https://99percentinvisible.org/article/biohazard-symbol-designed-to-be-memorable-but-meaningless/ Skip to Content [INS::INS] 99% Invisible Toggle Navigation * Episodes * Articles * About + The Show + The Staff + Job Opening + The Book + Pitch + Contact + Press + Sponsors * Subscribe + Apple Podcasts + Google Play + Stitcher + Pandora + RadioPublic + Podcast RSS + Newsletter * Shop * Book [ ] Submit Search * Facebook * Twitter * Instagram * Tumblr * Store 99% Invisible Newsletter 100% Fascinating Email Address [ ] Yes Please! By submitting this form, you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, that you understand them, and that you agree to be bound by them. If you do not agree to be bound by the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, you may not use the 99% Invisible website and services. see recent newsletter Close Article by Kurt Kohlstedt Biohazard: Iconic Symbol Designed to be "Memorable but Meaningless" Biohazard taped door by Tom Woodward (CC BY-SA 2.0)Click to enlarge image Visuals Category Visuals Date 06.06.16 Producer Kurt Kohlstedt Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Leave a Comment Before uniting behind a single symbol, scientists working with dangerous biological materials faced a dizzying array of warning labels that varied from one laboratory to the next. Then, in 1966, Charles L. Baldwin of Dow Chemical and Robert S. Runkle of the National Institutes of Health co-published a critical paper in Science. Their piece called for the adoption of the biological hazard (or: biohazard) symbol as we know it today. This new symbol they hoped to become standard, however, was unconventional: a crowd-tested solution designed to be maximally devoid of obvious meaning or associations. biohazard warning symbolBiological hazard warning symbol Like radiation risks, biological threats are often insidiously invisible, odorless and tasteless, and thus hard to symbolize in anything but an abstract way. Accordingly, rooms and packages containing dangerous microorganisms (or viruses or toxins) required high-visibility warnings, but these graphics generally lacked a common history or design language. In the early 20th Century, the United States Army labs used an inverted blue triangle, for instance, while the Navy employed a pink rectangle; meanwhile, Universal Postal Convention called for a white staff-and-snake on a violet field for biological transportation. While developing containment systems for dangerous biological materials with the NIH, workers at Dow grew concerned that this lack of universality was contributing to accidental infections of laboratory personnel. To address their concern, a group of engineers and designers at Dow began to work collaboratively toward a design solution. The project team drew up a set of six criteria for the development of a standard bio-hazardous material warning graphic. The symbol should be: 1. Striking in form in order to draw immediate attention 2. Unique and unambiguous, in order not to be confused with symbols used for other purposes 3. Quickly recognizable and easily recalled 4. Easily stenciled 5. Symmetrical, in order to appear identical from all angles 6. Acceptable to groups of varying ethnic backgrounds Without an obvious way to graphically connect the symbol to invisible biological matter, the design had to avoid creating accidental associations with things people can see. "We wanted something that was memorable but meaningless" said Baldwin in an interview, "so we could educate people as to what it means." biohard symbol failedProposed biohazard symbol examples With that guiding principle in mind, the team at Dow set about developing potential candidates. In order to ensure the final symbol was indeed both memorable and meaningless, the project engineers and designers took their six solutions to the public for mass psychological testing. First, 300 people from 25 cities were shown an array of six newly-designed symbols alongside 18 commonly-used symbols, including Mr. Peanut, the Texaco star, the Shell Oil symbol, the Red Cross and even the swastika. Participants were asked to identify or guess the meaning of each (creating an associated "meaningfulness score"). Mr. Peanut of Planters PeanutsMr. Peanut of Planters Peanuts One week later, those same participants were shown an array of 60 symbols, including the original 24, plus 36 more. They were asked to recall which symbols they had seen in the first round of the study, (creating an associated "memorability score"). One symbol stood out from the pack, having achieved the top score in both categories from among the six competing designs. The winning candidate was both the easiest to remember but hardest to associate with any particular meaning, according to the results of the survey. bio symbols orientations This biohazard symbol met or exceeded the various other initial criteria as well. It was not only easy to stencil, but possible to draw with just a straight edge and compass, despite the apparent complexity for the form. Its trefoil (three-leaved) design was another asset; a shape with three-way symmetry can be stuck or stenciled onto a surface in any orientation, and still be easily recognized if a barrel or box is overturned or flipped. Bright orange (against a contrasting background) made it easy to see. ionizing radiation symbolIonizing radiation trefoil warning symbol Still, despite its claim to be association-free, the biohazard symbol arguably benefited from its trefoil similarity to the ionizing radiation symbol developed a few decades prior. This simpler-looking predecessor was created at the University of California, Berkeley for use with things like x-ray apparatuses, medical beam cannons and particle accelerators. It looks a bit like radiation emitting from a central atom, which is arguably somewhat easier to visualize than microorganisms. Unlike the biohazard symbol, though, this relatively simple symbol was bound to have relatives, including an ancient Roman shield that likewise carries a black-and-yellow trefoil. biomedical wasteBiomedical waste by Mfermion (CC BY-SA 3.0) Visual connections aside, the next step for the biohazard symbol was to attach meaning to the still-meaningless form by associating it with a set of usage criteria. It "shall be used to signify the actual or potential presence of a biohazard," advised Baldwin and Runkle in 1966, "and shall identify equipment, containers, rooms, materials, experimental animals, or combinations thereof which contain or are contaminated with viable hazardous agents." The authors also define the term "biohazard" as referring to "those infectious agents presenting a risk or potential risk to the well being of man, either directly through his infection or indirectly through disruption of his environment." discard biohazard boxesSharps discard boxes via The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Research groups at the U.S. Army Biological Laboratories, Department of Agriculture and the NIH agreed to test the new symbol for six months. Once it was adopted by the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) and the Occupational Safety and Hazard Administration (OSHA), it quickly became the standard in (and in some cases beyond) America. logo deconstructionBiohazard symbol analysis by The Logo Factory Unlike most signs, designed to be visual analogues of physical phenomena, this symbol works by being distinctive, compelling and complex ... all while remaining easy to remember. Its success ultimately hinges on the design maintaining a safe distance from other familiar emblems, shapes and symbols. These days, however, its compelling distinctiveness (which has helped popularize biohazard t-shirts, mugs and stickers) may also be a drawback. Baldwin has expressed concern: "Every time I go into the doctor's office or the dentist's office or a hospital anywhere, I've always got my eye out for it. Naturally, I'm proud of the fact that I was able to ... direct a program that evolved into this symbol that's so widely recognized, so helpful. But I ran into a peculiar situation one time a couple years ago when someone was putting on a seminar on biohazards. As gifts for the participants, he devised a beautiful tie with little biohazard symbols all over it. This got me upset, and I sent him kind of a nasty letter saying this symbol was not designed to be used sartorially." biohazard productsBiohazard products: sports tape, water bottle, bag, sunglasses, helmet and lighter via Amazon His reaction and position may sound a bit harsh, but they are grounded in legitimate concerns: the more popular the symbol becomes outside of its intended use cases, the less effective it will be at saving lives by alerting people to actual biological hazards, now and in the future. 99% Invisible Ten Thousand Years Episode 114 Ten Thousand Years * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download 1 2 Next Page [engagemen] Enjoy 99pi? Subscribe to the podcast! iTunes RSS Feed [engagemen] Get the latest from 99pi each week in your inbox Email Address [ ] Yes Please! By submitting this form, you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, that you understand them, and that you agree to be bound by them. If you do not agree to be bound by the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, you may not use the 99% Invisible website and services. [engagemen] Enjoy 99pi? Subscribe to the podcast! Subscribe Subscribe Credits [INS::INS] Explore Architecture Infrastructure Cities Objects Sounds Visuals Technology History More in Visuals Podcast Episode Episode 411 - Podcast Episode * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download Hand Painted Signs Episode 74 - Hand Painted Signs * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download Full Spectrum Episode 456 - Full Spectrum * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download One Man Is An Island Episode 105 - One Man Is An Island * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download Alpha to Omega: An Introductory Field Guide... Kurt Kohlstedt - Alpha to Omega: An Introductory Field Guide... Masters of the Uni-verse Episode 111 - Masters of the Uni-verse * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download [INS::INS] Archives Uncensored Library: Banned Journalism... Kurt Kohlstedt - Uncensored Library: Banned Journalism... Search and Ye Might Find Episode 507 - Search and Ye Might Find * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download Design for Airports Episode 32 - Design for Airports * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download For Amusement Only Episode 135 - For Amusement Only * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download Wait Wait...Tell Me! Episode 369 - Wait Wait...Tell Me! * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download Stuff the British Stole Episode 450 - Stuff the British Stole * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download Previous Episode: Tilt & Turn: Ingenious Three-in-One Window for Security, Breezes & Egress Next Episode: Stop, Drop & Roll (or Throw): Fighting Fires with Fire Grenades [INS::INS] Comments (6) Share * Share on Twitter * Share on Facebook * Share on Tumblr * Share via Email 1. Teresa Newton 06.07.16 01:54 AM When I was training to be a teacher, I had to take language acquisition classes. One of the classes focused on "Universal Language". One of the most memorable bits from that class was a story in one of the textbooks about the hollow mountain on Native American land (whose name escapes me now) that is one site of our seriously long term nuclear waste storage. Since the half life of the radioactivity of the stuff is millions of years, the designers of the site needed a symbol that would be recognizable to our MANY times removed grandchildren as marking a very dangerous place. They had to assume the complete collapse of civilization and loss of records in a recognizable or known language that identified the place and its purpose. It had to be universally recognizable as a warning symbol. Sadly, the work was still in development when the textbook was written so I never saw the symbol, but I've always been curious as to what they designed. Reply 1. Alejandro Alonzo 06.08.16 08:07 AM A couple of years ago, 99PI did an episode about a similar topic, the design of marker systems for the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP). You can check it out here, if you haven't already: http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/ ten-thousand-years/ 2. Jeff Stockwell 06.07.16 05:39 AM I appreciated the inclusion of three of the other possible biohazard symbols that were considered, but I would really be interested to see ALL of the symbols that were considered. Also, I would be very interested to know about the people who did the design work and thoughts on their design process. Reply 1. 99pi 06.11.16 02:29 PM Hi Jeff - I searched for the full symbol set but, alas, was only able to find the few of them you see included in the article. -= Kurt 3. Normandie Rainwater 06.16.16 11:27 AM Thank you for this article. I'm really attracted to images that are graphically elegant, but also present a fearful message. I've been working with the biohazard symbol, along with similar graphics, in a series of paintings. You can see this work in my most recent blog post: http://www.studionhr.com/blog/ Reply 4. Elwin 06.28.20 05:41 AM In my uneducated opinion, they should have sticked with jolly roger. What else could have been better to symbolize death, universally and everlastingly, other than dead remains such as bones and dead flesh? Also in the case of WIPP nuclear waste. If we were to warn our organic successor in ten of thousand years about the danger of our nuclear waste, dead remains still have the same meaning; death. Even though in modern times we use jolly roger as accessories, they always mean the same, "I wear jolly roger because I am as deadly as pirates. This place is where we bury treasures, and we put our jolly roger to warn that death comes to those who dare to disturb." Reply Leave a Reply Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] Comment [ ] Name * [ ] Email * [ ] Website [ ] [Post] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] More in Visuals Episode 54 - The Colour of Money (R) * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download * Transcript Episode 205 - Flying Food * PlayPause * Add to QueueRemove from Queue * Download * Transcript Kurt Kohlstedt - Font of Future Past: The Fraught History and Persistent Popularity of... Unveiled as a font of the future, Futura... [Read More] 99pi - Fast Company's 100 Most Creative I was named one of Fast Company's 100... [Read More] All Categories Architecture Infrastructure Cities Objects Sounds Visuals Technology History 99% Invisible [listen-on-stit] (c) 99% Invisible Privacy Policy & Terms of Service * Episodes * Articles * About + The Show + The Staff + Contact + Press + Sponsors + Newsletter * Store Support the Show Your donations are vital to keeping us independent and strong! Contributions are used for: * Paying our exceptional staff * Paying outside contributors * Travel costs for more ambitious stories * Weekly Pakistani buffet [99PI_Donat] Donate Newsletter Signup [99PI_NewsletterModalImage] Hey there beautiful nerd! Sign up to for the 99PI newsletter to get our 1/week email with: * Excerpts and links to latest episodes and articles * Periodic, exclusive updates on 99PI goings-on Email Address [ ] Yes Please! [lg-arrow] [ ] By clicking this box, you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, that you understand them, and that you agree to be bound by them. If you do not agree to be bound by the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, you may not use the 99% Invisible website and services. Quantcast [p] Minimize Maximize Play Pause Mute Unmute Previous in Playlist Jump backward 15 seconds | Jump forward 15 seconds Next in Playlist Update Required To play the media you will need to update your browser to a version that supports HTML5. Minimize Maximize Playlist Playlist Drag and drop to reorder. Your playlist is stored within your cookies, clearing your browser data may remove your playlist. * Nothing here yet! Feel free to browse the archives to add episodes. More [lg-arrow-r] 99% Invisible uses cookies to help improve your user experience. Feel free to review our cookie policy here. Thanks, got it!