https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltnietzel/2022/07/07/the-fallout-continues-us-news-pulls-columbia-university-from-its-2022-rankings/ Explore * Billionaires + All Billionaires + World's Billionaires + Forbes 400 + America's Richest Self-Made Women + China's Richest + India's Richest + Indonesia's Richest + Korea's Richest + Thailand's Richest + Japan's Richest + Australia's Richest + Taiwan's Richest + Singapore's Richest + Philippines' Richest + Hong Kong's Richest + Malaysia's Richest + Money & Politics + 2020 Money * Innovation + All Innovation + 5G + AI + Big Data + Cloud + Cloud 100 + COP26 + Consumer Tech + Cybersecurity + Enterprise Tech + Future Of Work + Games + Healthcare + Innovation Rules + SAP BrandVoice | Paid Program + Science + ServiceNow BrandVoice | Paid Program + Social Media + Splunk BrandVoice | Paid Program + Sustainability + Venture Capital + Wind River BrandVoice | Paid Program * Leadership + All Leadership + Careers + CEO Network + CFO Network + CHRO Network + CIO Network + CMO Network + CxO + Deloitte BrandVoice | Paid Program + Diversity, Equity & Inclusion + Education + Forbes EQ | Paid Program + Forbes The Culture + ForbesWomen + Leadership Strategy + PwC Cloud and Digital Transformation BrandVoice | Paid Program + Under 30 + Working Remote + Over 50 * Money + All Money + Banking & Insurance + ETFs & Mutual Funds + Fintech + Hedge Funds & Private Equity + Investing + Investing Basics | Q.ai + Markets + Personal Finance + Premium Investing Newsletters + Retirement + Taxes + Top Advisor | SHOOK + Wealth Management * Forbes Digital Assets + All Forbes Digital Assets + Dashboard + Traded Assets + Research + Events + Crypto Portfolios * Business + All Business + Aerospace & Defense + Energy + Food & Drink + Hollywood & Entertainment + Manufacturing + Media + Mitsubishi Heavy Industries BrandVoice | Paid Program + Policy + Retail + SportsMoney + Tableau BrandVoice | Paid Program + Transportation * Small Business + All Small Business + Entrepreneurs + Franchises + Small Business Strategy * Lifestyle + All Lifestyle + Arts + Boats & Planes + Cars & Bikes + Dining + ForbesLife + Forbes Travel Guide + Spirits + Style & Beauty + Travel + Vices + Watches * Real Estate + All Real Estate + Commercial Real Estate + Forbes Global Properties + Residential Real Estate * Store + All Store * Vetted + All Vetted + Gear + Health & Wellness + Home & Kitchen + Style + Tech & Electronics * Coupons + All Coupons + Purple + Squarespace + Verizon + Lululemon + AT&T + Lowe's + Brooks Brothers + Tory Burch + Dr Martens + Dell + Chewy * Advisor + All Advisor + The Best Credit Cards Of 2022 + Best Balance Transfer Credit Cards + Best Cash Back Credit Cards + Best Travel Credit Cards + Best Business Credit Cards + Today's Mortgage Rates + Today's Refinance Rates + Best Mortgage Lenders 2022 + Best Crypto Exchange 2022 + Best Life Insurance + Best Travel Insurance 2022 + Covid-19 Travel Insurance + Online Car Insurance Quotes + Car Insurance Companies + Pet Insurance + Personal Loans + Debt Consolidation Loans + Student Loan Refinance + Business Loans + Forbes Advisor UK + Calculators + Best Online Banks + Best CD Rates + Best Savings Accounts + Best Checking Accounts * Health + All Health + Mind + Online Therapy + Body + BMI Calculator + Calorie Calculator + Family + Due Date Calculator + Healthy Aging + Medical Alert Systems + Hearing Aids + Walk-In Tubs + Health Insurance + Medicare Advantage Plans * Lists + All Lists * Video + All Video * Newsletters + Crypto Confidential + Editorial Newsletters + Investing Digest + Premium Investing Newsletters * Forbes Magazine + All Forbes Magazine + Forbes Asia + Free Issue of Forbes * Latest + Coronavirus Coverage + Daily Cover Stories + Dark Capital + Editors' Picks + Visual Web Stories * Featured + 4 Steps To Help Your Kids Build Smart Money Habits + 30 Under 30 2022 + America's Richest Self-Made Women 2022 + DNA of Success + Forbes Insights With SAP Concur | Paid Program + Forbes Insights With Treasure Data | Paid Program + Is It Better To Lease Or Buy A Car In Summer 2022? + Qlik BrandVoice | Paid Program + Right Now In Tech: PyCon U.S. 2022 + Snowflake Summit 2022 + The CISO Playbook | Paid Program + The Fintech 50 2022 + The Forbes World's Most Influential CMOs List: 2022 * Advertise with Forbes * Report a Security Issue * Site Feedback * Contact Us * Careers at Forbes * Tips * Corrections * Privacy * Do Not Sell My Personal Information * Terms * AdChoices * Reprints & Permissions (c) 2022 Forbes Media LLC. All Rights Reserved Subscribe Sign In BETA This is a BETA experience. You may opt-out by clicking here More From Forbes Jul 11, 2022,10:09am EDT How Democrats And Republicans Can Rally Behind An Education Freedom Bull Market Jul 11, 2022,07:51am EDT Your Chances Of Doing Well At School Are Higher If Your Older Sibling Did Well Too Jul 10, 2022,08:30am EDT Democratic Proposal Would Expand Federal Financial Aid To Dream Students Jul 9, 2022,06:00am EDT University Of Southern California Receives Historic Gift For Its History Department Jul 8, 2022,09:00am EDT CCR: College & Career Readiness Or Creedence Clearwater Revival? Jul 7, 2022,11:07am EDT How Gestures Can Help Students Learn Jul 7, 2022,10:10am EDT Idaho Shows How Not To Fill Empty Teaching Jobs Edit Story Education The Fallout Continues: U.S. News Pulls Columbia University From Its 2022 Rankings Michael T. Nietzel Senior Contributor Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. I am a former university president who writes about higher education. New! Follow this author to improve your content experience. Got it! Jul 7, 2022,03:51pm EDT| New! Click on the conversation bubble to join the conversation Got it! * Share to Facebook * Share to Twitter * Share to Linkedin One week after Columbia University declined to submit data to U.S. News for its next annual college ... [+] rankings, the publication unranked it in its 2022 rankings because of unanswered questions about the data it submitted. getty As questions continue to remain unanswered about the accuracy of data that Columbia University submitted to U.S. News & World Report for the 2022 edition of its Best Colleges rankings (first published September 2021), U.S. News reported today that it was "unranking" Columbia in those rankings. The magazine said it took the action after Columbia "failed to respond to multiple U.S. News requests that the university substantiate certain data it previously submitted to U.S. News." Columbia's troubles began, when in February of this year, Michael Thaddeus, a professor of mathematics at the university, posted a lengthy critique of many of the data that Columbia had submitted for the rankings, which placed it second (tied with Harvard) among the nation's best universities for 2022. Thaddeus compared institutional data to the numbers Columbia had submitted for the rankings and questioned the accuracy of several of the self-reported figures, including the number of classes of various sizes, the percentage of faculty with terminal degrees, the percentage of classes taught by full-time faculty, the student:faculty ratio, and the amount Columbia spent on instruction. Columbia defended its data at first. But on Thursday of last week, just before the July 1 deadline for submitting new data to U.S. News, Columbia changed its tune and, in a statement by Provost Mary Boyce, said it would not submit data this year, adding that the university had "embarked on a review of our data collection and submissions process." MORE FROMFORBES ADVISOR Best Travel Insurance Companies By Amy Danise Editor Best Covid-19 Travel Insurance Plans By Amy Danise Editor The statement continued, "Columbia has long conducted what we believed to be a thorough process for gathering and reporting institutional data, but we are now closely reviewing our processes in light of the questions raised. The ongoing review is a matter of integrity. We will take no shortcuts in getting it right." According to today's announcement, U.S. News said that after learning about questions relating to Columbia's submission, Robert Morse, its Chief Data Strategist, contacted Columbia in March 2022 requesting that it substantiate the data reported in its 2021 U.S. News statistical surveys for several variables, including those that Thaddeus had questioned. U.S. News said that because Columbia has been unable to provide satisfactory responses to its request, it was moving the university to being "Unranked" in National Universities. The action means Columbia no longer has a numerical rank in the 2022 National Universities, 2022 Best Value Schools, and 2022 Top Performers on Social Mobility because those rankings used data from the university's submission. The action did not affect all of Columbia's rankings. It will remain ranked in the 2022 Undergraduate Teaching, 2022 Most Innovative Schools, 2022 Writing in the Disciplines, 2022 First-Year Experience, 2022 Undergraduate Engineering and 2022 Undergraduate Computer Science rankings because those rankings were based entirely on ratings from officials at other universities and departments and did not rely on data reported by Columbia. Likewise, Columbia's graduate-level schools and programs remain ranked because the institution reported data on them through separate processes. U.S. News maintained that it "is committed to providing quality information on institutions across the country and relies on schools to accurately report their data so prospective students and their families can make informed decisions throughout their college search. When schools do not accurately report their data, U.S. News will review the matter on a case-by-case basis to determine appropriate remedial actions." U.S. News has also deleted the data in question from the Columbia's profile pages and in the U.S. News College Compass tool. Shortly after the U.S. News decision, Columbia spokesperson Ben Chang responded with the following statement: "As announced on June 30 by Provost Mary C. Boyce, Columbia is conducting a review of our data collection and submissions process for the undergraduate survey. We have been clear with U.S. News and World Report that, while that review is underway, we will refrain from submitting undergraduate-related information. Columbia takes seriously the questions raised about our data submission. A thorough review cannot be rushed. While we are disappointed in U.S. News and World Report's decision, we consider this a matter of integrity and will take no shortcuts in getting it right." Follow me on Twitter. Michael T. Nietzel Michael T. Nietzel * Editorial Standards * Print * Reprints & Permissions [ ]