https://www.science.org/content/article/twisty-device-explores-alternative-path-fusion Advertisement * * news * careers * commentary * Journals * Covid-19 Science Science * * * Log in * Become A Member [science] science [sciadv] science advances [sciimmunol] science immunology [scirobotics] science robotics [signaling] science signaling [stm] science translational medicine [spj-cover] science partner journals Quick Search anywhere Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Searching: Anywhere AnywhereScienceScience AdvancesScience ImmunologyScience Robotics Science SignalingScience Translational Medicine Advanced Search Search Trending Terms: * covid-19 * climate * monkeypox * abortion * perovskite Log In Become A Member Quick Search anywhere Enter Search Term[ ] science.org * Custom publishing * collections * videos * podcasts * blogs * visualizations * prizes and awards * authors & reviewers * librarians * advertisers * about * help * * * * * * AAAS Logo * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Accessibility * News Home * All News * ScienceInsider * News Features GET OUR E-ALERTS HomeNewsAll NewsTwisty device explores alternative path to fusion Back To All News * News * Physics Twisty device explores alternative path to fusion Revamped German stellarator should run longer, hotter and compete with tokamaks * 7 Sep 2022 * 1:40 PM * ByDaniel Clery illustration of Wendelstein 7-X Wendelstein 7-X's complex geometry was a nightmare to build but, when fired up, worked from the start. IPP, ADAPTED BY C. BICKEL/SCIENCE Share: * Twitter * Linked In * Facebook * Reddit * Wechat * Email issue cover image Table of contents A version of this story appeared in Science, Vol 377, Issue 6611. Download PDF Is the search for fusion energy, long dominated by doughnut-shaped devices called tokamaks, about to undergo a shape shift? Just as ITER, the world's largest tokamak--and at tens of billions of dollars the most expensive--nears completion in the hills of southern France, a much smaller testbed with a twistier geometry will start throttling up to full power in Germany. If the 16-meter-wide device, called a stellarator, can match or outperform similar-size tokamaks, it could cause fusion scientists to rethink the future of their field. Stellarators have several key advantages, including a natural ability to keep the roiling superhot gases they contain stable enough to fuse nuclei and release energy. Even more crucial for a future fusion power plant, they can theoretically just run and run, whereas tokamaks must stop periodically to reset their magnet coils. In runs of a few seconds, the EUR1 billion German machine, dubbed Wendelstein 7-X (W7-X), is already getting "tokamak-like performance," says plasma physicist David Gates, proving adept at preventing particles and heat from escaping the superhot gas. If W7-X can achieve long runs, "it will be clearly in the lead," he says. "That's where stellarators shine." Theorist Josefine Proll of the Eindhoven University of Technology is equally enthusiastic: "All of a sudden, stellarators are back in the game." The encouraging prospects are inspiring a clutch of startup companies, including one for which Gates is now leaving Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, to develop their own stellarators. W7-X has been operating since 2015 at the Max Planck Institute for Plasma Physics (IPP) in Greifswald, Germany, but only at relatively low power levels and for short runs. Over the past 3 years, W7-X's creators stripped it down and replaced all the interior walls and fittings with water-cooled versions, opening the way to much longer, hotter runs. At a W7-X board meeting last week, the team reported that the revamped plasma vessel has no leaks and is ready to go. It is expected to restart later this month, on its way to showing whether it can truly get plasma to conditions that, in a future device, would ignite fusion. inside Wendelstein 7-X Wendelstein 7-X's twisting inner surface is now water cooled, enabling longer runs.IPP/JAN HOSAN Both stellarators and tokamaks create magnetic cages for gas at more than 100 million degrees Celsius, so hot it would melt any metal container. Heating is provided by microwaves or high energy particle beams. The outlandish temperatures produce a plasma--a roiling mix of separated nuclei and electrons--and cause the nuclei to slam together with such force that they fuse, releasing energy. A fusion power plant would be fueled with a mix of the hydrogen isotopes deuterium and tritium, which react most readily. Research machines like W7-X that aren't trying to generate energy avoid radioactive tritium and stick to safer, more plentiful hydrogen or deuterium. To make their plasma-confining magnetic fields, tokamaks and stellarators employ electromagnetic coils looping around the vessel and through the central hole. But such a field is stronger nearer the hole than the outer edge, causing plasma to drift to the reactor's wall. Tokamaks tame the drift by making the plasma flow around the ring. That streaming generates another magnetic field, twisting the ionized gas like a candy cane and steadying it. Stellarators use weirdly shaped magnetic coils instead of streaming plasma to produce the twist. The tokamak scheme has long proved the more successful at holding plasma in place, but once plasma physicists had supercomputers powerful enough, they could tweak the complex geometries of stellarator magnets to improve confinement, a process called optimization. W7-X is the first large, optimized stellarator and contains 50 bizarrely twisted superconducting coils, each weighing 6 tons. Its construction, begun in the mid-1990s, was tortuous, completed 10 years late and costing almost twice the EUR550 million originally budgeted. Despite the wait, researchers haven't been disappointed. "The machine worked immediately," says W7-X director Thomas Klinger. "It's a very easy-going machine. [It] just did what we told it to do." This contrasts with tokamaks, which are prone to "instabilities"--the plasma bulging or wobbling in unpredictable ways--or more violent "disruptions," often linked to interrupted plasma flow. Because stellarators don't rely on plasma current, that "removes a whole branch" of instabilities, says IPP theorist Sophia Henneberg. In early stellarators, the geometry of the magnetic field caused some slower moving particles to follow banana-shaped orbits until they collided with other particles and got knocked out of the plasma, leaching out energy. W7-X's ability to suppress that effect means its "optimization worked as it was supposed to," Gates says. With this Achilles heel removed, W7-X mostly loses heat through other forms of turbulence--little eddies that push particles toward the wall. Simulating turbulence takes serious computing power, and theorists have only recently got a handle on it. W7-X's upcoming campaign should validate the simulations and test ways to combat turbulence. Wendelstein 7-X's construction was long and complex (video produced in 2015). The campaign should also showcase a stellarator's ability to run continuously, in contrast to the pulsed operation of a tokamak. W7-X has already operated for runs of 100 seconds--long by tokamak standards--but at relatively low power. Not only were its components uncooled, but the device's microwave and particle heating systems could only deliver 11.5 megawatts of power. The upgrade will boost the heating power by 60%. Running W7-X at high temperature, high plasma density, and for long runs will be the real test of stellarators' potential for producing fusion power. An initial aim, Klinger says, is to get the ion temperature up to 50 million degrees Celsius for 100 seconds. That would put W7-X "among the leading machines in the world," he says. Then, the team will push it for longer, up to 30 minutes. "We'll go step by step, exploring uncharted territory," he says. W7-X's achievements have prompted venture capitalists to back several startups developing commercial power-producing stellarators. First priority for the startups: Find a simpler way to make the magnets. Princeton Stellarators, founded this year by Gates and colleagues, has secured $3 million and is aiming to build a demonstration reactor that will forgo the twisted magnet coils of W7-X. Instead, it will rely on a mosaic of about 1000 tiny square coils made of high-temperature superconductor (HTS) on the outside surface of the plasma vessel. By varying the magnetic field produced by each coil, operators will be able to change the shape of the applied field at will. "It takes complexity out of the coils and puts it in the control system," Gates says. The firm hopes to initially develop a reactor that will fuse just cheap, abundant deuterium, to generate not power, but neutrons for manufacturing radioisotopes. If successful, the firm will then aim for a power-producing reactor. Renaissance Fusion, based in Grenoble, France, has raised EUR16 million and plans to coat segments of the plasma vessel in a multilayered HTS, forming a uniform coating. Then, using a laser, engineers will burn off tracks within the superconductor to etch a twisting pattern of magnet coils. They aim to make a meter-long test segment over the next 2 years and a full prototype by 2027. A third firm, Type One Energy in Madison, Wisconsin, received U.S. Department of Energy funding to develop HTS cables with enough bend to be used in stellarator magnets. The company would sculpt pieces of metal with computer-controlled etching machines, carving twisting channels into which the cable is wound to turn it into a coil. "Advanced manufacturing technology opens the door for the stellarator," says co-founder David Anderson of the University of Wisconsin, Madison. Anderson says the next phase of W7-X's operation will accelerate the boom in stellarator efforts. "With half-hour discharges, you're essentially steady-state," he says. "This is a big deal." --------------------------------------------------------------------- doi: 10.1126/science.ade7849 Relevant tags: Physics About the author Daniel Clery Daniel Clery mailTwitter Author Daniel Clery is Science's senior correspondent in the United Kingdom, covering astronomy, physics, and energy stories as well as European policy. --------------------------------------------------------------------- More from news Olof Wood walks across microbialites 9 Sep 2022 At the Great Salt Lake, record salinity and low water imperils millions of birds By * Eli Kintisch Lilly Downs pets facility dog Posey at Rocky Mountain Hospital for Children 8 Sep 2022 New private venture tackles the riddle of Long Covid--and aims to test treatments quickly By * Jennifer Couzin-Frankel Donkeys with packs on a trail in the Andes. 8 Sep 2022 From a single domestication, donkeys helped build empires around the world By * Elizabeth Pennisi View more Got a tip for Science's news department? Connect ScienceInsider Olof Wood walks across microbialites 9 Sep 2022By * Eli Kintisch At the Great Salt Lake, record salinity and low water imperils millions of birds Lilly Downs pets facility dog Posey at Rocky Mountain Hospital for Children 8 Sep 2022By * Jennifer Couzin-Frankel New private venture tackles the riddle of Long Covid--and aims to test treatments quickly Person stands at an open door that is blocked by a brick wall 7 Sep. 2022By * Jeffrey Brainard You've spotted a flaw in a top journal's paper. Good luck getting your critique published The LOFAR superterp 7 Sep 2022By * Jacklin Kwan Europe's energy crisis hits science View more Sifter Minerals in the fossilized teeth of the extinct mammal Pantolambda, pictured here, 31 Aug 2022By * Zack Savitsky Mammals got big quickly after dinosaurs died photo of two embryos side by side 25 Aug 2022By * Mitch Leslie New synthetic mouse embryos grown in lab Drought conditions at Dinosaur Valley State Park have exposed previously hidden dinosaur tracks, such as those of the Acrocanthosaurus. 25 Aug 2022By * Jacklin Kwan Texas drought uncovers dinosaur footprints from 113 million years ago four sets of nearly identical faces 24 Aug 2022By * Jocelyn Kaiser Those doppelgangers don't just look like you--they may share your DNA View more RecommendedClose In DepthSeptember 2022 Twisty device explores alternative path to fusion Research NewsJuly 1976 Fusion Research (III): New Interest in Fusion-Assisted Breeders LettersJuly 2006 Reexamining Fusion Power FeatureMay 2015 The new shape of fusion Subscribe to News from Science Don't yet have access? Subscribe to News from Science for full access to breaking news and analysis on research and science policy. Subscribe Support nonprofit science journalism Help News from Science publish trustworthy, high-impact stories about research and the people who shape it. Please make a tax-deductible gift today. Donate [logo-dark] x ( ) $25 (*) $50 ( ) $100 ( ) Other $ [ ] Please enter a valid email (*) Single ( ) Monthly Email: [ ] Please enter a valid email Country: [United States ] [ ] I also wish to receive emails from AAAS/Science and Science advertisers, including information on products, services and special offers which may include but are not limited to news, careers information & upcoming events. Donate now Support nonprofit science journalism If we've learned anything from the COVID-19 pandemic, it's that we cannot wait for a crisis to respond. Science and AAAS are working tirelessly to provide credible, evidence-based information on the latest scientific research and policy, with extensive free coverage of the pandemic. Your tax-deductible contribution plays a critical role in sustaining this effort. Charitable Disclosures Loading... Skip slideshow Follow Us * * * * * * * NEWS * All News * ScienceInsider * News Features * Subscribe to News from Science * News from Science FAQ * About News from Science * CAREERS * Careers Articles * Find Jobs * Employer Profiles * COMMENTARY * Opinion * Analysis * Blogs * JOURNALS * Science * Science Advances * Science Immunology * Science Robotics * Science Signaling * Science Translational Medicine * Science Partner Journals * AUTHORS & REVIEWERS * Information for Authors * Information for Reviewers * LIBRARIANS * Manage Your Institutional Subscription * Library Admin Portal * Request a Quote * Librarian FAQs * ADVERTISERS * Advertising Kits * Custom Publishing Info * Post a Job * RELATED SITES * AAAS.org * AAAS Communities * EurekAlert! * Science in the Classroom * ABOUT US * Leadership * Work at AAAS * Prizes and Awards * HELP * FAQs * Access and Subscriptions * Order a Single Issue * Reprints and Permissions * TOC Alerts and RSS Feeds * Contact Us Follow Us * * * * * * AAAS logo (c) 2022 American Association for the Advancement of Science. All rights reserved. AAAS is a partner of HINARI, AGORA, OARE, CHORUS, CLOCKSS, CrossRef and COUNTER. back to top * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Accessibility Thank you for reading News fromScience. You have reached your limit of 3 free news stories in the past 30 days. To gain unlimited access to News fromScience, pleaseLog inor subscribe to News from Science. AAAS Members canLog infor unlimited access. $2.99/Month$25/YearFrequently Asked Questions