https://www.wired.com/story/bots-online-advertising/ Skip to main content Open Navigation Menu To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Close Alert WIRED How Bots Corrupted Advertising * Backchannel * Business * Culture * Gear * Ideas * Science * Security More To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Close Alert Sign In Search * Backchannel * Business * Culture * Gear * Ideas * Science * Security * Podcasts * Video * Artificial Intelligence * Climate * Games * Newsletters * Magazine * Events * Wired Insider * Coupons Image may contain Logo Symbol Trademark Text and Word * Not All Bots Are Bad * The Botnet That Fooled Facebook * The Hole in Elon Musk's Twitter Standoff * I, Pro-Bot * The Search for Twitter's Spam Squad * How Bots Corrupted Advertising * Can You Spot the Bot? * They're Hot. They're Bots * The Trouble With Mental Health Chatbots * Subscribe to WIRED Morgan Meaker Business Sep 29, 2022 11:17 AM How Bots Corrupted Advertising Botmasters have created a Kafkaesque system where companies are paying huge sums to show their ads to bots. And everyone is fine with this. * * * * To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories . An illustration of robots holding up a sign that reads buy more new stuff ILLUSTRATION: ABBR. PROJECT * * * * To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories . Bots Run the Internet They're a scourge! They're a boon. They're the automated worker bees of cyberspace--and they influence everything you do online. * A group of devil robots crowd around an angel robot Not All Bots Are Bad * The Vietnam flag with bots surrounding it The Botnet That Fooled Facebook * A barometer measuring whether a Twitter account is a bot or human. The Hole in Elon Musk's Twitter Standoff * Elon Musk's head on an altar with candles and a bot holding up a heart I, Pro-Bot * A group of bots holding up a Twitter bird. The Search for Twitter's Spam Squad * An illustration of robots holding up a sign that reads buy more new stuff How Bots Corrupted Advertising Now Reading * An illustration of a bot next to a human. Can You Spot the Bot? * An illustration by ABBR. PROJECT of robots on the Hinge app They're Hot. They're Bots * An illustration of robots surrounding a goblet. The Trouble With Mental Health Chatbots * Image may contain Pattern Text and Symbol Subscribe to WIRED When Aleksandr Zhukov went on trial last year, he stood accused of defrauding US companies, including The New York Times and pet care brand Purina, out of millions of dollars. According to the court, the then 41-year-old set up a company that promised to show online adverts to humans, but he instead placed those adverts on an elaborate network of fake websites where they were seen only by bots. Yet Zhukov's defense did not center around his innocence or his remorse. Rather, he said he was giving the online economy exactly what it wanted: cheap traffic, whatever the source. "There was nothing to conceal," he said on the stand in May 2021. "We were making business. We are not making scam or fraud." Content This content can also be viewed on the site it originates from. The federal courthouse in Brooklyn disagreed and, in November 2021, Zhukov was sentenced to 10 years in prison. By extraditing the Russian cybercriminal from Bulgaria, the US justice system sent a message that this type of crime has consequences. Yet Zhukov's testimony hints at an uncomfortable truth: The online economy is willing to look the other way while bots distort it and line the pockets of cybercriminals. The Elon Musk v. Twitter trial is set to resurrect such concerns. Musk, who claims that Twitter has undercounted millions of fake accounts on its platform, was handed extra ammunition when Twitter's former head of security Peiter Zatko, known as Mudge, turned whistleblower in August. Mudge claimed that executives' bonuses were tied to increases in daily users, meaning they had no incentive to crack down on bots--an allegation Twitter's CEO, Parag Agrawal, has denied. Bots are polluting the internet. Fake online users make up as much as 40 percent of all web traffic, according to some estimates. Researchers specializing in advertising fraud describe a Kafkaesque system where businesses pay millions to advertise to bots and research their "opinions." Yet the digital advertising industry has grown so accustomed to working with inflated numbers that few are willing to unmask the fake clicks powering large swathes of the online economy. In June, the Association of National Advertisers (ANA), a US industry group, published a blog post that estimated that ad fraud is costing US advertisers $120 billion each year. Hours after it was published, those statements were removed. John Wolfe, the ANA's director of communications, tells WIRED that the figures were removed because they were out of date, but declines to provide any new figures. Most Popular * Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra smartphone resting on a white table on orange backdrop gear 19 Android Settings You May Not Know About David Nield * [undefined] gear Give Your Back a Break With Our Favorite Office Chairs Julian Chokkattu * An illustration by ABBR. PROJECT of robots on the Hinge app business I Uncovered an Army of Fake Men on Hinge Lauren Goode * Stripy mesh weaving cubes seamless pattern security Microsoft Exchange Server Has a Zero-Day Problem Lily Hay Newman * Zhukov's trial established how the trade in fake clicks works. Between 2014 and 2016, the so-called King of Fraud--a name he gave himself in a text message, revealed in court--ran an advertising network called Media Methane, which received payments from other advertising networks in return for placing brand's adverts on websites. But the company did not place those adverts on real websites. Instead it created fake ones, spoofing more than 6,000 domains. It then rented 2,000 computer servers in Texas and Amsterdam and programmed them to simulate the way a human would act on a website--using a fake mouse to scroll the fake website and falsely appearing to be signed in to Facebook. "As a result of this elaborate scheme, the defendant falsified billions of ad views and caused businesses to pay more than $7 million for ads that were never actually viewed by real human internet users," the Department of Justice said. Although The New York Times was named as a "victim" by the Justice Department, the publication declined to clarify whether it paid for fake ad views or whether its website was spoofed by one of Zhukov's fake sites. Nestle, the parent company of Purina, did not respond to a request for comment. Some companies have taken matters into their own hands. In 2017 Uber sued one of its advertising agencies for charging it for ads that were not seen by real people or placed on real websites. The case started when Uber pulled all online advertising and discovered barely any drop in app installs or sales. Why? Some claim online ads target people who already plan on buying that product or service. Others argue that ads often target bots. But it's hard to get a straight answer. Companies paying for advertising have an incentive to play down the number of bots to conceal how much cash they're wasting. And cybersecurity companies have an incentive to exaggerate numbers to sell anti-bot products. The technology to detect and block bots already exists, says Sandy Carielli, a principal analyst specializing in cybersecurity at the consultancy firm Forrester. But companies can be unwilling to investigate traffic that, on-the-surface, makes their website look popular, she says. "Keep in mind if you cut off the bots and it turns out that a large amount of traffic on your site is generated by bots, that's going to influence your performance numbers." Advertising didn't always used to be like this. Augustine Fou, who has been a digital marketer for 25 years, says that in the past decade there's been an explosion in fake traffic. Fou believes the industry was corrupted around a decade ago, when a series of opaque middlemen entered the scene. "Prior to that, advertisers would buy ads from publishers like The New York Times," he says. But now it's typical for brands to approach a digital ad exchange--which facilitates the buying and selling of advertising from different ad networks--to place their adverts on huge numbers of websites and apps. And it is this part of the system that has become vulnerable to bots, claims Fou. Most Popular * Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra smartphone resting on a white table on orange backdrop gear 19 Android Settings You May Not Know About David Nield * [undefined] gear Give Your Back a Break With Our Favorite Office Chairs Julian Chokkattu * An illustration by ABBR. PROJECT of robots on the Hinge app business I Uncovered an Army of Fake Men on Hinge Lauren Goode * Stripy mesh weaving cubes seamless pattern security Microsoft Exchange Server Has a Zero-Day Problem Lily Hay Newman * "The exchanges have deliberately looked the other way when there are fraudulent sites and mobile apps that become part of that exchange," he claims. Google and Facebook are among the companies that run these exchanges alongside other listed US companies such as Pubmatic and Magnite. "The ad exchanges don't want to solve fraud because fraud generates so much volume," Fou claims. "And the exchanges essentially make more money when more volume passes through their platforms." None of the exchanges responded to requests for comment. And it's not just the exchanges seemingly dodging the fraud issue. Advertisers are also reluctant, says Fou. "It's too embarrassing for them to admit that they purchased fraudulent inventory." He cites one rare attempt to sue by Uber, after it discovered Austin-based advertising company Phunware was selling fake app installs using bots. "Most of the Uber app installations that Phunware claimed to have delivered were generated by a fraudulent process known as 'click flooding,' which reports a higher number of clicks than those occurring," Uber's law firm Reed Smith said after winning the fraud suit. "Many still think ad fraud is a victimless crime," says Fou. "After all, who cares if big brands waste their money showing ads to bots?" But the industry is letting ad dollars flow into the pockets of cybercriminals, he adds, who can then use it to fund other illicit activities. It's a major problem, he argues. "One that no one talks about, no one writes about, everyone thinks it's someone else's problem." Read next An illustration of a bot next to a human. Read next Bot Hunting Is All About the Vibes More Great WIRED Stories * The latest on tech, science, and more: Get our newsletters! * When the Big One hits Portland, cargo bikers will save you * The mystery of why some people don't get Covid * What modern humans can learn from ancient software * It'll take more than banning gas cars to save the planet * The tricky ethics of being a teacher on TikTok * [?] Explore AI like never before with our new database * Upgrade your work game with our Gear team's favorite laptops, keyboards, typing alternatives, and noise-canceling headphones Morgan Meaker is a senior writer at WIRED covering European business. Before that, she was a technology reporter at The Telegraph and also worked for Dutch magazine De Correspondent. In 2019 she won Technology Journalist of the Year at the Words by Women Awards. She was born in Scotland, lives... Read more Senior Writer * TopicsbotsAdvertisingCommerceBots Run the Internet More from WIRED Illustration of heads of women and men of color with no faces Dall-E 2 Creates Incredible Images--and Biased Ones You Don't See OpenAI's new system is adept at turning text into images. But researchers say it also reinforces stereotypes against women and people of color. Khari Johnson Adam Neumann speaking on stage during The New York Times DealBook Online Summit on November 9, 2021 in New York City Get Used to Startups Trying to Reinvent Housing WeWork's controversial cofounder Adam Neumann is not the only entrepreneur to see opportunity in the generation of Americans unable to buy homes. Arielle Pardes Bailey Yard, world's largest railroad classification yard, North Platte, Nebraska, USA A US Freight Rail Crisis Threatens More Supply-Chain Chaos Federal regulators and the White House have been scrambling to prevent poor service and a possible strike from jamming up a vital but often overlooked network. Caitlin Harrington Red lego toy bricks in the shape of a heart on a white background 'Date Me' Google Docs and the Hyper-Optimized Quest for Love Some people have ditched dating apps--and opted to bare their souls via a public, view-only link instead. Lauren Goode An illustration by ABBR. PROJECT of robots on the Hinge app I Uncovered an Army of Fake Men on Hinge They had gleaming teeth, perfect hair, and selfies with baby animals. But could they pass the Turing test? Lauren Goode Boise Idaho The Next Silicon Valley Will Be in the US Heartland Steve Case, founder of AOL, predicts the dominance of tech companies on the coasts will give way to a flourishing of startups from smaller cities. Steven Levy Vitalik Buterin What's Next for Ethereum After the Merge The blockchain project's cofounder Vitalik Buterin says its recent big upgrade lays a path for more technical changes, and greater adoption. Lauren Goode newspaper folds Facebook Freeloads Off Newspapers. This Plan Might Stop It The Journalism Competition and Protection Act would allow publishers to finally bargain with Meta and Google. Benjamin Wofford WIRED WIRED is where tomorrow is realized. It is the essential source of information and ideas that make sense of a world in constant transformation. The WIRED conversation illuminates how technology is changing every aspect of our lives--from culture to business, science to design. The breakthroughs and innovations that we uncover lead to new ways of thinking, new connections, and new industries. * * * * * * More From WIRED * Subscribe * Newsletters * FAQ * Wired Staff * Press Center * Coupons * Editorial Standards Contact * Advertise * Contact Us * Customer Care * Jobs * RSS * Site Map * Accessibility Help * Conde Nast Store * Conde Nast Spotlight * Do Not Sell My Personal Info (c) 2022 Conde Nast. All rights reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights. WIRED may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Conde Nast. Ad Choices Select international siteUnited States * UK * Italia * Japon