https://irreal.org/blog/?p=10864 Irreal The minds had long ago come up with a proper name for it; they called it the Irreal, but they thought of it as Infinite Fun. That was what they really knew it as. The Land of Infinite Fun. -Iain M. Banks, Excession [sunset] Skip to content * Home * About - Volume 4B Red Meat Friday: Is The FSF Fighting The Previous War? Posted on 2022-10-07 by jcs This is a bit genuine red meat and perhaps a little sensitive for some people but it does raise a point that deserves discussion. A shorthand for that point is the title of today's post. A more descriptive way of describing it is, "Is the FSF's demand for purity actually harming the users they're striving to protect?" Some people obviously think so: that's why we have the OSS movement. I don't know anyone who doubts the goodwill or sincerity of RMS and the FSF. I certainly don't. But it's still worth asking if the policies they're pursuing are helping or harming the goal to which they're devoted. Ash, over at gay robot noises, has a post that explores how she thinks RMS and his insistance on purity are hurting the Free Software movement. She, as do I, has tremendous respect for Stallman but worries, as the title suggests, that he's fighting a war that's no longer going on. I disagree with her conclusion that the FSF has lost the battle. I believe that while they haven't won it, they certainly haven't lost it either. Take a look at her post and see what you think. Ariadne Conill makes a similar case for hardware. She says that strict adherence to the FSF's Respects Your Freedom program means that you'll be using only obsolete and probably broken hardware. No one but a Free Software Aesthete is going to do that so the FSF is crippling their crusade for free hardware. I have my own data point in this discussion. Back in May, there was a long thread on Emacs-Devel about removing ns-do-applescript from the Next Step branch. The problem, according to the instigator, was that applescript runs only on macOS which is not a free operating system--although it does represent over 25% of Emacs users--and therefore ns-do-applescript should not be in Emacs. Notice that code was already there so the poster was proposing more work just because of a purity issue. When I objected on the grounds the code wasn't hurting anyone, was useful to Mac users, and that it didn't make any sense to make Mac users lives more difficult, I was told that the FSF was not interested in making Mac users lives easier. On the contrary they wanted to make it more difficult so those users would abandon macOS and move to Linux. I'll let you draw your own conclusions. If you're particularly masochistic, here's the start of the thread on Emacs-Devel. I understand the FSF's insistence on "no inch given" but I do think that it may be time to explore how well that's working out. This entry was posted in General and tagged Emacs, RMF. Bookmark the permalink. - Volume 4B * Search for: [ ] [Search] * Recent Posts + Red Meat Friday: Is The FSF Fighting The Previous War? + Volume 4B + Emacs Debugging + A N00b's View of Emacs + Why You Shouldn't Be Using Chrome * Links + Useful Emacs Commands * Archives + October 2022 + September 2022 + August 2022 + July 2022 + June 2022 + May 2022 + April 2022 + March 2022 + February 2022 + January 2022 + December 2021 + November 2021 + October 2021 + September 2021 + August 2021 + July 2021 + June 2021 + May 2021 + April 2021 + March 2021 + February 2021 + January 2021 + December 2020 + November 2020 + October 2020 + September 2020 + August 2020 + July 2020 + June 2020 + May 2020 + April 2020 + March 2020 + February 2020 + January 2020 + December 2019 + November 2019 + October 2019 + September 2019 + August 2019 + July 2019 + June 2019 + May 2019 + April 2019 + March 2019 + February 2019 + January 2019 + December 2018 + November 2018 + October 2018 + September 2018 + August 2018 + July 2018 + June 2018 + May 2018 + April 2018 + March 2018 + February 2018 + January 2018 + December 2017 + November 2017 + October 2017 + September 2017 + August 2017 + July 2017 + June 2017 + May 2017 + April 2017 + March 2017 + February 2017 + January 2017 + December 2016 + November 2016 + October 2016 + September 2016 + August 2016 + July 2016 + June 2016 + May 2016 + April 2016 + March 2016 + February 2016 + January 2016 + December 2015 + November 2015 + October 2015 + September 2015 + August 2015 + July 2015 + June 2015 + May 2015 + April 2015 + March 2015 + February 2015 + January 2015 + December 2014 + November 2014 + October 2014 + September 2014 + August 2014 + July 2014 + June 2014 + May 2014 + April 2014 + March 2014 + February 2014 + January 2014 + December 2013 + November 2013 + October 2013 + September 2013 + August 2013 + July 2013 + June 2013 + May 2013 + April 2013 + March 2013 + February 2013 + January 2013 + December 2012 + November 2012 + October 2012 + September 2012 + August 2012 + July 2012 + June 2012 + May 2012 + April 2012 + March 2012 + February 2012 + January 2012 + December 2011 + November 2011 + October 2011 + September 2011 + August 2011 + July 2011 + June 2011 + May 2011 + April 2011 * Categories + Administrivia + Blogging + General + Programming * Meta + Log in + Entries feed + Comments feed + WordPress.org Irreal Proudly powered by WordPress.