https://www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2022/12/28/why-solana-was-decimated-by-bankman-frieds-downfall/ * + Crypto Prices + CoinDesk Market Index + TV & Videos + Newsletters + Podcasts + WhiteLayersIconConsensus Magazine + Learn + Bitcoin Calculator + Consensus + Webinars + Indices + About + Markets + Companies + Technology + Web3 + Policy + Sponsored Content Upcoming event (CoinDesk)Join the Most Important Conversation in Crypto and Web3 * TV & Videos TV & Videos + First Mover + The Hash + All About Bitcoin + Money Reimagined + Community Crypto + Consensus 22 Videos + View all shows Watch On + Twitter Twitter + Facebook Facebook * Newsletters Sign up for our newsletters Learn More [ ]UncheckedCheckbox Crypto Markets Today What happened today in crypto markets - and why. [ ]UncheckedCheckbox Crypto Investing Course Be a smarter, safer investor in eight weeks. [ ]UncheckedCheckbox The Node The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day. [ ]UncheckedCheckbox First Mover The latest moves in crypto markets, in context. [ ]UncheckedCheckbox Money Reimagined The transformation of value in the digital age. [ ]UncheckedCheckbox Crypto Long & Short News and analysis for the professional investor. [ ]UncheckedCheckbox State of Crypto Probing the intersection of crypto and government. [ ]UncheckedCheckbox Valid Points How Ethereum's evolution impacts crypto markets. [ ]UncheckedCheckbox Crypto for Advisors What financial advisors need to know about crypto. Enter your Email[ ] Subscribe By signing up, you will receive emails about CoinDesk products and you agree to our terms & conditions and privacy policy. * Podcasts Podcasts + The Hash + Markets Daily + Money Reimagined + The Breakdown, With NLW + Carpe Consensus Coindesk Logo * SearchIconBlack * Consensus Consensus + Go to Consensus 2023 Site + Consensus 2022 Videos + Powered By Consensus Content * Indices Indices + Bitcoin Price Index (XBX) + Ether Price Index (ETX) + Basic Attention Token Price Index (BTX) + Bitcoin Cash Price Index (BCX) + Cardano Price Index (ADX) --------------------------------------------------------------------- * Crypto Prices * CoinDesk Market Index --------------------------------------------------------------------- * TV & Videos * Newsletters * Podcasts * WhiteLayersIconConsensus Magazine * Learn * Bitcoin Calculator * Consensus * Webinars * Indices * About --------------------------------------------------------------------- * Markets * Companies * Technology * Web3 * Policy --------------------------------------------------------------------- * Sponsored Content --------------------------------------------------------------------- Upcoming event (CoinDesk)Join the Most Important Conversation in Crypto and Web3 * Markets Markets + Bitcoin + Ether + Altcoins + Trading + First Mover * Companies Companies + FTX Downfall: Full Coverage + Celsius + NFTs + Terra + Business * Policy Policy + Regulation + Crypto + Sanctions + SEC + Law * Technology Technology + The Merge + Ethereum + DeFi + Stablecoins + Terra * Web3 Web3 + Yuga Labs + NFTs + Metaverse + Dao + Gaming * Learn Learn + NFTs + Bitcoin + Ethereum + Cryptocurrency + Investing Crash Courses + Bitcoin 101 + DeFi 101 + Ethereum 101 + NFT 101 + Price Data 101 * Consensus Magazine Consensus Magazine + Most Influential + Sports Week + Future of Work Week + Metaverse Week + Payments Week Most Recent Issue CoinDesk - Unknown * Sponsored Content Sponsored Content + Gate.io + abra + Matrixport + SocialGood + Tron Bitcoin $16,490.08-1.16% Ethereum $1,184.51-2.24% Binance Coin $242.82-1.26% XRP $0.35796445-3.82% Binance USD $0.99985654+0.01% Dogecoin $0.07006844-4.42% Cardano $0.24784500-4.40% Stellar $0.07165400-3.10% Polygon $0.78014699-3.26% Crypto.com $0.05801474-1.29% Chainlink $5.65-3.93% Tron $0.05420005+0.54% Polkadot $4.26-4.83% Uniswap $4.97-3.48% Litecoin $65.99-3.25% Shiba Inu $0.00000786-3.71% Solana $9.75-11.65% Avalanche $11.14-4.26% Aptos $3.21-10.66% Wrapped Bitcoin $16,434.36-1.31% Cosmos $9.14-0.92% Monero $146.04+0.42% Quant $108.24-5.29% Ethereum Classic $14.96-4.89% Internet Computer $3.95+4.12% Bitcoin Cash $98.90-2.58% ApeCoin $3.62-0.55% Stepn $0.23024406-1.05% Algorand $0.16577899-1.74% VeChain $0.01562158-2.00% NEAR Protocol $1.30-3.68% Filecoin $2.99-2.23% dYdX $1.03-8.28% Luna Classic $0.00014781-14.67% Hedera $0.04037183-3.96% Load Network $0.95426716-6.34% Curve DAO Token $0.50868159-3.23% EOS $0.87010000-2.10% Paxos Dollar $0.99855722+2.45% Aave $53.46-6.65% Elrond $33.09-1.72% Bitcoin SV $40.59-9.40% Theta $0.75068263+0.02% Axie Infinity $6.24-6.93% Flow $0.68279521-7.24% Tezos $0.73210000-4.47% Decentraland $0.30426302-5.29% The Sandbox $0.40897652-6.29% NEO $6.03-2.47% BitTorrent $0.00000062-2.16% Chiliz $0.10272715-3.76% Maker $515.72-4.24% PancakeSwap $3.14-5.08% Fantom $0.19785050-1.38% Zcash $37.17-4.10% PAX Gold $1,795.70-1.07% Dash $42.72-2.64% IOTA $0.16853234-2.50% Synthetix $1.45-1.76% eCash $0.00002206-4.74% The Graph $0.05585948-5.62% THORChain $1.31-4.74% Mina $0.45146705-4.64% Nexo $0.62896592-2.29% Compound $31.89-2.16% Convex Finance $3.19-7.65% FTX Token $0.87987002-4.56% Immutable X $0.38976690-5.57% Stacks $0.20989065-5.21% Ethereum Name Service $10.96-1.71% Decred $18.71-3.09% Zilliqa $0.01626721-4.92% NEM $0.02807914-3.46% Basic Attention Token $0.16633000-6.50% Enjin $0.24232967-5.33% Loopring $0.19304382-5.88% Terra 2.0/LUNA $1.28-6.44% Kava.io $0.65369285-5.23% Sushiswap $0.95232932-3.67% Kusama $24.73-1.98% Bitcoin Gold $11.41-5.94% Ravencoin $0.01831640-4.16% Celo $0.45467226-6.23% Ribbon Finance $0.21165000-3.22% Mask Network $2.08-9.10% Celsius $0.49042854-7.99% TerraUSD $0.02017837-7.27% Qtum $1.85-2.95% Optimism $0.89546317-4.33% Yearn Finance $5,186.01-5.40% IoTeX $0.02000084-0.27% Oasis Network $0.03542677-1.77% Amp $0.00306884-1.80% Moonbeam $0.34187804-1.91% UMA Protocol $1.50-5.61% Band Protocol $1.35-6.10% 0x $0.15303595-3.75% Polymath Network $0.14532847-13.99% Woo Network $0.11929396-0.29% OMG Network $1.01-1.62% Waves $1.38-8.99% ICON $0.14355582-2.15% Gala $0.01674457-5.89% Ankr $0.01519748-7.99% SafePal $0.38405646-1.47% DigiByte $0.00756115-0.54% Audius $0.12841947-1.85% Livepeer $4.65-8.48% Secret $0.61216896-3.70% Siacoin $0.00222269-4.60% SXP $0.20884855-2.46% Lisk $0.71175701-6.62% Cartesi $0.10004214-2.62% Wax $0.04354933-7.80% Injective Protocol $1.25-1.58% iExec RLC $1.31-3.33% MetisDAO $16.21-2.16% Voyager Token $0.29678990-5.72% Aragon $2.19+2.03% Nano $0.64728058-1.96% Skale $0.02124535-3.78% Smooth Love Potion $0.00209893-2.37% Nervos Network $0.00236868-0.30% Civic $0.07752467-3.20% Numeraire $12.39-6.01% Spell Token $0.00052230-1.73% Syscoin $0.09959409-3.08% Ren $0.06575595-7.89% Request $0.08483693-2.84% Fetch.ai $0.09483726-3.19% Vulcan Forged PYR $2.70-3.82% COTI $0.05766598-2.05% WazirX $0.13728860-2.12% Bancor $0.32879340-2.41% MOBOX $0.37006531-3.30% Chromia $0.10451528-2.87% Steem $0.14561435-4.49% NKN $0.08283840-1.59% Augur $4.75-2.38% Joe $0.13884805-5.11% XYO Network $0.00370000+2.21% Sun Token $0.00507250-0.78% Verge $0.00270803-4.23% Ampleforth Governance $2.81-1.74% Orchid $0.06961660-2.79% Keep Network $0.07385550-0.54% Alchemy Pay $0.00781277-2.78% Alpaca Finance $0.24723437-0.25% Moonriver $6.66-2.74% Storj $0.25045401-2.89% Serum $0.13178613-7.57% Stormx $0.00366259-7.00% Polkastarter $0.33754140-2.44% Yield Guild Games $0.15921492-4.49% Index Chain $0.03721053-3.28% Enzyme $16.02-15.31% CLV $0.05169791-3.78% Quickswap $45.68-2.68% Raydium $0.14450266-1.09% Harvest Finance $29.55-0.07% Mirror Protocol $0.11659260-15.69% Samoyedcoin $0.00295895-15.92% SuperRare $0.10255521-14.93% Kyber Network $0.49978480-4.03% JasmyCoin $0.00282120-6.75% district0x $0.01774339+3.43% Quantstamp $0.01190000+1.54% Star Atlas DAO $0.34135068-2.88% SingularDTV $0.000402100.00% Tether $0.99925874-0.03% USD Coin $0.99956034+0.02% Dai $0.99956677+0.00% PlayIconNav Crypto Prices CoinDesk Market Index Opinion Why Solana Was Decimated by Bankman-Fried's Downfall The blockchain heavily tied to the disgraced founder of FTX has been badly wounded by his unmasking. Here are the headwinds facing the formerly hot project and its SOL token. By David Z. Morris AccessTimeIconDec 28, 2022 at 5:45 p.m. UTCUpdated Dec 28, 2022 at 7:57 p.m. UTC By David Z. Morris AccessTimeIconDec 28, 2022 at 5:45 p.m. UTCUpdated Dec 28, 2022 at 7:57 p.m. UTC Consensus 2023 Logo Join the most important conversation in crypto and Web3 taking place in Austin, Texas, April 26-28. Secure Your Seat CoinDesk - Unknown David Z. Morris David Z. Morris is CoinDesk's Chief Insights Columnist. He holds Bitcoin, Ethereum, and small amounts of other crypto assets. Follow @davidzmorris on Twitter Consensus 2023 Logo Join the most important conversation in crypto and Web3 taking place in Austin, Texas, April 26-28. Secure Your Seat Debate has accelerated in recent days over the future prospects of Solana, a layer 1 smart-contract blockchain that in some respects competes with Ethereum. The chain grew rapidly and saw immense hype during the 2020-2021 bull market, particularly from venture capitalists. But the recent departure of major projects to other chains and a massive drop in total value on the Solana chain have raised questions about its future prospects. Lingering technological challenges are a common worry cited by doubters. Competition from Ethereum layer 2s represent a growing threat to Solana's core premise of faster and lower-cost transactions. But the biggest cloud shading Solana's sunshine is the fall of Sam Bankman-Fried, founder of the FTX exchange and hedge fund Alameda Research. David Z. Morris is CoinDesk's chief insights columnist. Bankman-Fried was perhaps the single most prominent backer of Solana, and skeptics could reasonably argue that the price appreciation of the SOL token and related assets from 2020-2021 was driven at least in part by Bankman-Fried's market interventions and advocacy. The consequences of growing Solana skepticism have been dire, based purely on numbers. From a peak price of $258.78 on Nov. 6, 2021, Solana's SOL token has declined to just over $10. That's a drop of 96%, vastly sharper than the drawdowns from the peaks for BTC (-74.5%) and ETH (-74.6%). It's even a sharper drop, incredibly, than dogecoin (DOGE) has seen in the bear market - the meme coin is down a mere 76% from its October 2021 peak. From its position as the fifth-most valuable crypto token in early November, Solana's SOL token has dropped to 19th place, according to data from CoinGecko. See also: Solana DeFi Project Mercurial to Relaunch, Replace Token The total value of tokens staked in decentralized-finance (DeFi) protocols on Solana has declined even more dramatically, from nearly $10.2 billion on Nov. 9, 2021 to under $210 million at press time - a decline of nearly 98%. Solana is now only the 12th-largest DeFi chain by total value locked or TVL, trailing not only Ethereum layer 2s like Polygon and Optimism, but also far more obscure projects like Cronos and DefiChain. 'Samcoins' The single sharpest percentage drop in Solana's metrics came in early November following the collapse of FTX, and mounting evidence of massive fraud by Sam Bankman-Fried. It now seems increasingly likely that some of Bankman-Fried's extensive support for the chain was funded via FTX's wholesale theft of customer funds. Former Alameda executives including CEO Caroline Ellison, moreover, have claimed in recent statements to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission that Bankman-Fried encouraged market manipulation of FTX's FTT token. Given that, it seems improbable that Bankman-Fried wasn't also manipulating the price of Solana-based projects he helped launch , controlled large stakes in and used in the accounting and loan fraud that formed the core of the FTX swindle. Those related projects, including the Serum decentralized exchange and the self-described DeFi brokerage Oxygen, are sometimes derisively referred to as "Samcoins." They have seen catastrophic declines in their own token prices, and Serum was rendered "defunct" by the collapse of FTX, necessitating a community fork. Market manipulation via Alameda would have effectively been funded by the clandestine redirection of FTX customer funds from other assets, such as bitcoin and ether, toward the trading of SOL or other ecosystem tokens. Alameda's market-making and trading activities as a whole appear in retrospect to have been wildly unprofitable. Some critics have argued that their SOL activity would have amounted to propping up the value of Solana, while artificially holding down the price of blue chips like ETH and BTC. This chaos has led to hints of something like a death spiral as developers and projects depart the struggling chain. Most dramatically, the DeGods and Y00ts NFT (non-fungible token) projects were confirmed to be leaving Solana for Ethereum and Polygon, respectively. In November, stablecoin issuer Tether swapped $1 billion of USDT from Solana to Ethereum. Lingering issues All this comes on top of worries that predated the collapse of FTX. Solana has experienced repeated chain halts since its inception, often caused by "botting" or other forms of spam overwhelming the network. This is inextricably linked to Solana's core value proposition as a faster, cheaper layer 1 than Ethereum: For a blockchain, lower transaction costs and higher speed often come as a trade-off for security and stability. See also: Is Solana Leading Crypto Into Retail or Trailing Apple? | Opinion Moreover, that value proposition may itself be less compelling than it was when Solana launched in March 2020. The years since have seen significant growth in "layer 2" products on Ethereum that offer faster and less expensive transactions, but gain the benefit of Ethereum's security, mostly through the use of "rollup" technology. Those new competitors include Optimism, a layer 2 that launched in December 2021 and now has more than twice as much value locked as Solana. These are serious headwinds, and commentators across the crypto industry have been debating the chain's prospects in recent days. In a best-case scenario, Solana's remaining builders face a long road back to ecosystem health and relevance. The big question is whether there are enough of them, with enough conviction, to go the distance. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Read more about SolanaSOLSam Bankman-FriedFTXOpinion Consensus Magazine LogoJoin The Most Influential Conversation in Crypto and Web3!Secure Your Seat Issue Week Issue 17Most Influential 2022Explore This Issue --------------------------------------------------------------------- More from Consensus Magazine --------------------------------------------------------------------- Consensus Magazine CoinDesk Holiday Crossword CoinDesk Staff Dec 13, 2022 (CoinDesk) Consensus Magazine Birth of the Network Nations Jeff Wilser Dec 12, 2022 CDCROP: Gears on a globe in shape of Europe and Africa (Getty Images) Consensus Magazine CoinDesk Got Colorful With the Most Influential 2022 NFT Collection Sam Ewen Dec 5, 2022 CDCrop MI2022 NFT 14 (Kevin Ross/CoinDesk) Consensus Magazine Cryptocurrencies: A Necessary Scam? Matt Stoller Dec 13, 2022 CDCROP: Crypto Currency - nest egg (Douglas Rissing/Getty Images) Consensus Magazine Crypto 2023: It's Sanctions Season Anna Baydakova Dec 12, 2022 CDCROP: Bitcoin, 100 dollars, Russian Flag (Getty Images) Consensus Magazine Japan Was the Safest Place to Be an FTX Customer JP Koning Dec 13, 2022 (Su San Lee/Unsplash) Consensus Magazine Miladys NFT Community Is the Counterculture to Cancel Culture Marc Hochstein Dec 5, 2022 CDCrop Miladys MI2022 (Will Ess for Pixelmind.ai/CoinDesk) Consensus Magazine Blending the World's Most Successful Loyalty Program With Web3 Xinyi Luo Dec 5, 2022 CDCrop Adam Brotman MI2022 (Will Ess for Pixelmind.ai/CoinDesk) Consensus Magazine LogoJoin The Most Influential Conversation in Crypto and Web3!Secure Your Seat --------------------------------------------------------------------- Logo of BTCBTC$16,490.08 1.16% Logo of ETHETH$1,184.51 2.24% Logo of BNBBNB$242.82 1.26% Logo of XRPXRP$0.35796445 3.82% Logo of BUSDBUSD$0.99985654 0.01% --------------------------------------------------------------------- View All Prices --------------------------------------------------------------------- Sign up for Crypto Markets Today, our daily newsletter explaining what happened today in crypto markets - and why. Email address[ ] Sign Up By signing up, you will receive emails about CoinDesk product updates, events and marketing and you agree to our terms of services and privacy policy. DISCLOSURE Please note that our privacy policy, terms of use, cookies, and do not sell my personal information has been updated. The leader in news and information on cryptocurrency, digital assets and the future of money, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups. As part of their compensation, certain CoinDesk employees, including editorial employees, may receive exposure to DCG equity in the form of stock appreciation rights, which vest over a multi-year period. CoinDesk journalists are not allowed to purchase stock outright in DCG. CoinDesk - Unknown David Z. Morris David Z. Morris is CoinDesk's Chief Insights Columnist. He holds Bitcoin, Ethereum, and small amounts of other crypto assets. Follow @davidzmorris on Twitter CoinDesk - Unknown David Z. Morris David Z. Morris is CoinDesk's Chief Insights Columnist. He holds Bitcoin, Ethereum, and small amounts of other crypto assets. Follow @davidzmorris on Twitter --------------------------------------------------------------------- Logo of BTCBTC$16,490.08 1.16% Logo of ETHETH$1,184.51 2.24% Logo of BNBBNB$242.82 1.26% Logo of XRPXRP$0.35796445 3.82% Logo of BUSDBUSD$0.99985654 0.01% --------------------------------------------------------------------- View All Prices Trending 1 china computer flag Web3 China to Launch First National 'Digital Asset' Marketplace Dec 28, 2022 2 CDCROP: The HASH Podcast Graphic CoinDesk Podcast Network MicroStrategy's Bitcoin Bet; Pudgy Penguins NFTs Break All-Time Highs With Holiday Rally Dec 28, 2022 3 CDCROP: Polynetwork Hacker (Adam Levine/CoinDesk) Tech Anonymous Twitter User Leaks 3Commas API Database Dec 28, 2022 4 CoinDesk - Unknown Business Digital Dollar Will Come Eventually, Lobbyist Says Dec 28, 2022 Coindesk Logo About AboutMastheadContributorsCareersCompany News Stay Updated ConsensusNewslettersFollow Get In Touch Contact UsAdvertiseAccessibility HelpSitemap The Fine Print Ethics PolicyPrivacyTerms Of UseDo Not Sell My Personal Information --------------------------------------------------------------------- Please note that our privacy policy, terms of use, cookies, and do not sell my personal information has been updated. The leader in news and information on cryptocurrency, digital assets and the future of money, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups. As part of their compensation, certain CoinDesk employees, including editorial employees, may receive exposure to DCG equity in the form of stock appreciation rights, which vest over a multi-year period. CoinDesk journalists are not allowed to purchase stock outright in DCG. (c)2022 CoinDesk EnglishMenuUpIcon TikTokIcon