https://english.elpais.com/science-tech/2023-04-01/do-you-need-a-yearly-checkup-experts-warn-that-they-carry-risks-and-do-not-reduce-mortality.html Select: * - - - * Espana * America + Mexico + Colombia + Chile + Argentina * USA EL PAIS Science & Tech subscribeHHOLALOG IN Science & Tech Silicon ValleyYoutubeGoogleLatest News Medicine Do you need a yearly checkup? Experts warn that they carry risks and do not reduce mortality General health checks are unlikely to be beneficial, researchers say; even basic blood tests can lead to unnecessary interventions or treatments Indiscriminate screening increases the chances of overdiagnosis. Indiscriminate screening increases the chances of overdiagnosis. CARLOS ROSILLO Aser Garcia Rada Aser Garcia Rada 01 Apr 2023 - 22:10 UTC "We check our cars regularly, so why shouldn't we also check our bodies so that we can find and treat abnormalities before they cause too much harm?" This question was posed by a group of Danish researchers in a 2014 editorial published in The BMJ under an enlightening headline: "General Health Checks Don't Work." Their answer was clear: "It seems so easy, but the human body is not a car, and, in contrast to a car, it has self-healing properties." Not only that: they even warned that this type of examination, which is carried out on healthy people and may include diagnostic tests, "will cause harm in some people." The researchers went a step further and in 2019 made a systematic review for the renowned Cochrane Library. After analyzing 17 clinical trials involving 230,000 people and comparing adults from the general public who got checked to others who did not, they found that general checkups had "little or no effect" on total mortality or cancer, cardiovascular, heart disease and stroke mortality. Even if it seems counterintuitive, "general health checks are unlikely to be beneficial," the experts concluded. "Checkups are necessary when there is already a disease, but performing a screening on healthy people is debatable," confirmed Borja Rivero, a family doctor at the Doctor Morante health center in Santander, Spain. "People demand it, that's the problem," he added. But why is it that undergoing routine medical examinations may not be beneficial? The Danish specialists explained that "most of the commonly used individual screening tests offered in general health checks have been incompletely studied." Furthermore, "while we cannot be certain that screening leads to benefit, all medical interventions can lead to harm." In a report accompanying the research, lead author Lasse T. Krogsboll, of the Nordic Cochrane Center and Rigshospitalet in Copenhagen, added: "One reason for the apparent lack of effect may be that primary care physicians already identify and intervene when they suspect a patient is at high risk of developing disease when they see them for other reasons," making additional examinations unnecessary. However, in order for these people to be identified, they have to go to a health center from time to time, which may not happen in vulnerable groups due to marginalization or other access difficulties. "Those at high risk of developing disease may not attend general health checks when invited or may not follow suggested tests and treatments," added Krogsboll. This is known as the inverse care law, a term popularized by the British doctor Julian Tudor Hart, explained Rivero. "The one who demands it receives better care, not the one who needs it the most." However, Krogsboll warned about the importance of distinguishing between people who do not feel sick and those with symptoms or a personal or family history of risk factors. "The conclusions do not imply that physicians should stop clinically motivated testing and preventive activities," he pointed out. False positives and overdiagnosis Even basic tests, such as blood tests, can lead to unnecessary interventions or treatments. First of all, because there are no infallible tests and they can all give a false positive (an altered test that turns out to be nothing, with the additional stress and procedures it can entail) or a false negative (a normal result for someone who does have a problem, creating a false sense of security). "More medicine is not always better," argued retired specialist in preventive medicine and public health Andreu Segura in an EL PAIS article from 2008. "The confusion that occurs among people and among some colleagues has to do with the idea that the more data, the more knowledge, but this is not true," warned the expert, who is still a member of the Bioethics Committee of Catalonia and the Public Health Advisory Council of Catalonia. "It seems logical, but it is a very poor intuitive logic," he added, alluding to Bayes' theorem, which calculates the conditional probability, essential to interpret any diagnostic test: "the veracity of the results doesn't only depend on the accuracy of the measurement, but on the presence of what you are looking for in the population in which you are looking for it," he explained. Thus, for statistical reasons, the more patients there are in a population, the more reliable a positive result will be. Conversely, a positive is more likely to be false in the case of rare diseases. Segura warned of an additional risk. "With indiscriminate screening, when you start looking for things you don't expect, just in case, the probability of overdiagnosis is very high." This is what happens when they find latent or highly localized cancers that may never have progressed or may even have remitted spontaneously. Rivero used as an example a request he receives frequently: to check the cholesterol of young people with no risk factors. "Checking a 32-year-old man with no history of sudden death or hypercholesterolemia in the family is pointless," and can result in prescriptions for medication of questionable usefulness and that is not without risk in the event of minor changes. Another example of overdiagnosis could be the frequent vitamin D deficiencies that have been diagnosed since this parameter started being added to other laboratory tests. The truth is that the proper levels are not even clear, and the levels agreed today among experts could be encompassing many healthy people, as U.S. researchers warned in The New England Journal of Medicine. Scottish general practitioner and educator Margaret McCartney has studied extensively the use of screenings to find signs of disease in people who would otherwise never know about it or suffer any ill effects, and she agrees that more diagnoses may not necessarily translate into better outcomes. As she told The Guardian, "if everyone were scanned for aneurysms [abnormally dilated blood vessels], around 2% of people would be found to have one--but, since most would never cause problems, intervention might well do more harm than good." McCartney also mentioned a mass screening program for thyroid cancer carried out in South Korea that detected 15 times as many cases without improving mortality from this disease. In clinical practice, only interventions that work should be used, the Danish specialists point out in their editorial. They suggest focusing the efforts on structural interventions aimed at reducing disease, such as imposing higher taxes on tobacco and alcohol or restricting corporate advertising of harmful products. And instead of having a general checkup every year, added Rivero, "the key is to maintain the right weight, walk or do moderate physical exercise and not smoke." Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAIS USA Edition More information Cholera patients in Malawi in January, amid an outbreak that has caused more than a thousand victims. Infectious diseases study highlights inconsistent reporting and importance of the human factor Jon Gurutz Arranz Do herbal infusions really have an effect on health? 'Medicinal' plants? The supposed benefits of propolis, echinacea and other herbs Beatriz Robles Martinez Adheres toThe Trust ProjectMore information If you are interested in licensing this content, please contact ventacontenidos@prisamedia.com newsletter Sign up to EL PAIS in English Edition bulletin Most viewed 1. One of the world's most cited scientists, Rafael Luque, suspended without pay for 13 years 2. Extreme drought ended one of the ancient world's greatest empires 3. No dates, no sex, no weddings, no kids: Korean women are standing up to Asian machismo 4. Crypto evangelists enter the Bukele government: The dark business of bitcoin in El Salvador 5. She killed her lover's wife with 41 axe blows and was acquitted: Candy Montgomery's story returns to television Recomendaciones EL PAIS * Cursos * Centros * Frances online * Ingles online * Italiano online * Aleman online * Crucigramas & Juegos Cursos cursos Maestria en Big Data y Analytics 100% en linea Maestria en Big Data y Analytics 100% en linea cursos MBA Administracion y Direccion de Empresas en linea MBA Administracion y Direccion de Empresas en linea cursos Programa en linea en 'Project Finance' Internacional Programa en linea en 'Project Finance' Internacional cursos Maestria en linea en Direccion de Recursos Humanos y Gestion del Talento Maestria en linea en Direccion de Recursos Humanos y Gestion del Talento Centros cursosonline Maestria en linea en Gestion Ambiental Maestria en linea en Gestion Ambiental cursosonline Maestria en Comercio Internacional presencial en Madrid, Espana Maestria en Comercio Internacional presencial en Madrid, Espana cursosonline Maestria en Marketing Digital & E-Commerce. Semipresencial en Madrid, Espana Maestria en Marketing Digital & E-Commerce. Semipresencial en Madrid, Espana cursosonline Maestria en 'Data Management' e Innovacion Tecnologica 100% en linea Maestria en 'Data Management' e Innovacion Tecnologica 100% en linea Frances online cursosingles Mejora tu frances con 15 minutos al dia Mejora tu frances con 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfruta de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfruta de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita de nuestro curso de frances 'online' 21 dias de prueba gratuita de nuestro curso de frances 'online' Ingles online cursosingles Mejore su ingles con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia Mejore su ingles con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas cursosingles Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado cursosingles Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Italiano online cursosingles Mejore su italiano con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia Mejore su italiano con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas cursosingles Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado cursosingles Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Aleman online cursosingles Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas cursosingles Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado cursosingles Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Crucigramas & Juegos juegos Crucigramas minis Crucigramas minis juegos Crucigramas Tarkus Crucigramas Tarkus juegos Sudokus mini Sudokus mini juegos Sopas de letras Sopas de letras Recomendaciones EL PAIS * Cursos * Centros * Italiano online * Frances online * Aleman online * Crucigramas & Juegos Cursos cursos Maestria en Ciencias Ambientales presencial en Benito Juarez Maestria en Ciencias Ambientales presencial en Benito Juarez cursos Licenciatura en Administracion de Empresas presencial en Benito Juarez Licenciatura en Administracion de Empresas presencial en Benito Juarez cursos Maestria a distancia en Linguistica Aplicada a la Ensenanza del Espanol como Lengua Extranjera Maestria a distancia en Linguistica Aplicada a la Ensenanza del Espanol como Lengua Extranjera cursos Licenciatura Ejecutiva en Psicologia Semipresencial. Cinco sedes disponibles Licenciatura Ejecutiva en Psicologia Semipresencial. Cinco sedes disponibles Centros cursosonline Licenciatura Ejecutiva en Derecho. Semipresencial en Aguascalientes Licenciatura Ejecutiva en Derecho. Semipresencial en Aguascalientes cursosonline Maestria a distancia en Actividad Fisica y Salud Maestria a distancia en Actividad Fisica y Salud cursosonline Maestria a distancia en Energias Renovables Maestria a distancia en Energias Renovables cursosonline Descubre un completo Directorio de Centros de Formacion Descubre un completo Directorio de Centros de Formacion Italiano online cursosingles Mejore su italiano con solo 15 minutos al dia Mejore su italiano con solo 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! Frances online cursosingles Mejore su frances con solo 15 minutos al dia Mejore su frances con solo 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! Aleman online cursosingles Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! Crucigramas & Juegos juegos !Disfruta con nuestros Crucigramas para expertos! !Disfruta con nuestros Crucigramas para expertos! juegos Resuelve los ultimos Crucigramas de Mambrino Resuelve los ultimos Crucigramas de Mambrino juegos Juega a nuestros Sudoku para Expertos y mejora dia a dia tu nivel Juega a nuestros Sudoku para Expertos y mejora dia a dia tu nivel juegos Juega a las nuevas Sopas de letras clasicas y tematicas de EL PAIS Juega a las nuevas Sopas de letras clasicas y tematicas de EL PAIS Inicia sesion o registrate gratis para continuar leyendo en incognito Registrate gratisInicia sesion Suscribete y lee sin limites Ver opciones de suscripcion HOLA Subscribe for EUR 1 * My activity * My Subscription * My personal data * My newsletters * Rights and de-registration * Events and experiences logout change contrast: Buscar[ ] Select: * - - - * Espana * America + Mexico + Colombia + Chile + Argentina * USA If you want to follow all the latest news without any limits, subscribe to EL PAIS for just EUR1 the first month SUBSCRIBE NOW * Spain * Economy And Business * Society * Opinion * International * Culture * Sports * Science & Tech * Travel * USA * EPS * Podcasts Newsletter Follow on: