in Canadian ETFs after trading ban * Climate * Opinion Sections + Opinion Home + Columnists + The FT View + Lex + Obituaries + Letters Most Read + The west is in the grip of a decoupling delusion + Arsenal and Labour: lessons from two revolutions + One failed drone venture tells a tale of SVB's eccentric lending + Pentagon leak fallout will be felt far beyond the battlefield + Britain's elusive high-speed rail dream * Work & Careers Sections + Work & Careers Home + Business School Rankings + Business Education + Entrepreneurship + Recruitment + Business Books + Business Travel Most Read + Mayor Sadiq Khan: 'You don't make the UK more level by making London poorer' + The City workers who swapped the office for the great outdoors * Life & Arts Sections + Life & Arts Home + Arts + Books + Food & Drink + FT Magazine + House & Home + Style + Travel + FT Globetrotter Most Read + Hank Paulson: 'I think it's pretty likely we will see a recession' + The men trading their Rolexes for plastic sports watches + We must slow down the race to God-like AI + London stalling: inside the prime property stalemate + The new age of the night train * HTSI MenuSearch * Home * World * US * Companies * Tech * Markets * Climate * Opinion * Work & Careers * Life & Arts * HTSI Financial Times SubscribeSign In Search the FT[ ]SearchClose search bar FT Alphaville Passive Investing Add to myFT Yeah, about that active comeback . . . It's SPIVA scorecard time [https] * Yeah, about that active comeback . . . on twitter (opens in a new window) * Yeah, about that active comeback . . . on facebook (opens in a new window) * Yeah, about that active comeback . . . on linkedin (opens in a new window) * Yeah, about that active comeback . . . on whatsapp (opens in a new window) * Save * Yeah, about that active comeback . . . on twitter (opens in a new window) * Yeah, about that active comeback . . . on facebook (opens in a new window) * Yeah, about that active comeback . . . on linkedin (opens in a new window) * Yeah, about that active comeback . . . on whatsapp (opens in a new window) * Save Robin Wigglesworth Jump to comments sectionPrint this page Receive free Passive Investing updates We'll send you a myFT Daily Digest email rounding up the latest Passive Investing news every morning. After a barren decade dominated by bubbly technology stocks, feckless money printing, yada yada, last year was an unusually fertile environment for US stockpickers. Right? Right? It's true that dispersion between S&P 500 stocks hit the highest level since 2009 last year. Hello alpha opportunities! [https] Bigger stocks underperformed smaller ones, and most S&P 500 constituents actually outperformed the index -- almost a third beat it by more than 20 per cent. Basically, if you threw darts at a table of US stocks, chances were you'd outperform. [https] And yet . . . [https] These charts are from S&P's big fat asset-weighted survivorship-bias-corrected annual round-up of how active investment funds fare against their benchmarks, published Tuesday. One could choose to spin this as 2022 being the best year for active US equity fund managers in more than a decade, with almost half managing to outperform the stock market. You could even bolster the case by highlighting how a majority of small-cap funds bested their benchmarks (if you ignore an absolutely shocking year for small-cap growth managers). Or you could just gesture at the long-term performance data -- less than 7 per cent of US active equity funds have beat the market over the past decade -- and realise that the vagaries of year-to-year results don't alter the fundamental issues with active management. [https] Even if active managers had managed to notch up a great market-beating year (on average) it wouldn't have changed this. But given how many people have banged on about how active management would 'prove its worth' when central banks 'stopped printing money' and 'suppressing volatility' etc etc, it is pretty telling. Weighted by assets, the average US stockpicker lost 21 per cent last year, compared to the broad S&P Composite 1500's 18-per-cent decline. For small-cap funds it was a 21-per-cent asset-weighted loss, compared to a 16-per-cent decline for S&P's small-cap index. It was a similar picture internationally, with the average global fund losing 22 per cent, compared to the market's 17-per-cent fall. All in what was supposed to be an improved environment for active management. Bond funds, which ostensibly have an easier time outperforming in general (and certainly had choppy markets to prove their worth), also mostly stank up the place. As Morningstar said its own active-vs-passive report late last month: Brutal market performance in 2022 reignited the narrative that active funds can better navigate market turmoil than passive peers. Despite an uptick in success rates by US stock-pickers, the latest evidence debunks these claims yet again. As Warren Buffett once said, "only when the tide goes out do you discover who's been swimming naked." In 2022, it turned out that active bond and real estate funds were caught skinny-dipping. This is not because active managers are lazy or dumb. It is because they are increasingly smart and hard-working that markets are so hard to consistently beat. At the same time, the distributional skew in equity market returns is incredible. The main problem is that high fees are a high hurdle to clear. However, there is naught as resistant to data as predictions that NEXT YEAR will be the one where active management finally stages its comeback. Further reading: -- How passive are markets, actually? Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2023. All rights reserved. Reuse this content (opens in new window) CommentsJump to comments section Promoted Content Follow the topics in this article * Investing in funds Add to myFT * Passive Investing Add to myFT * S&P 500 Add to myFT * FT Alphaville Add to myFT * Robin Wigglesworth Add to myFT Comments Useful links Support View Site TipsHelp CentreContact UsAbout UsAccessibilitymyFT Tour Careers Legal & Privacy Terms & ConditionsPrivacy PolicyCookiesCopyrightSlavery Statement & Policies Services Share News Tips SecurelyIndividual SubscriptionsGroup Subscriptions RepublishingExecutive Job SearchAdvertise with the FTFollow the FT on TwitterFT ChannelsSecondary Schools Tools PortfolioToday's Newspaper (ePaper)Alerts HubBusiness School Rankings Enterprise ToolsNews feedNewslettersCurrency Converter Community & Events FT CommunityFT Live EventsFT ForumsFT Board DirectorBoard Director Programme More from the FT Group Markets data delayed by at least 15 minutes. (c) THE FINANCIAL TIMES LTD 2023. FT and 'Financial Times' are trademarks of The Financial Times Ltd. The Financial Times and its journalism are subject to a self-regulation regime under the FT Editorial Code of Practice. [px] Close side navigation menuFinancial Times International Edition Subscribe for full access Search the FT[ ]Search * Switch to UK Edition Top sections * Home * WorldShow more World + Global Economy + UK + US + China + Africa + Asia Pacific + Emerging Markets + Europe + War in Ukraine + Americas + Middle East & North Africa + Australia & NZ * USShow more US + US Economy + US Companies + US Politics & Policy * CompaniesShow more Companies + Energy + Financials + Health + Industrials + Media + Professional Services + Retail & Consumer + Tech Sector + Telecoms + Transport * Tech * MarketsShow more Markets + Alphaville + Markets Data + Cryptofinance + Capital Markets + Commodities + Currencies + Equities + Fund Management + Trading + Moral Money + ETF Hub * Climate * OpinionShow more Opinion + Columnists + The FT View + Lex + Obituaries + Letters * Work & CareersShow more Work & Careers + Business School Rankings + Business Education + Entrepreneurship + Recruitment + Business Books + Business Travel * Life & ArtsShow more Life & Arts + Arts + Books + Food & Drink + FT Magazine + House & Home + Style + Travel + FT Globetrotter * Personal FinanceShow more Personal Finance + Property & Mortgages + Investments + Pensions + Tax + Banking & Savings + Advice & Comment + Next Act * HTSI * Special Reports FT recommends * Lex * Alphaville * Lunch with the FT * FT Globetrotter * #techAsia * Moral Money * FTfm * Newsletters * Video * Podcasts * News feed * FT Live Events * FT Forums * Board Director Programme * myFT * Portfolio * Today's Newspaper (ePaper) * Crossword * Our Apps * Help Centre * Subscribe * Sign In