https://www.theregister.com/2023/02/12/software_freedom_conservancy_fights_agplv3/ [user] [user] Sign in / up The Register(r) -- Biting the hand that feeds IT [magn] [burg] [burg] Topics Security Security All SecurityCyber-crimePatchesResearchCSO (X) Off-Prem Off-Prem All Off-PremEdge + IoTChannelPaaS + IaaSSaaS (X) On-Prem On-Prem All On-PremSystemsStorageNetworksHPCPersonal Tech (X) Software Software All SoftwareAI + MLApplicationsDatabasesDevOpsOSesVirtualization (X) Offbeat Offbeat All OffbeatDebatesColumnistsScienceGeek's GuideBOFHLegalBootnotesSite NewsAbout Us (X) Vendor Voice Vendor Voice Vendor Voice All Vendor VoiceAmazon Web Services (AWS) Business Transformation Google Cloud for Startups (X) Resources Resources Whitepapers Webinars Newsletters [devops] Devops comment bubble on black How this database legal war could be decided by the name given to this license comment bubble on black Neo4j v PureThink rumbles on icon Thomas Claburn Sun 12 Feb 2023 // 14:44 UTC # Bradley Kuhn, policy fellow at the Software Freedom Conservancy, claims a California federal court has misinterpreted version 3 of GNU Affero General Public License (AGPLv3) by allowing it to be combined with the Common Clause software license. Kuhn, who created the Affero clause in the AGPLv1 and co-drafted v3, expects to serve as an expert witness for defendants PureThink and founder John Mark Suhy, who were sued by database biz Neo4j in November 2018, for alleged trademark and competition law violations. PureThink at the time distributed database software called ONgDB, which was marketed as an open-source licensed version of Neo4j EE. [devops] Neo4j EE is under a combined AGPLv3+Commons Clause license - the Commons Clause modified the APGLv3 by adding a restriction that forbids the sale of the software. However, PureThink offered a forked version of the Neo4j EE database software under the APGLv3 alone, having removed the Commons Clause from its version of the software. [devops] [devops] So Neo4j and its Swedish subsidiary sued PureThink and others claiming that they had violated the license terms and had infringed Neo4j's trademarks. * Court erred in Neo4j source license ruling, says Software Freedom Conservancy * False advertising to call software open source when it's not, says court * Florida man accused of breaking Mastodon's open-source license with botched social network launch * Someone has to pay to keep the lights so data-viz outfit Grafana switches licence regime to AGPLv3 In May 2021, Neo4j won a partial summary judgment [PDF] when the judge overseeing the case granted the company's request for a temporary injunction based on its trademark and unfair competition claims. PureThink was enjoined - until the matter can be resolved - from "advertising, promoting, representing or referring to ONgDB as a free and open source drop-in replacement for Neo4j Enterprise Edition" and making false representations about ONgDB to customers. The US Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals subsequently upheld that injunction, and the case has continued so far. [devops] Among the remaining disputed issues to be resolved, the most important for the Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) community is whether Neo4j's concatenation of the AGPLv3 and Commons Clause is allowed. Kuhn, in an expert report [PDF] prepared for the case, acknowledges that the AGPLv3 language can be re-mixed and used in another license, as long as that license is not called the AGPLv3. He cites MongoDB's modified AGPLv3 license, referred to as the Server-Side Public License, as an example of how the AGPLv3 can be altered into something that's not a FOSS license. But if the license is referred to as the AGPLv3, then its Further Restrictions Clause - which allows users of APGLv3 licensed software to remove added licensing terms - should apply. If the court accepts that argument, it would be a significant reversal: PureThink would be allowed to fork Neo4J EE under the AGPLv3. [devops] A trial date has yet to be set but several possibilities in July, 2023, have been proposed. (r) Get our Tech Resources # Share Similar topics * Database * FOSS * Neo4j More like these x Similar topics * Database * FOSS * Neo4j * Software * Software License Narrower topics * AdBlock Plus * App * Application Delivery Controller * Audacity * Confluence * FOSDEM * IDE * Jenkins * LibreOffice * Map * Microsoft 365 * Microsoft Office * Microsoft Teams * MongoDB * MySQL * NoSQL * OpenOffice * Open Source * PostgreSQL * Programming Language * QR code * Retro computing * Search Engine * Software bug * SQL Server * User interface * Visual Studio * Visual Studio Code * WebAssembly * Web Browser Broader topics * Copyright * Legal * Oracle Similar topics # Share comment bubble on black POST A COMMENT Similar topics * Database * FOSS * Neo4j More like these x Similar topics * Database * FOSS * Neo4j * Software * Software License Narrower topics * AdBlock Plus * App * Application Delivery Controller * Audacity * Confluence * FOSDEM * IDE * Jenkins * LibreOffice * Map * Microsoft 365 * Microsoft Office * Microsoft Teams * MongoDB * MySQL * NoSQL * OpenOffice * Open Source * PostgreSQL * Programming Language * QR code * Retro computing * Search Engine * Software bug * SQL Server * User interface * Visual Studio * Visual Studio Code * WebAssembly * Web Browser Broader topics * Copyright * Legal * Oracle TIP US OFF Send us news --------------------------------------------------------------------- Other stories you might like Voice.ai denies claim it violated open source software license requirements Maker of voice changing software says it has removed GPLv3 code "to alleviate any doubt" Devops8 Feb 2023 | 11 Best time to prepare to leave an Oracle ULA? The day after it starts, say licensing gurus Big Red 'will always start with a large number and negotiate down' Databases1 Feb 2023 | 10 Have we learnt nothing from SolarWinds supply chain attacks? Not yet it appears From frameworks to new federal offices it's time to get busy Security5 Feb 2023 | 26 What does it really take to be a leader when it comes to cloud databases? Here's what the AWS customer obsession means to you Sponsored Feature [devops] Oracle, Microsoft barely compete for a quarter of their US Federal contracts Vendor lock-in: savings of up to $750m a year possible if Uncle Sam didn't predetermine the victor Software1 Feb 2023 | 11 Open Source Policy Summit: Where FOSS and government meet FOSDEM Sometimes it takes a war to make people pay attention Applications9 Feb 2023 | 7 Jellyfish watches for the sting of developer bottlenecks Dashboard your DevOps data and see where your team has been slacking Devops1 Feb 2023 | 3 American jailed for smuggling controlled tech to Iran 30 months in prison for providing, um... enterprise mobile banking software dev tool Legal10 Feb 2023 | 10 US stalkerware developer fined $410,000 and ordered to modify apps so they reveal spying Creepy developer offers evasive apps that track victims, crack their cloud storage, enable harassment and worse Personal Tech7 Feb 2023 | 12 VMware turns 25 today: Is it a mature professional or headed back to Mom's house? Special feature Beat Microsoft. Set agendas. Became essential. Hiked prices. Now we wait for Broadcom's reign Virtualization10 Feb 2023 | 16 Transmission FOSS BitTorrent client hits version 4.0 Torrenting is still a thing, it still works, and it's not just for illegal downloads to get around streaming restrictions Applications8 Feb 2023 | 30 US warns aging air-traffic control code won't be fixed until 2030 NOTAM chance in hell this stuff is getting sorted soon despite outage Software7 Feb 2023 | 13 The Register icon Biting the hand that feeds IT About Us* * Contact us * Advertise with us * Who we are Our Websites* * The Next Platform * DevClass * Blocks and Files Your Privacy* * Cookies Policy * Privacy Policy * T's & C's * Do not sell my personal information Situation Publishing Copyright. All rights reserved (c) 1998-2023 no-js