https://english.elpais.com/science-tech/2023-04-02/one-of-the-worlds-most-cited-scientists-rafael-luque-suspended-without-pay-for-13-years.html Select: * - - - * Espana * America + Mexico + Colombia + Chile + Argentina * USA EL PAIS Science & Tech subscribeHHOLALOG IN Science & Tech Silicon ValleyYoutubeGoogleLatest News scientific ethics One of the world's most cited scientists, Rafael Luque, suspended without pay for 13 years The prolific chemist, who has published a study every 37 hours this year, has been sanctioned by the University of Cordoba over his research work for other institutions in Russia and Saudi Arabia Chemist Rafael Luque, in a laboratory at the University of Cordoba. Chemist Rafael Luque, in a laboratory at the University of Cordoba. Universidad de Cordoba Manuel Ansede Manuel Ansede 02 Apr 2023 - 19:20 UTC One of the most cited scientists in the world, the Spanish chemist Rafael Luque, has been suspended without pay for the next 13 years, according to Luque himself and the institution where he worked until recently, the University of Cordoba in Spain. The university has sanctioned Luque for working as a researcher at other centers, such as the King Saud University in Riyadh and the Peoples' Friendship University of Russia in Moscow, despite holding a full-time publicly funded contract with the Spanish institution. Luque, 44, is one of the most prolific scientists in Spain. He has published some 700 studies, mainly in the field of so-called green chemistry, which aims to synthesize products such as drugs and fuels while generating less waste. So far this year, Luque has published 58 studies at a rate of one every 37 hours. He has featured on the list of the world's most cited researchers, compiled by the specialist company Clarivate, for five years. Institutions all over the world compete to hire scientists like Luque, who can move a center up hundreds of positions in international academic rankings such as the influential Shanghai ranking, thusly attracting more students and more funding. "Without me, the University of Cordoba is going to drop 300 places [in the Shanghai ranking]. They have shot themselves in the foot," said Luque, who attributed his suspension to "pure envy." Over a decade ago, leading Saudi universities launched aggressive programs to recruit the world's most cited scientists. The King Abdulaziz University, for example, offered researchers around $76,000 per year, with the only stipulation being that spend just one week a year on its campus and, of course, add the name of the Saudi institution as a second affiliation, as revealed by industry journal Science. In 2019, Luque signed on as a researcher at King Saud, in addition to being a professor at the University of Cordoba. The Spanish chemist claimed that he never received money "directly" from either the Saudi or Russian institutions, beyond funding for his analyses, business class travel and luxury hotels. "In my [bank] account, they would not have found a single cent from Russia or Saudi Arabia or anywhere else," he said. Without me, the University of Cordoba will drop 300 places in the Shanghai ranking. They have shot themselves in the foot Rafael Luque, chemist The current scientific system is governed by the "publish or perish" imperative. Researchers are evaluated by the number of studies they publish in peer-reviewed journals and by the number of times these papers are cited by other colleagues. The well-intentioned mechanism, however, has produced adverse effects, as explained by the British engineer Nick Wise, a researcher at Cambridge University who, in his spare time, seeks out fraud in science. Wise has uncovered shady "factories of scientific studies," produced by copying and pasting other studies or by automatic text generators, and whose authorship is secretly sold for hundreds or thousands of dollars to inflate resumes. "I found a study by Rafael Luque whose authorship had previously been offered in a group on [the messaging platform] Telegram," Wise said. The Spanish researcher published that paper on the degradation of ibuprofen in wastewater five months ago, with six co-authors from the University of Bushehr and another from the University of Tabriz, both in Iran. Luque says that he has never paid to be added to someone else's research, but admitted he does not know all the Iranian co-authors listed on the study and cannot rule out the possibility some of them did pay to appear. "I obviously don't know that, but I'm amazed by this issue. Who pays to publish a study? Someone who needs it, maybe, I don't know," he said by videoconference from Dhahran, the heart of the Saudi oil industry, where he is considering a collaboration with a local university. Luque is constantly publishing papers. Last year he authored some 110 articles. So far this year he has published 58. The chemist admitted that since December, he has been using the artificial intelligence program ChatGPT to "polish" his texts. "These months have been quite productive, because there are articles that used to require two or three days and now I do them in one day," he said. ChatGPT, launched in December, is capable of generating in-depth texts in response to complex questions. Luque said he basically uses it to improve his written expression in English and strongly denies having any relationship with any wholesale research factory. I found a study by Rafael Luque whose authorship had previously been offered in a group on Telegram Nick Wise, Cambridge University engineer Russian mathematician Alexander Magazinov, like Wise, also spends his spare time combing scientific literature for "tortured phrases": unusual expressions that are added to plagiarized texts, precisely to avoid the computer programs that detect plagiarism. One example is to replace the usual "artificial intelligence" with "falsified consciousness". Magazinov mentioned that a non-existent "vegetative electron microscopy" appears in two studies by Luque published with Iranian colleagues. Scientists around the world use an American website called PubPeer to anonymously and ruthlessly comment on articles by other colleagues, and not always with reason on their side. There are critiques of around 90 of Luque's studies on PubPeer, many of them from Magazinov himself. A common reproach is that the Spanish chemist's papers include dozens of unnecessary citations to other articles to artificially inflate the number of citations from other colleagues. In 2018, the University of Cordoba boasted that 84 out of 100 of Luque's studies were cited by other scientists. Luque has received many awards including one from the UK Royal Society of Chemistry in 2013 and a mention as a Green Talent in 2011 by the German Ministry of Research. However, this is not the first time he has been involved in a scandal. Two professors at the Tenerife University of La Laguna, Jose Juan Marrero and David Diaz, reported in 2011 that one of their students had appropriated data from their laboratory and published it as his own, with Rafael Luque as sole co-author. A court in Santa Cruz de Tenerife last year convicted Luque and the former student of committing a crime against intellectual property: "I helped him to review the article, to put it in good English and to publish it, yes. I have appealed the sentence," Luque says. They have a grudge against me because I am a very prolific scientist and a lot of people adore me Rafael Luque, chemist Luque stopped working at the University of Cordoba on December 1, 2022, after 15 years there. Until then, his publication signature included the Spanish institution, often accompanied by the Russian or the Saudi institutions, as well as the Jiao Tong University in Xi'an (China) as of 2019 and the University of Central Sweden since the end of 2021. In recent months, he has added the ECOTEC University in Samborondon (Ecuador) and the Mediterranean University of Reggio Calabria (Italy). According to the Spanish chemist, his problems in Cordoba began when he started collaborating with King Saud University in 2019, and after signing a study "by mistake" as if he was a professor at the Russian university. The head of the Cordoba university at the time opened an investigation that ended with Luque being suspended without pay for 13 years, a sanction that was then ratified in autumn 2022 by the new university administration. EL PAIS asked Gomez Villamandos, the current Andalusian government's councilor for universities, about the case but did not receive a response. A spokeswoman for the University of Cordoba stressed that the sanction against Luque is for "violating aspects of incompatibility according to the rules of public personnel" and that the institution has not received any complaint about the quality of his studies. Luque acknowledges that he skipped the established procedures to collaborate with other institutions, but attributes the sanction to envy and a lack of understanding. "They have a grudge against me because I am a very prolific scientist and a lot of people adore me, because they know my worth. They are envious and mediocre people," he said. "I have never felt supported by the University of Cordoba, even though I put it on the Shanghai ranking. Being on the ranking is entirely due to me." Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAIS USA Edition More information Alejandro Cencerrado, the happiness scientist. The happiness scientist: 'Wealth is rising while well-being is falling' Sergio C. Fanjul Mexican scientist Hector Cabrera Fuentes. Mexican scientist Hector Alejandro Cabrera Fuentes pleads guilty to spying in the US Elias Camhaji | Mexico Archived In * Cordoba * Science Adheres toThe Trust ProjectMore information If you are interested in licensing this content, please contact ventacontenidos@prisamedia.com newsletter Sign up to EL PAIS in English Edition bulletin Most viewed 1. One of the world's most cited scientists, Rafael Luque, suspended without pay for 13 years 2. Extreme drought ended one of the ancient world's greatest empires 3. No dates, no sex, no weddings, no kids: Korean women are standing up to Asian machismo 4. Crypto evangelists enter the Bukele government: The dark business of bitcoin in El Salvador 5. She killed her lover's wife with 41 axe blows and was acquitted: Candy Montgomery's story returns to television Recomendaciones EL PAIS * Cursos * Centros * Frances online * Ingles online * Italiano online * Aleman online * Crucigramas & Juegos Cursos cursos Maestria en Big Data y Analytics 100% en linea Maestria en Big Data y Analytics 100% en linea cursos MBA Administracion y Direccion de Empresas en linea MBA Administracion y Direccion de Empresas en linea cursos Programa en linea en 'Project Finance' Internacional Programa en linea en 'Project Finance' Internacional cursos Maestria en linea en Direccion de Recursos Humanos y Gestion del Talento Maestria en linea en Direccion de Recursos Humanos y Gestion del Talento Centros cursosonline Maestria en linea en Gestion Ambiental Maestria en linea en Gestion Ambiental cursosonline Maestria en Comercio Internacional presencial en Madrid, Espana Maestria en Comercio Internacional presencial en Madrid, Espana cursosonline Maestria en Marketing Digital & E-Commerce. Semipresencial en Madrid, Espana Maestria en Marketing Digital & E-Commerce. Semipresencial en Madrid, Espana cursosonline Maestria en 'Data Management' e Innovacion Tecnologica 100% en linea Maestria en 'Data Management' e Innovacion Tecnologica 100% en linea Frances online cursosingles Mejora tu frances con 15 minutos al dia Mejora tu frances con 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfruta de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfruta de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita de nuestro curso de frances 'online' 21 dias de prueba gratuita de nuestro curso de frances 'online' Ingles online cursosingles Mejore su ingles con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia Mejore su ingles con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas cursosingles Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado cursosingles Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Italiano online cursosingles Mejore su italiano con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia Mejore su italiano con EL PAIS con 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas cursosingles Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado cursosingles Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Aleman online cursosingles Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas cursosingles Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado Evalue su nivel y obtenga un certificado cursosingles Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Pruebe 21 dias gratis y sin compromiso Crucigramas & Juegos juegos Crucigramas minis Crucigramas minis juegos Crucigramas Tarkus Crucigramas Tarkus juegos Sudokus mini Sudokus mini juegos Sopas de letras Sopas de letras Recomendaciones EL PAIS * Cursos * Centros * Italiano online * Frances online * Aleman online * Crucigramas & Juegos Cursos cursos Maestria en Ciencias Ambientales presencial en Benito Juarez Maestria en Ciencias Ambientales presencial en Benito Juarez cursos Licenciatura en Administracion de Empresas presencial en Benito Juarez Licenciatura en Administracion de Empresas presencial en Benito Juarez cursos Maestria a distancia en Linguistica Aplicada a la Ensenanza del Espanol como Lengua Extranjera Maestria a distancia en Linguistica Aplicada a la Ensenanza del Espanol como Lengua Extranjera cursos Licenciatura Ejecutiva en Psicologia Semipresencial. Cinco sedes disponibles Licenciatura Ejecutiva en Psicologia Semipresencial. Cinco sedes disponibles Centros cursosonline Licenciatura Ejecutiva en Derecho. Semipresencial en Aguascalientes Licenciatura Ejecutiva en Derecho. Semipresencial en Aguascalientes cursosonline Maestria a distancia en Actividad Fisica y Salud Maestria a distancia en Actividad Fisica y Salud cursosonline Maestria a distancia en Energias Renovables Maestria a distancia en Energias Renovables cursosonline Descubre un completo Directorio de Centros de Formacion Descubre un completo Directorio de Centros de Formacion Italiano online cursosingles Mejore su italiano con solo 15 minutos al dia Mejore su italiano con solo 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! Frances online cursosingles Mejore su frances con solo 15 minutos al dia Mejore su frances con solo 15 minutos al dia cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! Aleman online cursosingles Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' Las mejores oportunidades hablan aleman. Nuevo curso 'online' cursosingles Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. Disfrute de nuestras lecciones personalizadas, breves y divertidas. cursosingles Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. Obtendra un diploma con estadisticas de nivel, progresion y participacion. cursosingles 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! 21 dias de prueba gratuita. !Empiece ya! Crucigramas & Juegos juegos !Disfruta con nuestros Crucigramas para expertos! !Disfruta con nuestros Crucigramas para expertos! juegos Resuelve los ultimos Crucigramas de Mambrino Resuelve los ultimos Crucigramas de Mambrino juegos Juega a nuestros Sudoku para Expertos y mejora dia a dia tu nivel Juega a nuestros Sudoku para Expertos y mejora dia a dia tu nivel juegos Juega a las nuevas Sopas de letras clasicas y tematicas de EL PAIS Juega a las nuevas Sopas de letras clasicas y tematicas de EL PAIS Inicia sesion o registrate gratis para continuar leyendo en incognito Registrate gratisInicia sesion Suscribete y lee sin limites Ver opciones de suscripcion HOLA Subscribe for EUR 1 * My activity * My Subscription * My personal data * My newsletters * Rights and de-registration * Events and experiences logout change contrast: Buscar[ ] Select: * - - - * Espana * America + Mexico + Colombia + Chile + Argentina * USA If you want to follow all the latest news without any limits, subscribe to EL PAIS for just EUR1 the first month SUBSCRIBE NOW * Spain * Economy And Business * Society * Opinion * International * Culture * Sports * Science & Tech * Travel * USA * EPS * Podcasts Newsletter Follow on: