https://www.bicycling.com/culture/a29802208/helmet-laws-safety/ Search --------------------------------------------------------------------- * Subscribe * Shop + Editor Picks + Sale * 2022 Tour de France * Bikes and Gear + Bike Reviews + Electric Bikes + Road Bikes + Gravel Bikes + Fat Bikes + Gift Guide * Mountain Bikes * Culture + Essays and Long Reads + Women's Cycling * Skills & Tips * Training + Indoor Cycling + Beginner Cycling + Strength Training + Training Plans * Health & Nutrition * News * Racing * Repair * Rides * Newsletter * Follow + Facebook + Twitter + Pinterest + Instagram + Youtube * United States + US + Nederland * Do Not Sell My Personal Information Privacy NoticeTerms Of Use Skip to Content * Bikes & Gear * Health & Nutrition * Training * Repair * Exclusives Subscribe sign in 1. Culture 2. Cycling Gear 3. Mandatory Helmet Laws Make Cyclists Less Safe Turns Out, Mandatory Helmet Laws Make Cyclists Less Safe Requiring all riders to wear a helmet has proven negative effects. By Thomas DeVitoPublished: Oct 5, 2022 bike helmet laws Halfpoint//Getty Images If you're just tuning in, the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) recommended last year that all 50 states adopt laws mandating bicycle helmet use for adults. There's a huge problem with that: It actually makes streets less safe for cyclists. I have worked for two organizations dedicated to keeping cyclists safe--Transportation Alternatives and Families for Safe Streets--and we directly oppose these laws. According to the Governors Highway Safety Association, 21 states, the District of Columbia and the Northern Mariana Islands have a helmet law for bicyclists below a certain age, generally about 16. Of course, we encourage riders to wear helmets and take safety precautions while cycling. But when cities mandate and enforce helmet usage, evidence suggests a series of negative consequences to riders and ridership. Related Story * couple using rental bikes in the small town sausalito8 Ways to Demand Safer Streets for Bikes We have seen over and over again that the following outcomes result from even the best-intentioned mandatory helmet laws: * A reduction in the number of cyclists on streets; * Financial struggle for popular bike sharing systems; and * More exposure among vulnerable populations to unnecessary interactions with police. When the Australian cities of Melbourne and Brisbane mandated helmet use, it actually made streets less safe for cyclists. The number of people riding bikes dropped precipitously, which reduced the "Safety in Numbers" effect. Safety in Numbers is a straightforward concept: More people on bikes creates safer conditions on our streets. The National Association of City Transportation Officials (NACTO), which represents professional planners from 81 cities from around the United States, pointed this out in their own pushback on NTSB's recommendations. Related Story * New York City's 18th Bicycle-Traffic Fatality Of 2019 Prompts New Safety PlansNTSB: It's Up to Cyclists to Stop Getting Hit As far as killing bike share systems, look no further than Seattle, Washington. After they implemented similar policies, their bike share system floundered. The same has been seen in cities across Australia. Lastly, we know these "quality of life" laws are disproportionately enforced in communities of color and in lower income communities. In Austin and Dallas, Texas, for example, mandatory helmet laws were either repealed or changed after disturbing racial disparities became evident based on who was ticketed for not wearing a helmet. In Tampa, Florida, nearly 80 percent of bicycling-related citations issued by police during a three-year period were to African-Americans, even though African-Americans made up only 25 percent of the population. And in New York City, racial disparities in criminal summonses for bicycling-related offenses led The Village Voice to describe them as "the new stop-and-frisk" in 2014. As advocates for safe streets, Transportation Alternatives and Families for Safe Streets continue to encourage voluntary helmet usage and allow data and experience to be our guide when it comes to mandatory adult helmet laws. Right now, with nearly 40,000 people killed on American roads every year, that means we need to keep our leaders' attention focused on structural reforms like complete street redesigns, which are proven to make our public spaces safe for everybody, whether they are walking, biking, taking transit, and yes, driving too. The unfortunate truth is mandatory helmet laws simply don't lead to their purported goal, which is to make streets safer. In fact, and perhaps counter-intuitively for many of us, the opposite remains the case across a growing number of cities around the world. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Thomas DeVito was formerly the Senior Director of Advocacy at Transportation Alternatives. He promotes people-oriented cities through grassroots activism and practical research. This content is imported from OpenWeb. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site. Cycling Gear zwift hub The 7 Best Indoor Bike Trainers for $500 or Less best cold weather cycling gear The Best Winter Cycling Gear of 2022 prime day multitool Save 27% on a Great Multitool This Fall Prime Day pump testing The Best Bike Pumps of 2022 Advertisement - Continue Reading Below apple watch series 8 review Apple Watch Series 8 Review best cycling gloves 9 Great Gloves for Riding in Cold Weather best rain gear for biking The Best Rain Gear for Cyclists young boy on a bike riding around a corner of a brick building How to Choose a Kids' Bike bets bike chains The 10 Best Bike Chains best knee warmers The Best Knee Warmers for Cold-Weather Cycling best bike brake cable kits The Best Brake Cable Kits for DIY Maintenance light testing The 13 Best Bike Lights for Every Kind of Ride Advertisement - Continue Reading Below NewsletterPress RoomGive A GiftAbout BicyclingSubscribeWriter GuidelinesCustomer ServiceCommunity GuidelinesAdvertise OnlineOther Hearst SubscriptionsHearst Men's and Enthusiast Media Group - A Part of Hearst Digital Media A Part of Hearst Digital Media Gear-obsessed editors choose every product we review. We may earn commission if you buy from a link. (c)Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Notice/Notice at CollectionYour California Privacy Rights Interest-Based AdsTerms of UseSite Map Do Not Sell My Personal Information