https://www.cbsnews.com/news/salary-manager-jobs-fake-titles-save-4-billion-overtime-nber/ * CBS News App * Jan. 6 Probe * Ukraine Crisis * COVID Pandemic * CBS News Live * Managing Your Money * Essentials Shopping * Newsletters * News + o US o World o Politics o Entertainment o Health o MoneyWatch o CBS Village o Technology o Science o Crime o Sports o Essentials + o # Blinken postpones trip to China as balloon flies over U.S. # Arrests made in "cartel-style execution" that killed 6 people, including a baby # American aid worker killed in Ukraine, group says # George Santos may owe thousands for traffic violations in two states # Charges against Bengals running back Joe Mixon dropped # 3 bodies found near Detroit identified as missing rappers # Surveillance part on Chinese balloon over U.S. is as big as 2-3 school buses # California bicyclist struck by Lexus and then fatally stabbed by driver # Suspect arrested in case of 2 monkeys taken from Dallas Zoo * * Shows * Live * Local * More + o Latest o Video o Photos o Podcasts o In Depth o Local o Global Thought Leaders o Innovators & Disruptors + o Log In o Newsletters o Mobile o RSS o CBS Store o Paramount+ o Join Our Talent Community o Davos 2023 * Search * Search * Login Watch CBS News MoneyWatch Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fake "manager" titles, study shows moneywatch By Irina Ivanova Updated on: February 3, 2023 / 3:12 PM / MoneyWatch * * * How companies get away with wage theft How companies get away with wage theft 05:21 Would you rather be a front-desk clerk or "Director of First Impressions"? A barber or a "Grooming Manager"? How you answer could mean a significant difference in annual earnings. That's because companies routinely inflate workers' titles to avoid paying them in full for overtime work, according to researchers from the University of Texas and Harvard Business School. It's no secret companies go to great lengths to keep their labor costs down. What the new working paper reveals is that firms save a total of $4 billion in overtime payments a year simply by getting creative with titles. For employees, however, these inflated titles result in 13% less pay than they might otherwise get. "If you're relying on cheap labor -- you're a labor-intensive company and you can get away with it -- this becomes a tool that you can use to lower your costs," said Umit Gurun, professor of accounting and finance at the University of Texas at Dallas and one of the report's authors. Gurun said he and coauthor N. Bugra Ozel hit on the idea for the study, published by the National Bureau for Economic Research, while they were traveling through an airport and overheard two workers talking about a delayed flight. "One said, 'I don't complain because I get overtime.' The other guy was a manager, so he didn't," Gurun recalled. "But they were doing exactly the same job." After that discussion, the researchers started noticing dozens of examples in the news. It wasn't hard: Workers have filed lawsuits against some of the largest employers in the U.S., including Bank of America, Family Dollar, JPMorgan Chase, Starbucks and UPS. Companies are sued for wage theft more than almost anything else, with the exception of workplace safety and health violations. The $15 billion problem in America's workplaces 01:50 Falling through the cracks These lawsuits focus on a quirk in U.S. wage laws. Generally, companies are required to pay workers one-and-a-half times their hourly rate anytime they work more than 40 hours in a week. But there's an exemption for salaried managers, who receive the same amount of pay each week, as long as they earn above a certain minimum amount. During the time period analyzed by the authors, that cutoff to qualify for OT was $455 a week -- equivalent to an annual salary of $23,660. For the paper, Gurun and his co-authors analyzed a database of job postings from labor analytics firm Burning Glass Technologies between 2010 and 2018, paying particular attention to which ones listed managerial titles. They found that the incidence of fake-sounding manager titles spiked at the legal threshold of $455 a week -- exactly the cutoff at which a company would be allowed to put workers on salary and sidestep OT payment laws. "There is a systematic, robust and sharp increase in firms' use of managerial titles around the federal regulatory threshold that allows them to avoid paying for overtime," the paper concluded. Some of these unconventional manager titles, according to the researchers: food cart manager, price scanning coordinator, carpet shampoo manager, lead shower door installer, director of first impressions and grooming manager. Notably, this pattern didn't exist in states that set a different salary threshold for OT, nor with managerial titles that were paid hourly, reinforcing the idea that companies are doing this strategically to avoid paying overtime. The paper also found that inflated manager titles were more common in states with weaker labor laws, low union membership and higher unemployment. "Title inflation" on the rise These legally dubious tactics coexist with the phenomenon of "title inflation" in white-collar jobs, in which employers sometimes grant salaried workers ever-loftier titles in lieu of raising their pay. Common in startups, the phenomenon "exploded" during the pandemic, Shawn Cole, president of search firm Cowen Partners, told Bloomberg last year. "Entire careers of job titles are being condensed into a decade, 10 years worth of titles are being condensed into five, so new titles have had to be invented," he told the outlet. "Firms can only offer so much money." Hourly workers are well aware that fancy titles can be used to mask insufficient pay -- and so are regulators. As far back as 1940, the Department of Labor warned that companies are likely to game the system if they are allowed to exempt particular titles from their full legal pay. "Titles can be had cheaply," one official wrote. "[I] t is not hard to call a janitor a 'superintendent' or a 'superintendent of maintenance' if some result desirable to the employer will flow therefrom." * Child care disruptions continue for working parents of small children * Here's how much pay Americans say they'd need to start a new job * Why have so many American men given up on work? But companies continue strategic title-fudging because, well, it pays. In 2019, a year when the Department of Labor won $226 million in back wages for cheated workers, companies saved roughly 18 times that amount by calling frontline workers doing ordinary jobs "managers," the paper found. "The incredibly high [return on investment] on this activity of avoiding overtime wages might explain why we see firms across every industry -- from Staples to JPMorgan, to Facebook, to Walmart, to Verizon, to Avis, to Lowes -- engaging in this activity even up through the present day," the paper said. Trending News US-HEALTH-VIRUS-EPIDEMIC-POLITICS Companies give people fake "manager" titles, and save billions Tesla Responds To New Car License Rumors Tesla's Model Y, other EVs now qualify for $7,500 tax credit screen-shot-2023-02-03-at-12-19-09-pm.png Dad was distracted. His 6-year-old son ordered $1,000 from Grubhub. House with American flag and 'for sale' sign, low angle view Here are the states Americans are moving to -- and why 1740e4ad-ba7c-4374-8d7b-871ab77b7d09.jpg Egg prices have soared 60% in a year. Here's why. In: * Minimum Wage * Wage Theft First published on February 2, 2023 / 7:57 AM (c) 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. Thanks for reading CBS NEWS. Create your free account or log in for more features. [ ] Continue Please enter email address to continue Please enter valid email address to continue Copyright (c)2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. * Privacy Policy * Do Not Sell My Personal Information * Cookies Policy * Terms of Use * About * Advertise * Closed Captioning * CBS News Live on Paramount+ * CBS News Store * Site Map * Contact Us * Help Quotes delayed at least 15 minutes. Market data provided by ICE Data Services. ICE Limitations. Powered and implemented by FactSet. News provided by The Associated Press. Legal Statement. * * * * View CBS News In CBS News App Open Chrome Safari Continue Be the first to know Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. Not Now Turn On