https://www.newsnationnow.com/us-news/education/experiment-pay-students-to-tackle-learning-loss/ Skip to content NewsNation Sponsored By Toggle Menu Go [ ] [] Primary Menu * US + Politics + Elections 2022 + Missing + Business + Tech + Your Money + Recalls and Consumer Alerts + Health + Entertainment + Sports + Immigration + Race in America * Coronavirus + Vaccine * Weather + Climate + Space Top Stories Mid-Atlantic basks while Plains sweat, Midwest storms [Nantucket-] Top Stories Dangerous heat sweeps across the nation [AP22170671] Video Top Stories Yellowstone to partly reopen Wednesday after floods Gallery Montana governor under fire for trip to Italy during flood at home Uncertainty follows in wake of Yellowstone's 500-year flooding Video 'Real resilient' West Yellowstone mayor talks rebuilding after historic flood Video * World + Olympics + Russia At War * Shows + Morning In America + NewsNation: Rush Hour + NewsNation PRIME + On Balance with Leland Vittert + Dan Abrams Live + Banfield * The Hill * NewsNation Live + How To Watch NewsNation + NewsNation TV Schedule + Radio * More + Network + Your Morning + Meet The Team + Newsletters + Feedback + Advertise with Us * App * Channel Finder + How To Watch NewsNation + NewsNation TV Schedule Go Go [ ] [Go] Experiment: Pay students to tackle learning loss Education Zaid Jilani Posted: Jun 14, 2022 / 08:50 PM CDT | Updated: Jun 14, 2022 / 08:50 PM CDT [GettyImage] NEW ROCHELLE, - MARCH 18: Elin Eaton, 11, studies during home schooling on March 18, 2020 in New Rochelle, New York. Schools in New Rochelle, a hot spot in the U.S. for the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, were suspended on March 13, and parents have been tasked with carrying out distance learning programs at home. Nola's mother, Farrah Eaton, a former high school administrator, is holding sessions with her three children from 9am-12pm Monday-Friday. (Photo by John Moore/Getty Images) (NewsNation) -- Exacerbated by widespread school closures and remote instruction, pandemic-era learning loss has had devastating consequences for American students. In some cases, students are more than a year behind where they should be, and those in high-poverty districts are even worse off than most. As districts respond to the challenges brought on by learning loss, one possible approach would be to offer financial incentives to students in order to boost their motivation. That's an idea proposed by Roland Freyer, who is the John A. Paulson Fellow at the Manhattan Institute and a professor of economics at Harvard University, in a recent op-ed. Freyer has spent much of his life conducting research on the American educational system, and one intervention he tested years ago may be relevant to tackling pandemic-era learning loss. Freyer ran experiments funded by private donations in multiple cities in which students were offered small cash payments in exchange for improving certain academic-related behaviors such as good attendance and completing their homework. What he found was these payments made a real difference in student effort and boosted overall achievement, as measured through grades and test scores. In Dallas, for instance, second-grade students were paid $2 for reading a book and then completing a short quiz about that book. The resulting increase in student achievement from this intervention was equivalent to more than two months of schooling. FDA panel endorses Moderna's COVID vaccine for children NewsNation spoke with Freyer about how using financial incentives could help tackle learning loss. The interview has been edited for length and clarity. NewsNation: Explain the research you conducted on financial incentives for students. What did you find? Freyer: What we found is when you pay for outputs [such as higher grades], you get absolutely nothing. [...] We had a sociologist who also talked to the kids ... to the families so you can really understand how incentives were helping. [He] basically told us that the kids got really excited but said school's still hard, they have no idea what to do. Freyer (cont.): On the other hand, if you pay for inputs: reading books, turning in homework, coming to class, doing math homework, those kinds of things, those kids did exactly what we told them to do, and they crushed it. It turns out those things you told them to do, on average, were correlated with high test scores. So the irony in this is, if you pay for high test scores you get nothing. If you pay kids to read books or to do math homework, you get high test scores. Texas school district is closing the equity gap with a 'magic' school bus NewsNation: What do you think about the concern that paying students for academic behavior would create perverse incentives or undermine their natural desire to learn? Freyer: You know, I just don't see it. All the stuff where incentives destroy incentive, motivation are things that you like to do in the first place. So if you were donating blood, and you did it out of the goodness of your heart, and I start paying you incentives and I ask you to donate blood, and I stop that, you might say, hey, hey I'm not donating anymore blood unless you give me some money. Or there are other activities like that. These are, frankly, inner-city schools with low achievement. We were trying to foster a love of learning, getting them to try it and see that they can excel at it, not the other way around. We also did all the measures of intrinsic motivation, we found no effect on it whatsoever. So we didn't foster it, and we also didn't hurt it. NewsNation: Do you know how the students spent the money they were given? Freyer: Basically, what they did is they saved more. So the average kid that was in the treatment group actually saved more over the time than others, and they spent money on things like food, some for their families and some for just themselves. [...] We took a lot of criticism in the early days that you know these fourth graders but for 20 more dollars are going to go buy a lot of drugs. We don't have any evidence of that. What we have evidence of is they spent their money on normal things that youth might spend money on but more importantly to us, they actually saved more and that's in part because ... we gave them (a) financial literacy class. Native children's remains to be moved from Army cemetery NewsNation: What would it cost a school district to implement these financial incentives programs? Freyer: It just depends on, obviously, the amount of the incentives. I think for us we ended up, $30 or so a kid in Dallas. [...] For Houston, I think the average kid made a couple hundred bucks over the year. So I think a few hundred dollars over the year is what we're talking about. Which is, again, a tiny percentage of what we're paying now. And we can easily afford it by canceling all the programs where we have clear evidence they don't work. Outside of NewsNation's interview with Freyer, he explained in his op-ed that "monetary incentives at the level I studied might average, say, $700 per student for a whole year. Public schools in the U.S. currently spend more than $13,000 per student on average, so that reflects a change of only about 5%. To control costs, funding for such a program could be targeted to the neediest students and schools where parents don't have the resources to dole out allowances for model behavior." (c) 1998 - 2022 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. Share this story Trending on NewsNation Master of disguise wanted for questioning in disappearance of woman in Mexico U.S. Video Sam's Club makes memberships $8 - but only for a limited time Business Men charged after Missouri house explosion kills 4 Midwest Biden considering a gasoline tax holiday Your Money 1 hour ago Video SCOTUS security heightened ahead of Roe v. Wade decision Morning In America Video Four inmates escape from Virginia prison Southeast Video Elections 2022 DC mayor's race reflects Democratic dilemma over policing Elections 2022 [AP22165527] Gallery After vote to impeach Trump, Rice loses South Carolina House seat Elections 2022 [AP22165044] Video Texas 34th House district special election result Elections 2022 [NN_Electio] Maine 2022 primary election results Elections 2022 [NN_Electio] Nevada 2022 primary election results Elections 2022 [NN_Electio] North Dakota 2022 primary election results Elections 2022 [NN_Electio] More Elections 2022 More Stories Activists on both sides of abortion debate watched as SCOTUS decision looms Protests continue ahead of the Supreme Court's decision in a Mississippi case that could sharply reduce abortion access nationwide and in some areas, eliminate it entirely. Politics 27 mins ago [supremecou] Some states not on board with recognizing Juneteenth as public holiday Monday marks the public holiday for Juneteenth, the day set aside to commemorate the end of slavery in the United States. President Joe Biden signed the new holiday into law last year with bipartisan support. But on the state level, some still do not formally recognize the holiday. Race in America 36 mins ago [AP21169601] What triggers 'trigger laws' that ban abortions? There are 13 states with so-called "trigger" laws, abortion-restricting laws designed to take effect once abortion is no longer protected by the U.S. Constitution. U.S. 54 mins ago [abortion-r] Massive heat dome brings extra-hot weather to nearly every state Several states will see temperatures shoot over 100 degrees. In some places, it will feel hotter than 105. Rush Hour 1 hour ago [AP22167008] Video 7 Senate seats most likely to flip in 2022 Republicans need to net just one new seat this year to reclaim control of the upper chamber. Politics 1 hour ago [AP22148439] Video Deputies disciplined over handling Saget's death Two Florida deputies have been suspended for sharing the news of comedian Bob Saget's death before his family was alerted. Entertainment [Bob-Saget] Two former Mizzou frat members charged in hazing incident Two former members of a University of Missouri fraternity are now facing criminal charges for their role in a hazing incident that left 19-year-old Daniel Santulli paralyzed, blind and unable to speak. Mid-South [GettyImage] Video Biden considering a gasoline tax holiday President Joe Biden said Monday that he's considering a federal holiday on the gasoline tax, possibly saving U.S. consumers as much as 18.4 cents a gallon. Your Money 1 hour ago [AP22171574] Video How does inflation impact your credit score? While inflation is not a direct credit score factor, its influence can have a big impact. Your Money [GettyImage] More Stories Yellowstone aims for quick opening; flooded towns struggling U.S. [AP22170784] Video SCOTUS security heightened ahead of Roe v. Wade decision Morning In America [AP22161734] Video Mid-Atlantic basks while Plains sweat, Midwest storms Weather [Nantucket-] Savannah Bananas taking baseball world by storm Sports [savannah-b] Video Police: One dead, three injured in DC shooting Northeast [dc-shootin] Men charged after Missouri house explosion kills 4 Midwest [fox2now] Master of disguise wanted for questioning in disappearance of woman in Mexico U.S. [fox-5-san-] Video Dangerous heat sweeps across the nation Weather [AP22170671] Video Fire ravages downtown Las Vegas West [fremontfir] Legal in 30 states, sports betting expands to cruise ships Business [CarnivalVi] Video Poll: 58% say Trump should face Jan. 6 charges Capitol Riots [trumpdonal] Jan. 6 probe is telling a story, but gaps remain Capitol Riots [AP22164713] NewsNation Follow Us * * * * * News App Get the iOS app Get the Android app from Google Play * About * Contact * Meet The Team * Channel Finder * TV Schedule * Video * Closed Captioning * CALM Act Certification * Newsletters * Privacy Policy * About Our Ads * Do Not Sell My Personal Information * Privacy Policy * Terms Of Use * Covers * Best Reviews * Do Not Sell My Personal Information * FCC Applications * Public File Assistance Contact * --------------------------------------------------------------------- Nexstar Logo (c) 1998 - 2022 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. x Close Ad