https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/students-suing-elite-us-colleges-seek-wealth-favoritism-information-2023-02-09/ Skip to main content Exclusive news, data and analytics for financial market professionals Reuters home * World * Business * Legal * Markets * Breakingviews * Technology * Investigations * More My View Register * * * * * * * * * Antitrust * Litigation 3 minute readFebruary 9, 202310:09 PM UTCLast Updated ago Students suing elite U.S. colleges seek 'wealth favoritism' information By Mike Scarcella Students walk on the campus of Yale University in New Haven, Connecticut Students walk on the campus of Yale University in New Haven, Connecticut, October 7, 2009. REUTERS/Shannon Stapleton * Summary * Law firms * Related documents * Schools wanted to bar discovery of donation records * Case seeks class action status for students at 17 major schools * * * * * * * * (Reuters) - A Chicago federal judge has handed a key victory to students suing a group of elite U.S. universities and colleges over their financial aid practices, saying they can question school officials and search for records about whether "wealth favoritism" played into admission considerations. In his ruling on Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Matthew Kennelly rejected a bid from six schools -- Brown University, Columbia University, Dartmouth College, Northwestern University, University of Notre Dame and Yale University -- for an order barring the plaintiffs from accessing admission and development records, including details about donations. Brown and the other five schools must also allow senior university officials to sit for depositions on those matters, according to the court's ruling. The prospective class action filed last year against 17 schools alleged a price-fixing conspiracy in which schools restricted financial aid, causing a class of potentially more than 200,000 students to over-pay for tuition by tens of millions of dollars. The lawsuit survived an early bid by the schools to dismiss it. Latest Updates * TechnologycategoryConsultant in Musk litigation sues Twitter for $2.2 mln in fees, article with image * MarketscategoryFTC withdraws from adjudication in fight with Meta over Within deal, article with image View 2 more stories The schools have long denied taking a would-be student's financial need into account as part of the admission process. Kennelly's order "will allow the plaintiffs to develop the evidence to prove our case," plaintiffs' lawyer Bob Gilbert, on the team leading the case, said on Thursday. Attorneys for Brown and the other five schools did not immediately respond to messages seeking comment. Representatives from those schools either declined to comment or did not respond to similar requests. For their part, the defense lawyers for the schools won a chance on Wednesday to subpoena some financial aid application information from the parents of student plaintiffs in the case. Attorneys for the student plaintiffs are seeking among other records "documents and communications concerning the consideration of donor or legacy status in admissions," including details about donations totaling more than $50,000. "Records of donations of that magnitude in the President's office or Development office should stick out like needles that can be tracked into the Admissions office," the plaintiffs' lawyers told the court. The plaintiffs' lawyers said evidence of donation records linked to the admissions process would undermine the schools' claims that a would-be student's potential for financial aid was not weighed. Lawyers for the schools said in a court filing that the "plaintiffs' goal in pursuing such discovery is to harass and embarrass, rather than because it is relevant to their actual antitrust claim." The defense lawyers also called the demand for admissions and development records "intrusive and burdensome." The case is Henry v. Brown University, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, No. 1:22-cv-00125. For plaintiffs: Bob Gilbert of Gilbert Litigators & Counselors; Edward Normand of Freedman Normand Friedland; and other firms For Brown: Jon Roellke of Morgan, Lewis & Bockius; For Columbia: Amy Van Gelder of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom; For Dartmouth: Douglas Litvack of Jenner & Block; For Northwestern: Scott Stein of Sidley Austin; For Notre Dame: Bob Van Kirk of Williams & Connolly; For Yale: Chuck Loughlin of Hogan Lovells Read more: Major U.S. universities want family details of students suing over financial aid U.S. colleges lose early bid to toss financial aid antitrust claims Antitrust case against universities draws heavyweight defenders * * * * * Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. Read Next / Editor's Picks * WorldcategoryExclusive: U.S. lawmakers press Labor Department to probe child labor in Hyundai supply chain, article with image February 10, 2023 * Future of MoneycategoryExplainer: What is 'staking,' the cryptocurrency practice in regulators' crosshairs?, article with imageFebruary 10, 2023 * BusinesscategoryAurora Cannabis CEO says open to more M&A deals after upbeat Q2, article with imageFebruary 10, 2023 * WorldcategoryMemphis officers charged in Nichols death face review of older cases, article with image1:19 AM UTC refinitiv_image_desktop Industry Insight * Industry InsightRecommended change management practices to plan, build, then deploy successful legal tech [453bcfa2-8] [nadine_ezz] Kenneth Jones, Nadine Ezzie, Esq. February 3, 2023 * Industry InsightHow best to integrating climate-conscious clauses in supply chain contracts [da820977-2] Thomson Reuters Institute February 3, 2023 * Industry InsightUpcoming SEC climate disclosure rules bring urgency to ESG data strategy planning [bc70b454-9] Zach Warren January 30, 2023 * Industry InsightLaw firm pricing professionals in 2023: Examining compensation & team structures [william_jo] William Josten January 5, 2023 Site Index Browse * World * Business * Legal * Markets * Breakingviews * Technology * Investigations , opens new tab * Lifestyle About Reuters * About Reuters , opens new tab * Careers , opens new tab * Reuters News Agency , opens new tab * Brand Attribution Guidelines , opens new tab * Reuters Leadership , opens new tab * Reuters Fact Check , opens new tab * Reuters Diversity Report , opens new tab Stay Informed * Download the App , opens new tab * Newsletters , opens new tab Information you can trust Reuters, the news and media division of Thomson Reuters, is the world's largest multimedia news provider, reaching billions of people worldwide every day. Reuters provides business, financial, national and international news to professionals via desktop terminals, the world's media organizations, industry events and directly to consumers. Follow Us * * * * * Thomson Reuters Products * Westlaw , opens new tab Build the strongest argument relying on authoritative content, attorney-editor expertise, and industry defining technology. * Onesource , opens new tab The most comprehensive solution to manage all your complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs. * Checkpoint , opens new tab The industry leader for online information for tax, accounting and finance professionals. Refinitiv Products * Refinitiv Workspace , opens new tab Access unmatched financial data, news and content in a highly-customised workflow experience on desktop, web and mobile. * Refinitiv Data Catalogue , opens new tab Browse an unrivalled portfolio of real-time and historical market data and insights from worldwide sources and experts. * Refinitiv World-Check , opens new tab Screen for heightened risk individual and entities globally to help uncover hidden risks in business relationships and human networks. * Advertise With Us , opens new tab * Advertising Guidelines , opens new tab * Cookies , opens new tab * Terms of Use , opens new tab * Privacy , opens new tab * Digital Accessibility , opens new tab * Corrections , opens new tab * Site Feedback , opens new tab All quotes delayed a minimum of 15 minutes. See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. (c) 2023 Reuters. All rights reserved