https://www.theregister.com/2022/08/11/google_political_spam/ [user] [user] Sign in The Register(r) -- Biting the hand that feeds IT [magn] [burg] [burg] Topics Security Security All SecurityCyber-crimePatchesResearchCSO (X) Off-Prem Off-Prem All Off-PremEdge + IoTChannelPaaS + IaaSSaaS (X) On-Prem On-Prem All On-PremSystemsStorageNetworksHPCPersonal Tech (X) Software Software All SoftwareAI + MLApplicationsDatabasesDevOpsOSesVirtualization (X) Offbeat Offbeat All OffbeatDebatesColumnistsScienceGeek's GuideBOFHLegalBootnotesSite NewsAbout Us (X) Vendor Voice Vendor Voice Vendor Voice All Vendor VoiceAmazon Web Services (AWS) Business Transformation CofenseGoogle CloudGoogle Cloud & The FAOutsystemsProofpointRapid7 (X) Resources Resources Whitepapers Webinars Newsletters [personalte] Personal Tech Google gets the green light to flood US Gmail inboxes with political spam Federal Election Commission votes to let Google allow campaign email through filters Thomas Claburn in San Francisco Thu 11 Aug 2022 // 20:01 UTC 7 comment bubble on white --------------------------------------------------------------------- 7 comment bubble on white # reddit Twitter Facebook linkedin WhatsApp email [https://www.theregis] Copy The US Federal Election Commission on Thursday voted 4-1 to allow Google to create a program exempting qualified political email from Gmail spam filtering, despite emphatic objections from email users. The ad giant floated its proposal [PDF] after Republicans claimed Gmail's spam filtering is biased against them, and the party's lawmakers introduced a bill called the Political Bias in Algorithm Sorting (BIAS) Emails Act to punish Big Tech. Republicans seized upon an academic study [PDF] released in March to support their claims that Gmail is biased against them. The authors of the study, however, have insisted their study doesn't say that, and may prove the opposite. Google has challenged the study for supposed methodological flaws and a limited sample size. [personalte] Nonetheless, Republicans have managed to get Google to respond to their demands, echoing the political playbook during the Trump administration of claiming that Republican voices were being silenced by content moderation. [personalte] [personalte] At the FEC hearing on Thursday, Google attorney Claire Rajan, from Allen & Overy, insisted Google's spam filtering algorithm is not politically biased and also denied that the company's proposed politician email spam exemption was the result of political pressure. Rajan defended Google's now-approved program by suggesting it's simply part of the company's normal product development cycle. [personalte] "The purpose of asking for the pilot program is really that Google is constantly iterating and looking at ways to improve all of its products, including Gmail," said Rajan. "And it's looking to do that to enhance the user experience and to consider whether these modifications enhance or degrade the user experience." Google might gain some insight into what email users think about the prospect of allowing political messages to bypass spam filters if it reviewed the comments submitted to the FEC in opposition to the idea. Listen to the users For example, among the 39 comments sent to the FEC in this file [PDF] dated August 3, every single message opposes Google's proposal. The comments look largely like this, but with more capital letters: "This is a terrible idea. DO NOT approve this proposal. I don't care what political party is impacted." * Google said to be taking steps to keep political campaign emails out of Gmail spam bin * Google has more reasons why it doesn't like antitrust law that affects Google * Compsci guru wants 'right to be forgotten' for old email, urges Google and friends to expire, reveal crypto-keys * Google Mail outage: Did you see that error message last night? Why the 'account does not exist' response is a worry Another tranche of 85 comments about Google's proposal in a file [PDF] dated August 8 is similarly unanimous in its resistance to the idea. Not one person in the selection of messages wants more political spam; every one of the comments is opposed, many vehemently. Josh Nelson, CEO of Civic Shout, a petitioning service focused on progressive causes, condemned the FEC decision. "The FEC's vote today to greenlight Google's plan was misguided and deeply unfortunate," said Nelson told The Register. "Now the fight moves to Google." "Google should be aware that if it decides to move forward with its ridiculous and wildly unpopular plan to allow political campaigns to send spam email without consequence, it will face unprecedented backlash from its users, who overwhelmingly do not want this change to happen." [personalte] In a letter [PDF] to the FEC, Nelson argued that Google's proposal amounts to an in-kind contribution to Republican campaigns and rewards "disingenuous claims of Big Tech bias." FEC staff last week issued an advisory opinion [PDF] finding that Google's program would not amount to an in-kind contribution. Nelson said 15,000 people signed a petition at Civic Shout urging the FEC to reject Google's proposal. "Google is doing this in direct response to disingenuous Republican claims that the company is biased, in a blatant attempt to ward off legislation regulating their service," Nelson told The Register. "There's zero chance Gmail would be doing this if Republicans hadn't spent the past five months pressuring them to do so." (r) Get our Tech Resources # Share reddit Twitter Facebook linkedin WhatsApp email [https://www.theregis] Copy 7 Comments Similar topics * Email * Google * Government * Politics * Spamming Broader topics * Alphabet * Network * Search Engine * Sector * Security Narrower topics * Android * App stores * Chrome * Chromium * Exchange Server * Federal government of the United States * Google AI * Google Cloud Platform * Google Nest * Government of the United Kingdom * G Suite * Insider Trading * Kubernetes * Privacy Sandbox * Tavis Ormandy Corrections Send us news --------------------------------------------------------------------- Other stories you might like Google sues Sonos yet again, claiming it stole IP and infringed patents Patent lawsuits, the next saga Personal Tech8 Aug 2022 | 33 Student crashes Cloudflare beta party, redirects email, bags a bug bounty Simple to exploit, enough to pocket $3,000 Research4 Aug 2022 | 8 Bloke robbed of $800,000 in cryptocurrency by fake wallet app wants payback from Google I got played via the Play store Cyber-crime4 Aug 2022 | 57 At the edge, nobody can hear your IoT devices scream ... Red Hat's approach to locking down remote industrial networks and data processing facilities Sponsored Feature [personalte] Google hit with lawsuit for dropping free Workspace apps Free Forever, or Free Until We Decide It Isn't policy criticised in filing Legal8 Aug 2022 | 42 Google tells Apple to 'fix text messaging' in bid to promote RCS protocol iMessage talks to Android users via outdated SMS/MMS, ad giant complains Software10 Aug 2022 | 75 President Biden signs CHIPS and Science Act into law American semiconductor manufacturing is back, baby! Legal9 Aug 2022 | 15 Google postpones Chrome's third-party cookie bonfire yet again Construction delays for web giant's Privacy Sandbox keep these bickies on the menu Personal Tech28 Jul 2022 | 29 Ex-CISA chief Krebs calls for US to get serious on security Black Hat Black Hat kicks off with call for single infosec agency with real clout and less confused crossover Security10 Aug 2022 | 9 Google's bug bounty boss: Finding and patching vulns? 'Totally useless' Disclosing exploits, however, will earn you $100k Security10 Aug 2022 | 12 Google brings Street View back to India following 2016 ban This time local companies provide the images and there's no mention of national security worries Security28 Jul 2022 | 10 South Korean regulator worried Apple, Google, may be working around app store payment choice law Feels some actions may amount to coercion to stick with giants' own payment schemes Legal10 Aug 2022 | 9 ABOUT US* * Who we are * Under the hood * Contact us * Advertise with us MORE CONTENT* * Latest News * Popular Stories * Forums * Whitepapers * Webinars SITUATION PUBLISHING* * The Next Platform * DevClass * Blocks and Files * Continuous Lifecycle London * M-cubed Situation Publishing The Register - Independent news and views for the tech community. Part of Situation Publishing SIGN UP TO OUR DAILY NEWSLETTER Subscribe Twitter Facebook LinkedIn feeds no-js Biting the hand that feeds IT (c) 1998-2022 Do not sell my personal information Cookies Privacy Ts&Cs