https://www.theverge.com/2022/9/21/23364696/getty-images-ai-ban-generated-artwork-illustration-copyright Skip to main content The Verge logo.The Verge homepage * The Verge homepageThe Verge logo./ * Tech/ * Reviews/ * Science/ * Entertainment/ * MoreMenu The Verge logo.Menu * Tech/ * Artificial Intelligence/ * Creators Getty Images bans AI-generated content over fears of legal challenges Getty Images bans AI-generated content over fears of legal challenges / Getty Images is worried about future copyright claims By James Vincent Sep 21, 2022, 2:30 PM UTC| Share this story * * * A photo of a hand holding a digital stylus over an iPad showing an illustration of Kermit the Frog. Only human-drawn illustrations allowed. Photo by Amelia Holowaty Krales / The Verge Getty Images has banned the upload and sale of illustrations generated using AI art tools like DALL-E, Midjourney, and Stable Diffusion. It's the latest and largest user-generated content platform to introduce such a ban, following similar decisions by sites including Newgrounds, PurplePort, and FurAffinity. Getty Images CEO Craig Peters told The Verge that the ban was prompted by concerns about the legality of AI-generated content and a desire to protect the site's customers. "There are real concerns with respect to the copyright of outputs from these models" "There are real concerns with respect to the copyright of outputs from these models and unaddressed rights issues with respect to the imagery, the image metadata and those individuals contained within the imagery," said Peters. Given these concerns, he said, selling AI artwork or illustrations could potentially put Getty Images users at legal risk. "We are being proactive to the benefit of our customers," he added. The creators of AI image generators say the technology is legal, but that's no guarantee this status won't be contested. Software like Stable Diffusion is trained on copyrighted images scraped from the web, including personal art blogs, news sites, and stock photo sites like Getty Images. The act of scraping is legal in the US, and it seems the output of the software is covered by "fair use" doctrine. But fair use provides weaker protection to commercial activity like selling pictures, and some artists whose work has been scraped and imitated by companies making AI image generators have called for new laws to regulate this domain. The presence of copyrighted imagery in the training data of AI art generators is obvious from their tendency to reproduce the "Getty Images" watermark.The presence of copyrighted imagery in the training data of AI art generators is obvious from their tendency to reproduce the "Getty Images" watermark. The presence of copyrighted imagery in the training data of AI art generators is obvious from their tendency to reproduce the "Getty Images" watermark. Image: Lexica Peters refused to say whether Getty Images has received legal challenges over its sale of AI-generated content. He said such content was "extremely limited" on the platform and repeated his assertion that the company was only introducing this policy to "avoid risk to [customers'] reputation, brand and bottom line." One of Getty Images' biggest competitors, Shutterstock, seems to be limiting some searches for AI content but hasn't yet introduced specific policies banning the material. Other platforms have removed AI imagery for reasons other than protecting customers. Furry-focused social art site FurAffinity, for example, said it banned AI artwork because it undermines the work of human artists. Some art platforms have banned AI to support human artists "AI and machine learning applications (DALL-E, Craiyon) sample other artists' work to create content. That content generated can reference hundreds, even thousands of pieces of work from other artists to create derivative images," said FurAffinity's mods. "Our goal is to support artists and their content. We don't believe it's in our community's best interests to allow AI generated content on the site." When asked if AI-generated content was a threat to the livelihood of illustrators and photographers who sell their work on Getty Images, Peters suggested that these tools were just the latest example of technology expanding the amount of available imagery. "The world is already awash in imagery. Digital cameras generated an exponential growth in imagery given the reduced cost and simplicity of capture, transmission and use. The introduction of the smartphone and social media took this to all new levels, with trillions of images taken and posted," said Peters. "Our business has never been about the ease of creating imagery or the resulting volume. It is about connecting and cutting through." However, actually removing AI content may be difficult. Peters says Getty Images will rely on users to identify and report such images, and that it's working with C2PA (the Coalition for Content Provenance and Authenticity) to create filters. However, no automated filter will be wholly reliable, and it's not clear how easy Getty Images will find it to enforce its new ban. As of this morning, a quick search on the site for "AI-generated art" reveals plenty of content for sale. Update, Wed 21st September, 11:18AM ET: Story updated to clarify the description of fair use. Join the conversation Most Popular 1. Apple Watch Ultra review: an aspirational debut ----------------------------------------------------------------- 2. Tesla Megapack battery fire is 'fully controlled,' shelter-in-place advisory lifted ----------------------------------------------------------------- 3. Dozens of civil rights groups are calling on Amazon and MGM to cancel Ring Nation reality show ----------------------------------------------------------------- 4. Apple makes the battery indicator better in new iOS 16.1 beta ----------------------------------------------------------------- 5. Windows 11's 2022 Update has something new for everyone ----------------------------------------------------------------- Verge Deals / Sign up for Verge Deals to get deals on products we've tested sent to your inbox daily. Email (required)[ ]Sign up By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. From our sponsor Advertiser Content FromSponsor logo Sponsor thumbnail More from Tech * A Chromebook for the DIY-minded.A Chromebook for the DIY-minded. Framework's new Chromebook is upgradable and customizable * [yH5BAEAAAA][image] Kia plans to build EVs in the US to comply with new federal tax credit * NASA paused observations with one of the JWST modes.NASA paused observations with one of the JWST modes. NASA's deep space telescope is having instrument trouble caused by "increased friction" * A two-tone light-blue / black backpack laying on a gray concrete floor, with its rear side pointing upwards toward the camera.A two-tone light-blue / black backpack laying on a gray concrete floor, with its rear side pointing upwards toward the camera. Win a mystery bag of free stuff from The Verge and The Strategist * Advertiser Content FromSponsor logo Today's Storystream Feed refreshed 17 minutes ago * Alexa is better with buttons. E Elizabeth Lopatto17 minutes ago Crypto tokens are just "decentralized Ponzi schemes," says JP Morgan CEO Jamie Dimon. Previously, Dimon has called Bitcoin "a fraud," before deciding whoopsie, no, "The blockchain is real. You can have crypto yen and dollars and stuff like that." Okay, babe, now please explain how the London Whale happened just one more time. JPMorgan CEO Calls Crypto Tokens Like Bitcoin 'Decentralized Ponzi Schemes' [Bloomberg.com] J Jay PetersAn hour ago Twitter has disclosed yet another security issue. In some instances, accounts would remain logged in on mobile after a user voluntarily reset their password, according to a blog post. It's not a great look for a company already under significant scrutiny for its security practices following explosive allegations from its former head of security. We fixed a bug that didn't close all active logged in sessions on Android and iOS after an account's password was reset. To keep your account safe, we logged some of you out. You can log back in to keep using Twitter. For more details on what happened: https://t.co/OmjLKOe5bs -- Twitter Support (@TwitterSupport) September 21, 2022 Apple Apple Apple Watch Ultra review: an aspirational debut Victoria Song1:00 PM UTC The Apple Watch Ultra under water with the Depth app pulled upThe Apple Watch Ultra under water with the Depth app pulled up The Apple Watch Ultra under water with the Depth app pulled upThe Apple Watch Ultra under water with the Depth app pulled up Google Google Larry Page's flying car startup Kitty Hawk is shutting down Umar Shakir3 minutes ago In a clear and starry night sky, a red charter-sized aircraft stands. In a clear and starry night sky, a red charter-sized aircraft stands. In a clear and starry night sky, a red charter-sized aircraft stands. In a clear and starry night sky, a red charter-sized aircraft stands. Science Science NASA loads Artemis I rocket with fuel in major troubleshooting test Mary Beth Griggs7 minutes ago People in white lab coats and hard hats stand on stairs near the base of a massive rocketPeople in white lab coats and hard hats stand on stairs near the base of a massive rocket People in white lab coats and hard hats stand on stairs near the base of a massive rocketPeople in white lab coats and hard hats stand on stairs near the base of a massive rocket Google Google Framework's new Chromebook is upgradable and customizable Monica Chin45 minutes ago The Framework laptop open on a desk with notebooks to its left and parts to its right.The Framework laptop open on a desk with notebooks to its left and parts to its right. The Framework laptop open on a desk with notebooks to its left and parts to its right.The Framework laptop open on a desk with notebooks to its left and parts to its right. Must Reads Must Reads Must Reads 1. Microsoft announces a Surface event for October 12th Tom WarrenSep 21 2. I tried replacing Google with TikTok, and it worked better than I thought David PierceSep 21 3. Logitech's G Cloud Gaming Handheld arrives in October for $349.99 Tom WarrenSep 21 4. Framework's new Chromebook is upgradable and customizable Monica ChinSep 21 5. Logitech's new key light could almost pass for a regular desk lamp Jon PorterSep 21 E Elizabeth LopattoAn hour ago Meet the staffer behind Chancery Daily, a specialist publication that has been explaining Twitter v Musk. "Chance," one of the people behind the Chancery Daily Twitter account explains why the Delaware court is special. "Every little thing is going to be fought over in a $44 billion transaction, right?" Chance says. "Every little blessed thing." If you were wondering how the Twitter v Musk sausage is made in Delaware's Chancery Court, this is the inside-baseball podcast for you. S Sarah JeongAn hour ago The real victims of Facebook catfish scams are the scammers, who have been human trafficked into scamming as a job. Extraordinary investigative work from Cambodian news outlet VOD, interviewing Indonesian migrant workers who were allegedly brought to Cambodia and set to work as pretend beautiful women who would like you to invest in their cryptocurrency platform. The workers say they lived and worked in the same building, and that their personal phones were taken away; one said he was beaten and tased for a mistake. The workers were rescued after one of their siblings saw a "TikTok describing forced labor and detention" that made him suspicious of his sister's working conditions -- he eventually sought out an NGO that intervened. Learning to Scam Under the Threat of Tasers [VOD] Google Google Google's making it even easier to remove your personal info from search Mitchell ClarkTwo hours ago An illustration of Google's multicolor "G" logoAn illustration of Google's multicolor "G" logo An illustration of Google's multicolor "G" logoAn illustration of Google's multicolor "G" logo Apple Apple Filed under: The Verge Guide to the iPhone How to customize your iPhone's app icons Barbara KrasnoffTwo hours ago iPhone with icons and illustrated backgroundiPhone with icons and illustrated background iPhone with icons and illustrated backgroundiPhone with icons and illustrated background J Jay PetersTwo hours ago Turns out the Apple Watch Ultra is about the same size as a Fig Newton. In a TikTok video, Victoria Song, who reviewed the Apple Watch Ultra, compared the large smartwatch to a bunch of common household objects, like an AirPods case and a stack of quarters. One of the closest comparisons? A Fig Newton. @verge Size matters -- at least, seems like that's the approach Apple took when designing the Apple Watch Ultra. #applewatchultra # apple #techtok Canyons - Official Sound Studio [yH5BAEAAAA][image] Welcome to the new Verge Revolutionizing the media with blog posts Nilay PatelSep 13 Tech Tech * YouTube's 'dislike' and 'not interested' buttons barely work, study finds Mia SatoSep 20 YouTube's 'dislike' and 'not interested' buttons barely work, study findsYouTube's 'dislike' and 'not interested' buttons barely work, study finds * Larry Page's flying car startup Kitty Hawk is shutting down Umar ShakirSep 21 * Google's making it even easier to remove your personal info from search Mitchell ClarkSep 21 See all Tech See all Tech Deals Deals The best streaming service deals available right now Sheena VasaniTwo hours ago A character from the House of the Dragon sits on the Iron Throne.A character from the House of the Dragon sits on the Iron Throne. A character from the House of the Dragon sits on the Iron Throne.A character from the House of the Dragon sits on the Iron Throne. Apps Apps TikTok's BeReal clone app is gaining traction outside the US Mia SatoTwo hours ago The TikTok logo on a black background with repeating music note motifsThe TikTok logo on a black background with repeating music note motifs The TikTok logo on a black background with repeating music note motifsThe TikTok logo on a black background with repeating music note motifs Tech Tech Instagram's finally working on protecting users from unsolicited nude photos Sheena VasaniTwo hours ago The Instagram icon is featured in the middle of a background filled with pink, orange, and purple shapes.The Instagram icon is featured in the middle of a background filled with pink, orange, and purple shapes. The Instagram icon is featured in the middle of a background filled with pink, orange, and purple shapes.The Instagram icon is featured in the middle of a background filled with pink, orange, and purple shapes. E Elizabeth LopattoTwo hours ago The collapse of Three Arrows Capital has not put a dent in unsecured crypto lending. And because crypto is a relatively "concentrated ecosystem," there are systemic risks, S&P analyst Alex Birry tells Reuters. Which means the domino effect we saw this summer? That could absolutely happen again. What crisis? High-stakes crypto lending looks here to stay [Reuters] Gaming Gaming Sega Dreamcast's iconic memory card is making a (fundraised) comeback Cameron FaulknerTwo hours ago A screenshot showing the VM2, a modern recreation of Sega's original Dreamcast virtual memory unit.A screenshot showing the VM2, a modern recreation of Sega's original Dreamcast virtual memory unit. A screenshot showing the VM2, a modern recreation of Sega's original Dreamcast virtual memory unit.A screenshot showing the VM2, a modern recreation of Sega's original Dreamcast virtual memory unit. Gaming Gaming Microsoft is testing a way to mute the Xbox startup sound Jay Peters6:59 PM UTC An Xbox Series X console is placed on a white surface with a black background behind it.An Xbox Series X console is placed on a white surface with a black background behind it. An Xbox Series X console is placed on a white surface with a black background behind it.An Xbox Series X console is placed on a white surface with a black background behind it. Podcasts PodcastsSee more Podcasts Podcasts 1. Today on The Vergecast: GTA, TikTok, and iPhones. David PierceSep 21 2. I tried replacing Google with TikTok, and it worked better than I thought David PierceSep 21 3. Can software simplify the supply chain? Ryan Petersen thinks so Nilay PatelSep 20 4. Music labels are incorporating old songs into new songs to trigger your nostalgia. Alex CranzSep 19 5. Will the future of music sound a lot like the past? Alex CranzSep 19 See all Podcasts Apple Apple How to use Action mode on the iPhone 14 and iPhone 14 Pro Allison Johnson6:51 PM UTC Here's how to best use one of the iPhone 14's new camera features. Here's how to best use one of the iPhone 14's new camera features. Here's how to best use one of the iPhone 14's new camera features. Here's how to best use one of the iPhone 14's new camera features. C Corin Faife6:48 PM UTC Iran blocks mobile internet and social media in an attempt to curb growing protests. For days, Iran has been gripped by major protests after the death of 22 year old Mahsa Amini at the hands of the "morality police." The latest data from NetBlocks shows how the regime is responding: by making it all but impossible to access Instagram and WhatsApp, some of the only major social media apps accessible in the country. [?][?] #Iran is now subject to the most severe internet restrictions since the November 2019 massacre. >[?] Mobile networks largely shut down (MCI, Rightel, Irancell - partial) >[?] Regional disruptions observed during protests >[?] Instagram, WhatsApp restrictedhttps://t.co/8cCHIJA2Oi -- NetBlocks (@netblocks) September 21, 2022 J Jay Peters5:40 PM UTC Meta and Google's definitely-not-layoffs prod employees to compete for new jobs. Meta isn't saying it's laying off employees, but the WSJ reports department reorganizations are sending "a significant number of staffers" into a purgatory internally referred to as "the 30 day list" as they seek other jobs internally. When Google cut half of the incubating projects within Area 120 last week, it gave people until January to find new jobs, a longer than usual window. 1,400 staffers petitioned for more time for internal job searches in the spring. Meta and Google Are Cutting Staff. Just Don't Mention Layoffs. [WSJ] Apple Apple How to automatically change your Slack status when you have a meeting Sheena Vasani5:39 PM UTC A hand holding up an iPhone with a big Slack icon in the middle. A hand holding up an iPhone with a big Slack icon in the middle. A hand holding up an iPhone with a big Slack icon in the middle. A hand holding up an iPhone with a big Slack icon in the middle. Microsoft Microsoft Microsoft announces a Surface event for October 12th Tom Warren5:14 PM UTC A photo of multiple Surface devices on a colorful rugA photo of multiple Surface devices on a colorful rug A photo of multiple Surface devices on a colorful rugA photo of multiple Surface devices on a colorful rug Most Popular Most Popular Most Popular 1. Apple Watch Ultra review: an aspirational debut Victoria SongSep 21 2. Tesla Megapack battery fire is 'fully controlled,' shelter-in-place advisory lifted Umar ShakirSep 20 3. Dozens of civil rights groups are calling on Amazon and MGM to cancel Ring Nation reality show Charles Pulliam-MooreSep 20 4. Apple makes the battery indicator better in new iOS 16.1 beta Jay PetersSep 20 5. Windows 11's 2022 Update has something new for everyone Tom WarrenSep 20 D David Pierce5:08 PM UTC Today on The Vergecast: GTA, TikTok, and iPhones. We tried to figure out what's next for Grand Theft Auto after a huge leak, whether TikTok is the future of Google, and why Apple won't just make a camera. It's a fun Vergecast, available wherever podcasts are sold! A Alex Cranz4:54 PM UTC I regret to inform you that phones are not good for cloud gaming. Logitech announced the G Cloud Gaming Handheld earlier today. The new device comes with apps for some of the biggest cloud gaming services pre-installed, and you may be wondering what the point of it is when we all have very powerful phones with great screens. Don't worry, I answered this question months ago when I wrote about just how bad phones are for serious cloud gaming! I cannot wait until we can run this thing through its paces and see if it gives us the cloud gaming hardware we need. Razer KishiRazer Kishi The phone is terrible for cloud gaming Alex CranzJul 4 A Adi Robertson4:50 PM UTC I need to see Deathloop's new, longer ending. Deathloop's perfunctory endings were a weak spot in a game full of great ideas, so I'm intrigued to hear that on top of new weapons and trinkets, the Goldenloop update contains an enigmatic "extended ending." I'm not sure what that means, but it's enough to make me consider booting the game up again. Besides, I could murder Aleksis much more elegantly this time. Everything coming in Deathloop's big Goldenloop update [Polygon] Podcasts Podcasts I tried replacing Google with TikTok, and it worked better than I thought David Pierce4:30 PM UTC [yH5BAEAAAA][image] [yH5BAEAAAA][image] D Dan Seifert4:29 PM UTC Here come the Dynamic Island clones. It's no secret that once Apple does something, the industry tends to follow, so it's not much of a surprise that we're already seeing Dynamic Island clones materialize. Last week we saw MIUI (the Android-based software on Xiaomi phones) themers incorporate Dynamic Island-like ideas into their software, and today 9to5Google reports that Redmi is asking its fans to come up with ideas for what a "Redmi Island" could look like. Apparently Redmi wants to use to display alerts like incoming calls, notifications, and more. Sure sounds familiar. Android might get its own version of Apple's Dynamic Island if Realme get its way [9to5Google] Gaming Gaming A hacker used 2K Games' support desk to send gamers malware Corin Faife4:02 PM UTC 2K Games logo in white and red surrounded by a pattern of angular black bars2K Games logo in white and red surrounded by a pattern of angular black bars 2K Games logo in white and red surrounded by a pattern of angular black bars2K Games logo in white and red surrounded by a pattern of angular black bars Reviews Reviews * Apple iPhone 14 Pro review: early adopter island Nilay PatelSep 14 Apple iPhone 14 Pro review: early adopter islandApple iPhone 14 Pro review: early adopter island * Best cheap laptop 2022 Monica ChinSep 21 * Apple Watch Ultra review: an aspirational debut Victoria SongSep 21 See all Reviews See all Reviews A Andrew J. Hawkins4:01 PM UTC Tesla is buzzing with robot fever. Elon Musk's company is getting ready to debut its supposedly not-fake humanoid robot, Optimus, during its "AI Day" event September 30th. What evidence do we have that it won't just be another a person in a spandex robot costume doing an extremely awkward dance? There have been meetings! And job postings! And Elon tweeted that there may be a working prototype! Look, this will either be a major breakthrough in the field of robotics or a spectacular flop. But considering Musk has already solved the problem of self-driving cars, I'm inclined to-- what's that? [touches earpiece] I'm being told he hasn't solved the problem of self-driving cars? And that humanoid robots could prove even more difficult? Oh well, then bring on the spandex dancers I guess. Elon Musk faces skeptics as Tesla gets ready to unveil 'Optimus' robot [Reuters] Gaming Gaming Logitech's G Cloud Gaming Handheld arrives in October for $349.99 Tom Warren4:00 PM UTC Logitech's cloud gaming handheld has Xbox integration.Logitech's cloud gaming handheld has Xbox integration. Logitech's cloud gaming handheld has Xbox integration.Logitech's cloud gaming handheld has Xbox integration. Tech Tech Logitech's new key light could almost pass for a regular desk lamp Jon Porter4:00 PM UTC Logitech's Litra Beam key light sitting above a monitor.Logitech's Litra Beam key light sitting above a monitor. Logitech's Litra Beam key light sitting above a monitor.Logitech's Litra Beam key light sitting above a monitor. Gaming Gaming The new Astro A30 headset can pull in audio from three gadgets at once Cameron Faulkner4:00 PM UTC Logitech G Astro A30 gaming headset being worn by a person facing the camera.Logitech G Astro A30 gaming headset being worn by a person facing the camera. Logitech G Astro A30 gaming headset being worn by a person facing the camera.Logitech G Astro A30 gaming headset being worn by a person facing the camera. Gaming Gaming Logitech's G Fits can mold their ear tips to deliver made-for-you sound Cameron Faulkner4:00 PM UTC The Logitech G Fits wireless earbuds sitting in an opened yellow case.The Logitech G Fits wireless earbuds sitting in an opened yellow case. The Logitech G Fits wireless earbuds sitting in an opened yellow case.The Logitech G Fits wireless earbuds sitting in an opened yellow case. N Nilay Patel3:45 PM UTC I cannot stop laughing at Trombone Champ. You have to watch this video, and PC Gamer's writeup is also great. Accuracy and timing determine how well you play, with little words popping up to tell you how you're doing. Words like Perfecto! Or Nice! If you're sucking, as I typically do, you'll get a Meh or sometimes a Nasty, which is maybe the funniest word to use to describe someone playing a trombone poorly. The world's first trombone rhythm game is instantly a GOTY contender. And no, I'm not kidding. Turn up the volume and hear Beethoven like you've never heard it before. https://t.co/ Qu7Cmkhjzc pic.twitter.com/jTXNdWx3Zm -- PC Gamer (@pcgamer) September 20, 2022 Science Science * Telemed abortion is expanding in parts of the US Nicole WetsmanSep 19 Telemed abortion is expanding in parts of the USTelemed abortion is expanding in parts of the US * Ethereum just completed The Merge -- here's how much energy it's saving Justine CalmaSep 15 * NASA loads Artemis I rocket with fuel in major troubleshooting test Mary Beth GriggsSep 21 See all Science See all Science Policy Policy Your car should be able to tell if you're too drunk or impaired to drive, NTSB says Andrew J. Hawkins3:34 PM UTC Cars driving on a California freewayCars driving on a California freeway Cars driving on a California freewayCars driving on a California freeway Microsoft Microsoft The Xbox button on Elite 2 controllers now supports RGB colors Tom Warren3:33 PM UTC Microsoft now supports RGB colors on Xbox Elite 2 controllers Microsoft now supports RGB colors on Xbox Elite 2 controllers Microsoft now supports RGB colors on Xbox Elite 2 controllers Microsoft now supports RGB colors on Xbox Elite 2 controllers J Jay Peters3:31 PM UTC A lot of people are playing Cyberpunk 2077 right now. The game has had 1 million players, "both new and returning," each day this week, according to developer CD Projekt Red. Interest is likely up due to a big new update and the well-received Netflix anime . Each day of this week Night City has been visited by 1 million players, both new and returning. We wanted to use this opportunity to thank you for being with us and playing the game. Thanks, Chooms! pic.twitter.com/ zqggblztF8 -- Cyberpunk 2077 (@CyberpunkGame) September 21, 2022 Gaming Gaming Vampire Survivors' new higher price is still worth sinking your teeth into Jess Weatherbed3:30 PM UTC Vampire Survivors video gameVampire Survivors video game Vampire Survivors video gameVampire Survivors video game Pagination More Stories Creators Creators * TikTok's BeReal clone app is gaining traction outside the US Mia SatoSep 21 TikTok's BeReal clone app is gaining traction outside the US TikTok's BeReal clone app is gaining traction outside the US * Getty Images bans AI-generated content over fears of legal challenges James VincentSep 21 * Facebook is experimenting with letting users help write speech rules Casey NewtonSep 21 See all Creators See all Creators The Verge logo. * Terms of Use * Privacy Notice * Cookie Policy * Do Not Sell My Personal Info * Licensing FAQ * Accessibility * Platform Status * Contact * Tip Us * Community Guidelines * About * Ethics Statement The Verge is a vox media network * Advertise with us * Jobs @ Vox Media (c) 2022 Vox Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved