https://www.wired.com/story/tor-browser-russia-blocks/ Skip to main content Open Navigation Menu To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Close Alert WIRED How Tor Is Fighting--and Beating--Russian Censorship * Backchannel * Business * Culture * Gear * Ideas * Science * Security More To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Close Alert Sign In Search * Backchannel * Business * Culture * Gear * Ideas * Science * Security * Podcasts * Video * Artificial Intelligence * Climate * Games * Newsletters * Magazine * Events * Wired Insider * Coupons Matt Burgess Security Jul 28, 2022 10:34 AM How Tor Is Fighting--and Beating--Russian Censorship Russia has been trying to block the anonymous browser since December--with mixed results. * * * * To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories . Closeup of red lines on a redacted document Photograph: shaunl/Getty Images * * * * To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories . For years, the anonymity service Tor has been the best way to stay private online and dodge web censorship. Much to the ire of governments and law enforcement agencies, Tor encrypts your web traffic and sends it through a chain of computers, making it very hard for people to track you online. Authoritarian governments see it as a particular threat to their longevity, and in recent months, Russia has stepped up its long-term ambition to block Tor--although not without a fight. In December 2021, Russia's media regulator, Roskomnadzor, enacted a 4-year-old court order that allows it to order internet service providers (ISPs) to block the Tor Project website, where the Tor Browser can be downloaded, and restrict access to its services. Since then, censors have been locked in a battle with Tor's technical team and users in Russia, who are pushing to keep the Tor network online and allow people to access the uncensored web, which is otherwise heavily restricted in the country. Russia's efforts to block Tor come in two flavors: the technical and the political. So far, Tor has had some success on both fronts. It has found ways to avoid Russian blocking efforts, and this month, it was removed from Russia's list of blocked websites following a legal challenge. (Although this doesn't mean blocking efforts will instantly end.) "We are being attacked by the Russian government, they are trying to block Tor," says Gustavo Gus, community team lead of the Tor Project. The past few months have seen Russian officials adapt their tactics, Gus says, while the Tor Project's anti-censorship engineers have successfully launched updates to stop its services from being blocked. "The fight is not over," Gus says. "People can connect to Tor. People can easily bypass censorship." In Russia, the internet infrastructure is relatively decentralized: ISPs can receive blocking orders from Roskomnadzor, but it's up to individual companies to implement them. (China is the only country to have effectively blocked Tor, which was possible due to more centralized internet control). While Russian authorities have been installing new equipment that uses deep packet inspection to monitor and block online services, the effectiveness of these blocks is mixed. "The censorship that's happening in Russia is not constant and uniform," Gus says. Gus explains that because of different ISPs, Tor may be blocked for some people but not others, even those in the same city. Both Tor's metrics and external analysis appear to show the dwindling effectiveness of Russian censorship. Tor's data shows that since the end of 2021 there has been a big drop in the number of people directly connecting to Tor in Russia. However, people are able to connect to its services using volunteer-run bridges--entry points to the network that can't easily be blocked, as their details aren't public--and Tor's anti-censorship tool Snowflake. External data from the internet monitoring group Open Observatory of Network Interference shows a big rise in people in Russia accessing Tor using Snowflake. Most Popular * Mississippi Delta science The Controversial Plan to Unleash the Mississippi River Boyce Upholt * vaccine viles science These Vaccines Will Take Aim at Covid--and Its Entire SARS Lineage Maggie Chen * smear of white cream science After Roe, Men Might Finally Get Better Birth Control Emily Mullin * colorful still life with pill bottle, powders and other shapes backchannel The High-Stakes Race to Engineer New Psychedelic Drugs John Semley * Since the start of Russia's war with Ukraine in February, Russian officials have introduced a slurry of new laws to control the internet and have clamped down on civil society groups. Natalia Krapiva, tech legal counsel at NGO Access Now, says Russia blocking Tor is part of larger efforts to control people's access to information, such as the Kremlin's VPN clampdown. "Russia is trying to eliminate any possible sources of truthful alternative information about the war and about what is going on in Russia internally," Krapiva says. This feeds into a "chilling effect," where people change their behavior or self-censor. "Certain measures, even if they don't directly block or censor, create this fear of retaliation and fear of consequences coming later on." There have been two major incidents against Tor's Snowflake, Gus says. The first, in December, was fixed within 10 days. The second, in May of this year, was also patched shortly after it was discovered. "They were blocking Snowflake in different ways," Gus says. These attacks against Snowflake often involve fingerprinting, which uses small details about browsers and internet connections to try and uniquely identify the technology that someone is using. For instance, the number of times a browser connects with an external source may make it stand out from other browsers. If Snowflake can be identified, it is easier to block. Gus claims that some of the censorship efforts are being conducted by hand. "I have some evidence that they are doing that manually," he says. Gus claims it is likely that some officials in Russia appear to be downloading Tor and then fetching bridges so they can then take steps to block access. "They try to simulate that they are a user so they can get the bridge address, and then they block it," he says. Roskomnadzor, the Russian internet regulator, had not replied to a request for comment at the time of publication. The latest version of the Tor browser, 11.5, which was released last week, introduces new features to automatically try to help people circumvent censorship based on their location. In addition to issuing updates to circumvent the way Tor is being blocked, the nonprofit technology organization has also been directly gathering information from people in Russia. Gus says it has introduced more support for Russian users, who can report back if they are being blocked. There are also more volunteer-run bridges that people in Russia can use to access Tor. Gus also says that using Telegram to share details of Tor bridges has been effective in fighting blocks. "The bridges that they were blocking were not the same bridges that we were sharing with users," Gus says, adding that Tor has plans to share bridges via Signal and WhatsApp in the future. Tor is also working to stop the potential abuse of bridges. In 2016, researchers proposed a system called Salmon that aims to weed out those accessing bridge details with the intent of blocking or abusing them. Gus says the Tor team is working to turn this proposal into reality, and it would essentially assign "reliability" scores around the use of bridges. If someone requests a bridge and it ends up getting blocked, they may be considered less trustworthy. "If I give you another bridge and it gets blocked again, then you will get another bad score," Gus says. Most Popular * Mississippi Delta science The Controversial Plan to Unleash the Mississippi River Boyce Upholt * vaccine viles science These Vaccines Will Take Aim at Covid--and Its Entire SARS Lineage Maggie Chen * smear of white cream science After Roe, Men Might Finally Get Better Birth Control Emily Mullin * colorful still life with pill bottle, powders and other shapes backchannel The High-Stakes Race to Engineer New Psychedelic Drugs John Semley * Russia's efforts to block Tor aren't just confined to within its own borders, though. In some areas of occupied Ukraine, such as the city of Kherson, Ukrainian internet connections are being rerouted through Russian networks, and that brings censorship and surveillance with it. Gus says that as this shift has started to happen--signaling a potential long-term occupation and "Russification" of the areas--people using Tor in Ukraine have reported it not working and websites not loading. "They are being affected by the same censorship that people in other places in Russia were reporting to us," Gus says. If people are able to access Tor--both in Russia and occupied Ukraine--they will be able to access news and information that isn't controlled by the Russian government. Sarkis Darbinyan, head of legal practice of Russian digital rights group Roskomsvoboda, says more than 5,500 websites have been blocked in Russia since its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February. "For getting access to truthful information for Russian users, it is now critical to have tools like VPN and Tor, which let people quickly and effectively restore their violated rights," Darbinyan says. Roskomsvoboda has been representing Tor in its legal cases against Russian authorities pro bono. So far it has successfully overturned Roskomnadzor's December decision to block Tor--in part because of procedural issues. Although other related legal proceedings are ongoing, Darbinyan says Roskomsvoboda is seeking a "complete cancel" of the decision that Tor should be blocked. Krapiva describes the court case against Tor as a "rare victory" for digital and human rights in Russia. However, she cautions that it is likely to be a "temporary" win, and that Russian authorities may try to legally block Tor again. But this doesn't mean it will be able to stop people from using Tor. "We're still seeing that the technologies they have can be quite effective for blocking some things, but are not 100 percent effective," Krapiva says. "In practice, whether Tor will be fully blocked--I doubt it, to be honest. But legally, I think they will try again, and might eventually succeed." More Great WIRED Stories * The latest on tech, science, and more: Get our newsletters! * Meet the lobbyist next door * The "shamanification" of the tech CEO * The first--and last--time we rank the Star Wars movies * The secrets of Covid "brain fog" are starting to lift * The danger of license plate readers in post-Roe America * [?] Explore AI like never before with our new database * Optimize your home life with our Gear team's best picks, from robot vacuums to affordable mattresses to smart speakers Matt Burgess is a senior writer at WIRED focused on information security, privacy, and data regulation in Europe. He graduated from the University of Sheffield with a degree in journalism and now lives in London. Send tips to Matt_Burgess@wired.com. Senior writer * TopicscensorshipRussiaTorencryption More from WIRED An eye mischievously peeks through a Bitcoin B next to the words THE CRYPTO TRAP. The Bitcoin Bust That Took Down the Web's Biggest Child Abuse Site They thought their payments were untraceable. They couldn't have been more wrong. The untold story of the case that shredded the myth of Bitcoin's anonymity. Andy Greenberg Four colored balls (blue, red, yellow, green) illuminated by a line of light in a dark room How to Remove Your Personal Info From Google's Search Results Maybe you don't want your phone number, email, home address, and other details out there for all the web to see. Here's how to make them vanish. Reece Rogers Fingerprint shown through infrared camera in orange and yellow light A Sinister Way to Beat Multifactor Authentication Is on the Rise Lapsus$ and the group behind the SolarWinds hack have utilized prompt bombing to defeat weaker MFA protections in recent months. Dan Goodin, Ars Technica Chain reaction of dominoes falling Russia Is Being Hacked at an Unprecedented Scale From "IT Army" DDoS attacks to custom malware, the country has become a target like never before. Matt Burgess ball in center Google Warns of New Spyware Targeting iOS and Android Users The spyware has been used to target people in Italy, Kazakhstan, and Syria, researchers at Google and Lookout have found. Lily Hay Newman Thousands of abortion-rights activists gather in front of the U.S. Supreme Court The Post-Roe Privacy Nightmare Has Arrived Plus: Microsoft details Russia's Ukraine hacking campaign, Meta's election integrity efforts dwindle, and more. Andrew Couts Photo-illustration of handing appearing through hole to steal password asterisk icon Apple Just Killed the Password--for Real This Time Apple's iOS 16 and macOS Ventura will introduce passwordless login for apps and websites. It's only the beginning. Matt Burgess Internet Explorer icon on computer screen The Ghost of Internet Explorer Will Haunt the Web for Years Microsoft's legacy browser may be dead--but its remnants are not going anywhere, and neither are its lingering security risks. Lily Hay Newman WIRED WIRED is where tomorrow is realized. It is the essential source of information and ideas that make sense of a world in constant transformation. The WIRED conversation illuminates how technology is changing every aspect of our lives--from culture to business, science to design. The breakthroughs and innovations that we uncover lead to new ways of thinking, new connections, and new industries. * * * * * * More From WIRED * Subscribe * Newsletters * FAQ * Wired Staff * Press Center * Coupons * Editorial Standards Contact * Advertise * Contact Us * Customer Care * Jobs * RSS * Site Map * Accessibility Help * Conde Nast Store * Conde Nast Spotlight * Do Not Sell My Personal Info (c) 2022 Conde Nast. All rights reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights. Wired may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Conde Nast. Ad Choices