https://www.science.org/content/article/fruit-eating-responsible-big-brains Advertisement * * news * careers * commentary * Journals * Covid-19 Science Science * * * Log in * Become A Member [science] science [sciadv] science advances [sciimmunol] science immunology [scirobotics] science robotics [signaling] science signaling [stm] science translational medicine [spj-cover] science partner journals Quick Search anywhere Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Searching: Anywhere AnywhereScienceScience AdvancesScience ImmunologyScience Robotics Science SignalingScience Translational Medicine Advanced Search Search Trending Terms: * covid-19 * climate * monkeypox * abortion * perovskite Log In Become A Member Quick Search anywhere Enter Search Term[ ] science.org * Custom publishing * collections * videos * podcasts * blogs * visualizations * prizes and awards * authors & reviewers * librarians * advertisers * about * help * * * * * * AAAS Logo * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Accessibility * News Home * All News * ScienceInsider * News Features GET OUR E-ALERTS HomeNewsAll NewsIs fruit eating responsible for big brains? Back To All News * News * Evolution Is fruit eating responsible for big brains? Controversial study suggests diet, not social life, drove brain evolution * 27 Mar 2017 * ByLizzie Wade spider monkey hanging from a tree with his tail as he eats a ripe mango Fruit-eating spider monkeys have bigger brains than their leaf-eating counterparts.Wollertz/shutterstock Share: * Twitter * Linked In * Facebook * Reddit * Wechat * Email Ask any biologist what makes primates special, and they'll tell you the same thing: big brains. Those impressive noggins make it possible for primates from spider monkeys to humans to use tools, find food, and navigate the complex relationships of group living. But scientists disagree on what drove primates to evolve big brains in the first place. Now, a new study comes to an unexpected conclusion: fruit. "The paper is enormously valuable," says Richard Wrangham, a biological anthropologist at Harvard University who was not involved in the work. For the last 20 years, many scientists have argued that primates evolved bigger brains to live in bigger groups, an idea known as the "social brain hypothesis." The new study's large sample size and robust statistical methods suggest diet and ecology deserve more attention, Wrangham says. But not everyone is convinced. Others say that although a nutrient-rich diet allows for bigger brains, it wouldn't be enough by itself to serve as a selective evolutionary pressure. When the authors compare diet and social life, "they're comparing apples and oranges," says Robin Dunbar, an evolutionary psychologist at the University of Oxford in the United Kingdom and one of the original authors of the social brain hypothesis. Alex DeCasien, the new study's author, didn't set out to shake up this decades-long debate. The doctoral student in biological anthropology at New York University in New York City wanted to tease out whether monogamous primates had bigger or smaller brains than more promiscuous species. She collected data about the diets and social lives of more than 140 species across all four primate groups--monkeys, apes, lorises, and lemurs--and calculated which features were more likely to be associated with bigger brains. To her surprise, neither monogamy nor promiscuity predicted anything about a primate's brain size. Neither did any other measure of social complexity, such as group size. The only factor that seemed to predict which species had larger brains was whether their diets were primarily leaves or fruit, DeCasien and her colleagues report today in Nature Ecology & Evolution. That doesn't actually surprise Dunbar. "In order to have a bigger brain, you have to have a change in diet," he says. Leaves' nutrients are locked up behind thick cell walls, and breaking down those barriers takes a lot of time and energy. Primates that eat leaves have to lie around for hours, with all their energy going toward digestion. Eating fruit, on the other hand, offers an animal a jolt of calories in an easy-to-digest package. In primates, the main beneficiary of all that newly available energy is the brain. So far so good. But for Dunbar, a key question remains: Why was that energy directed toward developing a bigger brain, and not some other body part? That's where primates' complex social lives come in, he says. Living in big groups makes it easier for primates to fend off predators, but it also means managing increasingly complex social relationships. The cognitive demands of those relationships made bigger brains the best use of the extra fruit-derived energy. Better diets merely provided the fuel for that evolutionary change. "[Diet and sociality] are not alternative explanations" for larger brains, Dunbar says. "They are complementary explanations." DeCasien sees another possibility, one that keeps fruit-eating in the driver's seat. Eating fruit is more cognitively challenging than eating leaves, she says. A primate can find leaves basically anywhere, but it must remember where and when the best fruit is likely to grow. Fruit eaters also range over larger areas than leaf eaters, so they need top-notch navigation skills. And because some fruits may be hard to reach or protected by defenses like spines, primates also need problem solving skills or even tools. Evolution could have pushed fruit-eating primates to develop bigger brains to deal with these complex foraging conditions, DeCasien says. In that case, social life might be largely irrelevant. DeCasien admits the answer might not be black and white. Diets could have jump-started brain growth, enabling the first inklings of more complex social lives. The cognitive demands of those social lives, in turn, could have further driven evolution. "It's definitely impossible to tease apart at some point," she says. Any of these stories are plausible, Wrangham says, but it's notoriously hard to distinguish selective pressures from beneficial physiological changes in correlation studies like this one. He suspects that diet allowed, rather than drove, the evolution of big brains. But he's convinced that diet is intimately tied to evolution, especially in a particular species of primate: humans. "Cooking is what has taken the human lineage into a totally new realm," he says, especially after we learned to cook meat. The new study supports this history of diet-linked cognitive leaps, he says, and he hopes it will bring renewed attention to diet's role in evolution. --------------------------------------------------------------------- doi: 10.1126/science.aal0962 Relevant tags: EvolutionPlants & Animals About the author Lizzie Wade Lizzie Wade mailTwitter Author Lizzie is a contributing correspondent to Science, covering archaeology --------------------------------------------------------------------- More from news illustration of an unlocked padlock with researchers and documents inside 26 Aug 2022 White House requires immediate public access to all U.S.-funded research papers by 2025 By * Jeffrey Brainard, Jocelyn Kaiser Rochelle Walensky testifies during a Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee hearing 26 Aug 2022 'It's an incredible place': CDC Director Rochelle Walensky on how she hopes to reform her battered agency By * Jon Cohen Tucker Carlson delivers his monologue about Anthony Fauci 26 Aug 2022 Almost everything Tucker Carlson said about Anthony Fauci this week was misleading or false By * Jon Cohen View more Got a tip for Science's news department? Connect ScienceInsider illustration of an unlocked padlock with researchers and documents inside 26 Aug 2022By * Jeffrey Brainard, Jocelyn Kaiser White House requires immediate public access to all U.S.-funded research papers by 2025 Rochelle Walensky testifies during a Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee hearing 26 Aug 2022By * Jon Cohen 'It's an incredible place': CDC Director Rochelle Walensky on how she hopes to reform her battered agency Tucker Carlson delivers his monologue about Anthony Fauci 26 Aug 2022By * Jon Cohen Almost everything Tucker Carlson said about Anthony Fauci this week was misleading or false Quercus tardfolia, an oak tree thought to be extinct, found by researchers in July in Big Bend National Park 24 Aug 2022By * Gabriel Popkin Up to 135 U.S. tree species face extinction--and just eight enjoy federal protection View more Sifter photo of two embryos side by side 25 Aug 2022By * Mitch Leslie New synthetic mouse embryos grown in lab Drought conditions at Dinosaur Valley State Park have exposed previously hidden dinosaur tracks, such as those of the Acrocanthosaurus. 25 Aug 2022By * Jacklin Kwan Texas drought uncovers dinosaur footprints from 113 million years ago four sets of nearly identical faces 24 Aug 2022By * Jocelyn Kaiser Those doppelgangers don't just look like you--they may share your DNA dog smiling 22 Aug 2022By * David Grimm Do dogs cry 'happy tears' when reunited with owners? View more RecommendedClose News FocusOctober 2012 Why Are Our Brains So Big? [sn-rawdiet] 22 Oct 2012By * Ann Gibbons Raw Food Not Enough to Feed Big Brains News of the WeekSeptember 2001 New Route to Big Brains [2001050931] 9 May 2001By * Dan Ferber Making Sense of Big Brains Subscribe to News from Science Don't yet have access? Subscribe to News from Science for full access to breaking news and analysis on research and science policy. Subscribe Support nonprofit science journalism Help News from Science publish trustworthy, high-impact stories about research and the people who shape it. Please make a tax-deductible gift today. Donate [logo-dark] x ( ) $25 (*) $50 ( ) $100 ( ) Other $ [ ] Please enter a valid email (*) Single ( ) Monthly Email: [ ] Please enter a valid email Country: [United States ] [ ] I also wish to receive emails from AAAS/Science and Science advertisers, including information on products, services and special offers which may include but are not limited to news, careers information & upcoming events. Donate now Support nonprofit science journalism If we've learned anything from the COVID-19 pandemic, it's that we cannot wait for a crisis to respond. Science and AAAS are working tirelessly to provide credible, evidence-based information on the latest scientific research and policy, with extensive free coverage of the pandemic. Your tax-deductible contribution plays a critical role in sustaining this effort. Charitable Disclosures Loading... Skip slideshow Follow Us * * * * * * * NEWS * All News * ScienceInsider * News Features * Subscribe to News from Science * News from Science FAQ * About News from Science * CAREERS * Careers Articles * Find Jobs * Employer Profiles * COMMENTARY * Opinion * Analysis * Blogs * JOURNALS * Science * Science Advances * Science Immunology * Science Robotics * Science Signaling * Science Translational Medicine * Science Partner Journals * AUTHORS & REVIEWERS * Information for Authors * Information for Reviewers * LIBRARIANS * Manage Your Institutional Subscription * Library Admin Portal * Request a Quote * Librarian FAQs * ADVERTISERS * Advertising Kits * Custom Publishing Info * Post a Job * RELATED SITES * AAAS.org * AAAS Communities * EurekAlert! * Science in the Classroom * ABOUT US * Leadership * Work at AAAS * Prizes and Awards * HELP * FAQs * Access and Subscriptions * Order a Single Issue * Reprints and Permissions * TOC Alerts and RSS Feeds * Contact Us Follow Us * * * * * * AAAS logo (c) 2022 American Association for the Advancement of Science. All rights reserved. AAAS is a partner of HINARI, AGORA, OARE, CHORUS, CLOCKSS, CrossRef and COUNTER. back to top * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Accessibility Thank you for reading News fromScience. You have reached your limit of 5 free news stories in the past 30 days. To gain unlimited access to News fromScience, pleaseLog inor subscribe to News from Science. AAAS Members canLog infor unlimited access. $2.99/Month$25/YearFrequently Asked Questions