https://www.pugetsystems.com/labs/articles/Effects-of-Grill-Patterns-on-Fan-Performance-Noise-107/ Puget Systems logo Toggle navigation Puget Systems small logo * Talk to an Expert * Log In * Create Account * Start Search * Cancel Search Search Textbox [ ] Search Button * Solutions + Recommended Systems For: + Content Creation + Photography o Recommended Systems For: o Adobe Lightroom Classic ThumbnailAdobe Lightroom Classic o Adobe Photoshop ThumbnailAdobe Photoshop + Video Editing o Recommended Systems For: o Adobe After Effects ThumbnailAdobe After Effects o Adobe Premiere Pro ThumbnailAdobe Premiere Pro o DaVinci Resolve ThumbnailDaVinci Resolve o Foundry Nuke ThumbnailFoundry Nuke + 3D Design and Animation o Recommended Systems For: o Autodesk 3ds Max ThumbnailAutodesk 3ds Max o Autodesk Maya ThumbnailAutodesk Maya o Blender ThumbnailBlender o Cinema 4D ThumbnailCinema 4D o ZBrush ThumbnailZBrush + Real-Time Engines o Recommended Systems For: o Game Development ThumbnailGame Development o Unity ThumbnailUnity o Unreal Engine ThumbnailUnreal Engine o Virtual Production ThumbnailVirtual Production + Rendering o Recommended Systems For: o OTOY OctaneRender ThumbnailOTOY OctaneRender o Redshift ThumbnailRedshift o V-Ray ThumbnailV-Ray + Engineering + CAD o Recommended Systems For: o Autodesk AutoCAD ThumbnailAutodesk AutoCAD o Autodesk Inventor ThumbnailAutodesk Inventor o Autodesk Revit ThumbnailAutodesk Revit o SOLIDWORKS ThumbnailSOLIDWORKS + Photogrammetry o Recommended Systems For: o Agisoft Metashape ThumbnailAgisoft Metashape o Pix4D ThumbnailPix4D o RealityCapture ThumbnailRealityCapture + Scientific Computing o Recommended Systems For: o Data Science ThumbnailData Science o Machine Learning / AI ThumbnailMachine Learning / AI o Scientific Computing ThumbnailScientific Computing + More o Recommended Systems For: o NVIDIA Studio Desktop ThumbnailNVIDIA Studio Desktop o Compact Size ThumbnailCompact Size o Live Streaming ThumbnailLive Streaming o Quiet Operation ThumbnailQuiet Operation o Virtual Reality ThumbnailVirtual Reality * Products + Core system image Core Workstations with Intel Core processors on B560 and Z690 chipsets + Ryzen system image Ryzen Workstations with AMD Ryzen processors on B550 and X570 chipsets + Threadripper Pro system image Threadripper Pro Workstations with AMD Threadripper PRO processors on the WRX80 chipset + Xeon system image Xeon Workstations and servers built with various Intel Xeon processors + Server system image Server Servers and workstations in rackmount chassis + + Custom Computers Customize a desktop workstation from scratch. + Server icon Custom Servers Customize a rackmount server from scratch. + Monitor Icon Recommended Third Party Peripherals View our list of recommended peripherals to use with your new PC. * Publications + Articles + HPC Blog + Blog + Case Studies + Press * Support + Contact Support + Online Help Guides + Warranty Info * About Us + About Us + Contact Us + Support + Press Kit + Testimonials + Careers Puget Systems print logo https://www.pugetsystems.com 1. Home 2. View All Articles 3. Effects of Grill Patterns on Fan Performance/Noise Read this article at https://www.pugetsystems.com/guides/107 Effects of Grill Patterns on Fan Performance/Noise Written on September 19, 2011 by Matt Bach Share: Always look at the date when you read a hardware article. Some of the content in this article is most likely out of date, as it was written on September 19, 2011. For newer information, see our more recent articles. Introduction [pic_disp]Fan grills are often underestimated in terms of their contribution to both fan noise and airflow. It would stand to reason that the more raw material present on the grill would cause a more restricted airflow, which in turn would cause a drop in airflow and a rise in noise. In our experience however, the shape and pattern of the grill can have a huge impact on noise due to the different types of turbulence that can be caused. While the number of possible grill designs is essentially limitless, we will be testing some of the most common designs that come included with fans and chassis, as well as some popular after-market designs. A few of these grills can also found cut into window panels or stamped directly onto the metal body of a chassis itself by the manufacture. The goal of this article is to determine exactly how much a grill design contributes to both the noise and airflow of a fan. Test Grills For our testing, we will be using six different patterns cut out of 3mm acrylic as well as three common metal grills that often come included with fans/chassis. The grill patterns for each are shown below: Concentric Circles Angled Slats Grill Honeycomb Grill Grill Concentric Circles. Angled Slats. Often Honeycomb. Very Simple design, used found on pre-installed common on chassis widely in the fan mounts for acrylic where the grill is industry. chassis windows. stamped directly onto the chassis frame. Swirl Grill Loose Swirl Grill Turbine Acrylic Grill Swirl. Found on some Turbine. Uncommon, chassis fans, common Loose Swirl. Variation but shows up on large household of the swirl with sometimes on budget fans. Fragile due to larger open spaces. chassis. the thin arms. Metal Mesh Grill Metal Stamped Circle Metal Wire Grill Grill Stamped Circles. Wire. Most common Mesh. Very Variation of the after-market grill restrictive, often concentric circles with the grill doubles as a loose with the grill slightly raised above filter. slightly raised above the fan. the fan For all of our testing, we will be using an Antec 120mm Tri-Cool on both the low and high settings. This will give us both low and high airflow tests without the need to change the fan between tests. Noise We have found that the additional noise from grills is most prevalent on the intake side of the fan, so noise measurements will be taken in that configuration. The dBa meter was place at a 90 degree angle from the fan at a distance of two inches. This is much closer than dBa readings are normally taken at, but we expect the difference between some of these grills to be minimal so we wanted to make sure the changes were measurable. Because of this, our measurements will be in no way comparable to the manufacturer's specifications of noise. Results are reported in both the raw dBa reading as well as a percentage over the reading of the fan with no grill. *The ambient environment is 29 dBa Low fan speed Quietest No Grill 35.5 dBa Wire 36.0 dBa (1.4%) Mesh 36.0 dBa (1.4%) Swirl 36.0 dBa (1.4%) Loose Swirl 36.4 dBa (2.5%) [pic_disp] Stamped 38.0 dBa Difference in noise level starts Circles (7.1%) to become noticeable Honeycomb 38.0 dBa Grill starts to give a (7.1%) high-pitched "whining" noise Concentric 39.8 dBa Circles (12.1%) Angled 40.5 dBa Whining noise becomes very Slats (14.0%) pronounced Loudest Turbine 50.2 dBa Whining noise is more noticeable (41.4%) than the fan itself High fan speed Quietest No Grill 55.0 dBa 55.3 dBa Technically the quietest grill, Mesh (0.5%) but it raises the pitch of the fan noise making it more noticeable Swirl 55.6 dBa (1.1%) Wire 55.8 dBa (1.5%) Loose 56.3 dBa [pic_disp] Swirl (2.4%) Stamped 57.8 dBa Whining noise starts to occur Circles (5.1%) Honeycomb 58.0 dBa (5.5%) Angled 61.6 dBa Whining noise becomes very Slats (12%) pronounced Concentric 62.0 dBa Circles (12.7%) Loudest Turbine 71.0 dBa Whining noise is again more (29.1%) noticeable than the fan itself From a noise standpoint, what exactly do these results mean? Basically, you should avoid concentric circle, slat, honeycomb and turbine style of grills if possible. The mesh, wire and swirl grills were all clearly the best performers in both the low and high airflow tests with dBa readings within 1% of each other. Likewise, the turbine grill is the loudest grill by a healthy margin; increasing dBa readings by 29.1-41.4% The remaining question now is how much these grills are restricting the airflow of the fan. If the best grill in terms of noise is also is the most restrictive, it makes that grill much less desirable for use in a computer system. Airflow Extech AN100To measure the changes in airflow, we used an anemometer (Extech AN100) with a custom adapter to adapt from our 120mm test fan to the smaller 80mm diameter of the anemometer sensor. The adapter is 200mm long, giving us a smooth, gradual slope from the 120mm side to the 80mm side. Using this type of adapter means that our CFM readings will be nowhere near the manufacturer's specifications, but should do a good job at giving us comparison readings. It will also be more real-world as a fan installed into a chassis is never going to perform at the manufacture rated open-air CFM levels. We will again be testing with the fan on both low and high fan speeds, as well as testing with the grill on both the intake and exhaust sides of the fan. The results are listed below largely in order of best to least airflow. Due to some variances between the intake and exhaust results however, they are not 100% in order for each configuration. Results are reported in both the raw CFM reading, as well as a percentage of the airflow based on the CFM reading of the fan without a grill. *Results are in Low fan speed High fan speed CFM Intake side Exhaust Intake side Exhaust side side No Grill 22.6 (100%) 22.6 (100%) 46.7 (100%) 46.7 (100%) Wire 22.2 (98%) 21.7 (96%) 45.7 (98%) 45.2 (97%) Stamped Circles 21.3 (94%) 22.0 (97%) 43.6 (93%) 45.0 (96%) Swirl 21.5 (95%) 21.5 (95%) 44.3 (95%) 44.6 (96%) Loose Swirl 20.75 (92%) 21.3 (94%) 43.2 (93%) 44.3 (95%) Honeycomb 20.75 (92%) 20.6 (91%) 42.7 (91%) 42.7 (91%) Concentric Circles 20.6 (91%) 21.1 (93%) 42.0 (90%) 43.4 (93%) Mesh 20.2 (89%) 20.2 (89%) 43.0 (93%) 41.8 (89%) Angled Slats 19.3 (85%) 20.2 (89%) 40.0 (86%) 41.3 (88%) Turbine 19.5 (86%) 19.7 (87%) 39.7 (85%) 40.4 (87%) Conclusion The wire grill is easily the top choice in terms of both noise and performance. There are a few points where it was not the top result, but in those cases it was close enough that it was within our estimated margin of error. The mesh grill, while being one of the quietest grills, is also one of the poorest in terms of airflow. Interestingly, this grill is the only one whose results deviated largely between the noise and performance sections. This is likely due to the fact that it is a much different style than the other grills we tested. Instead of having relatively large frames and openings, the mesh grill has a lot of smaller openings, but placed very close together. So while it is very restrictive, it does not create the same type of turbulence noise that the other low-performing grill designs such as the angled slats and turbine. And lastly, the turbine grill is absolutely horrible; dropping airflow by ~15% and increasing fan noise by as much as 41% when the fan was on high. Taking both noise and airflow into account, here is our final list of grill designs in order of best to worse: 1. Wire 2. Swirl 3. Loose Swirl 4. Stamped Circles 5. Honeycomb 6. Mesh 7. Concentric Circles 8. Angled Slats 9. Turbine Tags: Performance, Cooling, Fans, Chassis Who is Puget Systems? Puget Systems builds custom PCs tailor-made for your workflow. * Extensive in-house testing, making you more productive and giving you more performance for your dollar * Reliable workstations with fewer crashes and blue screens means more time working, less time waiting on your computer * Support that understands your complex workflows and can get you back up and running ASAP * Proven track record: Check out our customer testimonials and Reseller Ratings Get Started Related Workstations Puget Serenity Puget Serenity Starting at $2737.97 Configure Related Articles * Impact of Temperature on Intel CPU Performance * NZXT Kraken G10 Review * Gaming PC vs. Space Heater Efficiency * Review: Corsair Hydro H60 CPU Cooler (Rev.2) * Thermal Paste Roundup * Thermal Paste Application Techniques Comments Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus. * Puget Systems white logo * Build Your Own PC * Site Map * FAQ facebook icon twitter icon instagram icon youtube icon linkedin icon rss feed icon * Solutions * Adobe Premiere * Adobe Photoshop * Solidworks * Autodesk AutoCAD * Machine Learning * Workstations * Content Creation * Engineering * Scientific PCs * More * Support * Online Guides * Request Support * Remote Help * Publications * All News * Puget Blog * HPC Blog * Hardware Articles * Case Studies * Policies * Warranty & Return * Privacy Policy * Delivery Times * Response Times * About Us * Testimonials * Careers * Accessibility * About Us * Contact Us * Support * Online Guides * Request Support * Remote Help * About Us * Testimonials * Careers * Accessibility * About Us * Contact Us (c) Copyright 2022 - Puget Systems, All Rights Reserved. * Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility