https://www.wired.com/story/the-extraordinary-shelf-life-of-the-deep-sea-sandwiches/ Skip to main content Open Navigation Menu To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Close Alert WIRED The Extraordinary Shelf Life of the Deep Sea Sandwiches * Backchannel * Business * Culture * Gear * Ideas * Science * Security More To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Close Alert Sign In Search * Backchannel * Business * Culture * Gear * Ideas * Science * Security * Podcasts * Video * Artificial Intelligence * Climate * Games * Newsletters * Magazine * Events * Wired Insider * Jobs * Coupons Gregory Barber Science Dec 8, 2022 7:00 AM The Extraordinary Shelf Life of the Deep Sea Sandwiches How did a lunch last underwater for 10 months? The answer relates to how carbon moves in the deep sea, and has implications for fighting climate change. * * * * To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories . Bologna Sandwich Photograph: Lauri Patterson/Getty Images * * * * To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories . In the late 1960s, a submersible named Alvin suffered a mishap off the coast of Martha's Vineyard. The bulbous white vessel, holding a crew of three, was being lowered for a dive when a cable snapped. Suddenly, Alvin was sinking. The scientists clambered out, shocked and a little bruised, as the vessel plunged, hatch ajar, eventually settling in the seabed some 4,500 feet below. Alvin was in a slightly embarrassing situation. Though the sub was only a few years old, it had an eclectic resume that included, in 1966, helping to recover a 70-kiloton hydrogen bomb that was dropped when two military planes collided over the Spanish coast. Now it was the one that needed saving. Ten months later, Alvin was pulled from the depths--a blip in the life of a vessel that makes dives to this day (though a steady replacement of parts means none of the original sub remains). But the accident left behind its own legacy in the form of a mysteriously preserved lunch. In their frantic escape, the crew had left behind six sandwiches, two thermoses filled with bouillon, and a handful of apples. After retrieving Alvin, researchers from the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution marveled at the state of this waterlogged feast. The apples looked slightly pickled by the briny water, but otherwise intact. The sandwiches smelled fresh, and the bologna (this being 1968) was still pink. They even still tasted good, the researchers confirmed upon taking a few bites. Similarly, although the thermoses had been crushed by the water pressure, the soup, once warmed up, was deemed "perfectly palatable." Those observations were published in the journal Science in 1971, after the surprised scientists raced to study the meal before it spoiled--which it did, within a few weeks under refrigeration. In addition to nibbling the bologna, the researchers measured the chemical properties of the food and the activity of the microbes gathered on it. Eventually, they concluded that the spoilage had been happening at 1 percent of the rate it would have at the surface, controlling for temperature. The question--one that has vexed researchers for decades--was why. In the 1960s, researchers had little experience in the cold, highly pressurized deep ocean, but they expected it to be filled with microbes ready to break down organic matter, even in extreme conditions. Perhaps there were fewer of those microbes than they thought, or not the right kinds. Or maybe not enough oxygen. Or it was just too cold or too pressurized. The answer was difficult to pin down. Over time, the question at the heart of the preserved-lunch mystery has become more urgent as scientists have come to understand the role that the oceans play in sequestering carbon. Around a third of the carbon people have put into the air has been sucked back out of it by the oceans--and much of it is thought to be stored in the deepest pools of water. So an accurate picture of how much carbon goes in and how much escapes back into the air is important. It's especially important if you want to manipulate that process, as some do, by doing things like growing seaweed--which removes carbon from the air through photosynthesis to build its tendrils--and then sinking it into deep ocean trenches to store that carbon away. In large part, the difficulty for researchers studying deep water carbon is that conditions at the seafloor are hard to replicate at sea level. Typically, researchers pull water up to the deck of a research vessel where they have equipment that can measure microbial activity. But this has resulted in a mismatch, says Gerhard Herndl, a bio-oceanographer at the University of Vienna. Aboard a ship, microbes are generally happy to chomp down on the nutrients available to them. Their appetite is so great, in fact, that it doesn't make much sense, because it is far greater than the nutrients found in the deep ocean can provide. "When you do these measurements at the surface, there is always a gap," he says. So instead, following the long legacy of the Alvin sandwiches, Herndl's team tried a new experiment. By sending autonomous instruments to incubate microbes where they actually live, they quickly found that microbes in the depths were far less happy and hungry. The differentiating factor, they wrote in a study recently published in Nature Geoscience, was pressure. Some organisms like being under extreme pressure--they're what's known as piezophilic--and happily metabolize material in the deep. But they represent a small slice of the microbial communities Herndl studied--about 10 percent. The rest were ill-adapted; chances are they were suited to some other, shallower environment and had floated their way down. Most Popular * blurred image of woman ideas 'Magic Avatar' App Lensa Generated Nudes From My Childhood Photos Olivia Snow * [undefined] gear 20 Viral TikTok Gifts That Are Actually Worth It Brenda Stolyar * Aerial drone view of a high voltage electrical power substation. security Attackers Keep Targeting the US Electric Grid Andy Greenberg * A face-tuned, smoothed-out version of a blonded painted woman with hair swirling around security What You Should Know Before Using the Lensa AI App Reece Rogers * In a rare opportunity, Herndl's team repeated these experiments around the world, taking samples from a global conveyor belt of nutrient-rich water (which includes the Gulf Stream) that connects the world's ocean basins and takes more than a thousand years to wrap its way around. They had the benefit of time, Herndl says, on voyages that were just for deep-sea scientists--with no pesky shallow water, algae-studying scientists getting impatient while they performed experiments 4,000 meters down and spent hours pulling water from the depths. The result of those newer methods is data that shows a major gap in prior studies, says Hilary Close, an oceanographer at the University of Miami who wasn't involved in the study. "It turns out that those past measurements were flawed," she says. In the deep, pressure is holding the microbes back. There are many other factors that control how that material breaks down. One is that much of the carbon down in the deep is old--tens of thousands of years old, according to research at Woods Hole. Over time, those carbon-based molecules have been oxidized and are no longer appetizing to the microbes down there. There's some newer and tastier material, but one theory is that the diversity of microbes slows down its degradation, because only some of these organisms are suited to breaking down certain molecules. Add to that the pressure constraints, and it doesn't get transformed back into carbon dioxide particularly fast. (It turns out many of the original hypotheses about the Alvin lunch were at least partially correct.) Altogether, that might look good for efforts to deliberately sink carbon in the deep. Essentially, if the lunch (or seaweed, or any other biomass) gets broken down by microbes that respire, like people do, then the carbon is more likely to escape back into the atmosphere as a gas. But if they snub the sandwiches, that's good, right? The biomass stays where it is. Herndl once believed that his research was making that case. But now he's skeptical of deliberate sinking. There are too many complexities to introducing a bunch of biomass into the sea, he says. If someone suddenly dumps in a pile of seaweed or the carcass of a dead whale, chances are they'll still stimulate an unusual flurry of microbe activity. There are a few reasons why. One is that the biomass--say, the whale carcass--may already have a bunch of microbes it picked up in shallower water riding along with it. They'll be slowed down by the extreme conditions, but they'll still be there, and hungry. Or maybe the carcass will get broken down before it sinks deep enough for the carbon to really get trapped by the pressure of the water above. Or maybe it depends on where the whale falls to the seafloor, and the exact makeup of the community of critters looking for a meal there. It's nuanced, and highly specific, says Close, and not particularly well understood. "We need to know what controls the metabolic rates of microbes in the deep ocean," she says. "What exact kind of organic matter are they receiving, and are they adapted to degrade that type of organic matter?" Plus, while the processing of nutrients may be slow in deep open water, portions of the seafloor are comparatively teeming with life. Herndl points to observations of whale carcasses on the seafloor. "They're degraded surprisingly quickly," he says. "This will also happen if you dump seaweed. So I'm really skeptical of these geoengineering ideas." That skepticism was also present in the 1970s, when the Woods Hole researchers examined the lunches abandoned aboard Alvin. Back then, talk of a different form of geoengineering was making the rounds: fertilizing the ocean by sinking large amounts of organic waste, which would perhaps support the food chain and rebuild fish populations. At the time, the researchers saw the preserved lunch as a cautionary tale--a reminder that the deep ocean remains mysterious and surprising, a place of chemical and biological processes that we do not fully understand. Even as some mysteries are solved, that remains very much true. More Great WIRED Stories * The latest on tech, science, and more: Get our newsletters! * We're in denial about the cost of a Twitter implosion * Android phone makers' encryption keys stolen * Ditch your USB-A dongle and embrace the USB-C life * Pliocene-like monsoons return to the Southwest US * Max Levchin's war on credit cards * [?] Explore AI like never before with our new database * Upgrade your work game with our Gear team's favorite laptops, keyboards, typing alternatives, and noise-canceling headphones [undefined] Gregory Barber is a staff writer at WIRED covering energy and the environment. He graduated from Columbia University with a bachelor's degree in computer science and English literature and now lives in San Francisco. Staff Writer * Topicsoceansmarine scienceclimate changeclimatecarboncarbon dioxide BiologyEcology More from WIRED An illustration of a solar storm in space Here Comes the Sun--to End Civilization Every so often, our star fires off a plasma bomb in a random direction. Our best hope the next time Earth is in the crosshairs? Capacitors. Matt Ribel Image may contain: Construction Crane Gravity Could Solve Clean Energy's One Major Drawback Finding green energy when the winds are calm and the skies are cloudy has been a challenge. Storing it in giant concrete blocks could be the answer. Matt Reynolds aerial of damaged homes are seen in a mobile home park in Ashland that was destroyed by wildfire As Climate Fears Mount, Some Are Relocating Within the US A small but growing number of Americans are moving to New England or the Appalachian Mountains, which are seen as safe havens from climate change. Jon Hurdle hand over heater Could Being Cold Actually Be Good for You? Researchers are exploring the health benefits of literally chilling out. Max G. Levy Jacques Vallee Jacques Vallee Still Doesn't Know What UFOs Are After six globe-trotting decades spent probing "the phenomenon," the French information scientist is sure of only one thing: The truth is really, really out there. Chantel Tattoli A collage with an image of people in PPE, and art by Jenny Sharaf Covid Will Become Endemic. The World Must Decide What That Means The task of 2022 will be figuring out how much action we're willing to take and how much disease and death we'll tolerate. Maryn McKenna Coloured transmission electron micrograph of an oligodendrocyte sending a cell process to a myelinated nerve fiber The Secrets of Covid 'Brain Fog' Are Starting to Lift Scientists are getting closer to understanding the neurology behind the memory problems and cognitive fuzziness that an infection can trigger. Maggie Chen space elevator in foundation What Happens If a Space Elevator Breaks These structures are a sci-fi solution to the problem of getting objects into orbit without a rocket--but you don't want to be under one if the cable snaps. Rhett Allain WIRED WIRED is where tomorrow is realized. It is the essential source of information and ideas that make sense of a world in constant transformation. The WIRED conversation illuminates how technology is changing every aspect of our lives--from culture to business, science to design. The breakthroughs and innovations that we uncover lead to new ways of thinking, new connections, and new industries. * * * * * * More From WIRED * Subscribe * Newsletters * FAQ * Wired Staff * Press Center * Coupons * Editorial Standards * Black Friday Contact * Advertise * Contact Us * Customer Care * Jobs * RSS * Accessibility Help * Conde Nast Store * Conde Nast Spotlight * Do Not Sell My Personal Info (c) 2022 Conde Nast. All rights reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights. WIRED may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Conde Nast. Ad Choices Select international siteUnited States * UK * Italia * Japon