https://cogdogblog.com/2022/09/google-broke-cc-image-search/ CogDogBlog Alan Levine barks about and plays with stuff here * Obligatory About + Calling Card + Web Folio + Best in Show (Presentations) + Cool Tech * What the ....? + First Bark + Last 100 Barks + Blogged This Day + Quotes On Blogging + Colo.. Coloph... * Dog-a-Gories + Photography + Odyssey + TRU Ideas + WordPress + Feed WordPress 101 + Rants + ds106 Class Notes and Stuff + Slices * Sights + Calling Card + Barking Dog Photos + Flickring Since 2004 + Giphy-ing + Medium Writing * Made By Moi + Flickr CC Attribution Helper + Pechaflickr + Five Card Flickr Stories + Feed2JS + ds106 Assignment Bank WordPress Theme + Daily Blank WordPress Theme + MOOC Mocking o Make a MOOC + SPLOT + Webmaker stuff o ImageSeeking For Fantastic Visual Metaphors + Words With No English Translations + WordPress Search Bookmarklet * Random Bone * Twitter * Mastodon * flickr * GitHub * Instagram * YouTube On Blogging I try to create sympathy for my [blog readers], then turn the monsters loose. -- Stephen King Others Bark Back * cogdog on Google Broke Image Search for Creative Commons and Hardly Anyone Noticed/Cares * John on Google Broke Image Search for Creative Commons and Hardly Anyone Noticed/Cares * cogdog on Google Broke Image Search for Creative Commons and Hardly Anyone Noticed/Cares * Lorna Campbell on Google Broke Image Search for Creative Commons and Hardly Anyone Noticed/Cares * Sheila MacNeill on Google Broke Image Search for Creative Commons and Hardly Anyone Noticed/Cares * Kevin Hodgson on Hello, Blog * cogdog on A Juicy Associative Trail * Shane McQuillan on A Juicy Associative Trail * cogdog on Shaping Your WordPress Tech Simply By Changing the Front Door * Tom on Looking Back & Forward: What Bloghicans Do I'll Fill Your Inbox Get your regular dose of CogDogBlog via email! Leave This Blank:[ ]Leave This Blank Too: [ ]Do Not Change This:[http:// ] Your email: [Enter email address.] [Subscribe] [Unsubscribe] Typically we end up in your spam box, so check there... Buried Toys Buried Toys [Select Month ] Search... [ ] On Sharing, Rants Google Broke Image Search for Creative Commons and Hardly Anyone Noticed/Cares Profile Picture for cogdog cogdog on September 27, 2022September 28, 2022 Except me. As of one minute ago I confirmed what I noticed last Wednesday. According to the all seeing Google, on the entire world wide web there are but three Creative Commons licensed images of a dog. People have worried about enclosure of the commons, these seems to be a whole lot worse. Or maybe I am being overly dramatic [dog-cc-1280x510]How sad that there are only three photos of dogs licensed for Creative Commons Where Have all the Doors Gone? This all began with writing my last post where the title included the words "front door." As my atypical method goes, I look for the featured image before writing anything else. I always seek open licensed images, and while many people have different sources they use, I still lean on Old Do Lots of Data Tracking Evil Google because (a) I can uses its advanced search features; (b) it hits a wide variety of sources than a single source (flickr and Wikimedia commons yeah, but also Pixabay, other public domain sources, etc; and (c) I have a honed set of bookmarklet tools and pre-rigged search engines. For the latest iteration of my whacky methods see the Magic Box of Image Search tricks for the last Open Education Week, the latest is setting my main browser interface to not return anything BUT Creative Commons licensed images. I was shocked a bit last week when I did a CC filtered Google image search for "door" returned a miserable 7 results before the end of internet sign "Looks like you've reached the end" [no-door-1280x724]These are not the open licensed door I was looking for (none are creative licensed, despite the setting) In the interest of he post, I went for my fall back, searching my own flickr images for door, which yielded 440 results, and all open licensed. "Hey Google! You suck!" As it ended up, while opening new tabs for links I was seeking, the Free to Use browser extension yielded a perfect public domain photo from the Library of Congress. Who Locked the CC Dogs Out? I felt this evisceration of the commons by Google was strange, so I dug in a bit, hence a search on the word that is part of my name and tends to produce gobs of images- dog. A standard google image search with no restrictions yielded lots of pooches, pages and pages, but flipping open the Tools, selecting Creative Commons from the Usage rights menu, cut it down to 3. I did the usual checks. I deleted my cache and cookies. I tried different browsers (Safari and Firefox). I switched networks from the home wireless to hotspotting from my mobile phone. De nada. Well, 3 dogs still. Even before tweeting, I thought first o report it to folks who ought to know about this, and posted it to the Creative Commons Slack (if you are not in there, that link won't do aTnything). I got a quick reply from Cable Green (thanks) who alerted some of the other CC folks. The first responder Timid Robot could not reproduce it (but later did) and others chimed in. Then I tweeted, and other confirmed the paucity of CC licensed dogs in Google Images (and even worse, cats were affected). Weird. Just me? It looks like Google Image search results filtered for Usage Rights = Creative Commons returns almost nothing. Hey Google, let the CC dogs out!https://t.co/XWm0UFRkHy pic.twitter.com/ 9NkT3FIz2K -- Alan Levine (@cogdog) September 22, 2022 Earl Does URL Dissection Now here is the strange oddity. From all the tools I have made/used I know that a google image search for dog with the Creative Commons license search produces results via a URL like: https://www.google.com/search?q=dog&tbm=isch&tbs=il:cl I know my parameters: q=dog is the search term, tbm=isch signifies and image search and tbs=il:cl should tell Google o return only results license Creative Commons. Now the strange thing that Timid Robot from CC reported was changing the URL to https://www.google.com/search?q=dog&tbm=isch&tbs=sur:fmc,il:cl makes it work like we'd expect (see if it works for you?) The big question is what the bleep is sur:fmc?? It's a big question because Google does not seem to document all its parameters. I know though because I have been making these URL search gizmos for a while. This goes back to the usage rights options that were first introduced by Google in 2009 where first aligned (mostly) with Creative Commons Licenses, where the usage rights were [search-era-2]The first options for limiting Google Image results for Usage Rights- and it applied to cats The options were written like a weird rephrasing of CC licenses, and you had to venture to an advanced search interface: * Not Filtered By License (all the cat photos) * Labeled for Reuse with Modification (cats licensed CC BY, CC BY-SA but not ND ?) * Labeled for Reuse (cats licensed under any CC license. ?) * Labeled for Non Commercial reuse with modification (cats licensed CC BY-NC, CC BY-NC-SA?) * Labeled for Non Commercial reuse (cats licensed CC BY-NC-ND, CC BY-NC-ND-SA?) The search queries in this era passed parameters (with actual licenses seen there) with a lot of logic passed for the usage rights, you can see this from what the old CC Search Engine produced: [https://www.go] https://www.google.com/search?as_rights=(cc_publicdomain| 1 cc_attribute|cc_sharealike).-(cc_noncommercial|cc_nonderived)&q=dog &hl= (which no longer works). Somewhere Google changed the parameters, as when I started fiddling with browser shortcuts for image searches filtered by CC licenses in 2013, the parameter to return images "free to use and share" was in the results as sur:fmc You can still find this in the antique Google Image advanced search (same results as the old CC Search), you get the CC licensed results. Mostly. [ffff-1280x686] But here is the kicker - look at the Usage Rights menu- it does not indicate the licensing. And there is no way to get this sur:fmc parameter or results from any selection/option from the Google Image Search form. What the bleep is tbs=sur:fmc Oh I searched! I found nothing from any Google.com sie, just bits of code for various image search scrapers (here's one example) (and another). And then I should not be surprised to find reference to this search parameter in a blogpost by my friend John Johnston where he showed how it can be used to aid searches on iPads (where the filter options for CC are not there). Google Ch-Ch-Ch-Changes Of course google changes itself. Sometime in 2020 Google changed the Usage Rights options to now offer the options under Usage Rights to be either "Creative Commons" or "Commercial and other Licenses" - you can inspect the URLs to find this is indicated in search parameters tbs=il:cl (Creative Commons) or tbs=il:ol (Commercial and other Licenses WTF does that even mean?). Of course, the Commercial license option currently produces lots of dogs but alas, the Creative Commons option gives you 3 bubkahs. Now What? I'm making noise to no avail. I put a question in the Google Help forum. What I got? https://www.google.com/search?q=crickets&tbm=isch& tbs=il%3Acl I think in my small knowledge of How Google Really Works that somewhere they munged up the search tool. I'd think they care, but why would they really care about open licensed images? there's no $$ in that. Google is broke, I spotted it, and no one really seems to care. I'm giving them The Stare. Try to Ignore My Eyes Try to Ignore My Eyes flickr photo by cogdogblog shared into the public domain using Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication (CC0) So I am not using Google Image search much, because it has been neutered. And yes, I agree for most folks the best option for CC licensed images is OpenVerse (ignoring the Build Your Own License every search site seems to do now) - look, there are over 10,000 CC licensed dog in OpenVerse, and you even get cut and paste attribution. You will find nearly all my Felix photos there. And again, I will craft a new image search strategy. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Featured Image: Who Broke the Internet? flickr photo by cogdogblog shared into the public domain using Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication (CC0) easily found in my own flicks stream, modified by me (Alan Levine) to include a screenshot of the only 3 CC license images google can find [google-images-broken33758778781_1e903c39a0_k-1280x960] If this kind of stuff has value, please support me by tossing a one time PayPal kibble or monthly on Patreon PayPal - The safer, easier way to pay online. * [become_a_p] * google * web bad dog Profile Picture for cogdog cogdog An early 90s builder of the web and blogging Alan Levine barks at CogDogBlog.com on web storytelling (#ds106 #4life), photography, bending WordPress, and serendipity in the infinite internet river. He thinks it's weird to write about himself in the third person. Comments 1. [4f7563af123d] Sheila MacNeill says: September 27, 2022 at 1:11 am Thanks for sharing Alan - even I noticed my last search for CC images on google got a quite thin response. Reply 2. [ff1e0caf1606] Lorna Campbell says: September 27, 2022 at 2:27 am Ooft. Thanks for the heads up Alan. We show our staff and students how to use Google image search to find open licensed images, along with other search tools such as OpenSearch, Flickr / Commons etc. I guess we'll be changing that recommendation! Reply 1. [240fefbb4462] cogdog says: September 27, 2022 at 7:25 am I'd like to think they will fix it because of my HUGE influence (hah). But I'd really recommend Openverse for staff and students because: o There is no question on the license, Openverse only indexes images with CC licenses. Google yields false results and includes a bunch of sketchy public domain sources and MaxPixel which just is a stolen copy of Pixabay. o Openverse indexes a lot of key GLAM sources that Google does not seem to grab o Openverse provides cut and paste attribution. o No Question on Remix It can make it more clear on doing remixes if you do not use sources where the licenses are explicit CC o Give Google less Data Juice I'm going to be a fan of Openverse! Reply 3. [6af1df804358] John says: September 27, 2022 at 8:46 am Hi Alan, I can't count the number of times google has broken something I use in ways that are hard to fix. I join you in the stare. A while ago I started messing with the OpenVerse API here: https://johnjohnston.info/tests/ov.html Hopefully to be used by kids. Of course it needs some more work. And lack of authentication has me limited I think. BTW, I got a web mention from this post:-) Reply 1. [240fefbb4462] cogdog says: September 27, 2022 at 9:43 am I can mention you on a regular basis. And nifty work on the stamper! Alan and his dog Felix Reply Leave a Reply Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] Comment * [ ] Name * [ ] Email * [ ] Website [ ] [ ] Notify me of follow-up comments by email. [ ] Notify me of new posts by email. [Post Comment] [ ] Check here to Subscribe to notifications for new posts [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] D[ ] Post navigation Previous post Shaping Your WordPress Tech Simply By Changing the Front Door dog icon Here I bark and growl about the web, edtech, photography, and other stuff that gets under my fur (more...). Send those e-cards and e-letters to cogdogblog at gmail dot com -- except requests to add links, insert ads, or write guest articles. I don't do that. Look around. If you bug me you may get the treatment. Each email you send me despite this obvious warning incurs a $250 handling fee. This doghouse is deftly powered by the awesomeness of WordPress and the typo prone hacking of Alan Levine. Creative Commons License Unless otherwise indicated all photos, animated gifs, remixes, and mangled words are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Powered by WordPress and Cover modded by @cogdog * Twitter * Mastodon * flickr * GitHub * Instagram * YouTube Loading Comments... Write a Comment... [ ] Email (Required) [ ] Name (Required) [ ] Website [ ] [Post Comment]