https://www.carwow.co.uk/blog/how-to-replace-fuel-duty-and-road-tax * New * Used * Sell * Sell * Electric * Leasing * Reviews ( ) ( ) * Your account + Part exchange + Settings + Archived cars + Report a purchase + Log out * Log in * Build new car * Browse in-stock new & used cars * Browse leasing deals * Sell your car * New car reviews * New car reviews + Car reviews + By make o Abarth o Alfa Romeo o Alpine o Aston Martin o Audi o Bentley o BMW o Citroen o Cupra o Dacia o DS o Fiat o Ford o Honda o Hyundai o Infiniti o Jaguar o Jeep o Kia o Land Rover o Lexus o Maserati o Mazda o McLaren o Mercedes o MG o MINI o Mitsubishi o Nissan o Peugeot o Polestar o Porsche o Renault o SEAT o Skoda o Smart o SsangYong o Subaru o Suzuki o Tesla o Toyota o Vauxhall o Volkswagen o Volvo Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser + By type o 4x4 Cars o 7-Seater Cars o Automatic Cars o Cheap Cars o Convertibles o Coupes o Crossovers o Economical Cars o Electric Cars o Estate Cars o Family Cars o First Cars o Hatchbacks o Hot Hatches o Hybrid Cars o Luxury Cars o MPVs o Motability Cars o SUVs o Saloon Cars o Small Cars o Sports Cars Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser + By popular models o Audi A1 Sportback o Audi A3 Sportback o BMW 1 Series o BMW 3 Series o Ford Fiesta o Ford Kuga o Ford Puma o Hyundai Tucson o Kia Sportage o Kia e-Niro o Land Rover Discovery o Mercedes A-Class o Nissan Leaf o Peugeot 3008 o Range Rover Evoque o Range Rover Sport o Skoda Enyaq o Skoda Karoq o Skoda Kodiaq o Tesla Model 3 o Toyota RAV4 Hybrid o Vauxhall Corsa-e o Vauxhall Mokka-e o Volkswagen Golf o Volkswagen ID.3 o Volkswagen ID.4 o Volkswagen Polo o Volkswagen T-Roc o Volkswagen Tiguan o Volvo XC40 o Volvo XC60 Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser + Nearly new + New car tools & offers o Car chooser o Compare cars side-by-side o New car delivery times o Fuel chooser o PCP calculator Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser * Used cars + Used cars + By make o Used Abarth cars o Used Alfa Romeo cars o Used Aston Martin cars o Used Audi cars o Used BMW cars o Used Bentley cars o Used Citroen cars o Used Cupra cars o Used DS cars o Used Dacia cars o Used Fiat cars o Used Ford cars o Used Honda cars o Used Hyundai cars o Used Infiniti cars o Used Jaguar cars o Used Jeep cars o Used Kia cars o Used Land Rover cars o Used Lexus cars o Used MG cars o Used MINI cars o Used Maserati cars o Used Mazda cars o Used McLaren cars o Used Mercedes cars o Used Mitsubishi cars o Used Nissan cars o Used Peugeot cars o Used Polestar cars o Used Porsche cars o Used Renault cars o Used SEAT cars o Used Skoda cars o Used Smart cars o Used SsangYong cars o Used Subaru cars o Used Suzuki cars o Used Tesla cars o Used Toyota cars o Used Vauxhall cars o Used Volkswagen cars o Used Volvo cars Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser + By popular models o Used Volkswagen Up o Used Volkswagen Polo o Used Ford Fiesta o Used Skoda Fabia o Used Audi A1 Sportback o Used Toyota Yaris Hybrid o Used Skoda Karoq o Used Mercedes A-Class o Used Volkswagen Golf o Used BMW 1 Series o Used Volvo XC40 o Used Volkswagen Tiguan o Used Skoda Kodiaq o Used BMW 2 Series o Used BMW X1 o Used Audi Q3 o Used BMW M140i (2015-2019) o Used Audi A4 o Used Range Rover Evoque o Used BMW 3 Series o Used Mercedes CLA o Used Discovery Sport o Used Mercedes C-Class Saloon o Used Audi A4 Avant o Used Mercedes GLA o Used Audi Q5 o Used BMW X3 o Used Volkswagen Golf R Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser * Car leasing + Car leasing + By make o Abarth lease deals o Alfa Romeo lease deals o Audi lease deals o BMW lease deals o Citroen lease deals o Dacia lease deals o Fiat lease deals o Ford lease deals o Honda lease deals o Hyundai lease deals o Jaguar lease deals o Jeep lease deals o Kia lease deals o Land Rover lease deals o Lexus lease deals o MG lease deals o MINI lease deals o Maserati lease deals o Mazda lease deals o Mercedes lease deals o Nissan lease deals o Peugeot lease deals o Porsche lease deals o Renault lease deals o SEAT lease deals o Skoda lease deals o Smart lease deals o Suzuki lease deals o Tesla lease deals o Toyota lease deals o Vauxhall lease deals o Volkswagen lease deals o Volvo lease deals o Cupra lease deals o DS lease deals o Polestar lease deals Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser + By type o 7-seater car lease deals o Electric car lease deals o Hybrid car lease deals o Small car lease deals o SUV lease deals Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser + By popular models o Vauxhall Corsa lease deals o Ford Fiesta lease deals o Volkswagen Polo lease deals o Skoda Kamiq lease deals o Audi A1 Sportback lease deals o Nissan Juke lease deals o Peugeot 2008 lease deals o Ford Focus lease deals o Ford Puma lease deals o Volkswagen Golf lease deals o Audi A3 Sportback lease deals o Volkswagen T-Roc lease deals o Nissan Qashqai lease deals o BMW 1 Series lease deals o Kia Sportage lease deals o Mercedes A-Class lease deals o BMW 2 Series Gran Coupe lease deals o Hyundai Tucson lease deals o Toyota C-HR lease deals o Volkswagen Tiguan lease deals o Mercedes A-Class Saloon lease deals o Ford Kuga lease deals o Volkswagen ID.3 lease deals o Range Rover Evoque lease deals o BMW 3 Series lease deals o Volvo XC40 lease deals o Volkswagen Golf GTI lease deals o Mercedes GLB lease deals o Volkswagen Golf R lease deals o Jaguar F-PACE lease deals o Range Rover Velar lease deals o Tesla Model 3 lease deals o Discovery lease deals o Audi Q7 lease deals o Defender lease deals o Range Rover Sport lease deals Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser * Car deals + Car deals + By make o Abarth Deals o Alfa Romeo Deals o Alpine Deals o Audi Deals o BMW Deals o Citroen Deals o Cupra Deals o DS Deals o Dacia Deals o Fiat Deals o Ford Deals o Honda Deals o Hyundai Deals o Jaguar Deals o Jeep Deals o Kia Deals o Land Rover Deals o Lexus Deals o MG Deals o MINI Deals o Mazda Deals o Mercedes Deals o Nissan Deals o Peugeot Deals o Renault Deals o SEAT Deals o Skoda Deals o Smart Deals o SsangYong Deals o Subaru Deals o Suzuki Deals o Tesla Deals o Toyota Deals o Vauxhall Deals o Volkswagen Deals o Volvo Deals Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser + By popular models o Dacia Sandero Deals o Dacia Duster Deals o Vauxhall Corsa Deals o Ford Fiesta Deals o Volkswagen Polo Deals o Ford Puma Deals o Volkswagen Golf Deals o Nissan Qashqai Deals o Kia Sportage Deals o Peugeot 2008 Deals o Nissan Leaf Deals o Hyundai Tucson Deals o Volkswagen Tiguan Deals o Ford Kuga Deals o Cupra Formentor Deals o Hyundai Kona Electric Deals o Mercedes A-Class Deals o MINI Electric Deals o Vauxhall Mokka-e Deals o Skoda Kodiaq Deals o Range Rover Evoque Deals o Peugeot 3008 Deals o Volvo XC40 Deals o Volkswagen ID.4 Deals o Hyundai Ioniq 5 Deals o Jaguar F-PACE Deals o Volvo XC60 Deals o Tesla Model 3 Deals o Volvo XC90 Deals o Audi e-tron Deals Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser + By latest deals o 0% Finance deals o No deposit deals o Cars with cheap insurance deals o Immediate delivery deals o Just add fuel deals o Free insurance deals Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser * Selling + Sell my car + Part exchange + Value my car + Scrap my car * Electric cars + Electric cars + By make o Audi o BMW o Citroen o Cupra o DS o Fiat o Ford o Honda o Hyundai o Jaguar o Kia o Lexus o Mazda o Mercedes o MG o MINI o Nissan o Peugeot o Polestar o Renault o SEAT o Skoda o Smart o Tesla o Toyota o Vauxhall o Volkswagen o Volvo Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser + By type o Best electric cars o Cheap electric cars o Electric cars by range o Electric family cars o Electric SUVs o Small electric cars o Used electric cars Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser + Popular electric models o Audi Q4 e-tron o Fiat 500 Electric o Ford Mustang Mach-E o Hyundai Ioniq 5 o Hyundai Kona Electric o Kia EV6 o MG ZS EV o MINI Electric o Mazda MX-30 o Nissan Leaf o Peugeot e-208 o Renault Zoe o Skoda Enyaq o Tesla Model 3 o Tesla Model Y o Vauxhall Corsa-e o Vauxhall Mokka-e o Volkswagen ID.3 o Volkswagen ID.4 o Volvo XC40 Recharge Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser + Electric car tools o Compare electric car costs o Electric car battery range calculator o Electric car charging map Not sure what you want? Find your perfect car with our Car chooser * Buying guides & news + Car news + Car guides + Best cars + carwow blog Help and support Monday to Friday 8.00 - 18.00 Saturday 9.00 - 17.30 Sundays and Bank Holidays CLOSED + Call: 0800 808 5885 + Email: help@carwow.co.uk Response time usually 4 hours Explore Log in My cars Messages Offers Menu * Home * New * Used * Sell * Sell * Electric * Leasing * Reviews Fuel duty and road tax: how to replace PS35 billion a year of lost revenue July 01, 2022 by Hugo Griffiths [Petrol-e16] The rise of EVs is blowing a big hole in the Government's tax take from cars, but a solution is slow to emerge * Petrol and diesel cars bring in PS35 billion a year through road tax and fuel duty * But EVs generate no fuel duty and are exempt from road tax * As sales of new petrol and diesel end in 2030-35, so will the revenue they provide Nobody likes to imagine that their income is going to be severely curtailed, but that's precisely the scenario facing the UK's HM Revenue and Customs and Treasury as we move to electric cars (EVs) after over a century of petrol and diesel-powered motoring. Background The UK government receives tax revenue from drivers of petrol and diesel cars via two key methods: fuel duty, which brings PS28 billion a year into government coffers, and Vehicle Excise Duty (road tax), which nets roughly PS7 billion. Combined, these sources make up 1.5% of the UK's GDP and account for around 4% of all tax revenue. The Treasury's problem stems from the fact that electric cars pay neither road tax nor fuel duty. So as new cars with petrol and diesel engines are banned from sale between 2030 and 2035, those two income streams face constriction and eventual extinction, representing the "largest fiscal cost" of the UK's net zero ambitions, according to the Office for Budget Responsibility. We know for a fact that the government is working on something to address this issue - it said as much when responding to a 2019 freedom of information request - though it also declined to explain what it was considering, as the information related to "an area of live policy development." The Transport Select Committee (TSC) - a cross-party group of MPs that advises the government - has offered more detail on potential solutions, saying that it "has not seen a viable alternative to a road charging system based on technology which measures road use." The TSC also advised the issue is "urgent", and said the Department for Transport and Treasury (which sets taxation policy) should work together to set out their "preferred options" for replacing fuel duty and road tax. The TSC isn't the only group to think this. The Climate Change Committee (CCC), which advises the government on emissions, recently said: "it will be necessary to introduce some form of road pricing, whereby drivers (of any vehicle type) are charged for how much (and possibly when/where) they drive". But precisely how will this be achieved, and what new schemes will be introduced to replace the PS35 billion that drivers of petrol and diesel cars contribute to the tax chest every year? Missing road tax - a simple problem to fix [] Lost revenue from road tax is an easy problem to solve. At present (in the 2022/23 tax year), the first-year rate of road tax is based on how much carbon dioxide a car emits, and a flat annual rate of PS165 follows that, as does a PS355 surcharge that runs for five years for cars costing more than PS40,000 from new. Electric cars are currently exempt from all three of those road-tax strands, but all the Treasury has to do is end the exemptions, treating EVs as it currently does petrol and diesel vehicles - albeit without a CO2-based element to the first-year tariff. Lost fuel duty - a harder nut to crack Replacing fuel duty is a far trickier problem to solve, and not just because the revenue it brings is higher. At present, for every litre of petrol or diesel you put in your car the taxman takes 52.95 pence, plus a 20% slice of VAT. This is effectively pay-as-you-go taxation, as the more you drive, the more tax you pay. [] The Treasury has even gone so far as to describe fuel duty as a "perfect tax", and there is even a means-tested element to the system, as drivers after economical motoring can seek out small cars with efficient engines, while those able and willing to buy big, potent cars are generally prepared for big, potent fuel bills. But electric cars obviously don't use any petrol or diesel, and with only new EVs and plug-in hybrids able to be sold from 2030, before only zero-emission vehicles can be bought from new in 2035, time is running out for a solution to be devised and implemented, not to mention sold to the motoring public. One answer would simply be to tax the electricity used to charge EVs. This would be a direct replacement for fuel duty, and electricity is already taxed: you pay 5% VAT on home electricity, and 20% VAT when you use a public EV chargepoint. But with charging at home a fact of life for many EV drivers, how do you differentiate the electricity used to charge a car with that used to boil a kettle? Smart home wallbox chargers could in theory tell the electricity grid it was a car being charged, but homeowners could just plug a three-pin extension lead into a normal socket to charge their car, circumventing any such communication between grid and charge. Road pricing is therefore the likely solution to the Treasury's PS35 billion black hole, but this is both complex and potentially unpopular. Road pricing - overview UK drivers are already familiar with road pricing. From the Dartford and Severn Crossing, to London's Congestion Charge and M6 Toll, individual fees for using specific areas or roads may not be as widespread as they are on France's motorway network, for example, but they're reasonably well established and accepted in the limited instances they occur. A nationwide programme of road pricing is more complex, not least because according to the TSC: "the history of road pricing is a history of public unpopularity", to the extent it has been "too toxic a prospect for successive Governments". Three of the most likely methods a nationwide road pricing system could be enacted are: * Charging based on the use of individual routes or road types * Using GPS-based telematics to track and charge road use * Measuring odometers periodically to calculate road use 1. Route taxation Great Britain has 247,500 miles of road. If the route-based pricing were introduced, every single one of those miles would arguably need to be chargeable. Adding tolls just to motorways and major trunk roads could see cost-conscious drivers divert onto smaller roads, with gridlock (and not enough revenue) the result. If a nationwide route-based charging system were introduced, this would most likely be based around automatic number plate recognition (ANPR) cameras, as these are cost-effective and have been widely deployed since the 1990s. []ANPR cameras are widely used and cost effective Disadvantages ANPR cameras would possibly need to be installed at regular intervals on every road and junction though, from the busiest motorway interchange to the smallest rural T-junction. Such a project would undoubtedly be both expensive and unsightly, as landscapes become peppered with poles for cameras; the potential for bridleways and similar paths to be used to circumvent charges would also need to be mitigated against. Leaving these issues aside, the TSC considers it may be "impossible to deliver a national road pricing scheme" due to the numerous devolved tolls and charging zones that already exist in the country. 2. Telematics taxation A more likely solution is one that relies on GPS satellite-based telematics that track where, when and how a vehicle is driven. Indeed, the TSC says it "has not seen a viable alternative to a road pricing system based on telematics." Such technology is also well established, with 'black box' insurance policies being closest to the system that the TSC considers likely to replace fuel duty. Telematic-based taxes would most likely see electronics wired into the car to track when and where a car is driven, with this data used to calculate tax owed. Electric cars could be the first to be subject to such a programme, with petrol and diesel vehicles continuing to be taxed via fuel duty. []Black box telematics trackers are sometimes installed to reduce insurance costs Disadvantages Potential issues related to telematics-based road pricing include: Privacy: Mobile phones already collect vast amounts of data and are widely popular, but the idea of a government knowing when and where the 41 million citizens who hold driving licences are travelling represents a very different proposition, even if data anonymity is promised. Security: With all cars tracked, the opportunities for criminal activity are myriad; data privacy would have to be beyond watertight. Mission creep: Telematics taxation could bring higher charges for driving in urban areas and at peak times, while calculating speed (and issuing speeding penalties) based on time and distance travelled would be a matter of simple mathematics. The perceived possibility of these extensions could make telematics too unpopular to implement. []Telematics systems could in theory issue speeding penalties The TSC itself recommends the government "must examine the role that telematic technology can play in delivering a replacement road pricing mechanism that sets the cost of motoring based on the duration and time of the journey". Technical problems: Drivers have been threatened with cancelled car insurance after they were accused of driving badly despite their car being parked at the time. Extrapolate this to a national level (there are 31 million cars in the UK), and opportunities for errors only increase. Government IT projects are also not renowned for their smooth or on-budget implementation. 3. Odometer taxation Rather than relying on telematics black boxes being installed in cars to log individual journeys, a broader but comparable solution would be for cars' odometers to be read periodically, with drivers charged for how many miles the car has been driven. The big advantage odometer-based taxation would have is that a central system for logging vehicle mileages already exists in the DVSA's MOT database. While cars do not require an MOT until they are three years old, the UK's network of MOT garages could presumably allow for newer cars to check in once or twice a year for mileage readings. [] Few people would be likely to want to pay for a year's worth of road use, but a monthly payment scheme could be introduced, with drivers being refunded or charged extra to mop up any discrepancies between the miles they cover. A similar scheme already exists in New Zealand, where petrol is taxed at the pump, but diesel is not. To make up for this, drivers of diesel vehicles pay a road user charge (RUC), which currently costs $76 per 1,000km driven (PS39 for 621 miles). Drivers buy tickets that log odometer readings from various official outlets, with police spot checks enforcing adherence to the rules. Disadvantages Electric cars are exempt from New Zealand's RUC at present, but conversations have already begun about ending this exemption, or even replacing the RUC scheme with a more GPS telematics system. Part of the reason for this is that odometer-based charging is a relatively blunt instrument: it doesn't allow for the more sophisticated applications telematics or road-based charging offer, such as varying the cost of driving based on what time of day it is, or whether a journey is being made in an area of high congestion. Means testing Whatever system is implemented to replace fuel duty, some degree of means testing - similar to the one that allows drivers to seek out small, efficient petrol and diesel cars cars - will need to be considered. Taxing electricity is likely to be too problematic to implement, so it will not be possible to simply rely on the fact that bigger, heavier, more powerful EVs use more electricity than smaller, lighter, cheaper ones. In fact, some expensive electric cars have better battery chemistries and management systems, and are actually more energy efficient than cheaper EVs. The Treasury may decide to vary the amount it charges for road use based on a number of factors. Cars that weigh more, cost more, have more power or larger battery packs could cost more to drive per mile, or alternatively drivers' incomes could be taken into account. It may also be that road charging is first introduced to electric cars, with fuel duty continuing for petrol and diesel drivers - not least because using vehicle-based measurements such as cost when new, or power, will be difficult if not impossible for older vehicles whose specifications may not be easy to determine. What do we really know? Not much, is the honest answer. The Transport Select Committee has recommended that: "Any alternative road pricing mechanism must be revenue neutral to the Government rather than causing drivers, as a whole, to pay more than they do currently. Such a mechanism should be phased in before fuel duty and vehicle excise duty decline to zero. The situation is urgent; work must begin without delay We asked the Treasury what the current state of play was, and were told: "The government has committed to ensuring that motoring tax revenues keep pace with the changes brought about by the switch to electric vehicles, whilst keeping the transition affordable for consumers. The Treasury added: "We will respond to the [Transport Select] Committee's recommendations in due course." So despite the relative certainty and urgency of the issues faced by the Treasury; the vast scale of any likely solution; and calls from the TSC for "an honest conversation with the public" on the subject, we still have no idea what the actual plans for replacing fuel duty and VED are. All we can do is sit, wait, and hope that whatever plans come about are workable, palatable, affordable, fair and secure. Compare cars using carwow * Compare cars using carwow. * View offers from local and national dealers. * Buy with confidence on carwow. carwow average saving PS2,900 Compare cars using carwow * Compare cars using carwow. * View offers from local and national dealers. * Buy with confidence on carwow. Select a car Like this article? Share it with others! Related articles (*) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs) explained 10 best handling cars Drug driving in the UK: what is the law? 4D number plates: are they legal? Drag race: BMW M240i vs Audi S3 vs MK1 Audi RS3 Are electric cars really better for the environment? Drag race: tuned Nissan GT-R vs EV Rallycross car vs Porsche 911 Turbo S Lamborghini Aventador generations group test: which is best? Business car lease vs personal car lease Hyundai RN22e concept previews future N models: price, specs and release date New MG 5 on sale now: price and specs Kia Sportage vs Nissan Qashqai Electric car glossary - everything you need to know about EVs UK number plates explained: how do they work? BMW 7 Series vs Lexus LS430: tested to destruction As featured on: Help and support Monday to Friday 8.00 - 18.00 Saturday 9.00 - 17.30 Sundays and Bank Holidays CLOSED * Call: 0800 808 5885 * Text: 0753 302 5324 * Email: help@carwow.co.uk Response time usually 4 hours * New car deals * Nearly new cars * Used cars * Car leasing * Car reviews * Car news * Car chooser * Car finance calculator * Compare cars * About us * How it works * Team * Press * Careers * For dealers * Contact us Rated 4.7/5 from 30,060 reviews (c) 2022 carwow Ltd. All rights reserved Terms & conditions Manage cookies Privacy policy Sitemap * UK * Germany * Spain Average savings are calculated daily based on the best dealer prices on carwow vs manufacturer RRP. carwow is the trading name of carwow Ltd, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority for credit broking and insurance distribution activities (firm reference number: 767155). carwow is a credit broker and not a lender. carwow may receive a fee from retailers advertising finance and may receive a commission from partners (including dealers) for introducing customers. All finance offers and monthly payments shown are subject to application and status. carwow is covered by the Financial Ombudsman Service (please see www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk for more information). carwow Ltd is registered in England (company number 07103079), registered office 2nd Floor, Verde Building, 10 Bressenden Place, London, England, SW1E 5DH.